Monday, June 16, 2003

The Christian Name of God - THE TRINITY

The long season of Trinity begins with Trinity Sunday and as we live through this second half of the Christian year, whether we recognise it or not we daily confess the Name of God, the Trinity (Trinitas), and clearly distinguish ourselves not only from pantheists but also from monotheists, even from Jews and Muslims.

In the New Testament the word "God" virtually always refers to "the Father", that is "the Father of the only-begotten Son, the Lord Jesus Christ". Likewise in Christian liturgy the addressing of "almighty God" virtually always means the addressing of the Father, who is approached in the name of Jesus Christ, the Mediator.

Thus "the Father" is a name that is inextricably part of the Christian Faith, Revelation and Vocabulary, and with it there is everlastingly associated "the Son" and "the Holy Ghost/Spirit". In this threefold Name Baptisms are performed and Blessings are given.

In Christian Tradition, from as early as the second century, the unique name of the Deity worshipped, adored and served by the Christian Church has been TRINITAS, the Trinity (and thus "the Holy Trinity" and "the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity"). The choice of this word was made necessary as the Church confessed that the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are God, one God, one LORD.

The Trinity is not a description of Deity but is the unique Christian Name for Deity, for the one Deity & Godhead. Hereby the identity of Deity/God for Christians is immediately seen to be different from, even if related to, the identity of God for Jews and Muslims.

Jews, Muslims and Christians reject polytheism and are committed to monotheism. But for Christians the belief in One God is belief in one Deity, Divinity and Godhead, which is wholly possessed by Three Persons, the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost. Thus Christians worship a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity: they adore the One Deity and Godhead as they also adore the Persons of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, in each of whom this one, only Godhead is fully possessed and manifested.

The confession of Jesus of Nazareth as the Christ and as the Son of God incarnate is the divine key that opens up the possibility of identifying the Godhead as Triune, as the Trinity. For the Trinity is known through the personhood, teaching and divine activity of the Lord Jesus Christ.

To confess Jesus as Lord and to state that he is of one substance (essence or being) with the Father is to make the first step in confessing the Trinity.

To confess the Trinity is to begin to be Trinitarian in mindset and in worship! It is to worship, serve and obey the Father through the Son and with the Holy Spirit and also it is to receive mercy, grace, gifts, knowledge and understanding from the Father through the Son and by the Holy Spirit.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

The Presiding Bishop of ECUSA writes to the bishops before General Convention

Frank is a confused man; he wants to participate in and commend the spirituality of the Orthodox together with an openness to what the Orthodox call immorality in sexual relations! Such is the confusion in the leadership of the ECUSA.
ACNS 3478 | USA | 16 JUNE 2003

June 12, 2003

For all bishops

Dear brothers and sisters:

General Convention is almost here and its theme, Engage God's Mission, draws upon energies and commitment evident around our church. We will be building on work in which we as a House of Bishops have been engaged for some time, particularly since our fall meeting in 2001 in Burlington, Vermont immediately following the events of September 11. Over these last three years, we have explored mission as our participation in God's work of reconciling all things to himself in Christ. I have every expectation that our forthcoming Convention will take us deeper into that work as we draw upon the grace of Christ and the wisdom of the Spirit. Everything that happens in the life of the church is an invitation to reveal more fully the reconciling power of the gospel: this is something I have been made freshly aware of by my recent visit to my brothers and sisters in the Church of Uganda.

The election of the Revd Canon V Gene Robinson by the laity and clergy of the Diocese of New Hampshire to serve as their Bishop Coadjutor has received wide comment in the press and other media. Great joy and deep distress are emotions being felt by many within our church. Some view the election as prophetic and an action of the Holy Spirit, while others view it as disregarding Scripture, Tradition and the larger view of the Anglican Communion, which they see as expressed in a resolution on sexuality of the 1998 Lambeth Conference. This variety of opinion should not surprise us. As the report of the Theology Committee so clearly stated, "The depth and complexity of human sexuality are reflected in the multiple understandings and interpretations held by thoughtful people." We have seen these various interpretations articulated over these last days in response to the New Hampshire election, and discussion will doubtless continue.

In the face of strongly-held divergent opinions on what constitutes God's desire, my concern is how we move with grace through this time. As Presiding Bishop and chief pastor of the church, it is my duty to ensure that all perspectives are treated with reverence, care and mutual respect in the service of a unity, not of our own creation, but rather given to us through our baptism into Christ. This means that though we may disagree, no one can say, "I have no need of you" to another member of the church. I hope that in the weeks ahead we will be mindful of this, and of the following points as well.

First, we need to respect the action of the Diocese of New Hampshire. After a search, nomination and election process they have made their choice of a priest who has served in their Diocese for 28 years. Gene Robinson was elected by the Diocese of New Hampshire because he is a highly respected person. He is a fellow member of the body of Christ, not the symbol of an issue.

The election of a bishop also involves approval by the whole church, inasmuch as a bishop is a bishop for the whole church. According to the Constitution of our church, when the election of a bishop occurs fewer than 120 days before a General Convention, the church's consent must be secured at the Convention by the House of Deputies and by the diocesan bishops with jurisdiction. By canon and by tradition, the House of Deputies first gives its consent and then the consents of bishops with jurisdiction are sought. At our forthcoming General Convention, the election of ten bishops will be put forward for consent. All of these are equally important.

And here I need to add that it is unfortunate, but predictable, that the media and some others will doubtless be focused upon consent in the case of the New Hampshire election. I hope that a distinction can be made between the consent to the consecration of a bishop who is a priest in good standing partnered with a member of the same sex, and the continuing debate regarding formal actions by the church in the area of human sexuality. We as bishops, together with our diocesan deputations, need to keep our eyes fixed on the larger purposes for which we gather as a church, namely the enduring mission of God in Christ who has reconciled all things to himself through the cross.

Last of all, let me share with you a prayer I recite frequently. You may find it useful as well, particularly during the days of our General Convention. It comes from a man who knew the burdens of episcope intimately - Philaret, Patriarch of Moscow. It runs as follows:

Lord, grant me to greet the coming day in peace.
Help me in all things to rely on your holy will.
In every hour of the day reveal your will to me.
Teach me to treat all that comes to me throughout the day with peace of soul, and with firm conviction that your will governs everything. In all my deeds and words guide my thoughts and feelings. In unforeseen events let me not forget that all are sent by you. Teach me to act firmly and wisely, without embittering and embarrassing others. Give me the strength to bear the fatigue of the coming day with all that it shall bring. Direct my will. Teach me to pray. Pray yourself in me.


As always, in the love of Christ, your brother,

Frank T. Griswold
Presiding Bishop and Primate

[Related articles and links are available from the ACNS Human Sexuality Issues section http://www.anglicancommunion.org/acns/special/humansexuality/index.html]

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Saturday, June 14, 2003

How regrettable on Trinity Sunday

Adelphoi,

On Trinity Sunday, when the Household of God, the Body of Christ, is called to adore, praise and celebrate the identify of the LORD GOD as a Trinity in Unity and an Unity in Trinity, and to utter with humility, reverence and passion, "Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost", it is extremely regrettable that neither the Collect nor the Post Communion Prayer in Common Worship (the new Directory of the Church of England) do not rise to the occasion.

For over a thousand years in the West there has been a particular style to the one sentence Collect which comes before the Epistle and Gospel in the Eucharist. Regrettably the Church of England has chosen to ditch this hallowed style for Trinity Sunday (the very day when she needed it most) in favour of a new style which carries the implication of arrogance before the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost.

The classic Collect, translated from the Latin in 1549, begins: "Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity and in the power of the Divine Majesty to worship the Unity:.." Here by the use of the relative clause, the people of God remember in God's presence his self-revelation by which they are able to know and confess his Identity as the Trinity. The wording encourages the virtues of humility and reverence.

The modern Collect, which attempts to maintain the doctrine of the traditional Collect, refuses to use the ancient devise of the relative clause and goes instead for a declaratory statement, a telling the Trinity what the same Trinity knows more perfectly and surely than any man could ever begin to know!

"Almighty and everlasting God, you have given us your servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the divine majesty to worship the Unity:."

This is like the preposterous - "You are God and we praise You."!

The modern Post-Communion Prayer is even more regrettable because (a) it purports to tell the LORD what he knows absolutely perfectly and experientially, and (b) what it tells him is possibly (by classic patristic standards) heresy!

"Almighty and eternal God, you have revealed yourself as Father, Son and Holy Spirit and live and reign in the perfect unity of love:."

Once again we have the declaratory clause instead of the relative clause. Then it is unclear to Whom the prayer is addressed. Is it addressed to the Godhead as One or the Trinity as Trinity? It sounds as though there is One God who is one Person who reveals to us that he has Three Names or Modes of Being? Or is it addressed to God the Father (as most prayers are so addressed?) If so then is it true that the Father has revealed himself as Father, Son and Holy Spirit? It seems as though - because of the way it ends - the prayer is actually addressed to God as Trinity and if so it does allow, because of careless wording, the interpretation of Modalism, that God is One Person with Three Modes of Being and Three Names.

The biblical way of revelation of the Triune Nature & Name is FROM the Father through the Son and by the Holy Ghost, to which the response of creatures is TO the Father through the Son and with the Holy Ghost.

When we are dealing with the Dogma of the Trinity and the Dogma of the Person of Christ, we moderns need to keep close to the Patristic Definitions which informed classic Liturgy! If we do not then we get into trouble!

PLEASE DO NOT FORGET TO USE THE ATHANASIAN CREED ON TRINITY SUNDAY

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Friday, June 13, 2003

Letter to the Church Times

From The Revd Dr Peter Toon
Sir,

In your editorial of 13 June on the nomination of Jeffrey John to the bishopric of Reading, you write: “People might have questions about his earlier life, but sexual history is not usually something with which the Church concerns itself. Most couples now cohabit before marriage, and yet the Church does not consider marrying them confers some approval of this…”

You are suggesting that it is not necessary or appropriate to consider the (publicly known) sexual history of one who is either to be ordained/consecrated or married in church. Perhaps in most cases with respect to marriage it is “not necessary”; but, in the former case of consecration to the episcopate it is “necessary”. How a priest has behaved publicly and what he has taught in the Church certainly ought to be “something with which the Church concerns itself” in choosing a bishop.

Your argument may well fit into a modern church morality based on human rights and be the norm in some dioceses for the choosing of ordinands. However, the Church of yesterday had a different approach. One has only to look at canon law to see this. Not only was repentance of heart and mind looked for but also public penance was imposed for sins, offences & irregularities against God’s law and Church law. Such penance included non-admission to Holy Communion and/or suspension or removal from an office of ordained ministry.

Fornication and adultery of any kind are still sins as far as God, the Bible and the Formularies of the Church are concerned. And they are still sins when committed by affable, attractive and gifted persons.

What is not considered in your editorial is this possibility - that for the eternal salvation & spiritual health of the person himself, as well as for the holiness, edification and good name of Church of God, he who has been a fornicator or an adulterer [or involved in a sexual partnership] while ordained, be not considered for any preferment, even if he has turned from that sin, sought forgiveness and has been through a period of penance.

Ordination or consecration is not a human right but a gift of the exalted Lord Christ to his Church for the edification and holiness of that Church, and it has always been the case that certain irregularities constitute the possibility of exclusion or expulsion from the sacred Ministry. In this day and age, it can surely be argued that for the true good of the Church of God and for the man’s own spiritual and moral progress, a priest who has been in a homosexual partnership or an adulterous relationship or is divorced [and remarried] ought to be excluded from preferment to the office of bishop. He may be an excellent person in terms of gifts, abilities and energy but he has no right to preferment because of them. Let him in penitence excel in the presbyterate and therein reveal the mercy of God.

Peter Toon,
The Rectory,
Biddulph Moor, ST8 7HP

Gay Bishops & Human Rights

Adelphoi,

For your consideration...


Is Ordination within human rights?

There is a general assumption by decent people in the Church of England (who think that active homosexuality is wrong) that if a priest has a homosexual partner, then gives him up, and does not take another casually or long-term, he is eligible as a candidate for preferment to the office of bishop - that is, if he promises to abide by the church's teaching on marriage and sexual relations in his public utterances.

Is this assumption correct?

Let us first assume that there is no heartfelt repentance for the involvement in same-sex activity but there is a clear recognition that it is not appropriate for a priest to be involved. If this man is elevated to the episcopate, we have there a person who does not in his heart and mind accept the teaching of the Bible as understood in the Church of God but who attempts to keep his views to himself, as he tries to commend the Church's teaching.

Let us assume, secondly, that there is genuine repentance for the sexual partnership and there is a fervent desire to live a chaste life and to teach the doctrine and morality of the Church on sexual relations. If he is elevated to the episcopate, he will certainly be able to teach from his heart with his mind and will the doctrine of the Church and may be able to offer specialist counselling to certain of his flock.

Now I comment on the two examples.

With regard to the first person, he is placed in a very odd situation where what he believes he denies publicly. It is surely psychologically bad for the man and pastorally dangerous for his diocese for he may at any time lose control!

With regard to the second man, there is a real possibility of his making a good and sound bishop. Nevertheless, there is the danger of reversal to the previous life-style if he does not live close to the Lord daily, every day!

But, is it wise for holy mother Church to elevate either man from the presbyterate to the episcopate (or earlier from the diaconate to the presbyterate, or from the laity to the diaconate)? In days when human rights have become the language and reference of discussion for morality, this may seem a stupid or inappropriate question. However, in terms of historic moral theology and canon law it is a most appropriate & urgent question!

The Church has always identified persons who are in all ways qualified to be candidates for ordination except for an irregularity. For example, a man before he became a baptized, committed Christian may have committed manslaughter, or a major crime, or he may have lived "in sin" with a man or woman, or he may have presided over a major disaster in a company or school, and so on. And he has paid the penalty of the law and is penitent.

In cases such as these, where there is repentance followed by appropriate penance (e.g., exclusion from Holy Communion for a season), the person may be restored to full fellowship in the Church of God. However, he is not usually considered for ordination since it is judged that his previous failings - though forgiven by God and forgiven by the Christian congregation - create a closed door to that office (which is an office of grace & holiness and not of right). And the reason for this is because of the good name of the church, for the spiritual health of the person himself, and so that he is not the occasion for (later) attacks from outside or inside the church concerning his previous life.

Not too long ago if a priest committed adultery or was involved in sodomy or anything of like nature, he was suspended from the active ministry with no possibility of preferment. Today a so-called "gay relationship" or marital infidelity or divorce (with or without remarriage) seem not to hinder a person's ecclesiastical career. The Chaste Life seems to be a remote ideal today rather than a direct command of the Lord to his presbyters. [In the Early Church if a deaconess married she was suspended from the ministry and from holy communion, as also was her husband! And this for the purity of the Church and her discipline.]

The human rights agenda - so dominant today in the churches - does not understand the traditional type of thinking concerning the closed door, for it is biblical thinking about the spiritual & moral health of the Body of Christ and of the precious value of baptized souls, where the individual person exists in fellowship for the good of the Body and its Head, Christ, and for the glory of God the Father.

Today, with the investigative powers of the media and the ability of that media to publish whatever it sees fit, the obvious dangers for the Church and for the spiritual and moral health of ordaining "gay" priests and bishops is clear. The wisdom of the Church over the centuries in not ordaining otherwise qualified persons can surely be seen - if and only if, the matter is viewed from a traditional biblical perspective and not from the perspective of human rights. Ordination in the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church should never be about "a person's right" to that office.

In this highly-sexed era, it is probably wise for the Church to be most discriminating in whom she ordains to any office, not allowing claimed human rights to dictate entry into the sacred ministry. And she must show her tough love in her discriminating concerning ordination both to heterosexual and homosexual/lesbian persons.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Scottish Episcopal Church votes to ordain women bishops

ACNS 3472 | SCOTLAND | 12 JUNE 2003

by Matthew Davies

The General Synod of the Scottish Episcopal Church (SEC), meeting in Edinburgh from 12-14 June, made an historic decision today by voting to accept women bishops and ending centuries of tradition. Today's decision could lead the way to give Scotland the first female bishops in the UK.

At the 2002 General Synod a vast majority of the 156 members supported the motion, which gave churches throughout Scotland the opportunity to spend a year discussing the issue further in their own dioceses.

The motion received its second and final reading today and required a two-thirds majority for it to be passed. Out of 153 votes cast, 124 voted in favour, including all seven bishops of the SEC.

At present, only the Anglican/Episcopal Churches of the USA, Canada and New Zealand have elected women as bishops, although the Anglican Church in Ireland has voted to allow women bishops but has yet to appoint one.

On 11 November 1992, the General Synod of the Church of England voted to open the priesthood to women, five years after women were first ordained to the diaconate. This vote came after 70 years of formal discussion and debate in the Anglican Communion, which began in 1920 when the Lambeth Conference first considered the issue. Currently, one in five Church of England priests is female.

The first women priests in the Anglican Communion were ordained in Hong Kong in 1944. During the 1960s and 70s there was a movement in many countries across the world towards the ordination of women as priests. In 1974 there was an irregular ordination of 11 women in the United States, and the Episcopal Church in the US authorised women's priestly ordination two years later. In 1993 and 1994 the Scottish Synod agreed to allow women to be ordained as priests and the first ordinations took place in December 1994.

Responding to today's decision, the Most Revd Bruce Cameron, Primus of the Scottish Episcopal Church, said, "The decision is a momentous one. For some it will be received with great joy, for others pain, but I know that most of us will want to be members of the same family in the Episcopal Church. We must seek to be sensitive to all people in our church."

Professor David Atkinson, lay member of the Diocese of Edinburgh, spoke in favour of the motion, saying, "Jesus took a common sense approach to what would be seen by others as very difficult questions. We need to look at what the purpose of our church is to mission and ministry. Ordination of women to the priesthood makes available to the Church the talents of a group of committed and skilled Christians."

He admitted that issues such as these always have upsides and downsides. He added, "I believe that common sense, fairness, inclusively of talented Christians and our ability to be effective in our ministry and mission, which needs to be seen as in touch with and understanding of society, dictates that we must pass this change to our canons."

The Revd Ruth Edwards, Diocese of Aberdeen and Orkney, also supported the motion saying that it follows on from the ordination of women to the diaconate and the presbyterate. "It seems very strange to fix on them a stained glass ceiling," she said. "It will help our ecumenical work much more if God can call men and women equally to all levels within the church...It is about faithfulness to the truth."

David Fuller, a member of the Diocese of Argyll and the Isles, strongly rejected the motion and asked for more debate. "We live in times of great change," he said. "No one before us has had to live in such a volatile world...but there is an understanding trend towards unity. We should try to steer clear of making serious doctrinal mistakes."

The Revd Canon John Riches from the Diocese of Glasgow and Galloway spoke briefly about his experience as a member of the International Anglican Orthodox Dialogue. He said that the Old Catholics and Orthodox in Eastern Europe issued a joint statement saying that they could find no reason why women should not be ordained. "The question really is, 'whatever decision is made will it cause a division?'" he said. "It would be discrimination if, in the absence of valid theological reasons, we chose not to support the motion."

The following motion was also passed:

Motion 4: That this Synod, having voted to admit women to the episcopate because a major majority of its members sufficient to satisfy the requirement of Canon 52 believes this to be a development, guided by the Holy Spirit, in the understanding of the Church's threefold ministry of Bishops, Priests and Deacons, as expressed in Canon 1:

1 desires and intends no break with the tradition of the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church of Christ in which the Scottish Episcopal Church has always professed itself to be.

2 acknowledges that within the Scottish Episcopal Church, there are those, who, for various reasons, cannot in conscience agree with its decision, recognizes the good faith in which their convictions are held and pledges that those who hold such convictions will continue for all time to come to have a valued and respected place within the Scottish Episcopal Church.

3 further acknowledges, with deep sadness, that in seeking to follow the guidance of the Holy Spirit, it has felt called to act without the existence of a consensus on the matter in all branches of the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church of Christ, and expresses penitence for the existing divisions within the Body of Christ and for any further division therein which today's decision may cause.

4 recognises its own fallibility, with that of all the Church's Councils, and prays that, by the guidance of the Holy Spirit, all branches of the Church may continue to work together in love, so that they may grow together in faith into the one Body of Christ.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Thursday, June 12, 2003

Homosexual Bishop-elect will be approved

(Here follows what will be a majority view in the ECUSA)


Statement by the Bishop of Oklahoma

The election of the Revd Gene Robinson to be the next Bishop of New Hampshire has caused several people in this diocese to call and inquire as to my reaction to his election. Will I support his election when it comes before the House of Bishops at the General Convention?

My reaction is one of respect for the people of the Diocese of New Hampshire. They did a bold thing in electing the Revd Gene Robinson. Homosexuals are modern outcasts, like lepers in Jesus' day. In many people, they engender fear and loathing. In my ministry I have seen good people become filled with hate and disgust when the subject was homosexuality. At a vestry meeting I once attended, one man said, "If my son said he was gay, I would disown him." The Episcopal Church in New Hampshire has obviously moved beyond that stage of fear and prejudice. They have seen the humanity in a gay man and they have decided that his humanity is more important than his gayness.

I do plan to support his election. The Diocese of New Hampshire elected him after knowing him and observing his ministry for many years. They have confidence that he will be a good bishop. New Hampshire is known as a conservative State and yet the clergy and people elected a man they knew was gay and living with another man in a committed relationship.

The Church has spent a great deal of time studying and debating the place of homosexual men and women in its life. It is a subject that elicits great passion and it has the potential to split apart the Body of Christ. So did the inclusion of Gentiles in the first century! So did the breaking down of slavery in the nineteenth century! So did Civil Rights! So did the ordination of women! I follow Christ as my Lord and Saviour and Christ keeps breaking down barriers that religious people once thought were sacred. I think that our Lord is doing the same thing today with our attitudes towards homosexual men and women, gays and lesbians. Thus, I will vote to support the election in New Hampshire and welcome Bishop-elect Robinson as a brother bishop in the Episcopal Church.

God bless this Church.

+Robert M Moody
Bishop of Oklahoma


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Wednesday, June 11, 2003

Bishop of Oxford defends nomination of Canon Jeffrey John as Bishop of Reading

For those who wish the inside story from Oxford diocese

In a personal statement given to the Oxford Diocesan Synod meeting in High Wycombe, UK, the Bishop of Oxford, the Rt Revd Richard Harries, described the process leading to the nomination of Canon Jeffrey John as the next Bishop of Reading, and explained his decision as an issue of principle.

The full text of his statement can be found at the Diocese of Oxford web site http://www.oxford.anglican.org/detail.php?id=435


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Scottish Episcopal Church faces two historic decisions

Adelphoi,

The General Synod of the Scottish Episcopal Church faces two historic decisions this week: whether to accept women bishops and whether to back plans for a three-way "super-church" merger in Scotland.

The Church's General Synod will decide on Thursday whether to end centuries of tradition and open the door to women becoming bishops. If the vote is passed it could give Scotland the first female bishops in the UK.

The first reading of the motion to accept women in the top job was passed overwhelmingly at last year's meeting of the General Synod. After that vote, the issue went out to the seven dioceses for further debate.

On Thursday, the motion will receive its second and final reading. It will need the support of two thirds of the Synod - made up of the seven bishops and 156 representatives of the clergy and congregations - to go through as a change to the church's rulebooks.

At present, only the Anglican churches in the USA , Canada and New Zealand have employed women as bishops. The Anglican Church in Ireland has voted to allow women bishops but has yet to appoint one. The Church of England does not allow women bishops.

The General Synod will also be asked whether it wants to press on with plans to merge with other Protestant churches in Scotland - despite the Church of Scotland's rejection of the proposals at its General Assembly last month. Members will debate whether to commend historic proposals set out by the Scottish Church Initiative for Union (SCIFU).

The proposals include plans to create "maxi-parishes" served by teams of ministers from all church traditions, led by "bishops" elected by regional church councils.

The governing bodies of the two other Churches involved in the SCIFU talks - the Methodists and the United Reformed Church - have both already overwhelmingly backed the merger proposals.

The Rt Revd Michael Henley, Episcopal Bishop of St Andrews, Dunkeld & Dunblane, and convener of the SCIFU working group, said, "The ideal of Christian unity does not live or die on the decision of one church. I am still very interested in pursuing the SCIFU initiatives with the Methodists and the URC. This idea is not going to go away."

If the general Synod supports the merger plans, they will go out to the dioceses for further debate before returning to the Synod next year.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Monday, June 09, 2003

Trinity Sunday, an occasion of GLORY

Let us not miss this wondeful opportunity for ADORATION and TEACHING

Trinity Sunday. Collect, Epistle & Gospel. (BCP, 1662)

“Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the Divine Majesty to worship the Unity: We beseech thee, that thou wouldest keep us stedfast in this faith, and evermore defend us from all adversities, who livest and reignest, one God, world without end. Amen.”

Epistle: Revelation 4.1-11 Gospel: St John 3:1-11

Trinity Sunday has been a Feast Day in the western Church since the fourteenth century. At the very centre of the Christian Faith is the Mystery and the Dogma of the Holy Trinity, into whose Triune Name we are baptized and by whose Name we are blessed. One cannot be a Christian without believing and confessing the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost, Three Persons and one God.

This Sunday & week is the only time in the Church Year that the Collect is addressed to the Holy Trinity as one God. Normally the Collect is addressed to the Father through the Son.

The Collect, which adores the Holy Trinity in the divine Unity and Trinity, does not however fit well or naturally with the Epistle [Revelation 4:1-11] and the Gospel [John 3: 1-15] readings. This is because these readings were chosen centuries before the establishment of the Feast, when this Sunday was within the octave of Pentecost. So the readings were originally chosen to contain the great theme of Pentecost, the Gift of the Holy Ghost from the Father and the Son to the Church. Thus the EPISTLE with its reference to the “seven lamps of fire” was taken to point to the sevenfold gifts of the Holy Ghost (see the Confirmation service for these). And the GOSPEL with its reference to being born again/from above by the Holy Ghost was taken to point to the regenerating work of the Holy Ghost in the souls of men.

Nevertheless in both readings there is the revelation of the one true and living God as a Trinity of Persons. The thrice “Holy” of the heavenly host in the EPISTLE has always been taken by the Church as a praising of each of the Three Persons, the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost. It is used in the Liturgy as such. And in the GOSPEL there is the constant reference to God [= the Father], the presence of the Lord Jesus Christ [the incarnate Son of the Father] and the presence and work of the Holy Ghost who regenerates believing sinners.

The Preface for Trinity Sunday within the Order for Holy Communion of the BCP (1662) is like the Collect unique in that it is addressed not to the Father but to the One Holy Trinity.

“It is very meet, right, and our bounden duty, that we should at all times and in all places, give thanks unto thee O Lord, Almighty Everlasting God. Who art one God, one Lord; not one only Person, but Three Persons in one Substance. For that which we believe of the Father, the same we believe of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, without any difference or inequality. Therefore, with angels and archangels….”

To become more acquainted with the dogma of the Holy Trinity, as that was worked out in the Early Church, we turn to the Quincunque Vult (Athanasian Creed) which is appointed to be used at Morning Prayer on Trinity Sunday. And for a less logical presentation we read the Nicene Creed which is appointed for use in the Order for Holy Communion on Trinity Sunday. Though we seek to understand (faith seeking understanding), our main vocation on this Sunday is to adore!

GLORY BE TO THE FATHER AND TO THE SON AND TO THE HOLY GHOST, AS IT WAS IN THE BEGINNING, IS NOW, AND EVER SHALL BE, WORLD WITHOUT END. AMEN.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),