DIVIDED WE STAND
A HISTORY OF THE CONTINUING ANGLICAN MOVEMENT
by Douglas Bess
Tractarian Press, 5225 Canyon Crest Drive, 71-295, Riverside, CA. 92507
320 pages ISBN 0-9719636-0-6
$22.00
I am told that it is filled with useful information but it is not easy reading. I am also told that it was in origins a thesis.
Buy direct for $22.00.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Thursday, December 12, 2002
"Liturgy is more than a text." Episcopalians & Lutherans find a common mind.
Pages 400-401 of the 1979 ECUSA prayer book contain the HERMENEUTICAL KEY.
In a lecture at Virginia Seminary to commemorate the 450th anniversary of the Anglican Common Prayer, the Lutheran scholar, Gordon W. Lathrop, stated: "American Episcopalians are in the forefront of those who know and teach that liturgy is more than text." And then he pointed to the book, Shaped by Images (1995), by William Seth Adams for illustration of this point.
He proceeded to claim that: "One way to understand the remarkable pages 400-401 at the center of the 1979 Book of Common Prayer -- the text-less 'Order for Celebrating the Holy Eucharist' -- is that they are the very hermeneutical key to the entire book." That is, these pages provide " a way to understand how the other texts of all the rites have their meaning as they are used in a shaped communal action." Further, "they are not an after-thought for 'informal services,' but they are an opening of the book towards its future, an awareness that the book of the church is always in process." (See Virginia Seminary Journal, January 2000, for the text of the lecture).
What Professor Lathrop asserts is not new. We have been hearing for several decades from liturgists and bishops in the ECUSA and in the C. of E. about "the shape of the liturgy" and that common prayer is to be seen not as a common text but as a common structure with common elements, allowing a variety of forms of words.
So what is on pages 400-401? The barebones structure of the Eucharist as envisaged by those who produced the 1979 prayer book. Parishes are free to insert material of their choice under the eight headings -- Gather, Proclaim, Pray, Exchange the Peace, Prepare the Table, Make Eucharist, Break the Bread & Share the Gifts of God.
In 1979 it was assumed that the material to fill in the spaces would be taken from the 1979 book itself, but now with the creation of more official Rites as Supplementary Texts (e.g., Enriching Our Worship, 1998) by the ECUSA, and with the existence of ecumenical web-sites containing all kinds of suggestions, the possibilities for experiment and novelty are immense. Further, with the pressure from the feminist lobby for "gender-neutral" or "feminine" names for God and forms of address to God, this possibility of novelty increases all the time, as congregations dare to move further away from traditional "God-language" and moral discourse. The worship committee meeting on Wednesday has great opportunity using the scissor and paste method to produce a liturgy to suit the most recent taste and preference (whether God be glorified or not!).
Thus what is claimed to be "Common Prayer" in the Episcopal Church is now effectively a minimal common structure wherein can be inserted anything from texts of historical orthodoxy in traditional or modern language to texts celebrating the goddess, Sophia. For some people, the structure is the most important thing for that is what makes Liturgy authentic!
It is important to note that this common structure for the modern Eucharist is not the same structure as found in the classic Book of Common Prayer (1549, 1662, 1928 etc.) and that it is not possible to fit the content of the historic BCP into the modern structure proposed by the 1979 book without changing its doctrine thereby.
Why would a Lutheran professor be so happy about the new Episcopalian/Anglican sense of "common prayer"?
Here is a possible answer. Lutherans have never had the equivalent of the Book of Common Prayer as Text and Formulary. They have never had Liturgical Formularies (e.g., as are the classic Anglican Book of Common Prayer & the Ordinal) to unite them as a jurisdiction of the Church. Rather they have been a Confessional Church ("We believe, teach and confess.") based upon the Augsburg Confession, and the structure of their worship has been guided in principle not by a common text but by common structures. Their Liturgical Books are not primarily collections of texts but essays on how to lead liturgy and teach the Faith. This is not to say that many Lutheran parishes have not used common services, but it is to say that for them common prayer does not mean a common text but a common (and minimal) structure for Word and Sacrament.
Now that the ECUSA and the ELCA [Evangelical Lutheran Church of America] have joined together in a practical union from January 1, 2001, Lutherans such as Dr Lathrop rejoice because the ECUSA has moved to the position in terms of common prayer where the ELCA can truly be glad. In effect the ECUSA has come to the position adopted by the Lutheran leaders in the 16th century concerning Rites and Ceremonies (but not, emphatically, we may add, with regard to doctrine & justification by faith in particular). What matters for leaders of Episcopalians and Lutherans now is NOT a common text but a common structure for liturgy.
Thus it seems that there is room in the uniting Episcopal-Lutheran body for all types of Lutherans and Episcopalians to be united in a common worship because they have reduced common prayer to a common structure, wherein they can insert material of choice. So one parish will seek to be orthodox in doctrine and morality while another will knowingly be neo-pagan. This will be possible because on the one side the Augsburg Confession and on the other the Anglican Formularies will be merely "historical documents." And the Bible will be seen not as authoritative in all matters of faith and morality; but as a collection of books describing the experiences of God by people in ancient times; therefore the Bible is authoritative only in that it is first in order, rather than first because foundational.
Some of us prefer the older Anglican Way of using classical, fixed texts for Liturgy and finding in these texts the richness of doctrine and devotion that the saints over the centuries have poured into them and found through them.
The centrality of structure for modern liturgists is seen in the new Common Worship of the C of E where before each service/rite, its structure is carefully set out on a page of its own! Happily the classic BCP of 1662 does not follow this method!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
In a lecture at Virginia Seminary to commemorate the 450th anniversary of the Anglican Common Prayer, the Lutheran scholar, Gordon W. Lathrop, stated: "American Episcopalians are in the forefront of those who know and teach that liturgy is more than text." And then he pointed to the book, Shaped by Images (1995), by William Seth Adams for illustration of this point.
He proceeded to claim that: "One way to understand the remarkable pages 400-401 at the center of the 1979 Book of Common Prayer -- the text-less 'Order for Celebrating the Holy Eucharist' -- is that they are the very hermeneutical key to the entire book." That is, these pages provide " a way to understand how the other texts of all the rites have their meaning as they are used in a shaped communal action." Further, "they are not an after-thought for 'informal services,' but they are an opening of the book towards its future, an awareness that the book of the church is always in process." (See Virginia Seminary Journal, January 2000, for the text of the lecture).
What Professor Lathrop asserts is not new. We have been hearing for several decades from liturgists and bishops in the ECUSA and in the C. of E. about "the shape of the liturgy" and that common prayer is to be seen not as a common text but as a common structure with common elements, allowing a variety of forms of words.
So what is on pages 400-401? The barebones structure of the Eucharist as envisaged by those who produced the 1979 prayer book. Parishes are free to insert material of their choice under the eight headings -- Gather, Proclaim, Pray, Exchange the Peace, Prepare the Table, Make Eucharist, Break the Bread & Share the Gifts of God.
In 1979 it was assumed that the material to fill in the spaces would be taken from the 1979 book itself, but now with the creation of more official Rites as Supplementary Texts (e.g., Enriching Our Worship, 1998) by the ECUSA, and with the existence of ecumenical web-sites containing all kinds of suggestions, the possibilities for experiment and novelty are immense. Further, with the pressure from the feminist lobby for "gender-neutral" or "feminine" names for God and forms of address to God, this possibility of novelty increases all the time, as congregations dare to move further away from traditional "God-language" and moral discourse. The worship committee meeting on Wednesday has great opportunity using the scissor and paste method to produce a liturgy to suit the most recent taste and preference (whether God be glorified or not!).
Thus what is claimed to be "Common Prayer" in the Episcopal Church is now effectively a minimal common structure wherein can be inserted anything from texts of historical orthodoxy in traditional or modern language to texts celebrating the goddess, Sophia. For some people, the structure is the most important thing for that is what makes Liturgy authentic!
It is important to note that this common structure for the modern Eucharist is not the same structure as found in the classic Book of Common Prayer (1549, 1662, 1928 etc.) and that it is not possible to fit the content of the historic BCP into the modern structure proposed by the 1979 book without changing its doctrine thereby.
Why would a Lutheran professor be so happy about the new Episcopalian/Anglican sense of "common prayer"?
Here is a possible answer. Lutherans have never had the equivalent of the Book of Common Prayer as Text and Formulary. They have never had Liturgical Formularies (e.g., as are the classic Anglican Book of Common Prayer & the Ordinal) to unite them as a jurisdiction of the Church. Rather they have been a Confessional Church ("We believe, teach and confess.") based upon the Augsburg Confession, and the structure of their worship has been guided in principle not by a common text but by common structures. Their Liturgical Books are not primarily collections of texts but essays on how to lead liturgy and teach the Faith. This is not to say that many Lutheran parishes have not used common services, but it is to say that for them common prayer does not mean a common text but a common (and minimal) structure for Word and Sacrament.
Now that the ECUSA and the ELCA [Evangelical Lutheran Church of America] have joined together in a practical union from January 1, 2001, Lutherans such as Dr Lathrop rejoice because the ECUSA has moved to the position in terms of common prayer where the ELCA can truly be glad. In effect the ECUSA has come to the position adopted by the Lutheran leaders in the 16th century concerning Rites and Ceremonies (but not, emphatically, we may add, with regard to doctrine & justification by faith in particular). What matters for leaders of Episcopalians and Lutherans now is NOT a common text but a common structure for liturgy.
Thus it seems that there is room in the uniting Episcopal-Lutheran body for all types of Lutherans and Episcopalians to be united in a common worship because they have reduced common prayer to a common structure, wherein they can insert material of choice. So one parish will seek to be orthodox in doctrine and morality while another will knowingly be neo-pagan. This will be possible because on the one side the Augsburg Confession and on the other the Anglican Formularies will be merely "historical documents." And the Bible will be seen not as authoritative in all matters of faith and morality; but as a collection of books describing the experiences of God by people in ancient times; therefore the Bible is authoritative only in that it is first in order, rather than first because foundational.
Some of us prefer the older Anglican Way of using classical, fixed texts for Liturgy and finding in these texts the richness of doctrine and devotion that the saints over the centuries have poured into them and found through them.
The centrality of structure for modern liturgists is seen in the new Common Worship of the C of E where before each service/rite, its structure is carefully set out on a page of its own! Happily the classic BCP of 1662 does not follow this method!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Wednesday, December 11, 2002
Traditional Language, inside and outside, the classic editions of the BCP.
How should we view the relation of traditional language services in modern prayer books to the services in the classic Book of Common Prayer (USA 1662 & USA 1928 & Canada 1960)?
If we look inside most of the new prayer books (e.g., 1979 ECUSA, 2000 C of E, 1985 Canada) we find that there are both "contemporary language" and "traditional language" rites!
Thus the question arises: Is using one or another of these "traditional language" rites any different from using the similar or related service in the classic BCP?
A. Let us first consider the Rite I for Holy Communion in the 1979 ECUSA prayer book.
Thus while users of Rite I may have the best of intentions of having a Service that is really and truly the classic Anglican service this is impossible, strictly speaking.
Happily the opening Acclamation with its questionable grammar & content is optional in Rite 1 (not in Rite II) but the structure of the whole Rite is not and neither is the association of questionable ideas/doctrines.
If the desire is only for "traditional language" (and not full traditional style and content) then one can only have 95 percent of this (the 5% from the Psalter is modern). Yet traditional language in and of itself is no guarantee of doctrinal orthodoxy. Using Rite I, one has to be especially aware of possible pitfalls through association of ideas in order to remain doctrinally sound!
B. Let us now consider the new C of E prayer book, Common Worship. Here there is much greater supply of traditional language for there is provided (a) traditional language forms of modern Rites, and (b) the BCP service itself [with a few minor modifications] according to its own structure, not made to conform to the structure of the modern Rites as in the USA book.
Even so the Service of Holy Communion is not identical with that in the BCP because (a) the BCP Collects and Eucharistic Lectionary are missing to be replaced by those of the Common Worship scheme; and (b) the association of ideas and doctrines produced by a book of many options provides a strange context for the BCP Rite.
Therefore, those who want to keep the classic BCP in total use do so out of a strategy of thinking that this Prayer Book, with the Bible, is a unified whole. It represents the provision of a total means of public and private worship, daily prayer, celebrating of the Church Year, public and family spirituality & piety and provision for all the major events in life and of death and so on.
In other words, it is not just this or that service, this or that collect, this or that rubric, but the whole as an expression of the godly life for family and for parish that is cherished. Thus while a Rite I service from the 1979 book, and the BCP-type Rite from the 2000 book are not to be despised, yet they are not the same as the classic Service within the BCP. So the latter is to be preferred and should be kept available to Anglicans everywhere as part of the whole package that is the BCP.
The classic BCP in any of its major editions contains not merely traditional language but a certain style, doctrine and ethos within that traditional language of public worship & common prayer. It is the whole that is precious and it is the whole that must be preserved for posterity.
Rendering the services of the BCP into "contemporary language" if done faithfully can be a blessing to people entering the Anglican Way or Canterbury trail; but, it is difficult in a modern rendering to preserve the emphases contained within the much used and loved traditional language of prayer. Contemporary language is so unstable and is always open to reflecting the latest ideologies from popular culture.
The Prayer Book Societies of the Anglican Communion of Churches seek to keep in print and available the whole Book of Common Prayer, and they also seek to help people understand and use the same in public worship and at home. The American Society is ready to send its magazine to any who wish to receive it -- 1 800 PBS 1928 or on the website.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
If we look inside most of the new prayer books (e.g., 1979 ECUSA, 2000 C of E, 1985 Canada) we find that there are both "contemporary language" and "traditional language" rites!
Thus the question arises: Is using one or another of these "traditional language" rites any different from using the similar or related service in the classic BCP?
A. Let us first consider the Rite I for Holy Communion in the 1979 ECUSA prayer book.
1.The language used in Rite I of 1979 is much the same as that in the BCP (1928) but not identical.
2.The structure of the Service in Rite I is very definitely not the same as that in the BCP for Rite 1 is made to conform to the structure of Rite II, the "contemporary language" Rite.
3.The doctrinal content of Rite I is modified from that of the BCP through the change of structure, through a different Eucharistic Lectionary, through the presence of an alternative Prayer of Consecration, through innovations in the naming and addressing of God, the Holy Trinity, through the use of the required Collects, by the way that confession of sins is presented and understood, and by other significant verbal changes to significant Prayers.
4.The doctrinal content of Rite I is also affected because the Psalter to be used is the inclusive language Psalter of the 1979 prayer book. Thus the well beloved Psalter of the BCP cannot be used (unless one breaks the rubrics) and the Christological emphasis (Christ praying the Psalms in his Body) is lost.
5.The doctrinal content of Rite I is also affected because it is to be understand according to the doctrine in the Catechism in the 1979 prayer book and this doctrine at odds with the Catechism in the BCP.
Thus while users of Rite I may have the best of intentions of having a Service that is really and truly the classic Anglican service this is impossible, strictly speaking.
Happily the opening Acclamation with its questionable grammar & content is optional in Rite 1 (not in Rite II) but the structure of the whole Rite is not and neither is the association of questionable ideas/doctrines.
If the desire is only for "traditional language" (and not full traditional style and content) then one can only have 95 percent of this (the 5% from the Psalter is modern). Yet traditional language in and of itself is no guarantee of doctrinal orthodoxy. Using Rite I, one has to be especially aware of possible pitfalls through association of ideas in order to remain doctrinally sound!
B. Let us now consider the new C of E prayer book, Common Worship. Here there is much greater supply of traditional language for there is provided (a) traditional language forms of modern Rites, and (b) the BCP service itself [with a few minor modifications] according to its own structure, not made to conform to the structure of the modern Rites as in the USA book.
Even so the Service of Holy Communion is not identical with that in the BCP because (a) the BCP Collects and Eucharistic Lectionary are missing to be replaced by those of the Common Worship scheme; and (b) the association of ideas and doctrines produced by a book of many options provides a strange context for the BCP Rite.
Therefore, those who want to keep the classic BCP in total use do so out of a strategy of thinking that this Prayer Book, with the Bible, is a unified whole. It represents the provision of a total means of public and private worship, daily prayer, celebrating of the Church Year, public and family spirituality & piety and provision for all the major events in life and of death and so on.
In other words, it is not just this or that service, this or that collect, this or that rubric, but the whole as an expression of the godly life for family and for parish that is cherished. Thus while a Rite I service from the 1979 book, and the BCP-type Rite from the 2000 book are not to be despised, yet they are not the same as the classic Service within the BCP. So the latter is to be preferred and should be kept available to Anglicans everywhere as part of the whole package that is the BCP.
The classic BCP in any of its major editions contains not merely traditional language but a certain style, doctrine and ethos within that traditional language of public worship & common prayer. It is the whole that is precious and it is the whole that must be preserved for posterity.
Rendering the services of the BCP into "contemporary language" if done faithfully can be a blessing to people entering the Anglican Way or Canterbury trail; but, it is difficult in a modern rendering to preserve the emphases contained within the much used and loved traditional language of prayer. Contemporary language is so unstable and is always open to reflecting the latest ideologies from popular culture.
The Prayer Book Societies of the Anglican Communion of Churches seek to keep in print and available the whole Book of Common Prayer, and they also seek to help people understand and use the same in public worship and at home. The American Society is ready to send its magazine to any who wish to receive it -- 1 800 PBS 1928 or on the website.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Tuesday, December 10, 2002
“ECUSA may be apostate but its Liturgy is OK.”
In the last 10 years of my 12 years of residence in the USA (1992 –2002) it always seemed odd – sometimes amazing -- to me that, amongst those members of ECUSA who bemoaned her downward spiral into apostasy, very few (Anglo-Catholic or Evangelical) entertained the possibility that her public, official Liturgy was a cause of, or a part of, or an expression of, that apostasy.
At the Atlanta Congress of Dec 4-7 2002 I met the same attitudes all over again! Thus I am more sad and more amazed in late 2002 than I was in early 2002!
If a Church is in doctrinal, moral and numerical decline, the probability is that anything she produces will be affected by that decline, especially if she produces a whole new prayer book and rejects her former formularies (BCP, Ordinal & Articles of Religion) in so doing.
It is hard for me to forget (a) the oft-repeated mid-Western anglo-catholic claim that the 1979 prayer book of the ECUSA is the “most catholic” [read “best”] edition of the prayer book since the short-lived first edition in 1549 of “The Book of the Common Prayer”, and (b) the persistent Evangelical claim that with the Rite II services they had a relevant means of evangelism & worship.
(a) A common anglo-catholic view has been that the first edition of the BCP was “catholic” but that it was heavily protestantised by Archbishop Cranmer to make what became the 2nd edition of 1552, which (with few changes) became the classic edition of 1662. The American Liturgical Commission (though filled primarily with modern liberally inclined liturgists) of the 1960s and 1970s had helped, it was said, to recover the truly catholic elements of the western tradition in their 1979 book of alternative services (called the 1979 BCP by the General Convention). They pointed to the new “Shape” of the Eucharist and to the inclusion of “the Peace” and the placing of the Gloria at the beginning; they also pointed to the availability of a rite for auricular confession and to the Holy Week and Easter Eve services.
What they did not often mention was that in general terms all these “catholic” provisions came in a reduced or revised form and did not have their full patristic or catholic flavour (as my learned friend Professor Caldwell often pointed out). Also they did not mention the novel expressions of the doctrine of the Triune God and of the Person of Christ found here and there in the Rite II material (see the Catechism for summaries of them) or the doctoring of the Psalter and some Canticles in order to make them serve a liberationist agenda ( e.g., “Happy are they” for “Blessed is the Man [Jesus]…” in Psalm 1) or the great changes in the Ordination Services, allowing women to be priests and bishops.
(b) At the other end of the scale the Evangelicals were all taken up with the themes of intelligibility, simplicity, accessibility, relevance and meaningfulness and so they saw in the Rite II material of the 1979 book in so-called modern English a means of making their services and outreach popular and attractive. So they paid little attention to the actual doctrinal content – i.e., they did not check it against the doctrinal content of the classic BCP & the Articles of Religion in terms of who is God, who is Jesus and what is salvation. Further, being persuaded by theories of dynamic equivalency they did not seriously consider whether the 1979 Psalter could be used for genuine Christian worship or whether the NIV and NRSV etc were suitable versions for reading in public worship.
So while Catholics were deeply upset by the feminist agenda & movement in the ECUSA with its ordination of women and the changing of God-language to please women, and while the Evangelicals were upset by the seeming setting aside of the authority of Scripture, it did not seem to occur to them that the 1979 prayer book with its additions in the 1980s, and the momentum of liturgy and doctrine it expressed, created & encouraged, actually was a vehicle for the promotion of what they disliked or hated. That is, while they used the 1979 rites in their own ways for their own churchmanship, the larger church constituency was using the rites, and those spawned after 1979 and approved by the General Convention, to promote the very agendas that the traditional catholics and evangelicals hated! And this did not seem to bother them or alert them to the true nature of the 1979 book as an encouragement on the way to apostasy.
Various reasons come to mind for the support of the 1979 book by those who claimed to be orthodox and biblical -- some knew nothing else but the 79 book and it gave them a certain measure of freedom in their own situations; others felt committed to the 79 book for it is the official Prayer Book of the Church in which they were ordained and in whose pension fund is vested their future livelihood; then the bishops had gone to great lengths to force this prayer book on to parishes; further it was the ECUSA which had (in many cases) allowed priests and laity a second marriage in church with a blessing and thus their very daily life and relations were dependent upon that Church, whose liturgy they were thus not quickly disposed to criticize.
What I have also noticed is how many persons (claiming to be biblical and orthodox) quickly come to the defence of the 1979 book and its innovations if someone, like my good friend Professor Caldwell or myself, dare to warn against what we see as its doctrinal innovations
Whatever be the fundamental reasons, it is an amazing phenomenon that those who are so critical of the ECUSA – of its bishops, its general convention’s legislation and so on -- should both use the 1979 book as though it were fully and truly orthodox, and further should call it by a name that is a huge lie (it is not a Book of Common Prayer at all but a book of varied services). It is also amazing to me that much of the AMiA seems to use this ECUSA book in their separation from the ECUSA without too much concern! But, on the other hand, the genuine Continuing Anglican Churches of America keep far from it and use only classic editions of the BCP or of the Missal; and the Reformed Episcopal Church uses the BCP 1662.
Had the ECUSA made the 1979 book (as the C of E made its 1980 book and the Anglican Church in Canada its 1985 book) to exist alongside but not to replace the classic edition of the BCP (1928 USA; 1662 England; 1960 Canada) and to be dependent upon the classic BCP for its doctrinal integrity & interpretation, then the story of the demise of the ECUSA would certainly have taken a different routing. Maybe there would not have been a demise at all! God only knows, and to him be praise and glory unto ages of ages.
----------------------------------------------
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
At the Atlanta Congress of Dec 4-7 2002 I met the same attitudes all over again! Thus I am more sad and more amazed in late 2002 than I was in early 2002!
If a Church is in doctrinal, moral and numerical decline, the probability is that anything she produces will be affected by that decline, especially if she produces a whole new prayer book and rejects her former formularies (BCP, Ordinal & Articles of Religion) in so doing.
It is hard for me to forget (a) the oft-repeated mid-Western anglo-catholic claim that the 1979 prayer book of the ECUSA is the “most catholic” [read “best”] edition of the prayer book since the short-lived first edition in 1549 of “The Book of the Common Prayer”, and (b) the persistent Evangelical claim that with the Rite II services they had a relevant means of evangelism & worship.
(a) A common anglo-catholic view has been that the first edition of the BCP was “catholic” but that it was heavily protestantised by Archbishop Cranmer to make what became the 2nd edition of 1552, which (with few changes) became the classic edition of 1662. The American Liturgical Commission (though filled primarily with modern liberally inclined liturgists) of the 1960s and 1970s had helped, it was said, to recover the truly catholic elements of the western tradition in their 1979 book of alternative services (called the 1979 BCP by the General Convention). They pointed to the new “Shape” of the Eucharist and to the inclusion of “the Peace” and the placing of the Gloria at the beginning; they also pointed to the availability of a rite for auricular confession and to the Holy Week and Easter Eve services.
What they did not often mention was that in general terms all these “catholic” provisions came in a reduced or revised form and did not have their full patristic or catholic flavour (as my learned friend Professor Caldwell often pointed out). Also they did not mention the novel expressions of the doctrine of the Triune God and of the Person of Christ found here and there in the Rite II material (see the Catechism for summaries of them) or the doctoring of the Psalter and some Canticles in order to make them serve a liberationist agenda ( e.g., “Happy are they” for “Blessed is the Man [Jesus]…” in Psalm 1) or the great changes in the Ordination Services, allowing women to be priests and bishops.
(b) At the other end of the scale the Evangelicals were all taken up with the themes of intelligibility, simplicity, accessibility, relevance and meaningfulness and so they saw in the Rite II material of the 1979 book in so-called modern English a means of making their services and outreach popular and attractive. So they paid little attention to the actual doctrinal content – i.e., they did not check it against the doctrinal content of the classic BCP & the Articles of Religion in terms of who is God, who is Jesus and what is salvation. Further, being persuaded by theories of dynamic equivalency they did not seriously consider whether the 1979 Psalter could be used for genuine Christian worship or whether the NIV and NRSV etc were suitable versions for reading in public worship.
So while Catholics were deeply upset by the feminist agenda & movement in the ECUSA with its ordination of women and the changing of God-language to please women, and while the Evangelicals were upset by the seeming setting aside of the authority of Scripture, it did not seem to occur to them that the 1979 prayer book with its additions in the 1980s, and the momentum of liturgy and doctrine it expressed, created & encouraged, actually was a vehicle for the promotion of what they disliked or hated. That is, while they used the 1979 rites in their own ways for their own churchmanship, the larger church constituency was using the rites, and those spawned after 1979 and approved by the General Convention, to promote the very agendas that the traditional catholics and evangelicals hated! And this did not seem to bother them or alert them to the true nature of the 1979 book as an encouragement on the way to apostasy.
Various reasons come to mind for the support of the 1979 book by those who claimed to be orthodox and biblical -- some knew nothing else but the 79 book and it gave them a certain measure of freedom in their own situations; others felt committed to the 79 book for it is the official Prayer Book of the Church in which they were ordained and in whose pension fund is vested their future livelihood; then the bishops had gone to great lengths to force this prayer book on to parishes; further it was the ECUSA which had (in many cases) allowed priests and laity a second marriage in church with a blessing and thus their very daily life and relations were dependent upon that Church, whose liturgy they were thus not quickly disposed to criticize.
What I have also noticed is how many persons (claiming to be biblical and orthodox) quickly come to the defence of the 1979 book and its innovations if someone, like my good friend Professor Caldwell or myself, dare to warn against what we see as its doctrinal innovations
Whatever be the fundamental reasons, it is an amazing phenomenon that those who are so critical of the ECUSA – of its bishops, its general convention’s legislation and so on -- should both use the 1979 book as though it were fully and truly orthodox, and further should call it by a name that is a huge lie (it is not a Book of Common Prayer at all but a book of varied services). It is also amazing to me that much of the AMiA seems to use this ECUSA book in their separation from the ECUSA without too much concern! But, on the other hand, the genuine Continuing Anglican Churches of America keep far from it and use only classic editions of the BCP or of the Missal; and the Reformed Episcopal Church uses the BCP 1662.
Had the ECUSA made the 1979 book (as the C of E made its 1980 book and the Anglican Church in Canada its 1985 book) to exist alongside but not to replace the classic edition of the BCP (1928 USA; 1662 England; 1960 Canada) and to be dependent upon the classic BCP for its doctrinal integrity & interpretation, then the story of the demise of the ECUSA would certainly have taken a different routing. Maybe there would not have been a demise at all! God only knows, and to him be praise and glory unto ages of ages.
----------------------------------------------
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Monday, December 09, 2002
On the Continuing Churches & the Atlanta Congress:
My friend David Kletzing wrote the other day:
In response, on my return to the UK, may I say that like David I have studied and tasted the phenomenon of the anglican witness outside the PECUSA and that in articles for the Prayer Book Society and the Anglican Communion Secretariat I have listed up to 40 such anglican jurisdictions, of which the largest are the PCK, the ACA & the ACC. There are around 100 bishops in these jurisdictions.
The bishops of the few jurisdictions outside of PECUSA represented at the Congress make up possibly 7 per cent of Anglicans outside the PECUSA. The leaders of the remaining 90 per cent or more see PECUSA as apostate, and for them to attend a congress which is slanted towards PECUSA charismatic evangelicals who in general see no errors/heresy in the 1979 prayer book and who favor the ordination of women from the PECUSA, is neither an obvious duty nor a priority. Only gracious and persistent charm would have engaged them to consider attending in any capacity!
Whilst the momentum of the REC and other groups is towards the conservative end of the PECUSA and acceptance therein (e.g. the diocese of Pittsburgh), the momentum of the other 90 per cent of non-ECUSA anglicans is the opposite direction, away from what they see as the apostasy of the ECUSA, although they tend to remain friendly especially with the bishop of Quincy and some members of FinF NA. Then the venue especially -- a cathedral of an apostate church - was hardly a selling point to them!
I myself was very disappointed that there were not observers from the major Continuing Churches present. I think that it will now be nearly impossible to get them to join in this project especially since a Reformed Episcopal Bishop is the leader of the steering committee for the future and (for all kinds of historical and churchmanship and doctrinal reasons) the major Continuing Churches tend not to take this jurisdiction too seriously ( I merely repeat here what I have often been told).
It may be that as David says a little start has been made. But I am not optimistic about success on a scale that makes sense to observers & outsiders since the major Continuers were not fully engaged in the project from the word go. In fact had I been organizing it I would not have gone ahead with a Congress, without their promised presence at least as observers. (In fact I wish that all organzing this Congress had taken very seriously the writings of Lou Tarsitano on the topic of a national Congress.) One must get the momentum right from the word go and without the major Continuers and their 1977 St Louis Affirmation (which it seemed I was the only one publicly to mention) there can be no real beginning of the bringing together of Anglicans who desire to be orthodox in doctrine and faithful in practice.
No doubt many who were in Atlanta felt uplifted and blessed. I myself appreciated the fellowship and signs of grace but felt deeply sad because the euphoria concerning unity generated especially on the Saturday morning seemed to me to be built, as it were, like a house on sand.
It may be not too late for a major attempt to be made to engage the major Continuing Churches in preliminary discussion with a view to doing some practical things in common and thus growing in respect one for another. I hope that this will be done as a major priority.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Regarding David Virtue's post on the 16 bishops who signed the ecumenical statement. I must say it's wonderful to see these Godly leaders putting pen-and-ink where their mouths are. May God bless their efforts!
On the other hand, conspicuous by their absence are the many continuing Anglican bishops of various other jurisdictions throughout North America and the world. From the USA we had only four representations: ECUSA, AMIA, REC, and APA. The latter two already have a concord to unite within several years. Where are all the other continuing Anglican jurisdictions? Their absence speaks so loudly that one wonders about the real meaning of this declaration to the Anglican world at large.
On the other hand [we have three hands!], Seeing the absence of so many other jurisdictions helps those who signed to focus their efforts to incorporate those who for one reason or another didn't sign. So let's be optimistic.
In response, on my return to the UK, may I say that like David I have studied and tasted the phenomenon of the anglican witness outside the PECUSA and that in articles for the Prayer Book Society and the Anglican Communion Secretariat I have listed up to 40 such anglican jurisdictions, of which the largest are the PCK, the ACA & the ACC. There are around 100 bishops in these jurisdictions.
The bishops of the few jurisdictions outside of PECUSA represented at the Congress make up possibly 7 per cent of Anglicans outside the PECUSA. The leaders of the remaining 90 per cent or more see PECUSA as apostate, and for them to attend a congress which is slanted towards PECUSA charismatic evangelicals who in general see no errors/heresy in the 1979 prayer book and who favor the ordination of women from the PECUSA, is neither an obvious duty nor a priority. Only gracious and persistent charm would have engaged them to consider attending in any capacity!
Whilst the momentum of the REC and other groups is towards the conservative end of the PECUSA and acceptance therein (e.g. the diocese of Pittsburgh), the momentum of the other 90 per cent of non-ECUSA anglicans is the opposite direction, away from what they see as the apostasy of the ECUSA, although they tend to remain friendly especially with the bishop of Quincy and some members of FinF NA. Then the venue especially -- a cathedral of an apostate church - was hardly a selling point to them!
I myself was very disappointed that there were not observers from the major Continuing Churches present. I think that it will now be nearly impossible to get them to join in this project especially since a Reformed Episcopal Bishop is the leader of the steering committee for the future and (for all kinds of historical and churchmanship and doctrinal reasons) the major Continuing Churches tend not to take this jurisdiction too seriously ( I merely repeat here what I have often been told).
It may be that as David says a little start has been made. But I am not optimistic about success on a scale that makes sense to observers & outsiders since the major Continuers were not fully engaged in the project from the word go. In fact had I been organizing it I would not have gone ahead with a Congress, without their promised presence at least as observers. (In fact I wish that all organzing this Congress had taken very seriously the writings of Lou Tarsitano on the topic of a national Congress.) One must get the momentum right from the word go and without the major Continuers and their 1977 St Louis Affirmation (which it seemed I was the only one publicly to mention) there can be no real beginning of the bringing together of Anglicans who desire to be orthodox in doctrine and faithful in practice.
No doubt many who were in Atlanta felt uplifted and blessed. I myself appreciated the fellowship and signs of grace but felt deeply sad because the euphoria concerning unity generated especially on the Saturday morning seemed to me to be built, as it were, like a house on sand.
It may be not too late for a major attempt to be made to engage the major Continuing Churches in preliminary discussion with a view to doing some practical things in common and thus growing in respect one for another. I hope that this will be done as a major priority.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Monday, December 02, 2002
CD Offer
Good friends,
Best wishes for Advent, Christmas and Epiphany.
I write to tell you that this little parish has just completed making a CD. It is in an attractive presentation box and lasts for 70 mins in all with six tracks.
We began with creating a web site in 2002, then we added to it a sound facility, and now we have recorded some talks by me on themes from the Book of Common Prayer and in defence of its classical language of public prayer and made them into a CD. Believe me this is a great achievement for a working-class small semi-rural parish in Northern England!
I say "we" but the major work has been done by a lady, Barbara, who is disabled and all this is a triumph to her perseverance and skill. I have merely encouraged her.
We are charging only what it costs us to make it -- £2.50 plus post per copy or 2 for £5.00 post free.
However, for those in the USA we can send a copy by air mail if you send me a $10.00 bill. 2 copies for $15.00 by air.
For people in Canada, we will do the same for a $10.00 bill or $15.00 bills.
Checks are not much use to us for it costs more to negotiate them than they are worth.
Please encourage the good lady in her important ministry and listen [I hope!] to some authentic expositions of prayer-book religion.
My address is:
The Rectory, Hot Lane, Biddulph Moor,
Stoke on Trent ST8 7HP Great Britain.
Thank you for your patience
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Best wishes for Advent, Christmas and Epiphany.
I write to tell you that this little parish has just completed making a CD. It is in an attractive presentation box and lasts for 70 mins in all with six tracks.
We began with creating a web site in 2002, then we added to it a sound facility, and now we have recorded some talks by me on themes from the Book of Common Prayer and in defence of its classical language of public prayer and made them into a CD. Believe me this is a great achievement for a working-class small semi-rural parish in Northern England!
I say "we" but the major work has been done by a lady, Barbara, who is disabled and all this is a triumph to her perseverance and skill. I have merely encouraged her.
We are charging only what it costs us to make it -- £2.50 plus post per copy or 2 for £5.00 post free.
However, for those in the USA we can send a copy by air mail if you send me a $10.00 bill. 2 copies for $15.00 by air.
For people in Canada, we will do the same for a $10.00 bill or $15.00 bills.
Checks are not much use to us for it costs more to negotiate them than they are worth.
Please encourage the good lady in her important ministry and listen [I hope!] to some authentic expositions of prayer-book religion.
My address is:
The Rectory, Hot Lane, Biddulph Moor,
Stoke on Trent ST8 7HP Great Britain.
Thank you for your patience
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
MODALISM
Adelphoi,
One gentleman in our midst wrote:
"Peter Toon makes the very serious charge that,
Regrettably, when we move into the new type of Anglican prayer books - the books of alternative services (e.g. ECUSA 1979 prayer book) - we find that to these two meanings there is added at least one further meaning. This is the doctrine that GOD IS ONE PERSON who has three dominant Names/Modes/Aspects ("God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit") of expression. Anyone who knows the history of doctrine will known that this Modalism is heretical and it has been anathematized as such by the Church in days past! Yet happily, it seems, modern Episcopalians embrace it."
I am on my way to the Anglican Congress in Atlanta, but here is a quick response. I shall not be able to reply to any further correspondence for 6 or 7 days.
Please read what follows:
The Christian doctrine that there is one Godhead/Deity/Divine Nature yet Three Persons, A Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity, is difficult to grasp and easy to falsify. Therefore, the Church in the 4th & 5th centuries - and since - went to great troubles to find the best way to express the Unity of God together with the Trinity of Persons (see the Dogma of the Councils of Nicea, Constantinople and Chalcedon, St Augustine's De Trinitate, the Quincunque Vult).
The same careful statement of the doctrine of the blessed, holy and undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, is found in the classic Liturgies of Rome and Constantinople [here most beautifully expressed], in the Scholastic Divinity of the middle ages and in the Protestant Confessions of Faith & Liturgies of the 16th & 17th centuries.
Truth matters and thus we must aim for the most truthful propositions. There is no place for carelessness and simplification in the statement of the Church dogma of the Trinity in Unity and Unity in Trinity.
One heresy that the early Fathers faced and wrote against (and composed the Quicunque Vult to oppose) was Modalism, which came in various forms. In essence it emphasised that there is One and One only Deity, the Lord God, and that he has made himself known in Three modes of being, named in the NT and by the church as Father, Son and Holy Ghost. (In other words God is One Person, with one Nature but with three ways of expression to the world.)
In order not to allow in either Modalism or Tritheism (Arianism) the Church went to great pains to state precisely the orthodox dogma so as to exclude it.
Moving into the 20th century, we find that a form of Modalism is present in several of the much read liberal theologians in the 1950s & 1960s ---e.g. Tillich & Macquarrie, who sought to make the Faith acceptable to the post World II mindset. Episcopal Seminaries in the 1950s-1970s had everyone reading Tillich and Macquarrie in systematic theology.
So when the process of liturgical revision began in earnest in the ECUSA we find that for the 1967 Order for Holy Communion, there is a new acclamation or greeting at the beginning, never before found in Anglican Liturgy or Roman Litrugy, and that this acclamation stayed throughout all the revision and occurs multiple times in various services in the 1979 ECUSA prayer book of alternative services.
This acclamation (as far as I can tell) is nowhere found in public liturgy in English or any other European language before 1967. It is "Blessed be
God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit." Note that a COLON divides the sentence into two halves and Note that there are no definite articles. Note also that the English translation of the beginning of the Roman Mass has always been "In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost."
Obviously a dominant person on the Liturgical Commission wanted the new formula and got it and it remained through to 1979 ( I suggest Massey Shepherd). If you read the explanation for it in the commentaries on the 79 book, you find that it is supposed to be a shortened form of the Greeting in the Greek Liturgy. Now this great Blessing is always translated: "Blessed be the kingdom of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, now and always, even unto ages of ages!" In the Greek there is no colon and there is the very obvious presence of the definite article.
The high probability is that in the liberal elite of the ECUSA, where Tillich and Macquarrie had much influence, Modalism was incipient and thus in adopting the acclamation, "Blessed be God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit" no one really saw that this was an innovation in terms of stating the Name and Presence of the Triune Lord.
If we examine it grammatically what it is saying is that there is a God who has three Names or Modes of Being or Attributes. After God it is not a comma but a colon! And there is no definite article before "Father" etc. In its grammatical form, standing alone, it is not the orthodox dogma of the Blessed and Holy Trinity, but Modalism.
Maybe for those, who in using it, already possessed a sound understanding of the doctrine of the Holy Trinity in mind, this expression could be seen as a short-cut expression. But for those without any grounding in the classic dogma of Holy Mother Church, this expression gives them the mental picture of one Deity or God, who is one Person as it were, and who has three dominant Names or three only Names.
Now it is true that in other places of the 1979 book the right and proper doctrine of the Trinity is set forth (but not in its Catechism!). So at best the situation is confusing.
Happily there are some clergy in the ECUSA who say, "Blessed be God, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit" (changing the colon to a comma and adding the definite articles) in order to seek to make the acclamation sound like genuine orthodox doctrine - I confess that I am responsible for much of this revisionism! Some modern liturgists hate me for it, and this tells one quite a lot about how important it is to them in its original form and in its modern variations -- e.g. "God: creator, redeemer and sanctifier" and variations on this theme. There is now no attempt even to pretend that it is orthodoxy. And it never was orthodox.
In the present ECUSA those who minister and want to preserve orthodoxy ought to do all that they can to ensure that the basic doctrines of the Trinity and the Person of Christ be rightly stated in acclamation, prayer, blessing and sermon. If there is doubt then go for the well tried and the classic, not for the innovation!
I have written about this matter on numerous occasions - see e.g., my book on the 7 ecumenical councils, "Yesterday, Today & Forever, Jesus Christ and the Holy Trinity in the teaching of the 7 Councils", (Appendix 2). Also in my book on the Holy Trinity, recently republished by Regent College Vancouver BC; "Our Triune God".
May we be both orthodox in doctrine in holy in living.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
One gentleman in our midst wrote:
"Peter Toon makes the very serious charge that,
Regrettably, when we move into the new type of Anglican prayer books - the books of alternative services (e.g. ECUSA 1979 prayer book) - we find that to these two meanings there is added at least one further meaning. This is the doctrine that GOD IS ONE PERSON who has three dominant Names/Modes/Aspects ("God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit") of expression. Anyone who knows the history of doctrine will known that this Modalism is heretical and it has been anathematized as such by the Church in days past! Yet happily, it seems, modern Episcopalians embrace it."
I am on my way to the Anglican Congress in Atlanta, but here is a quick response. I shall not be able to reply to any further correspondence for 6 or 7 days.
Please read what follows:
The Christian doctrine that there is one Godhead/Deity/Divine Nature yet Three Persons, A Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity, is difficult to grasp and easy to falsify. Therefore, the Church in the 4th & 5th centuries - and since - went to great troubles to find the best way to express the Unity of God together with the Trinity of Persons (see the Dogma of the Councils of Nicea, Constantinople and Chalcedon, St Augustine's De Trinitate, the Quincunque Vult).
The same careful statement of the doctrine of the blessed, holy and undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, is found in the classic Liturgies of Rome and Constantinople [here most beautifully expressed], in the Scholastic Divinity of the middle ages and in the Protestant Confessions of Faith & Liturgies of the 16th & 17th centuries.
Truth matters and thus we must aim for the most truthful propositions. There is no place for carelessness and simplification in the statement of the Church dogma of the Trinity in Unity and Unity in Trinity.
One heresy that the early Fathers faced and wrote against (and composed the Quicunque Vult to oppose) was Modalism, which came in various forms. In essence it emphasised that there is One and One only Deity, the Lord God, and that he has made himself known in Three modes of being, named in the NT and by the church as Father, Son and Holy Ghost. (In other words God is One Person, with one Nature but with three ways of expression to the world.)
In order not to allow in either Modalism or Tritheism (Arianism) the Church went to great pains to state precisely the orthodox dogma so as to exclude it.
Moving into the 20th century, we find that a form of Modalism is present in several of the much read liberal theologians in the 1950s & 1960s ---e.g. Tillich & Macquarrie, who sought to make the Faith acceptable to the post World II mindset. Episcopal Seminaries in the 1950s-1970s had everyone reading Tillich and Macquarrie in systematic theology.
So when the process of liturgical revision began in earnest in the ECUSA we find that for the 1967 Order for Holy Communion, there is a new acclamation or greeting at the beginning, never before found in Anglican Liturgy or Roman Litrugy, and that this acclamation stayed throughout all the revision and occurs multiple times in various services in the 1979 ECUSA prayer book of alternative services.
This acclamation (as far as I can tell) is nowhere found in public liturgy in English or any other European language before 1967. It is "Blessed be
God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit." Note that a COLON divides the sentence into two halves and Note that there are no definite articles. Note also that the English translation of the beginning of the Roman Mass has always been "In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost."
Obviously a dominant person on the Liturgical Commission wanted the new formula and got it and it remained through to 1979 ( I suggest Massey Shepherd). If you read the explanation for it in the commentaries on the 79 book, you find that it is supposed to be a shortened form of the Greeting in the Greek Liturgy. Now this great Blessing is always translated: "Blessed be the kingdom of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, now and always, even unto ages of ages!" In the Greek there is no colon and there is the very obvious presence of the definite article.
The high probability is that in the liberal elite of the ECUSA, where Tillich and Macquarrie had much influence, Modalism was incipient and thus in adopting the acclamation, "Blessed be God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit" no one really saw that this was an innovation in terms of stating the Name and Presence of the Triune Lord.
If we examine it grammatically what it is saying is that there is a God who has three Names or Modes of Being or Attributes. After God it is not a comma but a colon! And there is no definite article before "Father" etc. In its grammatical form, standing alone, it is not the orthodox dogma of the Blessed and Holy Trinity, but Modalism.
Maybe for those, who in using it, already possessed a sound understanding of the doctrine of the Holy Trinity in mind, this expression could be seen as a short-cut expression. But for those without any grounding in the classic dogma of Holy Mother Church, this expression gives them the mental picture of one Deity or God, who is one Person as it were, and who has three dominant Names or three only Names.
Now it is true that in other places of the 1979 book the right and proper doctrine of the Trinity is set forth (but not in its Catechism!). So at best the situation is confusing.
Happily there are some clergy in the ECUSA who say, "Blessed be God, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit" (changing the colon to a comma and adding the definite articles) in order to seek to make the acclamation sound like genuine orthodox doctrine - I confess that I am responsible for much of this revisionism! Some modern liturgists hate me for it, and this tells one quite a lot about how important it is to them in its original form and in its modern variations -- e.g. "God: creator, redeemer and sanctifier" and variations on this theme. There is now no attempt even to pretend that it is orthodoxy. And it never was orthodox.
In the present ECUSA those who minister and want to preserve orthodoxy ought to do all that they can to ensure that the basic doctrines of the Trinity and the Person of Christ be rightly stated in acclamation, prayer, blessing and sermon. If there is doubt then go for the well tried and the classic, not for the innovation!
I have written about this matter on numerous occasions - see e.g., my book on the 7 ecumenical councils, "Yesterday, Today & Forever, Jesus Christ and the Holy Trinity in the teaching of the 7 Councils", (Appendix 2). Also in my book on the Holy Trinity, recently republished by Regent College Vancouver BC; "Our Triune God".
May we be both orthodox in doctrine in holy in living.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Sunday, December 01, 2002
THE ONE GOD AND THE GOD WHO IS THE FATHER
(a meditation in Advent in preparation for Christmas)
For many centuries, the Church of God in her liturgy and her theology has used the expression "one God" to bear two distinct meanings, both of them with roots in the Bible.
There would be no Christmas without the initiative of the one God who is the Father and without the presence of "Emmanuel", God with us.
1. The FIRST meaning is found in the Nicene Creed and also in prayers as the One to whom prayers are addressed. We say: "I believe in one God, the Father almighty." This One God who is the Father has an unique and eternal relation to "the Son" who is the only-begotten Son of the Father. Prayer is offered to the Father (who is often just called "God") through the Son and with the Holy Ghost.
This usage takes up the meaning of the One God in the New Testament where He is named by the Lord Jesus Christ as "the Father' and "his Father."
Thus the Christian Confession is to believe in God the Father, together with His only-begotten Son and together with His Holy Spirit. This God, who is the Father, is worshipped in, through and with the only-begotten Son and by and with the Holy Ghost.
This FIRST meaning has never left the Church and is most clearly present in the Eucharistic Prayers of East and West (addressed to the Father through the Son and with the Holy Spirit) and in most Collects for the Christian Year.
At Christmas we think of God [= the Father] sending his only and eternal Son to take our nature & flesh in the womb of the Virgin and to be born as Jesus, her Son. "God so loved the world that He have his only begotten Son."
2. The SECOND meaning became more prominent in the Church after the debates and controversies surrounding Arianism and is found in the famous statement "Three Persons, one God" or "one divine nature/substance and Three Persons." Here "God" ceases to be the personal Name and the equivalent of "the Father" who is the First Person of the Holy Trinity and becomes the word for the ONE "Divinity" or "Deity" or "Divine Nature/Substance", the very Godhead possessed entirely and wholly by each of the Three Persons. Thus the formulation: One in Three and Three in One, A Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity.
Here the Persons of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are seen as different from each other because of their differing relations to each other; but they are wholly equal to each other in that each one possesses in full and undivided the one and the same, the identical Godhead/Deity/Substance/Divine Nature. The Divine Nature is not divided into Three but is possessed wholly and totally by each of the Three Persons, and thus there is One God or Godhead only.
A wonderful statement of this SECOND meaning, and based on the teaching of St Augustine of Hippo, is found in the Creed called The Quicunque Vult (= the Athanasian Creed).
At Christmas when we look to Jesus as Emmanuel, meaning, "God with us", it is possible that we are thinking that eternal Deity & Divinity & Godhead are revealed in this babe, whom later the Church will call the Second Person of the Holy Trinity.
In this tradition of understanding the noun "God", then THE TRINITY, or THE HOLY TRINITY becomes a proper Name for Deity. Thus Churches and Colleges and Hospitals are consecrated in the Name of THE TRINITY and prayers are addressed to this TRIUNE GOD.
"O holy, blessed and glorious Trinity, three Persons and One God: have mercy upon us miserable sinners" (Litany).
If you turn to the Proper Prefaces for Trinity Sunday in the Order for Holy Communion in the 1928 BCP of the Protestant Episcopal Church USA, you find that both these meanings are present.
In the traditional Anglican Preface (p.79) we have both meanings run together:
"Who [the Father], with thine only-begotten Son, and the Holy Ghost, art one GOD [Godhead], one Lord in Trinity of Persons and in Unity of Substance. For that which we believe of thy glory, O Father, the same we believe of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, without any difference of inequality."
Then if you look at the Collect for Trinity Sunday you see that the Second meaning is prominent:
"Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the Divine Majesty to worship the Unity, we beseech thee that thou wouldest keep us steadfast in this faith..who livest and reignest, one God, world without end."
Only on Trinity Sunday does the Church in her Collect address the Holy Trinity as the One God.
Postscript
Regrettably, when we move into the new type of Anglican prayer books - the books of alternative services (e.g. ECUSA 1979 prayer book) - we find that to these two meanings there is added at least one further meaning. This is the doctrine that GOD IS ONE PERSON who has three dominant Names/Modes/Aspects ("God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit") of expression. Anyone who knows the history of doctrine will known that this Modalism is heretical and it has been anathematized as such by the Church in days past! Yet happily, it seems, modern Episcopalians embrace it.
Let us worship the Father, through His Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, and with His Holy Spirit, our Advocate & Comforter. Amen. AND, therefore, "Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost, Three Persons and One God."
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
For many centuries, the Church of God in her liturgy and her theology has used the expression "one God" to bear two distinct meanings, both of them with roots in the Bible.
There would be no Christmas without the initiative of the one God who is the Father and without the presence of "Emmanuel", God with us.
1. The FIRST meaning is found in the Nicene Creed and also in prayers as the One to whom prayers are addressed. We say: "I believe in one God, the Father almighty." This One God who is the Father has an unique and eternal relation to "the Son" who is the only-begotten Son of the Father. Prayer is offered to the Father (who is often just called "God") through the Son and with the Holy Ghost.
This usage takes up the meaning of the One God in the New Testament where He is named by the Lord Jesus Christ as "the Father' and "his Father."
Thus the Christian Confession is to believe in God the Father, together with His only-begotten Son and together with His Holy Spirit. This God, who is the Father, is worshipped in, through and with the only-begotten Son and by and with the Holy Ghost.
This FIRST meaning has never left the Church and is most clearly present in the Eucharistic Prayers of East and West (addressed to the Father through the Son and with the Holy Spirit) and in most Collects for the Christian Year.
At Christmas we think of God [= the Father] sending his only and eternal Son to take our nature & flesh in the womb of the Virgin and to be born as Jesus, her Son. "God so loved the world that He have his only begotten Son."
2. The SECOND meaning became more prominent in the Church after the debates and controversies surrounding Arianism and is found in the famous statement "Three Persons, one God" or "one divine nature/substance and Three Persons." Here "God" ceases to be the personal Name and the equivalent of "the Father" who is the First Person of the Holy Trinity and becomes the word for the ONE "Divinity" or "Deity" or "Divine Nature/Substance", the very Godhead possessed entirely and wholly by each of the Three Persons. Thus the formulation: One in Three and Three in One, A Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity.
Here the Persons of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are seen as different from each other because of their differing relations to each other; but they are wholly equal to each other in that each one possesses in full and undivided the one and the same, the identical Godhead/Deity/Substance/Divine Nature. The Divine Nature is not divided into Three but is possessed wholly and totally by each of the Three Persons, and thus there is One God or Godhead only.
A wonderful statement of this SECOND meaning, and based on the teaching of St Augustine of Hippo, is found in the Creed called The Quicunque Vult (= the Athanasian Creed).
At Christmas when we look to Jesus as Emmanuel, meaning, "God with us", it is possible that we are thinking that eternal Deity & Divinity & Godhead are revealed in this babe, whom later the Church will call the Second Person of the Holy Trinity.
In this tradition of understanding the noun "God", then THE TRINITY, or THE HOLY TRINITY becomes a proper Name for Deity. Thus Churches and Colleges and Hospitals are consecrated in the Name of THE TRINITY and prayers are addressed to this TRIUNE GOD.
"O holy, blessed and glorious Trinity, three Persons and One God: have mercy upon us miserable sinners" (Litany).
If you turn to the Proper Prefaces for Trinity Sunday in the Order for Holy Communion in the 1928 BCP of the Protestant Episcopal Church USA, you find that both these meanings are present.
In the traditional Anglican Preface (p.79) we have both meanings run together:
"Who [the Father], with thine only-begotten Son, and the Holy Ghost, art one GOD [Godhead], one Lord in Trinity of Persons and in Unity of Substance. For that which we believe of thy glory, O Father, the same we believe of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, without any difference of inequality."
Then if you look at the Collect for Trinity Sunday you see that the Second meaning is prominent:
"Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the Divine Majesty to worship the Unity, we beseech thee that thou wouldest keep us steadfast in this faith..who livest and reignest, one God, world without end."
Only on Trinity Sunday does the Church in her Collect address the Holy Trinity as the One God.
Postscript
Regrettably, when we move into the new type of Anglican prayer books - the books of alternative services (e.g. ECUSA 1979 prayer book) - we find that to these two meanings there is added at least one further meaning. This is the doctrine that GOD IS ONE PERSON who has three dominant Names/Modes/Aspects ("God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit") of expression. Anyone who knows the history of doctrine will known that this Modalism is heretical and it has been anathematized as such by the Church in days past! Yet happily, it seems, modern Episcopalians embrace it.
Let us worship the Father, through His Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, and with His Holy Spirit, our Advocate & Comforter. Amen. AND, therefore, "Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost, Three Persons and One God."
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Saturday, November 30, 2002
What has The Trinity to do with Christmas?
A Meditation for Advent
First of all, we note that neither the expression "The Trinity" nor the word "Christmas" is found in the biblical narratives concerning the birth of Jesus who was called the Christ. This is true both of the New Testament (Matthew 1, Luke 1, John 1) and of the passages in the Old Testament regarded as prophetic of this birth (e.g., Isaiah 8:14).
"Christmas" is a noun used in the Church to speak of the festival of the birth of Jesus, son of Mary and Son of God the Father, who is the Christ [Christ-Mass]; while "The Trinity" is the Name given by the Church to the One God, who by self-revelation has made it known that He exists eternally as Three Persons [the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost].
This said, The Trinity (as the Christian word for Deity) has much to do with that which is celebrated in the festival of Christmas. Let me explain.
In the Gospel accounts of the birth of Jesus and its meaning we certainly read of "God the Lord" [Jehovah/Yahweh], of the presence of "the Holy Ghost/Spirit" of and from this God [who is the God of Moses, David and the Prophets], and of Jesus who is called "Emmanuel" [God with us]. Further, "God the Lord" is also called "the Father" and Jesus is called "the Word made flesh" and "the Father's only [begotten] Son."
We may say that what we have in the New Testament are doctrines about God as the Father, about Jesus as his Son, about the Holy Ghost as the Spirit of the Father and the Spirit of the Son. In the narratives and the doctrines of the N.T. are examples of how each of the Three acts in human redemption in relation to the Others and in relation to mankind. So the Father loves the Son and the Son obeys the Father. The Holy Ghost causes the conception in Mary's womb which is also simultaneously the assumption by the eternal Son of human nature/flesh. And so on. Yet in the NT we have not reached any fixed or settled way of stating the unique equality and unity of the Three and of how they are a plurality in unity so that there is only one God.
From this teaching and evidence, and through her ongoing experience of God as One yet Three, the Church by the 4th century created what we call the dogma of the Holy Trinity [Nicene Creed]. This is first of all a statement about God as God is in and unto Himself - He is a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity: One God and three Persons. There are not three gods but there is One God (one Godhead, divine nature/substance) who eternally exists as three Persons [the Father & the Son & the Holy Ghost]. For Western Christians the fullness of this dogma is declared most succinctly and powerfully in the Creed we know as the Athanasian Creed [the Quincunque Vult].
Then from this dogma of The Trinity (known to theologians as the doctrine of "the immanent Trinity") the Church created what is called the doctrine of the Economic Trinity [God the Trinity acting in relation to the world and to the human race]. That is, with the insights from the dogma of the immanent Trinity, and using the biblical material, the Church spoke of the action of God in space/time and especially in the economy or action of salvation/redemption. This sophisticated talk of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost (the Economic Trinity) engaged in the creation and redemption of the world is found in sermons and liturgies from the Early Church and is the most basic level of the language in the classic liturgies of the Church through time. For example, it underlies all statements in the Anglican Book of Common Prayer (first edition 1549). In the historic Divine Liturgy of the Orthodox Churches we have marvelous presentations of both the Dogma of the [immanent] Holy Trinity (one Substance/three Persons) and of the doctrine of the Economic Trinity based upon that Dogma and interpreting the biblical doctrines and narratives for the purpose of doxology.
Thus what occurred in the original historical actions that we commemorate in the Festival of Christmas is, we may say, an Event of the Holy Trinity. The Father sends His Only Son, the Word, into space and time, and in that coming the Holy Ghost causes Him to assume human nature and flesh in the womb of the Virgin Mary and to be born from her. Though there are specific actions of each of the Three [the Father, Jesus the Son and the Holy Ghost], in and through all these actions is the action of the One Godhead, the One Deity. Thus we celebrate the action of a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity as the essential background to the very human story of a young woman giving birth to her first child, a son, and giving him a name, Jesus [the Lord our salvation]. By and through this son who is also the incarnate, enfleshed Son of God the Father, the Trinity has devised and will accomplish the salvation of the world.
To continue this meditation -- we see in all the great saving events of the life of Jesus the revelation of the Holy Trinity - e.g. in his baptism at the Jordan, in his Transfiguration on the Mountain, in his death on the Cross and in his Resurrection from the dead. The Incarnate Son is never alone for he is in Communion with the Father; and the Holy Ghost rests upon him and indwells his human nature. Further, at the deepest level He is the Second Person of the Holy Trinity and shares the one and identical divine nature with the Father and the Holy Ghost.
The LOVE that came down at Christmas is movement from the Love of the Father for the Son in the Holy Ghost, the inter-Trinitarian love, focused upon human sinners and their need in space and time.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
First of all, we note that neither the expression "The Trinity" nor the word "Christmas" is found in the biblical narratives concerning the birth of Jesus who was called the Christ. This is true both of the New Testament (Matthew 1, Luke 1, John 1) and of the passages in the Old Testament regarded as prophetic of this birth (e.g., Isaiah 8:14).
"Christmas" is a noun used in the Church to speak of the festival of the birth of Jesus, son of Mary and Son of God the Father, who is the Christ [Christ-Mass]; while "The Trinity" is the Name given by the Church to the One God, who by self-revelation has made it known that He exists eternally as Three Persons [the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost].
This said, The Trinity (as the Christian word for Deity) has much to do with that which is celebrated in the festival of Christmas. Let me explain.
In the Gospel accounts of the birth of Jesus and its meaning we certainly read of "God the Lord" [Jehovah/Yahweh], of the presence of "the Holy Ghost/Spirit" of and from this God [who is the God of Moses, David and the Prophets], and of Jesus who is called "Emmanuel" [God with us]. Further, "God the Lord" is also called "the Father" and Jesus is called "the Word made flesh" and "the Father's only [begotten] Son."
We may say that what we have in the New Testament are doctrines about God as the Father, about Jesus as his Son, about the Holy Ghost as the Spirit of the Father and the Spirit of the Son. In the narratives and the doctrines of the N.T. are examples of how each of the Three acts in human redemption in relation to the Others and in relation to mankind. So the Father loves the Son and the Son obeys the Father. The Holy Ghost causes the conception in Mary's womb which is also simultaneously the assumption by the eternal Son of human nature/flesh. And so on. Yet in the NT we have not reached any fixed or settled way of stating the unique equality and unity of the Three and of how they are a plurality in unity so that there is only one God.
From this teaching and evidence, and through her ongoing experience of God as One yet Three, the Church by the 4th century created what we call the dogma of the Holy Trinity [Nicene Creed]. This is first of all a statement about God as God is in and unto Himself - He is a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity: One God and three Persons. There are not three gods but there is One God (one Godhead, divine nature/substance) who eternally exists as three Persons [the Father & the Son & the Holy Ghost]. For Western Christians the fullness of this dogma is declared most succinctly and powerfully in the Creed we know as the Athanasian Creed [the Quincunque Vult].
Then from this dogma of The Trinity (known to theologians as the doctrine of "the immanent Trinity") the Church created what is called the doctrine of the Economic Trinity [God the Trinity acting in relation to the world and to the human race]. That is, with the insights from the dogma of the immanent Trinity, and using the biblical material, the Church spoke of the action of God in space/time and especially in the economy or action of salvation/redemption. This sophisticated talk of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost (the Economic Trinity) engaged in the creation and redemption of the world is found in sermons and liturgies from the Early Church and is the most basic level of the language in the classic liturgies of the Church through time. For example, it underlies all statements in the Anglican Book of Common Prayer (first edition 1549). In the historic Divine Liturgy of the Orthodox Churches we have marvelous presentations of both the Dogma of the [immanent] Holy Trinity (one Substance/three Persons) and of the doctrine of the Economic Trinity based upon that Dogma and interpreting the biblical doctrines and narratives for the purpose of doxology.
Thus what occurred in the original historical actions that we commemorate in the Festival of Christmas is, we may say, an Event of the Holy Trinity. The Father sends His Only Son, the Word, into space and time, and in that coming the Holy Ghost causes Him to assume human nature and flesh in the womb of the Virgin Mary and to be born from her. Though there are specific actions of each of the Three [the Father, Jesus the Son and the Holy Ghost], in and through all these actions is the action of the One Godhead, the One Deity. Thus we celebrate the action of a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity as the essential background to the very human story of a young woman giving birth to her first child, a son, and giving him a name, Jesus [the Lord our salvation]. By and through this son who is also the incarnate, enfleshed Son of God the Father, the Trinity has devised and will accomplish the salvation of the world.
To continue this meditation -- we see in all the great saving events of the life of Jesus the revelation of the Holy Trinity - e.g. in his baptism at the Jordan, in his Transfiguration on the Mountain, in his death on the Cross and in his Resurrection from the dead. The Incarnate Son is never alone for he is in Communion with the Father; and the Holy Ghost rests upon him and indwells his human nature. Further, at the deepest level He is the Second Person of the Holy Trinity and shares the one and identical divine nature with the Father and the Holy Ghost.
The LOVE that came down at Christmas is movement from the Love of the Father for the Son in the Holy Ghost, the inter-Trinitarian love, focused upon human sinners and their need in space and time.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Friday, November 29, 2002
Archbishop Rowan Williams, Homosexuality & a Third Province
In a wide-ranging interview with the London Church Times (29th November), Dr Williams states that the Church of England should seriously consider creating a Third Province (to exist alongside those of Canterbury & York) for those parishes and priests opposed to women bishops. (It will be recalled that it was Dr Williams who pushed the Church in Wales to appoint an Episcopal Visitor for parishes in Wales which did not wish to receive bishops who ordained women.) At the moment there is a C of E Commission headed by the Bishop of Rochester looking into the ordaining of women to the Episcopate and these statements will probably have an influence on what is recommended to the Church.
Further, since Williams will have great influence in the General Synod when this is discussed this is good news for traditional anglo-catholics and evangelicals.
Williams also states that he will not ordain any person who is living in "a relationship" or partnership with a person of the same sex and that he will publicly abide by the resolution of the Lambeth Conference, 1998 on this matter. He had already made this clear in a Letter to all the Primates. Yet, at the same time, he would like the topic of sexuality still to be discussed.
In my judgment Williams' theology has been somewhat misunderstood and unfortunately attacked by some conservative evangelicals. There is no doubt but that he is a liberal Catholic theologian who has drunk deeply of Orthodox theology (he studied orthodox theology in Russia for his doctorate) and so he is deeply committed to the traditional and orthodox dogmas of the Person of Christ as the God-Man and of the Holy Trinity as Three Persons and one God. He has the great ability to take seriously all competent expressions of theology and is much more tolerant of traditional believers than most bishops I know. Further he is very gracious and kind person.
I repeat my call again to pray for him as he gets near to taking up his new Vocation in the See of Canterbury. Here is the Collect that I wrote several months ago, and I am grateful that some parishes in several provinces use it weekly.
"Almighty God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who in thy providence hast established the ancient See of Canterbury as the primary instrument of unity of the Anglican Communion of Churches, we pray for Rowan whom thou hast called to be the Archbishop of Canterbury: By the abundance of they mercy, grant that he, repenting of his sins and conforming to thy holy law and wisdom, will enter into this holy office in the fullness of the blessing of the Gospel of the same Lord Jesus Christ, thy Son, to whom with thee and the Holy Ghost be ascribed glory and dominion now and for ever. Amen."
Web site of the CT is www.churchtimes.co.uk
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Further, since Williams will have great influence in the General Synod when this is discussed this is good news for traditional anglo-catholics and evangelicals.
Williams also states that he will not ordain any person who is living in "a relationship" or partnership with a person of the same sex and that he will publicly abide by the resolution of the Lambeth Conference, 1998 on this matter. He had already made this clear in a Letter to all the Primates. Yet, at the same time, he would like the topic of sexuality still to be discussed.
In my judgment Williams' theology has been somewhat misunderstood and unfortunately attacked by some conservative evangelicals. There is no doubt but that he is a liberal Catholic theologian who has drunk deeply of Orthodox theology (he studied orthodox theology in Russia for his doctorate) and so he is deeply committed to the traditional and orthodox dogmas of the Person of Christ as the God-Man and of the Holy Trinity as Three Persons and one God. He has the great ability to take seriously all competent expressions of theology and is much more tolerant of traditional believers than most bishops I know. Further he is very gracious and kind person.
I repeat my call again to pray for him as he gets near to taking up his new Vocation in the See of Canterbury. Here is the Collect that I wrote several months ago, and I am grateful that some parishes in several provinces use it weekly.
"Almighty God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who in thy providence hast established the ancient See of Canterbury as the primary instrument of unity of the Anglican Communion of Churches, we pray for Rowan whom thou hast called to be the Archbishop of Canterbury: By the abundance of they mercy, grant that he, repenting of his sins and conforming to thy holy law and wisdom, will enter into this holy office in the fullness of the blessing of the Gospel of the same Lord Jesus Christ, thy Son, to whom with thee and the Holy Ghost be ascribed glory and dominion now and for ever. Amen."
Web site of the CT is www.churchtimes.co.uk
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)