There is an increasing realization and call from a growing number of sources (e.g. the Prayer Book Society of the USA, the Moderator of the ACN, the AAC, the AMiA, the Common Cause Partners of the ACN) to make the BCP 1662 the standard of doctrine and liturgy for the whole of the North American (Orthodox) Anglican Family (Families). This makes sense since the BCP 1662 is the primary Formulary of most of the Provinces of the Anglican Communion, and it exists in 150 different languages through translation. And it was the first edition of the BCP used in America. Further, it is the basis of the 1962 Canadian edition of the BCP and of the (regrettably rejected by ECUSA) American 1789-1928 edition of the BCP.
At the same time there is a rapidly growing desire to make the basic services of the same BCP 1662 available in a form of “contemporary” or “modern” English which is accessible to generations of people who have lost the art of praying in the classic form of English Prayer.
Therefore the AMiA decided to make such a contemporary form available for trial use. I assisted on behalf of the Prayer Book Society and there is now a book (“The Green Book”) wherein are the Daily Offices, Holy Communion, Baptism, Confirmation, Burial and Marriage. The Bible used is either the RSV or the ESV. While the BCP of 1662 has been followed, some use has been made of the Canadian BCP of 1962 to allow an extended Consecration Prayer This set of services is not for general use but for testing. I am conscious that it can be improved in various ways. I have it in PDF and serious minded people may take a look at it and make comment to help in the improvement of it for the future.
Perhaps out of this experimental use will come –as the AMIA Primate and Bishops hope—a prayer book that is wholly 1662 in doctrine but in an acceptable form of current English. There needs to be some basic standardization of liturgy in North America, for too many options are in play and it is very confusing both for people inside and wanting to enter from outside.
But alongside the AMiA project there is no reason why there should not be similar projects in operation and that when the current crisis of Anglicanism ceases down the road, out of these similar versions a uniform version will be agreed to become the 1662 BCP in current American English—with few options and alternatives within it—for the new unified Province. So I hope that the Prayer Book Societies of the world—especially those in Canada and the USA-- will both initiate and be asked to engage in such work, both to preserve the 1662 in its original form as formulary and to make available suitable equivalents of it for trial use today. The Anglican Way has strayed from the narrow highway and gone off into all kinds of side-roads and its needs some liturgical security to help it get back on track!
The temptation in this work of editing and modernizing is to say “I prefer this” and “I like that” and if this approach is followed then there are so many options (from a continent where having an opinion is regarded as a sacred privilege) that the idea of a fixed and authoritative text is lost. What is needed is a text that has the same doctrine and ethos and style as the 1662 itself but is in a language form that is accessible to modern folks. To achieve this is a high calling and great task and the more able and committed people involved the better.
The Anglican Way needs a basic Uniformity (if it is not to disintegrate wholly in the USA & Canada), but one which allows varieties of churchmanship and local color and style. Please think and pray about this idea and proposal
Please pray for me as people continually ask me for advice in this matter of both updating and standardizing the received Liturgy
Thank you.
The Rev’d Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Thursday, November 09, 2006
Wednesday, November 08, 2006
That BOOK on the Holy Table...And do please purchase The Altar Edition soon!
What since medieval times has been called “The Missal” is the Book used by the Priest to celebrate Mass. It contains not only the text to read or sing but also the rubrics or instructions to follow. Roman Catholics and Anglo-Catholics still speak of “The Missal” as “that Book on the Altar.”
In the reformed Church of England and in Anglican Churches around the world “that Book on the Holy Table” which has larger print, often printed in two colors and used by the Celebrant at Holy Communion (and in the Blessing of a Marriage) is referred to as “The Altar Edition” of the Prayer Book or “The Chancel Edition” of the Prayer Book. Thus it is not the whole of The Book of Common Prayer [BCP] but contains the Order for Holy Communion, the Collects, Epistles and Gospels for the Church Year and sometimes the Marriage Service (for part of this is taken from within the Chancel). One can find “Altar Books” whose content is taken from the BCP editions of 1662, 1962 (Canada) and 1928 (USA). One can also find “Altar Books” for the various forms of modern Anglican “Books of Alternative Services” used in various Churches of the Anglican Communion.
If one visits an Anglican church which is part of one of the small, traditional Continuing Anglican denominations in the USA (e.g., ACA, ACC, APCK and offshoots from them) for Sunday morning service, it may well be called “The Mass” and on the Holy Table/Altar will not be “The Altar Edition of the BCP 1928” but “The Anglican Missal.” And in the pews will be either the BCP 1928 or “the People’s Missal.” However, the content of the Mass will be determined by the Priest using the Missal on the altar, a complex book which contains not only the Communion Service with Collects, Epistles and Gospels from the BCP 1928 but also many additions and extras which are taken from the traditional (pre-Vatican II) Roman Rite and translated into English. The assumption is that the BCP Service is inadequate and incomplete when standing alone and needs to be supplemented in order to reach the standard of being a true Mass.
[It is worth noting that the use of such a Missal is rare in Britain for those who think that the Anglican Rite is imperfect and needs supplementing actually usually take the logical step of using the modern Roman Missal.]
Let us now reflect upon the symbolism which The BCP Altar Edition on the one hand, and The Anglican Missal on the other, can generate for the thoughtful and imaginative observer.
First of all, an observer may wonder why those who use the Missal remain Anglicans when they obviously feel the need to supplement the official Anglican text in so many ways at so many places.
In the second place, an observer may be so impressed by the complexity and richness of the Missal (where the Celebrant and assistants are “professional”) as to think the BCP to be pale in comparison. He may ask: why do not all Anglicans adopt all this?
Thirdly, an observer who is learned in the history of doctrines, may ask how it is that Anglicans use in the Missal a text which asserts doctrines and customs which are prohibited in the classic Anglican Formularies, especially in The Articles of Religion and by the Ordinal.
Fourthly, an observer, who is a Roman Catholic, may complain that he is missing so much in the modern short Catholic Mass and express a desire for his own Church to return to the Tridentine Rite.
Of course, one can think of other possible observations people would make.
What I now would like to suggest is this that the two following situations are very different.
1 Where the BCP only is on the altar and where some of the “extras” found in the Missal are used by the choir (from musical texts), the Celebrant (from memory) and congregation (from memory), the BCP remains the fundamental text, the formulary. Here ceremonial and extras are added to the BCP text at the local level and are seen as enriching for this particular congregation—yet what is done is regarded as optional and not binding on any other congregation.
2 Where the Missal alone is on the altar and where its whole content is regarded as authoritative and where it is used because the priest believes that it is the superior text and the better/best way. And, further, it is seen as the better/best way for all who would be real anglo-catholics! It is not just an option is the real and true way, for anything less may be mistaken for “Protestant.” In this mindset there is also usually an open rejection of the Thirty-Nine Articles as authoritative.
The second position knowingly and deliberately rejects the Reformed Catholic character of the Anglican Way as that is known through the Anglican Formularies and seeks to change the Anglican Way into an old-style “Catholic” way. The first position sits, as it were, at the edge of the comprehensiveness of the Anglican Way for it claims only local option for its extras and recognizes that the Formulary is the BCP. There is a world of difference between the two positions.
Of course, as many old-time Anglicans and Episcopalians knew, it is possible to use the BCP as it is and “enrich” it with appropriate ceremonial, based on what was in use in England in the 1540s. See the The Parson’s Handbook by Percy Dearmer.
A final word: THE PRAYER BOOK SOCIETY OF THE U.S.A. has available a first-class edition of the BCP 1928 for the Altar. It is printed in two colors and is bound in good leather. It is the edition originally produced by Oxford University Press and is made by the printers and binders used by that distinguished Press. It is on special offer from Thanksgiving until the end of December. Call 1-800-727-1928.
Peter Toon drpetertoon@yahoo.com
In the reformed Church of England and in Anglican Churches around the world “that Book on the Holy Table” which has larger print, often printed in two colors and used by the Celebrant at Holy Communion (and in the Blessing of a Marriage) is referred to as “The Altar Edition” of the Prayer Book or “The Chancel Edition” of the Prayer Book. Thus it is not the whole of The Book of Common Prayer [BCP] but contains the Order for Holy Communion, the Collects, Epistles and Gospels for the Church Year and sometimes the Marriage Service (for part of this is taken from within the Chancel). One can find “Altar Books” whose content is taken from the BCP editions of 1662, 1962 (Canada) and 1928 (USA). One can also find “Altar Books” for the various forms of modern Anglican “Books of Alternative Services” used in various Churches of the Anglican Communion.
If one visits an Anglican church which is part of one of the small, traditional Continuing Anglican denominations in the USA (e.g., ACA, ACC, APCK and offshoots from them) for Sunday morning service, it may well be called “The Mass” and on the Holy Table/Altar will not be “The Altar Edition of the BCP 1928” but “The Anglican Missal.” And in the pews will be either the BCP 1928 or “the People’s Missal.” However, the content of the Mass will be determined by the Priest using the Missal on the altar, a complex book which contains not only the Communion Service with Collects, Epistles and Gospels from the BCP 1928 but also many additions and extras which are taken from the traditional (pre-Vatican II) Roman Rite and translated into English. The assumption is that the BCP Service is inadequate and incomplete when standing alone and needs to be supplemented in order to reach the standard of being a true Mass.
[It is worth noting that the use of such a Missal is rare in Britain for those who think that the Anglican Rite is imperfect and needs supplementing actually usually take the logical step of using the modern Roman Missal.]
Let us now reflect upon the symbolism which The BCP Altar Edition on the one hand, and The Anglican Missal on the other, can generate for the thoughtful and imaginative observer.
First of all, an observer may wonder why those who use the Missal remain Anglicans when they obviously feel the need to supplement the official Anglican text in so many ways at so many places.
In the second place, an observer may be so impressed by the complexity and richness of the Missal (where the Celebrant and assistants are “professional”) as to think the BCP to be pale in comparison. He may ask: why do not all Anglicans adopt all this?
Thirdly, an observer who is learned in the history of doctrines, may ask how it is that Anglicans use in the Missal a text which asserts doctrines and customs which are prohibited in the classic Anglican Formularies, especially in The Articles of Religion and by the Ordinal.
Fourthly, an observer, who is a Roman Catholic, may complain that he is missing so much in the modern short Catholic Mass and express a desire for his own Church to return to the Tridentine Rite.
Of course, one can think of other possible observations people would make.
What I now would like to suggest is this that the two following situations are very different.
1 Where the BCP only is on the altar and where some of the “extras” found in the Missal are used by the choir (from musical texts), the Celebrant (from memory) and congregation (from memory), the BCP remains the fundamental text, the formulary. Here ceremonial and extras are added to the BCP text at the local level and are seen as enriching for this particular congregation—yet what is done is regarded as optional and not binding on any other congregation.
2 Where the Missal alone is on the altar and where its whole content is regarded as authoritative and where it is used because the priest believes that it is the superior text and the better/best way. And, further, it is seen as the better/best way for all who would be real anglo-catholics! It is not just an option is the real and true way, for anything less may be mistaken for “Protestant.” In this mindset there is also usually an open rejection of the Thirty-Nine Articles as authoritative.
The second position knowingly and deliberately rejects the Reformed Catholic character of the Anglican Way as that is known through the Anglican Formularies and seeks to change the Anglican Way into an old-style “Catholic” way. The first position sits, as it were, at the edge of the comprehensiveness of the Anglican Way for it claims only local option for its extras and recognizes that the Formulary is the BCP. There is a world of difference between the two positions.
Of course, as many old-time Anglicans and Episcopalians knew, it is possible to use the BCP as it is and “enrich” it with appropriate ceremonial, based on what was in use in England in the 1540s. See the The Parson’s Handbook by Percy Dearmer.
A final word: THE PRAYER BOOK SOCIETY OF THE U.S.A. has available a first-class edition of the BCP 1928 for the Altar. It is printed in two colors and is bound in good leather. It is the edition originally produced by Oxford University Press and is made by the printers and binders used by that distinguished Press. It is on special offer from Thanksgiving until the end of December. Call 1-800-727-1928.
Peter Toon drpetertoon@yahoo.com
Anglican—how I understand this description of 75 million baptized Christians
Peter Toon November 7
This is a short essay aimed at inspiring others to think through some of the issues I raise. It is not intended as theological warfare but as a statement both for discussion and improvement.
Though I believe that the Church of God is in a profound sense “invisible,” I also believe that this dimension is primarily God’s business for He is himself invisible, being pure Spirit, and we as enfleshed are very much seen and visible.
So I have to make sense of the fact that what claims to be the Church of God exists through space and time and does so in some places in a bewildering variety of forms, as a complex assortment of jurisdictions, denominations and groups. Of all these, the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Churches have the clearest claim to both antiquity and continuity through space and time. However, we have to remember that many of the other smaller jurisdictions, denominations and groups exist because many people from the sixteenth century through to the present have sincerely believed that these two ancient Churches have seriously departed from their “first love” and from their apostolic origins, faith and practice.
Anglican
The word “Anglican” when used of God’s Church comes from the Latin word anglicana in the name ecclesia anglicana , which is the Church of God in/of England. So “an Anglican Church” is either the Church of England itself or one of those Churches formed by it or from it since the sixteenth century. Thus we speak of “the Anglican Communion of Churches.” And “an Anglican” is a member of one of these Churches.
It was only from the middle of the sixteenth century that the ecclesia anglicana was declared by the monarch and government of England to be an autonomous National Church, not under the authority of any other Church or ecclesiastical rule. This situation was not wholly new for in the long history of the Church of England from the patristic period, there were long periods when this Church was not directly under the supervision of the Pope.
Thus to be a member of the Church of England (or one of its global offshoots and extensions) is to be a member of a Church which has existed through space and time and which may be traced back as a congregation of Christ’s flock to the period after the apostles. That is, it always was a jurisdiction and part of the Catholikos, and in the sixteenth century it adopted a distinctive form of Catholicism, without ceasing to be part of the one Catholikos. This Anglican Church has grown since then and is now a global Communion of Churches. It expressed itself and explained itself through its Formularies—the Book of Common Prayer, The Ordinal and The Articles of Religion.
Regrettably, where we are now in history in 2006, the fact of being an Anglican does not also mean that we are in full communion with the Roman Church and the Orthodox Churches; but, it does mean that we are in full communion with most if not all of those other National Churches (and their own global offshoots) which also came into separated existence in the sixteenth century—e.g. the Lutheran Churches of Europe and around the world.
For an Anglican, this real but imperfect relation to the whole, historical Catholic Church of God is most important as a place to stand and as a people of God to belong to. At the same time, what is also very important is the actual experiential relation to the Father through the Son in the worship of the local Body of Christ and in personal devotion and service. Through careful and devoted use of the Bible and other means, an Anglican alone and with others looks up to the Lord Jesus and through him to the Father in adoration; he looks backwards to the apostolic age and all the saints who have been graced by God through the centuries and provide holy examples; he looks around and sees the divided and confused state of the Church of God today and also he sees the mission and vocation of the Church in the world today; and, at the same time, he looks forward in hope for the glorious appearing of the Lord Jesus Christ to raise the dead and to judge the people and to bring the Church, which he bought with his precious blood ,to glorious perfection and unity.
Continuity of the Church through space and time is important for the Anglican mind and this is seen in terms of continuity in the Faith of Christ, in ecclesial institutions (provinces, dioceses etc) and in Ministry, particularly, of Pastors (Bishops). It is not one of these without the others but all together that is important for the claim of the Anglican Churches to be a jurisdiction within, and a part of, the Catholikos. That is, Anglicans can humbly recite the Nicene Creed with its declaration of belief in the one holy, catholic and apostolic Church, because they have been baptized in the Triune Name and they are members of a Church which claims to be a microcosm of the whole Church of God and for which continuity of faith, order and institutions through space and time point back to the primitive Church. This claim has been set forth from the beginning in the Anglican Formularies—Book of Common Prayer, Ordinal and Articles of Religion—which have been a kind of glue binding together the Family of Churches.
In 2006 the Family of Churches is facing an identity problem of what it means to be Anglican. And at the personal level individual members are asking the same question. Here are several examples of what is being said and asked in the USA:
What happens to the claim to be in the Catholikos when a member Church of the Anglican Family in synodical action rejects the received Faith and Order and Formularies and engages in innovations which most of the Family think are heretical and immoral? Are the members who wish to be orthodox to stay or to leave, and to where are they to go if they want to remain within the Catholikos?
The major claim of the Continuing [Anglo-Catholic] Anglican Churches—the small denominations which have deliberately left one or another of the Churches of the Anglican Family—to be in the Catholikos is by a strong claim that their bishops are in “apostolic succession” which means that they can trace their consecration through the laying on of hands back through space and time (not a few of them have charts in their offices showing this long line through the centuries). Being successors of the apostles, they hold, brings with it the claim that they can dispense “valid sacraments.” But is this claim to apostolic succession in some ways negated or mitigated by the fact that these groups are “schismatic”? Is there not within the Anglican claim to authenticity also the reality of a real living connection with the original Anglican Identity and Family, usually through the See of Canterbury (as the Affirmation of St Louis 1977 appears to recognize)?
And what about the action taken by evangelical and charismatic groups who leave an Episcopal diocese in the USA or an Anglican one in Canada, form themselves into a congregation and choose a bishop from overseas to be their Pastor? What kind of a church is it that they have formed by their schism and by their looking around for a suitable Guide? Is it part of the Catholikos?
Conclusion
Maybe it’s because I was born in England and ordained in the ecclesia anglicana in 1973 that I cling (perhaps weakly) to the claim that I am in the Catholikos of God the Father by reason of membership in that Church or in another formed from it—even if that Church is weak in its commitment to historical Christianity and traditional doctrine. Though I surely know that they are many people of deeper faith and devotion than I possess, and there are many clergy with greater commitment and energy than I have in the various Continuing Anglican denominations and in the various Extra-Mural Anglican entities, I myself still feel “more secure” and on “safer ground” within one of the Churches of the Anglican Communion. I say this because of my sense that to be Catholic there needs to be continuity through space and time. And I say this very conscious of the many problems and difficulties faced especially in the West by this imperfect and fractured Anglican Family and Communion of Churches in 2006. I think of the Lambeth Conference of July 2008 as the final opportunity in my lifetime on earth for it to be made clear how the Anglican Way is to be set right, to work with a conciliar polity, and how its members will be energized to begin to walk in harmony and in truth to evangelize the nations and to be fully engaged in God’s own mission.
[My long essay on ANGLICAN IDENTITY as a 64 page booklet will be published next week and will be available for purchase from November 16th at www.anglicanmarketplace.com and from 1-800-727-1928. It deals in some detail with the three major Reports—Eames, Virginia & Windsor—and other recent statements and events in search of an answer.]
This is a short essay aimed at inspiring others to think through some of the issues I raise. It is not intended as theological warfare but as a statement both for discussion and improvement.
Though I believe that the Church of God is in a profound sense “invisible,” I also believe that this dimension is primarily God’s business for He is himself invisible, being pure Spirit, and we as enfleshed are very much seen and visible.
So I have to make sense of the fact that what claims to be the Church of God exists through space and time and does so in some places in a bewildering variety of forms, as a complex assortment of jurisdictions, denominations and groups. Of all these, the Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Churches have the clearest claim to both antiquity and continuity through space and time. However, we have to remember that many of the other smaller jurisdictions, denominations and groups exist because many people from the sixteenth century through to the present have sincerely believed that these two ancient Churches have seriously departed from their “first love” and from their apostolic origins, faith and practice.
Anglican
The word “Anglican” when used of God’s Church comes from the Latin word anglicana in the name ecclesia anglicana , which is the Church of God in/of England. So “an Anglican Church” is either the Church of England itself or one of those Churches formed by it or from it since the sixteenth century. Thus we speak of “the Anglican Communion of Churches.” And “an Anglican” is a member of one of these Churches.
It was only from the middle of the sixteenth century that the ecclesia anglicana was declared by the monarch and government of England to be an autonomous National Church, not under the authority of any other Church or ecclesiastical rule. This situation was not wholly new for in the long history of the Church of England from the patristic period, there were long periods when this Church was not directly under the supervision of the Pope.
Thus to be a member of the Church of England (or one of its global offshoots and extensions) is to be a member of a Church which has existed through space and time and which may be traced back as a congregation of Christ’s flock to the period after the apostles. That is, it always was a jurisdiction and part of the Catholikos, and in the sixteenth century it adopted a distinctive form of Catholicism, without ceasing to be part of the one Catholikos. This Anglican Church has grown since then and is now a global Communion of Churches. It expressed itself and explained itself through its Formularies—the Book of Common Prayer, The Ordinal and The Articles of Religion.
Regrettably, where we are now in history in 2006, the fact of being an Anglican does not also mean that we are in full communion with the Roman Church and the Orthodox Churches; but, it does mean that we are in full communion with most if not all of those other National Churches (and their own global offshoots) which also came into separated existence in the sixteenth century—e.g. the Lutheran Churches of Europe and around the world.
For an Anglican, this real but imperfect relation to the whole, historical Catholic Church of God is most important as a place to stand and as a people of God to belong to. At the same time, what is also very important is the actual experiential relation to the Father through the Son in the worship of the local Body of Christ and in personal devotion and service. Through careful and devoted use of the Bible and other means, an Anglican alone and with others looks up to the Lord Jesus and through him to the Father in adoration; he looks backwards to the apostolic age and all the saints who have been graced by God through the centuries and provide holy examples; he looks around and sees the divided and confused state of the Church of God today and also he sees the mission and vocation of the Church in the world today; and, at the same time, he looks forward in hope for the glorious appearing of the Lord Jesus Christ to raise the dead and to judge the people and to bring the Church, which he bought with his precious blood ,to glorious perfection and unity.
Continuity of the Church through space and time is important for the Anglican mind and this is seen in terms of continuity in the Faith of Christ, in ecclesial institutions (provinces, dioceses etc) and in Ministry, particularly, of Pastors (Bishops). It is not one of these without the others but all together that is important for the claim of the Anglican Churches to be a jurisdiction within, and a part of, the Catholikos. That is, Anglicans can humbly recite the Nicene Creed with its declaration of belief in the one holy, catholic and apostolic Church, because they have been baptized in the Triune Name and they are members of a Church which claims to be a microcosm of the whole Church of God and for which continuity of faith, order and institutions through space and time point back to the primitive Church. This claim has been set forth from the beginning in the Anglican Formularies—Book of Common Prayer, Ordinal and Articles of Religion—which have been a kind of glue binding together the Family of Churches.
In 2006 the Family of Churches is facing an identity problem of what it means to be Anglican. And at the personal level individual members are asking the same question. Here are several examples of what is being said and asked in the USA:
What happens to the claim to be in the Catholikos when a member Church of the Anglican Family in synodical action rejects the received Faith and Order and Formularies and engages in innovations which most of the Family think are heretical and immoral? Are the members who wish to be orthodox to stay or to leave, and to where are they to go if they want to remain within the Catholikos?
The major claim of the Continuing [Anglo-Catholic] Anglican Churches—the small denominations which have deliberately left one or another of the Churches of the Anglican Family—to be in the Catholikos is by a strong claim that their bishops are in “apostolic succession” which means that they can trace their consecration through the laying on of hands back through space and time (not a few of them have charts in their offices showing this long line through the centuries). Being successors of the apostles, they hold, brings with it the claim that they can dispense “valid sacraments.” But is this claim to apostolic succession in some ways negated or mitigated by the fact that these groups are “schismatic”? Is there not within the Anglican claim to authenticity also the reality of a real living connection with the original Anglican Identity and Family, usually through the See of Canterbury (as the Affirmation of St Louis 1977 appears to recognize)?
And what about the action taken by evangelical and charismatic groups who leave an Episcopal diocese in the USA or an Anglican one in Canada, form themselves into a congregation and choose a bishop from overseas to be their Pastor? What kind of a church is it that they have formed by their schism and by their looking around for a suitable Guide? Is it part of the Catholikos?
Conclusion
Maybe it’s because I was born in England and ordained in the ecclesia anglicana in 1973 that I cling (perhaps weakly) to the claim that I am in the Catholikos of God the Father by reason of membership in that Church or in another formed from it—even if that Church is weak in its commitment to historical Christianity and traditional doctrine. Though I surely know that they are many people of deeper faith and devotion than I possess, and there are many clergy with greater commitment and energy than I have in the various Continuing Anglican denominations and in the various Extra-Mural Anglican entities, I myself still feel “more secure” and on “safer ground” within one of the Churches of the Anglican Communion. I say this because of my sense that to be Catholic there needs to be continuity through space and time. And I say this very conscious of the many problems and difficulties faced especially in the West by this imperfect and fractured Anglican Family and Communion of Churches in 2006. I think of the Lambeth Conference of July 2008 as the final opportunity in my lifetime on earth for it to be made clear how the Anglican Way is to be set right, to work with a conciliar polity, and how its members will be energized to begin to walk in harmony and in truth to evangelize the nations and to be fully engaged in God’s own mission.
[My long essay on ANGLICAN IDENTITY as a 64 page booklet will be published next week and will be available for purchase from November 16th at www.anglicanmarketplace.com and from 1-800-727-1928. It deals in some detail with the three major Reports—Eames, Virginia & Windsor—and other recent statements and events in search of an answer.]
Tuesday, November 07, 2006
BCP 1662 & 1928—the Burial of the Dead
Since there is no belief in purgatory, and since it is believed that the souls of baptized believers go to be with God and to wait in his presence for the resurrection of the dead and the glorious life of the age to come, the Order for the Burial of the Dead is both a proclamation of the Gospel and as such a pastoral means of grace and of comfort to the mourners.
First there is the procession into church led by the Minister as various scriptural verses are said or sung.
Secondly there is the singing of one or more Psalms (1662 has Psalm 39 and 90; 1928 has these and others to choose from).
Thirdly, there is the reading of the Lesson (1662 only has 1 Corinthians 15:20ff., while 1928 also offers Romans 8:14ff., or St John 14:1ff.)
[Here the 1928 allows for but does not require the singing of a hymn, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, another Prayer and the Blessing. There is no provision for a sermon.]
Then there is a procession from church to the grave where the Anthem (from the Sarum Compline Service or a medley of Scriptural verses) is said or sung while preparation is made for burial. When the body is in the grave, the Committal is said. The dead body is committed to the ground in sure and certain hope of the resurrection of the body at the last day when the soul and body will be reunited in a body of glory to be with Christ in the kingdom of heaven.
With the body in the grave the second Anthem (Revelation 14:13) is said or sung, and this is followed by the Kyrie (“Lord have mercy”), the Lord’s Prayer, and Prayers (of which the 1928 has a large selection). One of the 1928 prayers, which is optional (and based upon a Latin collect from a Sarum Requiem Mass) actually prays for the soul of the departed Christian in these words: “Accept our prayers on behalf of the soul of thy servant departed, and grant him an entrance into the land of light and joy, in the fellowship of thy saints…” Such prayer for the departed is found nowhere in the 1662 edition; however, it may be said to be present in minimal form in Prayer for “the whole state of Christ’s Church” in 1928. At the end the Minister prays for those who have died and says: “grant them continual growth in thy love and service.”
The Order for the Burial of the Dead is truly a proclamation of the Gospel and the Christian Hope and as such gives true comfort to those who mourn. It is not in any way whatsoever a memorial service, where the virtues of the deceased are celebrated, nor is it a requiem mass where the soul of the departed is prayed for. It is a celebration of the Christian Faith in which the baptized believer has died and which all present also hope to live and die in order to be with Christ for ever in glory. Thus it does not need a sermon for there is proclamation of the Gospel all round.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
First there is the procession into church led by the Minister as various scriptural verses are said or sung.
Secondly there is the singing of one or more Psalms (1662 has Psalm 39 and 90; 1928 has these and others to choose from).
Thirdly, there is the reading of the Lesson (1662 only has 1 Corinthians 15:20ff., while 1928 also offers Romans 8:14ff., or St John 14:1ff.)
[Here the 1928 allows for but does not require the singing of a hymn, the Creed, the Lord’s Prayer, another Prayer and the Blessing. There is no provision for a sermon.]
Then there is a procession from church to the grave where the Anthem (from the Sarum Compline Service or a medley of Scriptural verses) is said or sung while preparation is made for burial. When the body is in the grave, the Committal is said. The dead body is committed to the ground in sure and certain hope of the resurrection of the body at the last day when the soul and body will be reunited in a body of glory to be with Christ in the kingdom of heaven.
With the body in the grave the second Anthem (Revelation 14:13) is said or sung, and this is followed by the Kyrie (“Lord have mercy”), the Lord’s Prayer, and Prayers (of which the 1928 has a large selection). One of the 1928 prayers, which is optional (and based upon a Latin collect from a Sarum Requiem Mass) actually prays for the soul of the departed Christian in these words: “Accept our prayers on behalf of the soul of thy servant departed, and grant him an entrance into the land of light and joy, in the fellowship of thy saints…” Such prayer for the departed is found nowhere in the 1662 edition; however, it may be said to be present in minimal form in Prayer for “the whole state of Christ’s Church” in 1928. At the end the Minister prays for those who have died and says: “grant them continual growth in thy love and service.”
The Order for the Burial of the Dead is truly a proclamation of the Gospel and the Christian Hope and as such gives true comfort to those who mourn. It is not in any way whatsoever a memorial service, where the virtues of the deceased are celebrated, nor is it a requiem mass where the soul of the departed is prayed for. It is a celebration of the Christian Faith in which the baptized believer has died and which all present also hope to live and die in order to be with Christ for ever in glory. Thus it does not need a sermon for there is proclamation of the Gospel all round.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
Matrimony in the BCP 1662 & 1928 editions
Neither The Book of Common Prayer nor The Articles of Religion regard marriage as a sacrament (even if it is “commonly called a sacrament”), but rather as an ordinance of God the Creator, an ordinance which, when properly entered into by the two parties, the Church blesses, prays for and supports. That is, two persons covenant to marry each other and are the ministers of the nuptial bond. They do this, however, in the presence of God, the Judge, who knows the secrets of all our hearts. The Church supervises the marriage ceremony and witnesses to the covenant made between them. Then through its Minister the Church bestows a blessing of God the Holy Trinity upon the couple with appropriate prayers for their well-being.
The rites in the 1662 and 1928 editions have the same basic structure and content, but the 1928 is shorter, having none of the psalms and versicles of 1662. Further, the 1928 has been edited so as to remove from it that which “Enlightenment” sensitivity in 1789 and women’s dignity in 1928 found unacceptable. Thus the “three causes for which Matrimony was ordained by God” in the Preface of 1662 are missing from that of the first American edition of 1789 (and then also of 1892 & 1928). The verb “to obey” found in the covenantal promise of the wife to the husband in 1662, 1789 and 1892 is removed from 1928. Further, the short Sermon provided in 1662, in which the relation and duties of husband and wife are declared according to the teaching of St Paul, does not occur in any of the American editions, and neither do several of the concluding prayers. Then also while 1662 clearly assumes that procreation is an essential part of marriage (unless age or infirmity prevent) 1928 is much less clear and actually requires no statement or prayer concerning the duty of procreation (the one prayer for children is optional).
Therefore we find that a very clear doctrine of “headship” of the husband is both presupposed and declared in 1662 whilst in 1928, though there is a priority given to the man—he coming first in responding to the questions—the “headship” is minimized in nature and scope, so that unless you are looking for it you will not find it. Also, the hesitation or even refusal of 1928 to declare that procreation is a godly duty points to the context of the growing use of artificial birth-control (which in 1930, pressed by American Bishops, the Lambeth Conference endorsed—much to the horror of the Pope and the Vatican!).
It seems to be a natural development—given the growing secularization and liberalization of The Episcopal Church in the twentieth century—from this 1928 text to the Marriage Service in the 1979 Episcopal Prayer Book, where, as would expect, there is no sign of male headship, where procreation is presented as a choice, where the use of artificial birth control is assumed and where the possibility of divorce and remarriage in church is taken for granted. It seems that once the church gives up a high doctrine of marriage it quickly moves to affirming a minimal one. Of course, neither in 1928 nor in the 1979 Prayer Book is there any hint whatsoever of same-sex marriage.
What then are the “three causes for which Matrimony was ordained”? Here they are from the 1662 edition:
First, it was ordained for the procreation of children, to be brought up in the fear and nature of the Lord, and to the praise of his holy name.
Secondly, it was ordained for a remedy against sin, and to avoid fornication; that such persons as have not the gift of continency might marry, and keep themselves undefiled members of Christ’s body.
Thirdly, it was ordained for the mutual society, help, and comfort, that the one ought to have of the other, both in prosperity and adversity.
Though the Canadian edition of 1962 did not follow the example of 1928 and remove these statements completely, it did revise them to read:
Matrimony was ordained for the hallowing of the union betwixt man and woman; for the procreation of children to be brought up in the fear and nurture of the Lord; and for the mutual society, help, and comfort, that the one ought to have of the other, in both prosperity and adversity.
This or course avoids the reference to the “negative cause,” the disordered soul of man, the reality of human nature as we know it. Like the 1928 the Canadian 1962 has removed obedience from the promise of the woman to the man.
It would appear that 1662 is so anti-cultural today (even if it is rendered into a suitable form of contemporary English) that few would want to use it—the man because he is embarrassed to have his wife obey him and the woman because she wants a marriage of equals.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
The rites in the 1662 and 1928 editions have the same basic structure and content, but the 1928 is shorter, having none of the psalms and versicles of 1662. Further, the 1928 has been edited so as to remove from it that which “Enlightenment” sensitivity in 1789 and women’s dignity in 1928 found unacceptable. Thus the “three causes for which Matrimony was ordained by God” in the Preface of 1662 are missing from that of the first American edition of 1789 (and then also of 1892 & 1928). The verb “to obey” found in the covenantal promise of the wife to the husband in 1662, 1789 and 1892 is removed from 1928. Further, the short Sermon provided in 1662, in which the relation and duties of husband and wife are declared according to the teaching of St Paul, does not occur in any of the American editions, and neither do several of the concluding prayers. Then also while 1662 clearly assumes that procreation is an essential part of marriage (unless age or infirmity prevent) 1928 is much less clear and actually requires no statement or prayer concerning the duty of procreation (the one prayer for children is optional).
Therefore we find that a very clear doctrine of “headship” of the husband is both presupposed and declared in 1662 whilst in 1928, though there is a priority given to the man—he coming first in responding to the questions—the “headship” is minimized in nature and scope, so that unless you are looking for it you will not find it. Also, the hesitation or even refusal of 1928 to declare that procreation is a godly duty points to the context of the growing use of artificial birth-control (which in 1930, pressed by American Bishops, the Lambeth Conference endorsed—much to the horror of the Pope and the Vatican!).
It seems to be a natural development—given the growing secularization and liberalization of The Episcopal Church in the twentieth century—from this 1928 text to the Marriage Service in the 1979 Episcopal Prayer Book, where, as would expect, there is no sign of male headship, where procreation is presented as a choice, where the use of artificial birth control is assumed and where the possibility of divorce and remarriage in church is taken for granted. It seems that once the church gives up a high doctrine of marriage it quickly moves to affirming a minimal one. Of course, neither in 1928 nor in the 1979 Prayer Book is there any hint whatsoever of same-sex marriage.
What then are the “three causes for which Matrimony was ordained”? Here they are from the 1662 edition:
First, it was ordained for the procreation of children, to be brought up in the fear and nature of the Lord, and to the praise of his holy name.
Secondly, it was ordained for a remedy against sin, and to avoid fornication; that such persons as have not the gift of continency might marry, and keep themselves undefiled members of Christ’s body.
Thirdly, it was ordained for the mutual society, help, and comfort, that the one ought to have of the other, both in prosperity and adversity.
Though the Canadian edition of 1962 did not follow the example of 1928 and remove these statements completely, it did revise them to read:
Matrimony was ordained for the hallowing of the union betwixt man and woman; for the procreation of children to be brought up in the fear and nurture of the Lord; and for the mutual society, help, and comfort, that the one ought to have of the other, in both prosperity and adversity.
This or course avoids the reference to the “negative cause,” the disordered soul of man, the reality of human nature as we know it. Like the 1928 the Canadian 1962 has removed obedience from the promise of the woman to the man.
It would appear that 1662 is so anti-cultural today (even if it is rendered into a suitable form of contemporary English) that few would want to use it—the man because he is embarrassed to have his wife obey him and the woman because she wants a marriage of equals.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
Monday, November 06, 2006
Baptism and the Covenant [of Grace]: The BCP editions of 1662 & 1928
Baptism is a Sacrament instituted by the Lord Jesus and is intimately related to the proclamation and the reception of the Gospel of the Father concerning the same Lord Jesus. “Go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” (Matt.28:18-20). Therefore, The Book of Common Prayer provides both for the Baptism of the infant children of baptized, believing parents as well as of adult converts to Christ.
While the two editions have the same doctrine of Baptism, they do not have identical provision of Services, and this is due in major part to the different time and social contexts in which they were created and approved. In 1662 there is one service for infants and another “for those of riper years,” while in 1928 there is one service for all, with provision for infants and adults within it. And, importantly, in both editions it is assumed that in the case of both infants and adults, Baptism is to be followed by Confirmation, either immediately in the case of adults or when reaching maturity in terms of infants.
Basic doctrines in the Services
Perhaps it would be useful to state briefly what are the basic doctrines which are either presupposed or set forth in these Services in order that their shape and structure can be the more easily appreciated.
1. Each and every child born into the world as a descendant of Adam is already a sinner before God’s tribunal because of the presence of original sin in the soul—that is an inborn bias towards evil and self-centeredness.
2. Each child also commits actual sin throughout his life.
3. Jesus Christ, as the New and Second Adam, offered himself as a sacrifice and atonement for the sins of the world and this offering was accepted by God the Father.
4. In order to receive forgiveness and cleansing both for original and actual sin, each human being needs to be baptized both with water and the Holy Spirit.
5. That is he needs to be born again (regenerated in soul) by the Holy Spirit and to be baptized in water as he (or his sponsors) believes the Gospel of the Father concerning his Son and commits himself to the service of Christ Jesus.
6. Baptism is the outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace.
7. Infants with Christian parents (who are within the covenant of grace – Acts 2:39) are baptized only if Christian sponsors (godfathers and god-mothers) stand in their place (and nurture them) until they reach an age whereby they can appropriate and make the Faith truly their own.
8. In and by Baptism “in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” a believer is made a member of the congregation of Christ’s flock and becomes a soldier in the army of Christ to fight against the devil and all evil.
9. Baptism is completed in Confirmation, where by the laying on of the hands of the Bishop, the baptized believer is strengthened by the reception of gifts from the ascended Lord Jesus through the presence of the Holy Spirit.
10. Infant Baptism only makes sense if (a) the child is from baptized Christian parents, and (b) he is “virtuously brought up to lead a godly and a Christian life” at home and in the local Church—thus provision of the Catechism in both editions and “The Offices of Instruction” in the 1928.
11. The relation established with God by Baptism in terms of internal regeneration and outward faith and commitment “to confess the faith of Christ crucified and manfully to fight under his banner against sin, the world and the devil” is not a covenant where God is the senior partner. The baptized believer has no rights only wonderful privileges and daily duties in the service of the Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the Father almighty, within the fellowship of the Church and in the world. In the covenant of grace, God establishes both the covenant itself and its terms; therefore human beings are called into it on terms that already exist and which they accept willingly as forgiven sinners.
12. Normally, but not absolutely, First Communion for the baptized will be after Confirmation. (On this, see the important study by Roger Beckwith & Andrew Daunton-Fear, The Water and the Wine, The Latimer Trust, 2006—www.latimertrust.org )
Comparison with 1979 prayer book of The Episcopal Church, USA
Those who created the 1979 prayer book rejected the doctrine and shape of the Baptismal Services in the classic Common Prayer Tradition in the editions of 1662, 1928 and Canada 1962. First of all, they claimed to follow the ancient Church of the East (rather than of the West) and insisted that “Initiation is complete in Baptism” and that Confirmation as a ceremony is not to be used as the completion of Baptism but, where desired, as a kind of public reception into church membership. Secondly, they downplayed the traditional doctrines of sin, Satan and the evil world, together with regeneration, in order to exalt the doctrine of human freedom and co-operation with God. Thus they created “The Baptismal Covenant” as the centerpiece. This they present as the human side of the agreement made with God in Baptism; and it is a commitment, amongst other things, by the covenant partners to radical social action to improve God’s world for him with peace and justice. (To the latter the new PB of the ECUSA is deeply committed, at least in word as her sermons in the National Cathedral on Nov. 4 & 5 demonstrated.)
Faithful Episcopalians need to return immediately to the Baptismal Services in one of the classic editions of the one Book of Common Prayer and avoid the service in the 1979 book.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
While the two editions have the same doctrine of Baptism, they do not have identical provision of Services, and this is due in major part to the different time and social contexts in which they were created and approved. In 1662 there is one service for infants and another “for those of riper years,” while in 1928 there is one service for all, with provision for infants and adults within it. And, importantly, in both editions it is assumed that in the case of both infants and adults, Baptism is to be followed by Confirmation, either immediately in the case of adults or when reaching maturity in terms of infants.
Basic doctrines in the Services
Perhaps it would be useful to state briefly what are the basic doctrines which are either presupposed or set forth in these Services in order that their shape and structure can be the more easily appreciated.
1. Each and every child born into the world as a descendant of Adam is already a sinner before God’s tribunal because of the presence of original sin in the soul—that is an inborn bias towards evil and self-centeredness.
2. Each child also commits actual sin throughout his life.
3. Jesus Christ, as the New and Second Adam, offered himself as a sacrifice and atonement for the sins of the world and this offering was accepted by God the Father.
4. In order to receive forgiveness and cleansing both for original and actual sin, each human being needs to be baptized both with water and the Holy Spirit.
5. That is he needs to be born again (regenerated in soul) by the Holy Spirit and to be baptized in water as he (or his sponsors) believes the Gospel of the Father concerning his Son and commits himself to the service of Christ Jesus.
6. Baptism is the outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace.
7. Infants with Christian parents (who are within the covenant of grace – Acts 2:39) are baptized only if Christian sponsors (godfathers and god-mothers) stand in their place (and nurture them) until they reach an age whereby they can appropriate and make the Faith truly their own.
8. In and by Baptism “in the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” a believer is made a member of the congregation of Christ’s flock and becomes a soldier in the army of Christ to fight against the devil and all evil.
9. Baptism is completed in Confirmation, where by the laying on of the hands of the Bishop, the baptized believer is strengthened by the reception of gifts from the ascended Lord Jesus through the presence of the Holy Spirit.
10. Infant Baptism only makes sense if (a) the child is from baptized Christian parents, and (b) he is “virtuously brought up to lead a godly and a Christian life” at home and in the local Church—thus provision of the Catechism in both editions and “The Offices of Instruction” in the 1928.
11. The relation established with God by Baptism in terms of internal regeneration and outward faith and commitment “to confess the faith of Christ crucified and manfully to fight under his banner against sin, the world and the devil” is not a covenant where God is the senior partner. The baptized believer has no rights only wonderful privileges and daily duties in the service of the Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the Father almighty, within the fellowship of the Church and in the world. In the covenant of grace, God establishes both the covenant itself and its terms; therefore human beings are called into it on terms that already exist and which they accept willingly as forgiven sinners.
12. Normally, but not absolutely, First Communion for the baptized will be after Confirmation. (On this, see the important study by Roger Beckwith & Andrew Daunton-Fear, The Water and the Wine, The Latimer Trust, 2006—www.latimertrust.org )
Comparison with 1979 prayer book of The Episcopal Church, USA
Those who created the 1979 prayer book rejected the doctrine and shape of the Baptismal Services in the classic Common Prayer Tradition in the editions of 1662, 1928 and Canada 1962. First of all, they claimed to follow the ancient Church of the East (rather than of the West) and insisted that “Initiation is complete in Baptism” and that Confirmation as a ceremony is not to be used as the completion of Baptism but, where desired, as a kind of public reception into church membership. Secondly, they downplayed the traditional doctrines of sin, Satan and the evil world, together with regeneration, in order to exalt the doctrine of human freedom and co-operation with God. Thus they created “The Baptismal Covenant” as the centerpiece. This they present as the human side of the agreement made with God in Baptism; and it is a commitment, amongst other things, by the covenant partners to radical social action to improve God’s world for him with peace and justice. (To the latter the new PB of the ECUSA is deeply committed, at least in word as her sermons in the National Cathedral on Nov. 4 & 5 demonstrated.)
Faithful Episcopalians need to return immediately to the Baptismal Services in one of the classic editions of the one Book of Common Prayer and avoid the service in the 1979 book.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
Burn brightly with Primate Katherine- Nov 5 sermon in DC
Burn brightly with Katherine to bring in the kingdom of God.
The new Primate preaches again—November 5, All Saints’ Sunday
In the National Cathedral in Washington D.C. there is a special seat—cathedra—for the Presiding Bishop of The Episcopal Church. On Sunday November 5, Katherine Jefferts-Schori was formally seated in that chair as the new Presiding Bishop. In the Eucharist where this seating occurred, she was the preacher. Significantly there was also in this service (as there had been the day before at her Recognition Service) the increasingly popular ceremony in this Church of the sprinkling of everyone with “Baptismal Water” to emphasize that all are committed to the terms of “the Baptismal Covenant” (see the 1979 prayer book for details).
In her homily she sought to combine the theme of All Saints’ with that of “The Baptismal Covenant.” However, like her sermon from the previous day her “Gospel” was a message of what can and should be in this world if all of us love justice and peace and work for human dignity and reconciliation—the kingdom of God on earth. She seems to regard only as inspirational symbolism the New Testament vision of the Jerusalem that is above where Christ reigns as Lord and King, where the angels and saints in glory praise him, and to where the pilgrim Church of God is heading on the narrow way that leads to life. Rather, her emphasis and concern is to improve the lot of people of earth in ways to which most decent people could say “Amen,” even if they do (as yet) little to achieve such a state of health, peace and justice.
Katherine is aware that in order truly to get involved in the bringing of peace and justice most baptized Episcopalians need a mighty push:
Saints are those who are vulnerable to the gut-wrenching pain of this world. Some of us have to be seized by the throat or thrown into the tomb before we can begin to find that depth of compassion. And perhaps unless we are, we won't leave our comfortable narrow lives - or our remarkably nasty ones - to wake up and begin to answer that pain.
And she believes that they can get some encouragement from the Early Church to make commitment to their baptismal covenant:
In the early church, baptism was meant to be that kind of life-altering encounter. New saints spent three years in the readying, and then were taken in the dead of night into the crypt, stripped naked, and drowned - only to emerge filled with new breath, doused with sweet-smelling oil, and given a new white robe. What you and I do on Sunday mornings today sometimes seems a pale imitation, yet it can have every bit the same effect.
Then she referred to the experience of sprinkling with baptismal water that all soon would experience in the service:
When we remember our baptisms in the sprinkling in a few minutes most of us will probably cringe. We don't like to get wet. But I hope and pray that you and I can welcome those surprising drops as a tiny reminder of what is meant to happen to us, over and over again,day after day after day. Die to the old, be unbound, come out into abundant life in service to the world. Wake up, and notice the suffering around us.
It is the willingness to experience that pain which more than anything else marks us as saints. The pain of the whole world - those who agree with us and those who might be called enemies. The pain of creation, abused for our pleasure. The pain of a six-year old child in Ghana, sold into slavery, to bail a fishing canoe and repair nets for 100 hours a week so that his parents might eat.
In the Early Church Baptism was seen, not as a being born anew to improve this world by social, medical, political and economic action by available worldly means, but rather as being born into the new age of the kingdom of God and united to Christ in the death to sin and to new life in him by the Spirit in order to be a citizen of the heavenly Jerusalem. And then to live as the salt of the earth and the light of the world as disciples of Christ in this world, working for the conversion and sanctification of the people of this world but not belonging to the ethos and spirit of this sinful world, and very specifically rejecting Satan and all his wiles.
Katherine ended her second sermon from that pulpit in two days with an inspiring call to the Cathedral congregation to action. It began with an illustration taken from Oregon where she once lived and worked and ends by using the symbolism of the heavenly Jerusalem:
In western Oregon for decades the usual way to clean up the fields after a crop of grass seed was harvested was to set the stubble afire. Clouds of noxious smoke filled the skies, and often drifted for dozens of miles. Air quality issues have led to other ways of controlling the smoke output, but burning is still the very best way to sanitize the fields and get rid of the stubble. What do you think? Can we make holy smoke?
The episkopeis of the saints, their ministry, cleans the fields of that which cannot survive in God's dream of shalom, it burns away whatever limits that dream or cannot contribute to it. The ministry of governance, whether in the legislature, the polling booth, or in raising a child, is meant to prepare the ground for a new and abundant crop of life. Most of us here this morning will have an opportunity to exercise that kind of ministry on Tuesday. Will you consider your vote as an act of "running through the stubble?" Would that we might all be able to answer, "I will, with God's help."
Let the pain of this world seize us by the throat. Listen for Jesus calling us all out of our tombs of despair and apathy. May the shock of baptismal dying once more set us afire. This place we call home is meant to be a new heaven, a new earth, a holy city, a new Jerusalem. It is the sparks in the stubble that will make it so.
Turn inward for a moment and greet the spirit planted within you. When we come to the [passing of the] peace, turn to your neighbors and greet the saints, the fire-lighters in this field. Welcome, saint! Burn brightly and transform this world into God's field for life, full measure, pressed down and overflowing, meant for all humanity and all creation. Burn!
Episcopalians are called to BURN!
Unlike her predecessor, Frank Griswold, who often sought to hide his radical mindset and agenda through rhetorical devices, Katherine makes it all clear. She looks for the kingdom of God on earth in the form of a renewed human life together on this planet, and in the pursuit of this Goal the baptized and covenanted people of God [Episcopalians] need to be wholly committed.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
The new Primate preaches again—November 5, All Saints’ Sunday
In the National Cathedral in Washington D.C. there is a special seat—cathedra—for the Presiding Bishop of The Episcopal Church. On Sunday November 5, Katherine Jefferts-Schori was formally seated in that chair as the new Presiding Bishop. In the Eucharist where this seating occurred, she was the preacher. Significantly there was also in this service (as there had been the day before at her Recognition Service) the increasingly popular ceremony in this Church of the sprinkling of everyone with “Baptismal Water” to emphasize that all are committed to the terms of “the Baptismal Covenant” (see the 1979 prayer book for details).
In her homily she sought to combine the theme of All Saints’ with that of “The Baptismal Covenant.” However, like her sermon from the previous day her “Gospel” was a message of what can and should be in this world if all of us love justice and peace and work for human dignity and reconciliation—the kingdom of God on earth. She seems to regard only as inspirational symbolism the New Testament vision of the Jerusalem that is above where Christ reigns as Lord and King, where the angels and saints in glory praise him, and to where the pilgrim Church of God is heading on the narrow way that leads to life. Rather, her emphasis and concern is to improve the lot of people of earth in ways to which most decent people could say “Amen,” even if they do (as yet) little to achieve such a state of health, peace and justice.
Katherine is aware that in order truly to get involved in the bringing of peace and justice most baptized Episcopalians need a mighty push:
Saints are those who are vulnerable to the gut-wrenching pain of this world. Some of us have to be seized by the throat or thrown into the tomb before we can begin to find that depth of compassion. And perhaps unless we are, we won't leave our comfortable narrow lives - or our remarkably nasty ones - to wake up and begin to answer that pain.
And she believes that they can get some encouragement from the Early Church to make commitment to their baptismal covenant:
In the early church, baptism was meant to be that kind of life-altering encounter. New saints spent three years in the readying, and then were taken in the dead of night into the crypt, stripped naked, and drowned - only to emerge filled with new breath, doused with sweet-smelling oil, and given a new white robe. What you and I do on Sunday mornings today sometimes seems a pale imitation, yet it can have every bit the same effect.
Then she referred to the experience of sprinkling with baptismal water that all soon would experience in the service:
When we remember our baptisms in the sprinkling in a few minutes most of us will probably cringe. We don't like to get wet. But I hope and pray that you and I can welcome those surprising drops as a tiny reminder of what is meant to happen to us, over and over again,day after day after day. Die to the old, be unbound, come out into abundant life in service to the world. Wake up, and notice the suffering around us.
It is the willingness to experience that pain which more than anything else marks us as saints. The pain of the whole world - those who agree with us and those who might be called enemies. The pain of creation, abused for our pleasure. The pain of a six-year old child in Ghana, sold into slavery, to bail a fishing canoe and repair nets for 100 hours a week so that his parents might eat.
In the Early Church Baptism was seen, not as a being born anew to improve this world by social, medical, political and economic action by available worldly means, but rather as being born into the new age of the kingdom of God and united to Christ in the death to sin and to new life in him by the Spirit in order to be a citizen of the heavenly Jerusalem. And then to live as the salt of the earth and the light of the world as disciples of Christ in this world, working for the conversion and sanctification of the people of this world but not belonging to the ethos and spirit of this sinful world, and very specifically rejecting Satan and all his wiles.
Katherine ended her second sermon from that pulpit in two days with an inspiring call to the Cathedral congregation to action. It began with an illustration taken from Oregon where she once lived and worked and ends by using the symbolism of the heavenly Jerusalem:
In western Oregon for decades the usual way to clean up the fields after a crop of grass seed was harvested was to set the stubble afire. Clouds of noxious smoke filled the skies, and often drifted for dozens of miles. Air quality issues have led to other ways of controlling the smoke output, but burning is still the very best way to sanitize the fields and get rid of the stubble. What do you think? Can we make holy smoke?
The episkopeis of the saints, their ministry, cleans the fields of that which cannot survive in God's dream of shalom, it burns away whatever limits that dream or cannot contribute to it. The ministry of governance, whether in the legislature, the polling booth, or in raising a child, is meant to prepare the ground for a new and abundant crop of life. Most of us here this morning will have an opportunity to exercise that kind of ministry on Tuesday. Will you consider your vote as an act of "running through the stubble?" Would that we might all be able to answer, "I will, with God's help."
Let the pain of this world seize us by the throat. Listen for Jesus calling us all out of our tombs of despair and apathy. May the shock of baptismal dying once more set us afire. This place we call home is meant to be a new heaven, a new earth, a holy city, a new Jerusalem. It is the sparks in the stubble that will make it so.
Turn inward for a moment and greet the spirit planted within you. When we come to the [passing of the] peace, turn to your neighbors and greet the saints, the fire-lighters in this field. Welcome, saint! Burn brightly and transform this world into God's field for life, full measure, pressed down and overflowing, meant for all humanity and all creation. Burn!
Episcopalians are called to BURN!
Unlike her predecessor, Frank Griswold, who often sought to hide his radical mindset and agenda through rhetorical devices, Katherine makes it all clear. She looks for the kingdom of God on earth in the form of a renewed human life together on this planet, and in the pursuit of this Goal the baptized and covenanted people of God [Episcopalians] need to be wholly committed.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
What do the Lady Primate and 7 protesting Bishops have in common?
Question: What do the new Lady Primate of TEC and the Seven “orthodox” Bishops of TEC and of the ACN, who applied for Alternative Primatial Oversight to Lambeth in 2006, have in common?
Answer: They all appeal to “The Baptismal Covenant” of the 1979 Prayer Book as the basis of their faith and their Anglicanism. The lady had it recited in full and preached on it at her public service of recognition on Nov 4, and the Seven made it the basis of their confession of faith in their appeal to the Arch of Cant.
The lady interprets it as it was intended to be understood by its framers in the 1970s and as successive General Conventions and PB’s have interpreted it –- as the charter of progressive liberal religion—while the Seven, pretending that the 1979 Book is an orthodox document, seek to make its radical center into something that it has never been, the basis of [their definition of] orthodoxy--(we ask: why are they so against the historic Formularies of the Anglican Way which are also those of The Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA as the basis of their Anglican Faith?).
In the New Province desired by the Seven there must surely be a repudiation of this Covenant and the interpretation of it in TEC since 1970s, and the use instead of the traditional Baptismal Services in the BCP 1662, 1928 and (Canada) 1962 for the Anglican understanding of the beginning and nature of the Christian life!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Answer: They all appeal to “The Baptismal Covenant” of the 1979 Prayer Book as the basis of their faith and their Anglicanism. The lady had it recited in full and preached on it at her public service of recognition on Nov 4, and the Seven made it the basis of their confession of faith in their appeal to the Arch of Cant.
The lady interprets it as it was intended to be understood by its framers in the 1970s and as successive General Conventions and PB’s have interpreted it –- as the charter of progressive liberal religion—while the Seven, pretending that the 1979 Book is an orthodox document, seek to make its radical center into something that it has never been, the basis of [their definition of] orthodoxy--(we ask: why are they so against the historic Formularies of the Anglican Way which are also those of The Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA as the basis of their Anglican Faith?).
In the New Province desired by the Seven there must surely be a repudiation of this Covenant and the interpretation of it in TEC since 1970s, and the use instead of the traditional Baptismal Services in the BCP 1662, 1928 and (Canada) 1962 for the Anglican understanding of the beginning and nature of the Christian life!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Sunday, November 05, 2006
Holy Communion in the BCP editions of 1662 & 1928
Comparison and Contrast in the Light of Bp Duncan’s call for the acceptance of 1662 as the primary Prayer Book
When Archbishop Thomas Cranmer and his fellow Reformers read the accounts in the Gospels of the Last Supper in the 1540s, what deeply impressed them, amongst other things, was the fact that between the words of Jesus, “This my body” and “This my blood,” there was no delay in the eating of the [blessed] bread and drinking of the [blessed] wine by the disciples (see Matthew 26:26ff.; Mark 14:22ff.; and Luke 22:14ff.). Thus in The Order for Holy Communion in the English Prayer Book from 1552 the communion of the clergy and people comes immediately after the recital of the words of the Lord Jesus. Nothing stands between the Words of Blessing/Consecration by the Lord Jesus and the receiving of the sacramental bread and wine by the congregation at the hands of Christ’s Minister.
In constructing the service in this way Cranmer and his colleagues knew that they were not following the order in either the medieval Latin Mass or in the late Greek patristic tradition. However, as the Scriptures were for them the primary authority, and since this is a Gospel Sacrament, they believed it to be required of them by the Lord Jesus himself to follow the Lord’s example. So what is usually called the Prayer of Consecration in 1662 is short and that which had usually been included within it in the Western Rite is separated from it and placed at other points in the Service.
New Shape
It was to be expected that sooner or later amongst Anglicans outside, and then inside the Church of England and related Churches, there would be a call to revise the order of contents in the service of Holy Communion, to bring it in line with the order in the Divine Liturgy from the ancient patriarchates of the patristic period. This was attempted by those in schism from the Church of England after 1689 and known as the Non-Jurors and they were followed by the Episcopal Church in Scotland in its Communion Rite of 1764. From this development, Samuel Seabury, who was consecrated bishop in Scotland for the new Protestant Episcopal Church of the U.S.A., inherited the principles which deeply affected the structure of the Prayer of Consecration in the first American edition of The Book of Common Prayer (1789), which is a fusion of the English and Scottish Prayers.
It is useful to know that the learned divines of the Anglican Way in the reigns of Elizabeth I, James I, Charles I and Charles II were in general wholly satisfied with the structure and content of The Order for Holy Communion, as they had it in essentially the same wording as the later 1662 edition.
In BCP 1662, used in the American colonies until 1789, the order of content is as follows:
Sursum Corda (“Lift up your hearts”)
Preface
Sanctus
Prayer of Humble Access (“We do not presume…”)
Prayer of Consecration
Communion of the People in both Kinds
Lord’s Prayer
Either (a) Prayer of Oblation or (b) Prayer of Thanksgiving
Gloria in excelsis
Blessing
In BCP 1928 (continuing from the edition of 1789) the order of content in the 1662 is re-arranged as follows:
Sursum Corda
Preface
Sanctus
Prayer of Consecration (which includes The Oblation & The Invocation and Prayer of Oblation from 1662)
Lord’s Prayer
Prayer of Humble Access
Communion of the People in both Kinds
Prayer of Thanksgiving
Gloria in excelsis
Blessing
Here we see that (a) there is a long gap between the Dominical Words, which occur in the first part of the Consecration Prayer, to the actual Communion of the people; and (b) the verbal content of 1928 is larger than that of 1662 and is so by the inclusion of (i) two short paragraphs in the middle of the Prayer of Consecration—the Oblation and the Invocation—and (ii) the use of both prayers (in different places) provided after the Lord’s Prayer in 1662.
Comment
Those who follow Cranmer’s lead insist that the authority of the Biblical narratives is greater than the influence of the usage in ancient Liturgies of East or West and so it is good and right to connect communion with the recital of the Lord’s words. Those who follow the lead of the Non-Jurors and others after them believe that the Anglican Way should follow the example of the ancient Church of the East in the important matter of the structure and content of the Prayer of Consecration. Further, they offer justification for the Oblation and Invocation in these terms:
“The Oblation is the hinge of the whole Consecration prayer. It gathers up the thanksgivings and memorials that have gone before and offers them to God by means of the “holy gifts”, the instruments of bread and wine which our Lord himself chose to represent his own Sacrifice, and to be the occasion of its continuing and innumerable benefits to his Church. Thus the words ‘which we now offer unto thee’ are seen to be of great importance.
“The Invocation is a prayer of benediction over the “holy food and drink” to sanctify them to our use. It is the return of God’s blessing to us by ‘his Word and Holy Spirit’ in and through these representative gifts which we have offered up to him in thanksgiving and memorial in the Oblation.”
However, we need to note that the Invocation is carefully worded so as not to give the impression that the Invocation itself actually makes the bread and wine into the actual body and blood of Jesus. And the Western Latin Rite has no specific Epiclesis or Invocation.
Whatever we make of these differences today, it was the judgment of the Archbishop of Canterbury and the English Bishops that the revised Order for Holy Communion of the American Church of 1789 was of the same basic doctrine as that of the English Church in its 1662 text and so they gave their approval to the revised Order.
Other differences
In comparison with the differences in the shape of the Consecration Prayer other differences between the English and the American editions of The Book of Common Prayer are relatively minor. They include:
1. The option in 1928 of using the Summary of the Law instead of the full Ten Commandments.
2. Prayer for the Monarch in 1662 only.
3. Required use of the Exhortation in 1662 each Sunday while only required in 1928 on three Sundays (First of Advent and of Lent and Trinity Sunday).
4. The use of the verb “offer” with reference to the Bread and Wine in the rubrics after the Offertory Sentences in 1928 but not in 1662.
5. The rubric on kneeling and adoration at the end of the Service in 1662 but not in 1928.
Contrary to what some people think the 1928 does not allow in its rubrics either (a) the transfer of Gloria in excelsis to the beginning of the whole Service or (b) the cleansing of the vessels immediately after Communion—they are cleansed at the end of the Service in both 1662 and 1928. Neither does it require the use of an Old Testament Lesson since it assumes that such has already been read in Morning Prayer, and the ancient Eucharistic Lectionary used in The Book of Common Prayer does not have an O.T. lesson, only the Epistle and Gospel.
Canada 1962, Rite 1 (1979) and the Missal (1961).
The Canadian edition of The Book of Common Prayer (1962) also revises the order and contents of The Order for Holy Communion but in less detail than 1928. The Prayer of Consecration is lengthened to include a brief Oblation and Invocation; pax vobiscum (while kneeling) follows it and then comes the Prayer of Humble Access before Communion.
Rite One of 1979 in The Episcopal Church on first glance appears much the same as the 1928 Service of Holy Communion. However, on closer inspection, one sees that it is given the same structure as the innovatory Rite Two Service of Holy Communion, and so the 1928 shape is bent to fit into the new shape. Adjustments are also made to individual prayers to trim their doctrine; there is an alternative Consecration Prayer to that taken over from 1928, and different Collect, Epistles and Gospels are appointed for use with this Service than those appointed for 1928.
“The Ordinary of the Mass” in The People’s Anglican Missal in the American Edition (1961 and reprinted since), while based on the Book of Common Prayer, and used by some devoted church-people of anglo-catholic persuasion, appears to go beyond the BCP not only in ceremonial but also in doctrine. Also it seems not to have the same doctrine of the vocation and purpose of the Ministry as that in The Ordinal (1662 & 1928) and seems to contain some teaching that is actually rejected in The Articles of Religion (1662 & 1928).
In conclusion
If there is in real terms a primary Anglican Rite for Holy Communion it is that which is in 1662; and it is this Rite which has satisfied ordinary and learned people from 1552 to the present both in English and in over one hundred and fifty other languages. It has the distinct advantage of having a short Prayer of Consecration and of keeping people focused on the Words of the Lord Jesus as they receive his sacramental body and blood. Further, in terms of Anglican unity—something that is extremely important in the present identity crisis of Anglicanism—the 1662 is so widely used around the Global Anglican Communion that it has no competitor as “the standard Rite” of the past, for the present and on into the future.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
When Archbishop Thomas Cranmer and his fellow Reformers read the accounts in the Gospels of the Last Supper in the 1540s, what deeply impressed them, amongst other things, was the fact that between the words of Jesus, “This my body” and “This my blood,” there was no delay in the eating of the [blessed] bread and drinking of the [blessed] wine by the disciples (see Matthew 26:26ff.; Mark 14:22ff.; and Luke 22:14ff.). Thus in The Order for Holy Communion in the English Prayer Book from 1552 the communion of the clergy and people comes immediately after the recital of the words of the Lord Jesus. Nothing stands between the Words of Blessing/Consecration by the Lord Jesus and the receiving of the sacramental bread and wine by the congregation at the hands of Christ’s Minister.
In constructing the service in this way Cranmer and his colleagues knew that they were not following the order in either the medieval Latin Mass or in the late Greek patristic tradition. However, as the Scriptures were for them the primary authority, and since this is a Gospel Sacrament, they believed it to be required of them by the Lord Jesus himself to follow the Lord’s example. So what is usually called the Prayer of Consecration in 1662 is short and that which had usually been included within it in the Western Rite is separated from it and placed at other points in the Service.
New Shape
It was to be expected that sooner or later amongst Anglicans outside, and then inside the Church of England and related Churches, there would be a call to revise the order of contents in the service of Holy Communion, to bring it in line with the order in the Divine Liturgy from the ancient patriarchates of the patristic period. This was attempted by those in schism from the Church of England after 1689 and known as the Non-Jurors and they were followed by the Episcopal Church in Scotland in its Communion Rite of 1764. From this development, Samuel Seabury, who was consecrated bishop in Scotland for the new Protestant Episcopal Church of the U.S.A., inherited the principles which deeply affected the structure of the Prayer of Consecration in the first American edition of The Book of Common Prayer (1789), which is a fusion of the English and Scottish Prayers.
It is useful to know that the learned divines of the Anglican Way in the reigns of Elizabeth I, James I, Charles I and Charles II were in general wholly satisfied with the structure and content of The Order for Holy Communion, as they had it in essentially the same wording as the later 1662 edition.
In BCP 1662, used in the American colonies until 1789, the order of content is as follows:
Sursum Corda (“Lift up your hearts”)
Preface
Sanctus
Prayer of Humble Access (“We do not presume…”)
Prayer of Consecration
Communion of the People in both Kinds
Lord’s Prayer
Either (a) Prayer of Oblation or (b) Prayer of Thanksgiving
Gloria in excelsis
Blessing
In BCP 1928 (continuing from the edition of 1789) the order of content in the 1662 is re-arranged as follows:
Sursum Corda
Preface
Sanctus
Prayer of Consecration (which includes The Oblation & The Invocation and Prayer of Oblation from 1662)
Lord’s Prayer
Prayer of Humble Access
Communion of the People in both Kinds
Prayer of Thanksgiving
Gloria in excelsis
Blessing
Here we see that (a) there is a long gap between the Dominical Words, which occur in the first part of the Consecration Prayer, to the actual Communion of the people; and (b) the verbal content of 1928 is larger than that of 1662 and is so by the inclusion of (i) two short paragraphs in the middle of the Prayer of Consecration—the Oblation and the Invocation—and (ii) the use of both prayers (in different places) provided after the Lord’s Prayer in 1662.
Comment
Those who follow Cranmer’s lead insist that the authority of the Biblical narratives is greater than the influence of the usage in ancient Liturgies of East or West and so it is good and right to connect communion with the recital of the Lord’s words. Those who follow the lead of the Non-Jurors and others after them believe that the Anglican Way should follow the example of the ancient Church of the East in the important matter of the structure and content of the Prayer of Consecration. Further, they offer justification for the Oblation and Invocation in these terms:
“The Oblation is the hinge of the whole Consecration prayer. It gathers up the thanksgivings and memorials that have gone before and offers them to God by means of the “holy gifts”, the instruments of bread and wine which our Lord himself chose to represent his own Sacrifice, and to be the occasion of its continuing and innumerable benefits to his Church. Thus the words ‘which we now offer unto thee’ are seen to be of great importance.
“The Invocation is a prayer of benediction over the “holy food and drink” to sanctify them to our use. It is the return of God’s blessing to us by ‘his Word and Holy Spirit’ in and through these representative gifts which we have offered up to him in thanksgiving and memorial in the Oblation.”
However, we need to note that the Invocation is carefully worded so as not to give the impression that the Invocation itself actually makes the bread and wine into the actual body and blood of Jesus. And the Western Latin Rite has no specific Epiclesis or Invocation.
Whatever we make of these differences today, it was the judgment of the Archbishop of Canterbury and the English Bishops that the revised Order for Holy Communion of the American Church of 1789 was of the same basic doctrine as that of the English Church in its 1662 text and so they gave their approval to the revised Order.
Other differences
In comparison with the differences in the shape of the Consecration Prayer other differences between the English and the American editions of The Book of Common Prayer are relatively minor. They include:
1. The option in 1928 of using the Summary of the Law instead of the full Ten Commandments.
2. Prayer for the Monarch in 1662 only.
3. Required use of the Exhortation in 1662 each Sunday while only required in 1928 on three Sundays (First of Advent and of Lent and Trinity Sunday).
4. The use of the verb “offer” with reference to the Bread and Wine in the rubrics after the Offertory Sentences in 1928 but not in 1662.
5. The rubric on kneeling and adoration at the end of the Service in 1662 but not in 1928.
Contrary to what some people think the 1928 does not allow in its rubrics either (a) the transfer of Gloria in excelsis to the beginning of the whole Service or (b) the cleansing of the vessels immediately after Communion—they are cleansed at the end of the Service in both 1662 and 1928. Neither does it require the use of an Old Testament Lesson since it assumes that such has already been read in Morning Prayer, and the ancient Eucharistic Lectionary used in The Book of Common Prayer does not have an O.T. lesson, only the Epistle and Gospel.
Canada 1962, Rite 1 (1979) and the Missal (1961).
The Canadian edition of The Book of Common Prayer (1962) also revises the order and contents of The Order for Holy Communion but in less detail than 1928. The Prayer of Consecration is lengthened to include a brief Oblation and Invocation; pax vobiscum (while kneeling) follows it and then comes the Prayer of Humble Access before Communion.
Rite One of 1979 in The Episcopal Church on first glance appears much the same as the 1928 Service of Holy Communion. However, on closer inspection, one sees that it is given the same structure as the innovatory Rite Two Service of Holy Communion, and so the 1928 shape is bent to fit into the new shape. Adjustments are also made to individual prayers to trim their doctrine; there is an alternative Consecration Prayer to that taken over from 1928, and different Collect, Epistles and Gospels are appointed for use with this Service than those appointed for 1928.
“The Ordinary of the Mass” in The People’s Anglican Missal in the American Edition (1961 and reprinted since), while based on the Book of Common Prayer, and used by some devoted church-people of anglo-catholic persuasion, appears to go beyond the BCP not only in ceremonial but also in doctrine. Also it seems not to have the same doctrine of the vocation and purpose of the Ministry as that in The Ordinal (1662 & 1928) and seems to contain some teaching that is actually rejected in The Articles of Religion (1662 & 1928).
In conclusion
If there is in real terms a primary Anglican Rite for Holy Communion it is that which is in 1662; and it is this Rite which has satisfied ordinary and learned people from 1552 to the present both in English and in over one hundred and fifty other languages. It has the distinct advantage of having a short Prayer of Consecration and of keeping people focused on the Words of the Lord Jesus as they receive his sacramental body and blood. Further, in terms of Anglican unity—something that is extremely important in the present identity crisis of Anglicanism—the 1662 is so widely used around the Global Anglican Communion that it has no competitor as “the standard Rite” of the past, for the present and on into the future.
The Revd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil (Oxford)
Home, sweet Home! Shalom, sweet Shalom! The sermon of the new Presiding Bishop of The Episcopal Church
On November 4, 2006, in the National Cathedral in Washington D.C., the new Lady Presiding Bishop, The Most Rev. Katharine Jefferts Schori, publicly took up her new vocation. Her sermon followed in the Service that which for her was necessary and highly significant, while for others it was puzzling. She had everyone in the Cathedral involved in “The Baptismal Covenant” from the 1979 prayer book, not only in terms of making the commitments of it, but also being sprinkled with baptismal water by a team of bishops and deacons as a external sign of an internal covenant they all made with God. Only in her sermon did one realize why she places so much emphasis upon this “Covenant.” It is for her the basis of the Church’s mission and work in the world and also the basis of her own ministry. Thus, though she gave out no text for her sermon, we may assume that it was the words of this Covenant and in particular the commitment made to God in it to “strive for justice and peace among all people, and respect the dignity of every human being.”
In moving and at times eloquent terms she spoke of the human yearning for home and for vital community life:
We all ache for a community that will take us in, with all our warts and quirks and petty meannesses - and yet they still celebrate when they see us coming! That vision of homegoing and homecoming that underlies our deepest spiritual yearnings is also the job assignment each one of us gets in baptism - go home, and while you're at it, help to build a home for everyone else on earth. For none of us can truly find our rest in God until all of our brothers and sisters have also been welcomed home like the prodigal.
Then she took up the theme of peace through the familiar Hebrew word, “shalom.”
There's a wonderful Hebrew word for that vision and work - shalom. It doesn't just mean the sort of peace that comes when we're no longer at war. It's that rich and multihued vision of a world where no one goes hungry because everyone is invited to a seat at the groaning board, it's a vision of a world where no one is sick or in prison because all sorts of disease have been healed, it's a vision of a world where every human being has the capacity to use every good gift that God has given, it is a vision of a world where no one enjoys abundance at the expense of another, it's a vision of a world where all enjoy Sabbath rest in the conscious presence of God. Shalom means that all human beings live together as siblings, at peace with one another and with God, and in right relationship with all of the rest of creation. It is that vision of the lion lying down with the lamb and the small child playing over the den of the adder, where the specter of death no longer holds sway. It is that vision to which Jesus points when he says, "today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing." To say "shalom" is to know our own place and to invite and affirm the place of all of the rest of creation, once more at home in God.
Then she connected the commitment to peace of the Baptismal Covenant to the “Peace” which is the aim of the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals and to which The Episcopal Church is committed by its General Convention:
This church has said that our larger vision will be framed and shaped in the coming years by the vision of shalom embedded in the Millennium Development Goals - a world where the hungry are fed, the ill are healed, the young educated, women and men treated equally, and where all have access to clean water and adequate sanitation, basic health care, and the promise of development that does not endanger the rest of creation. That vision of abundant life is achievable in our own day, but only with the passionate commitment of each and every one of us. It is God's vision of homecoming for all humanity.
At this point there was sustained applause. Her vision is powerful and moves people of good will. But then she went on to ask the hard question of why we are all not more full committed to the pursuit of shalom.
What keeps us from the tireless search for that vision of shalom? There are probably only two answers, and they are connected - apathy and fear. One is the unwillingness to acknowledge the pain of other people, the other is an unwillingness to acknowledge that pain with enough courage to act. The cure for each is a deep and abiding hope. If God in Jesus has made captivity captive, has taken fear hostage, it is for the liberation and flourishing of hope. Augustine said that as Christians, we are prisoners of hope - a ridiculously assertive hope, a hope that unflinchingly assails the doors of heaven, a hope that will not cease until that dream of God has swallowed up death forever, a hope that has the audacity to join Jesus in saying, "today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing."
Finally, she described how the vision will be realized in practical terms:
In the courage to challenge our legislators to make poverty history, to fund AIDS work in Africa, and the distribution of anti-malarial mosquito nets, and primary schools where all children are welcomed. In the will to look within our own hearts and confront the shadows that darken the dream that God has planted there. That scripture is fulfilled each time we reach beyond our narrow self-interest to call another home.
And she concluded:
God has spoken that dream in us, let us rejoice! Let us join the raucous throngs in creation, the sea creatures and the geological features who leap for joy at the vision of all creation restored, restored to proper relationship, to all creation come home at last. May that scripture be fulfilled in our hearing and in our doing.
Shalom, chaverim, shalom, my friends, shalom.
Here the congregation cried out, “Shalom.”
What one misses in this sermon—if one had listened carefully to the reading from Ephesians which was chosen by Katherine as part of this service and if one has learned the basic Catechism of the classic Prayer Book—is the biblical, Christian vision of a regenerated and renewed cosmos. In Ephesians 1-4 it is intimately related to, indeed centered upon, the saving and redeeming work of Jesus Christ in his Cross, Resurrection, Exaltation and Return to earth. Why did Katherine say virtually nothing about the Lord Jesus and the place of the local church where is truth and unity as a kind of illustration and promise of the cosmic renewal which shall be?
In fact her message, whilst moving and idealistic in a good sense, could have been preached to any group of people who say they believe in God and also desire to see the genuine improvement of the daily lives of people in this world—which seems to be the only world for her. Her message fits well into Deism or Unitarianism or any kind of theism, which has no distinctive message of the absolute need of personal salvation from sin and corrupt society into a new people of God being saved for eternal life in the kingdom of heaven of the age to come with the Lord Jesus Christ and his saints. Her Shalom lacks the biblical dimension of peace with God in terms of everlasting salvation in and through Jesus Christ and the creation of a new people of God, who are destined to be the very center of a renewed and regenerated cosmos. And so with all her fine commitment to the improvement of this world and of the lot of needy people in this world, and her desire for genuine and real community, she does not present herself as a Christian theologian but rather as a gifted advocate for a liberal, progressive, Unitarian vision of this world as “the kingdom of God.”
drpetertoon@yahoo.com Nov 4, 2006
In moving and at times eloquent terms she spoke of the human yearning for home and for vital community life:
We all ache for a community that will take us in, with all our warts and quirks and petty meannesses - and yet they still celebrate when they see us coming! That vision of homegoing and homecoming that underlies our deepest spiritual yearnings is also the job assignment each one of us gets in baptism - go home, and while you're at it, help to build a home for everyone else on earth. For none of us can truly find our rest in God until all of our brothers and sisters have also been welcomed home like the prodigal.
Then she took up the theme of peace through the familiar Hebrew word, “shalom.”
There's a wonderful Hebrew word for that vision and work - shalom. It doesn't just mean the sort of peace that comes when we're no longer at war. It's that rich and multihued vision of a world where no one goes hungry because everyone is invited to a seat at the groaning board, it's a vision of a world where no one is sick or in prison because all sorts of disease have been healed, it's a vision of a world where every human being has the capacity to use every good gift that God has given, it is a vision of a world where no one enjoys abundance at the expense of another, it's a vision of a world where all enjoy Sabbath rest in the conscious presence of God. Shalom means that all human beings live together as siblings, at peace with one another and with God, and in right relationship with all of the rest of creation. It is that vision of the lion lying down with the lamb and the small child playing over the den of the adder, where the specter of death no longer holds sway. It is that vision to which Jesus points when he says, "today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing." To say "shalom" is to know our own place and to invite and affirm the place of all of the rest of creation, once more at home in God.
Then she connected the commitment to peace of the Baptismal Covenant to the “Peace” which is the aim of the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals and to which The Episcopal Church is committed by its General Convention:
This church has said that our larger vision will be framed and shaped in the coming years by the vision of shalom embedded in the Millennium Development Goals - a world where the hungry are fed, the ill are healed, the young educated, women and men treated equally, and where all have access to clean water and adequate sanitation, basic health care, and the promise of development that does not endanger the rest of creation. That vision of abundant life is achievable in our own day, but only with the passionate commitment of each and every one of us. It is God's vision of homecoming for all humanity.
At this point there was sustained applause. Her vision is powerful and moves people of good will. But then she went on to ask the hard question of why we are all not more full committed to the pursuit of shalom.
What keeps us from the tireless search for that vision of shalom? There are probably only two answers, and they are connected - apathy and fear. One is the unwillingness to acknowledge the pain of other people, the other is an unwillingness to acknowledge that pain with enough courage to act. The cure for each is a deep and abiding hope. If God in Jesus has made captivity captive, has taken fear hostage, it is for the liberation and flourishing of hope. Augustine said that as Christians, we are prisoners of hope - a ridiculously assertive hope, a hope that unflinchingly assails the doors of heaven, a hope that will not cease until that dream of God has swallowed up death forever, a hope that has the audacity to join Jesus in saying, "today this scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing."
Finally, she described how the vision will be realized in practical terms:
In the courage to challenge our legislators to make poverty history, to fund AIDS work in Africa, and the distribution of anti-malarial mosquito nets, and primary schools where all children are welcomed. In the will to look within our own hearts and confront the shadows that darken the dream that God has planted there. That scripture is fulfilled each time we reach beyond our narrow self-interest to call another home.
And she concluded:
God has spoken that dream in us, let us rejoice! Let us join the raucous throngs in creation, the sea creatures and the geological features who leap for joy at the vision of all creation restored, restored to proper relationship, to all creation come home at last. May that scripture be fulfilled in our hearing and in our doing.
Shalom, chaverim, shalom, my friends, shalom.
Here the congregation cried out, “Shalom.”
What one misses in this sermon—if one had listened carefully to the reading from Ephesians which was chosen by Katherine as part of this service and if one has learned the basic Catechism of the classic Prayer Book—is the biblical, Christian vision of a regenerated and renewed cosmos. In Ephesians 1-4 it is intimately related to, indeed centered upon, the saving and redeeming work of Jesus Christ in his Cross, Resurrection, Exaltation and Return to earth. Why did Katherine say virtually nothing about the Lord Jesus and the place of the local church where is truth and unity as a kind of illustration and promise of the cosmic renewal which shall be?
In fact her message, whilst moving and idealistic in a good sense, could have been preached to any group of people who say they believe in God and also desire to see the genuine improvement of the daily lives of people in this world—which seems to be the only world for her. Her message fits well into Deism or Unitarianism or any kind of theism, which has no distinctive message of the absolute need of personal salvation from sin and corrupt society into a new people of God being saved for eternal life in the kingdom of heaven of the age to come with the Lord Jesus Christ and his saints. Her Shalom lacks the biblical dimension of peace with God in terms of everlasting salvation in and through Jesus Christ and the creation of a new people of God, who are destined to be the very center of a renewed and regenerated cosmos. And so with all her fine commitment to the improvement of this world and of the lot of needy people in this world, and her desire for genuine and real community, she does not present herself as a Christian theologian but rather as a gifted advocate for a liberal, progressive, Unitarian vision of this world as “the kingdom of God.”
drpetertoon@yahoo.com Nov 4, 2006
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)