Monday, January 09, 2006
ECUSA’s Religion – a relevant and credible modern Faith or a rejection of “Mere Christianity”?
After World War II the [Protestant] Episcopal Church as a mainline denomination made a major attempt to discover and present both a relevant and credible form of Christianity, having a Catholic & liturgical face.
It began by seeking to update its liturgy which its “experts” judged was too inflexible, traditional and pessimistic in order to be appropriate for the new era where more celebration was required. After a series of published studies and experimental trial liturgies, General Convention approved what became known as “The Book of Common Prayer, 1979.” Although this book shared the same title as the earlier official editions of the Prayer Book (1662, 1789, 1892 & 1928), it was a wholly new kind of Prayer Book, similar in style to that called “The Alternative Service Book, 1980” in England and “The Book of Alternative Services, 1985” in Canada. Obviously it had the wrong title! In it flexibility, variety and relativism had replaced traditional order and style. Further, the “You-God” had achieved dominance over the “Thou-God” as the classic English form and style of Public Prayer gave way to an upgraded form of contemporary street language. Finally, this new Book replaced the classic Book of Common Prayer, Ordinal and Articles of Religion as the Formulary of the Episcopal Church.
Whilst the “renewal” of the liturgy was progressing within ECUSA a cultural revolution, which began in the 1960s and stretched well into the 1970s, was turning American society and values inside out. Naturally the ECUSA felt the winds of change and began immediately to adjust its worship, doctrine and discipline to the canons of modernity.
First of all, in the context of what was now a “divorce culture” in the USA, the General Convention in 1973 set aside its ordered canonical discipline for marriage, divorce and possible remarriage (under very strict conditions), replacing it with a new approach that was deemed “pastoral.” By this the marriage of divorcees in church became much easier and over the years became normal and common. Jesus Christ’s rules for Christian marriage were effectively made an option not church law in ECUSA.
Secondly, General Convention set aside the received doctrine of the relation of man and woman as given by God in creation by (a) the seating of female deputies in 1970, and much more obviously by (b) providing for the ordination of women to all three Orders of the Ministry in 1976. Meanwhile abortion on demand, as a means of birth control for a woman, was stated to be a women’s right by the same Convention.
Thirdly, to confirm the liberation of women from a supposed evil and oppressive patriarchy, the Convention decided that a different language of prayer was necessary, a language which gave equal emphasis to feminine and masculine metaphors, images, names and pronouns. This principle, begun in the 1979 Prayer Book, was continued more specifically in books of services approved in the 1980s and 1990s. By this, the revelation written in the Holy Scriptures was effectively revised and changed, and as a result all the received dogma of the Church became subject to revision or rejection.
Fourthly, with women’s rights fully acknowledged, and the biblical doctrine of marriage as a one-flesh union for life without divorce made optional, space was created for the Les[bian]Bi[sexual]Gay agenda to be pushed in the Convention. Those persons who believed that they have an “orientation” to persons of the same “gender/sex” and that this is God-given and should be recognized by the Church had their day and the result was – to cut a long story short – the approval of Gene Robinson (a divorced man with children now living in a same-sex union with a man) as a Bishop of New Hampshire in 2003. Here the move from order to disorder in human and sexual relations was proclaimed from the housetops.
Just where the General Convention and its House of Bishops will take the ECUSA next in this pilgrimage within the canons of modernity and post-modernity is anyone’s guess. As it has followed liberal society and culture since the 1960s, it is most probable that it will continue to do so well into the new century.
Meanwhile, a minority of ECUSA members of a socially conservative background desire that the Church slow down in its embracing of daring innovations, while a smaller minority (mostly Network and AAC members) desire that it begin a U-turn at its June 2006 General Convention. In particular, the latter minority is working hard to get the Convention to reverse itself on the LesBiGay agenda for to this group this particular innovation is that which God in heaven most abhors.
It is certainly conceivable that the Convention in mid 2006 will begin a U-turn; and with God (if HE so purposes) all things are possible. However, it is very difficult to believe that there will be anything more than a politically guided attempt to appease offended Anglicans abroad even as the progressive agenda continues apace, perhaps in hidden and mysterious ways. Reasons for saying this are: (a) major Western provinces of the Anglican Family have traveled in much the same direction as the ECUSA, if not so far; (b) all the mainline denominations of the USA are going in parallel tracks to the ECUSA; (c) since the time of Bishop Pike of California, the House of Bishops has shown no resolution to drive out error and heresy, but in fact has usually done the opposite, welcome disorder; and (d) the elite who run the ECUSA and the majority of the membership believe that the ECUSA is on its way to becoming a true church for the 21st century, a community of love, an inclusive community of justice and thus a credible and relevant expression of Christian faith and morality – and as such it remains attractive to many of liberal disposition in modern America.
When C.S.Lewis’ book, Mere Christianity, was published after World War II in the USA one could say that the vast majority of the PECUSA agreed with it. Now in 2006 the majority would see it as commending oppressive patriarchy, sexism, androcentrism and outdated theological traditionalism. Times have changed and with them the PECUSA.
drpetertoon@yahoo.com January 8, 2006
Saturday, January 07, 2006
ECUSA 2006: A prayer starter
1. The progressive Liberals who effectively guide and run the Episcopal Church believe that God has given them a vision and with it a vocation. They are called to be prophets to call this and all the main-line Churches to a vigorous commitment to being communities of inclusivity, wherein there is love, peace and justice. As such they are to be the salt of the earth and the light of the world.
Justice for women, for ethnic and racial minorities, for people whose “orientation” is “Gay, Bisexual or Lesbian” is well on the way to being realized in the ECUSA, they believe. God is giving signs of the success all the time, most recently in the consecration of Gene Robinson. Yet there is much to do since each generation has to be educated in the vocation of progressive liberalism and the mantle of the prophet(ess) handed on to it. To turn back, to begin a U-turn, would be to betray the Spirit and all that She has taught and continues to reveal to this Church.
2. The small group of Evangelicals and Anglo-Catholics of the Network and the AAC certainly oppose the more daring parts of the prophetic vocation of the progressive Liberals (whom they call “revisionists”) and they have major allies abroad who agree with them; but most of them share the earlier parts of this vocation. The presence of women with dog-collars, the relatively high number of re-married clergy and laity in their leadership and ranks, and the way they worship and what they use, all reveal most clearly their commitment to the innovations of the ECUSA between 1970 and 1980. They appear committed to the revised Canon on Marriage of 1973, the ordination of women of 1976, and the removal of the classic Anglican Formularies in 1979 (through the adoption of a wholly new kind of prayer book, ordination services and statement of Faith). However, unlike the progressive Liberals who are happy to attribute their prophetic vision to God speaking to them through contemporary experience and movements (e.g., human rights), the Evangelicals tend to look for biblical texts, or new forms of biblical interpretation to justify, their acceptance of these innovations. (In contrast they use old forms of biblical interpretation to attack the LesBiGay agenda!)
So for the progressive Liberals like Bishop Griswold the ECUSA is moving, howbeit slowly, towards the promised land, while for the Network it is stuck in the wilderness, waiting for the LesBiGay agenda to be dropped – hopefully at the General Convention, June 2006, or if not later – before there can be movement forward following the Shekinah.
Yet for a minority, an exceedingly small minority of traditional Episcopalians, the Episcopal Church is heading straight into full-blown apostasy, into the abyss. In their estimation it has systematically, even joyfully, set aside revealed divine order for marriage, for the family, for divine worship and for the Ministry and introduced dis-order at all levels of its life and witness. The blessing of same-sex-unions and ordaining people in such arrangements is but the most recent of a long series of innovation and setting aside of God’s will for his creation and his Church. This minority stays around because they believe it is their humble vocation to witness to and feel God’s judgment, to praise him for it, and to share its pain and weight with fellow Episcopalians in all humility and grace. They believe that God may choose in his covenant mercy to bring this Church or a remnant thereof back from the Abyss, out of Exile, to the promised land.
petertoon@msn.com January 7, 2006
Thursday, January 05, 2006
Epiphany – journeying by faith to a known goal
In contrast, when the wise men, the sages of the East, set off on their journey Westwards they knew where they were going and for whom they were looking, even though the specifics were not clear until they got near to their destination (Matthew 2). No doubt they had both uplifting and depressing experiences on their long journey; yet they kept going in the one direction because the goal of the journey was what made the journey necessary. They intended to see and worship the One born to be King of the Jews and they were not satisfied until they could present him with their precious gifts and worship him.
On the Feast of the Epiphany (January 6) we pray:
O God, who by the leading of a star didst manifest thy-only begotten Son to the Gentiles:….
We read the biblical account of “the wise men from the East,” we meditate upon it and we marvel how non-Jews could be so inspired and so dedicated in their determination to see and adore the Messiah of the Jews, whom they came to see is also the Saviour of the world. We note the sacrifice and time they were prepared to offer in order to gain knowledge of God’s salvation and we compare it with what we are prepared to make and give -- and we feel ashamed, but also inspired.
Mercifully grant, that we, which know thee now by faith, may after this life have the fruition of thy glorious Godhead, through Jesus Christ our Lord.
The sages knew Jesus by sight and by faith; but we know him only by faith. Certainly we can know about him by education, instruction, reading and study; certainly we can be very well informed about his titles, commandments, teachings, ministry and saving work; but in and above and through this knowledge about him we must know him by faith – that is to be practically and experimentally (experientally) in touch and fellowship with him. To know God requires knowledge about him from his self-revelation but the real knowing is by faith, a faith that works by love.
In this mortal life and in this evil age, the baptized people of God are on a journey, and it is a journey which has a goal, a real goal, and it is a journey in which faith in the Incarnate Son of God is the primary means of staying on the road, which is a narrow way towards the end of that road. The end of the road is to gaze upon the glory of the Father as it shines in the face of the Lord Jesus Christ and to serve the Holy Trinity unto ages of ages. For inside the gates of heaven faith will be fulfilled in sight of Jesus and hope will be fulfilled in the beatific vision. As the star led the pilgrims from the East towards the Saviour, so the revealed word of God as taught in the Church of God, our “Mother”, teaches the people of God to walk by faith in the light of Christ Jesus towards the land of promise. There they will taste the glorious fruit of perfect communion with the Godhead, that is with the Person of the Father through the Person of the Incarnate Son by the presence of the Person of the Holy Ghost.
In its original medieval form in Latin this Collect prayed: “May we be led onwards, until we come to gaze upon thy Majesty by sight.” The journey is important for by it we are prepared in heart and mind (through testing and chastisement) for the contemplating, adoring and gazing upon the Majesty of God as this is reflected through, by and in the Incarnate Son. However, let us be clear, the journey is not important in and of itself but only as it is the means, the pilgrimage, ordained by God to bring us through the evil world into the world of pure delight, the heavenly Jerusalem.
The sages of the East saw the Majesty of God clothed in humility and in relative poverty and then they returned home to live by faith until they were given the sight of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ at death. But the baptized people of God head for the Goal and when they reach it they remain there for ever going from “glory unto glory” in the glorious light of the heavenly Lamb of God, and surrounded by the redeemed people of God and the hierarchy of heavenly choirs.
January 5, 2006 petertoon@msn.com
Sunday, December 25, 2005
Collects to Pray on Christmas Day
In the Ecclesia Anglicana before she began to use English (as the Church of England) for the whole of the Liturgy in 1549, there were Three Latin Collects for Christmas Day. The Missal of Sarum (Salisbury) in use up to 1549 made provision for three Masses for this high festival – one at cockcrow, one at the break of dawn, and one in full daylight. (No midnight Mass then!)
At the Mass at cockcrow the Collect prayed (in translation):
O God, who madest this most sacred night to shine with the brightness of the true Light; Grant, we beseech thee, that we, as we have known the revelations of the Light upon earth, so we may also have the fruition of his joys in heaven; who with thee and the Holy Ghost liveth and reigneth one God world without end. Amen.
This recalls Jesus as the Light of the world especially as he is so presented in the Prologue and Text of the Gospel according to St. John.
At the Mass at dawn the Collect prayed:
Grant, we beseech thee, Almighty God, to us upon whom the new light of the Word made flesh is shed forth, that the light which shines by faith in our hearts may also shine brightly in our works. Through the same Jesus Christ, thy Son, our Lord. Amen.
This also specifically recalls the Prologue of the Gospel according to St. John.
At the Mass in the full light of day the Collect prayed:
Grant, we beseech thee, Almighty God, that the new birth of thy only-begotten Son through the flesh may set free those, who are held fast by the old bondage under the yoke of sin. Through the same Jesus Christ, thy Son, our Lord. Amen.
Here the Incarnation of the Son of God, born from Mary his virgin mother, is seen as the basis for the salvation offered to us through the same Jesus Christ.
In the provision for the new Book of the Common Prayer (1549), the reformed Church of England provided only one Collect along with the Epistle and Gospel set for the third Mass in the Latin Church. However this Collect was a new creation from the hand of Archbishop Thomas Cranmer.
Almighty God, who hast given us thy only-begotten Son to take our nature upon him, and as at this time to be born of a pure Virgin; Grant that we being regenerate, and made thy children by adoption and grace, may daily be renewed by thy Holy Spirit through the same Lord Jesus Christ, who liveth and reigneth with thee and the same Spirit, ever one God, world without end. Amen.In this Collect we have a most beautiful combination of sound doctrine and of inspired petition.
The Son of God was the Second Person of the Holy Trinity before he took to himself human nature in the womb of the Virgin Mary. At the Annunciation and Conception, Mary conceived Jesus miraculously by the presence of the Holy Ghost; at the same time the Son of God who had eternally his divine nature acquired the beginnings of a human nature, so he became One Person made known in two natures, divine and human.
As the Son of God was born according to his human nature from Mary, Blessed Virgin, so each of us is to be born of the Holy Ghost into the kingdom of God and thereby made into the adopted children of God, through the love of the Father and the grace of the Son, our Lord Jesus Christ.
And as the Son of God in his human nature lived as Jesus of Nazareth, fulfilling the vocation of the Messiah and Suffering Servant of God, so we are to fulfill the vocation of the children of God called unto holiness and service in the kingdom and church of God our Father.
Christmas is a time for rejoicing with the heavenly host that the Son of God has become man for us and our salvation. It is also a time to see and accept what is the vocation of the regenerate children of God and by the help of the Holy Ghost fulfill the same.
A BLESSED AND JOYFUL TWELVE DAYS OF CHRISTMAS!
Peter Toon December 23, 2005
Friday, December 16, 2005
Russian Orthodox Back Vatican Stance On Gays.
“Homosexuality was called a sin in Holy Scripture – there’s no possibility of any other interpretation,” said Fr Igor Vyzhanov, chairman of the Moscow Patriarchate’s Commission for Inter-Christian Dialogue. “There are certain differences in how we handle candidates for priesthood, since celibacy is obligatory for Catholics whereas Orthodox can marry if they don’t aspire to hierarchical posts. But there’s total agreement between both Churches as concerns candidates’ homosexual tendencies.”
The priest was speaking a fortnight after an instruction by the Vatican’s Congregation for Catholic Education reaffirmed the Catholic Church’s “profound respect” for homosexuals, but said Catholic seminaries should not admit students for ordination who “practise homosexuality, present deep-seated homosexual tendencies or support the so-called ‘gay culture’”.
He told Russia’s Interfax newsagency Orthodox leaders were “astonished” at attempts by Protestant communities “to revise Biblical teachings”, believing it reflected their “dependence on influence from secular currents devoid of all moral foundations”.
“Homosexuals should be viewed as people suffering from a serious illness,” said Fr Vyzhanov, who handles the Russian Church’s ties with Catholics. “If laypeople are forbidden to engage in homosexual acts, so much more should priesthood candidates and Church people seek not political correctness, but a firm foundation for their faith in life.”
The comments came as another Russian Orthodox leader repeated his call for a “Catholic-Orthodox Alliance” to negotiate with European institutions and other faiths on behalf of “traditional Christianity”.
“The main themes would be social, ethical and bioethical questions and family policy,” Bishop Hilarion Alfeyev, the Church’s representative to the European Union, told an inter-Church conference in Vienna. “But the group could also work out a code of behaviour for Catholics in predominantly Orthodox countries and for Orthodox in Catholic countries. In this way, it could contribute to overcoming the problem of proselytism.”
Catholic-Orthodox ties have long been tense in Russia and Eastern Europe over Orthodox complaints of Catholic proselytism, as well as over the revival of Greek or Eastern Catholic churches, who combine the eastern liturgy with loyalty to Rome and are known pejoratively as “Uniates” by Orthodox leaders.
An International Commission for Catholic-Orthodox Theological Dialogue met again this week in Rome, five years after breaking down over the issue of “Uniatism” at its last session in Baltimore, in the United States.
Bishop Hilarion said he believed Catholic Bishops’ Conferences should “unite their efforts” with Orthodox Churches to stem Europe’s “rapid de-Christianisation” and prevent the continent from losing its “centuries-old Christian identity”.
Jonathan Luxmoore, Warsaw
http://www.thetablet.co.uk/cgi-bin/citw.cgi/past-00261#EUROPE
Thursday, December 15, 2005
The Demise of Evangelicals in PECUSA: A cautionary tale
Why did such a large party, with such distinctive views, collapse and disappear? Professor Gillis J. Harp has made a major beginning in answering this question by his essay entitled, “The Strange Death of Episcopalianism” in Anglican and Episcopal History, Volume LXXIV, No.2., 2005, pp.180ff. He groups his different explanations under three headings – generational (the torch was not passed on by the older generation to the young one), institutional (the seminaries did not maintain and commend a viable evangelical Faith, Churchmanship and lifestyle); and cultural/theological (evangelicals tended to be of step with the romanticism and idealism whereas the new school of anglo-catholicism walked more in step with them). To these he adds two further factors, the departure of some Evangelicals to form the Reformed Episcopal Church in 1873 and before this, the American Civil War which (in my judgment he does not emphasize sufficiently) seriously caused the weakening of the evangelical party.
I do urge my readers to study what Dr Harp has written and follow up suggestions in his notes.
My particular interest here is to suggest that the massive demise of Evangelicalism in the PECUSA provides us with a “cautionary tale” (I am rather fond of this expression for in his Preface to my first book, The Emergence of Hyper-Calvinism in England [1967] Dr James I Packer stated that the story I told of the formation of this extreme type of Calvinism was a cautionary tale to all would-be Calvinists!) And this 19th century story of PECUSA Evangelicals is a cautionary tale not only to present-day Evangelicals in the ECUSA and AMiA but also to old-style Anglo-Catholics in the Continuing Anglican jurisdictions and also in the ECUSA.
In the latter part of the 19th century, the general cultural setting was such as to make the ceremonial, ritualism and drama of anglo-catholic liturgy more appealing to Episcopalians than the stolid and formal low-church, evangelical service of the Word. The shape and content of the Eucharist in the candle-lit building was more attractive than the preacher in a Geneva gown speaking from the big pulpit after the singing of canticles. The Evangelicals tended to carry on after the Civil War as before and much like they did at the beginning of the 19th century. They united their changeless Gospel to a seemingly changeless presentation and dress. And that dress was not in fashion after the mid-century. Apparently they did not distinguish the essence from the social and cultural setting and thus they did not do sufficient to adapt in terms of music, drama and the aesthetics of their services and liturgy. They acted as though the reading and exposition of the Word of God alone done in an eighteenth-century style would be sufficient to maintain the cause. And all this was done, to a large degree, because they believed that they were resisting the inroads of [roman] Catholicism into the Protestant ECUSA.
And so while the Evangelicals fumbled, the Anglo-Catholics (the “ritualists”) gained greater support; and even the low and broad churchmen of the day began slowly to make their services more colorful and ornate.
Evangelicalism wearing its early 19th century dress was not acceptable to churchgoers in the last part of the same century and so it did not reproduce itself and it gradually died out. Further, the three evangelical seminaries lost their fervor in mid-century and so they produced more ministers for the broad church school than for the evangelical cause. And once a great movement gets into decline, then the decline tends to accelerate! So Evangelicalism went off the map!
What is the cautionary tale here?
Perhaps it is that a church cannot live on nostalgia and imagine it can either maintain or re-create a past period of bliss or success. The 19th century Evangelicals erred in their seeking to keep the old ways in place when the changing world around them required that they adapt to be seen and heard. Modern traditionalists in the ECUSA and in the Continuing Jurisdictions, whatever their churchmanship, have to face this temptation and danger of thinking that, for example, the 1950s, before the ravages of the 1960s, is the decade to be made present again for then the traditional ways seemed to prosper.
Or perhaps it is that the Evangelical movement to be “successful” has to be securely based on Scripture and the classic Formularies, but at the same time has to be open to a variety of possible ways of worshipping God and serving him – without denying its true character. If it goes overboard on the side of relevance, simplicity and acceptability, then it loses its classic character and its Anglican nature; if it simply glories in its security in Scripture and the Formularies, then it soon ceases to be an active church. The 19th century Evangelicals had the Faith but they put it in sealed boxes, as it were, and so their worship and witness began to lose authenticity and appeal.
Modern ECUSA Evangelicals seem not to be in danger of losing the desire to minister to their generation in appropriate ways, but they are perhaps dangerously near to losing hold on their roots, of forgetting the historic and classic Formularies of the Anglican Way. So they are possibly near to being merely Evangelicals who happen to use a simplified liturgy, and, as such, they may be a long way from the wholeness of the Anglican Way.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Evangelicalism in the [Protestant] Episcopal Church of the USA: The mid-19th and early 21st centuries contrasted
Looking back, the evangelical school of the Church of England and the Protestant Episcopal Church in the mid-nineteenth century may be characterized in six ways, by its commitment to:
- Conversionism – expecting repenting, believing sinners to have an experience of conversion;
- Activism – showing evangelistic energy and busy pastoral work;
- Biblicism – committed to the final authority of the holy Scriptures for faith and conduct;
- Crucicentrism -- preaching the message of Christ crucified and teaching the centrality of the Atonement at Calvary;
- Churchmenism – loyal members of the national Church and committed to its Formularies as evangelical Churchmen; and
- Anti-Ritualism – opposed to the emerging agenda in liturgy and doctrine of the anglo-catholic movement.
In the 19th century USA Evangelicals founded three seminaries (in Alexandria VA, in Gambier, OH, and in Philadelphia, PA), published newspapers (Episcopal Record and The Episcopalian) and ran evangelistic and educational societies (e.g. the Evangelical Knowledge Society). They were in mid-century a force to be reckoned with!
Yet, by 1914 this school or party was gone and the reasons for it cannot simply be attributed to schism which led to the formation of The Reformed Episcopal Church in 1873, for this schism only took a small proportion of the evangelical clergy and laity out of the PECUSA.
For too long insufficient academic effort has been devoted to seeking to establish the reasons for the total demise of the evangelical party in PECUSA. However, with the publication of the essay “The Strange Death of Evangelical Episcopalianism” by Professor Gillis J. Harp in Anglican and Episcopal History, Vol LXXIV, No 2, 2005, pp/180 ff. a wrong has been righted and we are well on the way to discovering what happened to the Evangelical School and its institutions, parishes and organizations.
I urge the serious-minded to read this essay, if for no other reason that it is a “cautionary tale” from which modern Evangelicals can possibly learn. (I will return to its thesis in a further e-mail essay.)
The introduction of Evangelicalism into the (now) ECUSA in the 1970s is easy to explain for it was basically an implant, although there were those within ECUSA (a) of the more hearty Low Church School and (b) who had been influenced by the Charismatic Movement (via Dennis Bennet, Terry Fulham et al) who were most welcoming of the new religion. This new Evangelicalism shared the characteristics of conversionism, activism, Biblicism and crucicentrism. Yet it did so in what we may call a generic evangelical way (being much influenced by the strong, general evangelical movement of the period). Regrettably, it was not specifically committed to the historic formularies of the Church (for in the ECUSA these were removed in the 1970s) and it was more than content to use the new forms of liturgy and new paraphrases of the Bible then being pressed on parishes by their bishops, for these new creations were seen as being relevant, accessible and simple because in contemporary language. Further, it was happy to work within a basic ritualism (which liberal Catholicism had introduced with the new forms of liturgy) and to call its clergy “Father” – because it was not conscious of or perhaps interested in the doctrinal questions involved (see Peter Toon, Evangelical Theology 1833-1856, A Response to Tractarianism, 1979, UK & USA).
If we look at the Evangelical movement now in the ECUSA as found for example in The Network we can see that it is the true continuation of that which was begun in the 1970s. It does not seriously question anything that was in place in the ECUSA when it was started and it only protests against innovations that it has seen emerge during its own lifetime – e.g., forms of extreme inclusive language; the requirement that all office holders agree to the ordination of women, and most obviously the blessing of same-sex couples and the ordaining of persons in such partnerships.
Thus its members find somewhat irrelevant the calls from some quarters (e.g. the Prayer Book Society of the USA) for the restoration of the historic and classic Formularies as the standard of Faith for the Church, and the making of the 1979 Book to be what it actually is in its content, a Book of Alternative Services. They are, however, more sensitive to the calls for a restoration of marriage discipline for in their sober, reflective moments they know that the present situation of the right of any divorcee to remarriage in church and the high percentage of divorced and remarried clergy are scandalous – as is also the culture that allows abortion as a means of birth control.
My own hope is that the present Evangelical (and also Charismatic) school that dominates The Network’s membership will make time to look seriously at the Evangelical Movement in history and will be prepared to add to its zeal for evangelization and church growth a zeal for true and proper foundations in Scripture and the historic Formularies for the Anglican Way. I hope it will discover a genuine hearty and zealous form of Reformed Catholicism as the true religion of the Anglican Way, which on this sure foundation, is a truly comprehensive Way, allowing for a variety of churchmanship and theological emphases!
petertoon@msn.com December 15, 2005
Monday, December 12, 2005
When Christmas triumphs over the Lord’s Day
While Christmas as a Festival kept annually by the Church only goes back to the fourth century, the Lord’s Day, the first Day of the week, as the weekly Celebration of the resurrection of the Lord Jesus from the dead goes back to the apostolic age (see Revelation 1: 10).
The English Puritans and Scottish Presbyterians – and their New England descendants – did not celebrate Christmas because it was not clearly a biblical festival, there being no command with reference to it in the New Testament. They treated it as a normal day. However, they did have a very high doctrine of the Lord’s Day as the Christian Sabbath and the keeping of this was a basic moral duty (see the Ten Commandments!).
Against this background, it is at first sight perhaps NOT surprising to see an advert such as this which appeared in Oklahoma recently:
However it is surprising for here we find an amazing thing -- that the leadership of a supposed Christian congregation, a very large one, is saying that there is NO duty to worship God the Father in the Name of the Lord Jesus on the weekly celebration of the resurrection in late December. What may be called the secular understanding of Christmas – family get together for a holiday celebration – has triumphed and the assembly of Christians is closed down on that day which is this year, nothing less than the Lord’s Day. (And the same is happening in many similar churches of the Willow Creek type across the USA.)Life Church
Christmas Eve Worship ExperiencesJoin us on December 24 at the Oklahoma City Campus for our Christmas Eve celebration! Experiences will be held at 2:30 PM, 4 PM, 5:30 PM, and 7 PM.
Because Christmas falls on a Sunday this year, all Christmas worship experiences will take place on Saturday December 24, Christmas Eve only. There will be not be worship experiences on Sunday, December 25.
It is our most sincere hope that you will be able to use this opportunity to spend some time with your family and enjoy the holiday together.
The practice of being user-friendly, relevant and “with it” has here clearly triumphed over the clear teaching of the New Testament and the requirement of the law of God.
In defense of the leadership of the “Life Church” one may note that they are asking people to attend services on the Saturday, the 24th. However, why they could not have also opened their building for one service, just one, for those who have a sense of “Sunday duty” is puzzling. Also why they could not, like the Catholic Church, have a Midnight Celebration, on the 24th, is also puzzling. For they are not like the Puritans of the 17th and 18th centuries who abolished Christmas but most seriously kept the Lord’s Day. In fact they are so committed to Christmas as a public holiday and general family get-to-together that they are ready to close down their church on the festival day, even if that day is the day of days, the festival of the Resurrection of Jesus from the dead.
What is clear is that churches such as this one in Oklahoma will (at least in the short term) grow in numbers and popularity. It may be observed that at least part of their attraction is that they tailor Christianity to fit into American life so that there is a minimum break with American culture and society for church members.
In contrast, the fullness of Catholic & Evangelical doctrine and practice stands in in contrast to, even in conflict with, much American culture and practice.
Maybe this Christmas we all need to hear these solemn words:
“Enter by the narrow gate. For the gate is wide and the way is easy that leads to destruction, and those who enter it are many. For the gate is narrow and the way is hard that leads to life and those who find it are few.” (Jesus in the Sermon on the Mount)
petertoon@msn.com December 12, 2005
Sunday, December 11, 2005
Anglican Formularies – Are Evangelicals really missing out?
When an evangelical and/or charismatic Episcopalian congregation is told: “the Formularies are necessary, and, while you can be ECUSA members without them, you cannot be genuine Anglicans without them,” it responds by making it clear that such talk is irrelevant, untrue and unhelpful.
However, for the few who pay a little attention to this message, questions arise like: What are the Formularies? Which of our leaders has said anything about them? We have the Scriptures which are our authority for faith and conduct; we are submitted to the Lordship of Christ, and we are obeying the great commission to evangelize, what more is there?
And thus even the few, who are busy with good works, deem the pursuit of this matter not urgent and thus suitable perhaps for another day.
But a few of the few go past this point and are ready to learn that the Formularies are those forms of doctrine which stand under the authority of Scripture to indicate the nature and character of the Anglican Way as a jurisdiction in the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. And so the questions that this minority raise are: Are not the old Book of Common Prayer, Ordination Services, and Thirty-Nine Articles from the sixteenth century and do they not speak to their own place and time? Why do we need Formularies when we have good translations of the Bible, the Creeds, and commentaries on the Bible to unlock its meaning to us?
And so most in this minority stop here. There are many things to do and to pursue and this matter is not first on the agenda but may could be looked at later – maybe in a Lenten course.
Finally, the very tiny minority who get past these questions, and who accept the necessity of Formularies to be the means of providing both the standards of, and the direction for, a national Church (e.g., C of E) and then for each of the member churches of a Communion of Churches (Anglican), ask such questions as: How can we convince our brethren that the Anglican Way is actually by nature and in character Reformed Catholicism and that as such it has its basic, foundational Formularies, without which it is as a boat without a rudder on the ocean, i.e., that it is merely a liturgical form of modern generic evangelicalism sailing in circles on the same ocean? How can we arrange our own worship, life and witness so that they are true to the Scriptures and to the form of Christianity, Reformed Catholicism, which we have embraced?
And this very tiny minority, though feeling satisfied in their own souls that they are where they ought to be, are very conscious that the majority around them claims the name of “Anglican” for what seem to be only experiential, practical and administrative reasons – not for genuine, historic and classical doctrinal ones.
Perhaps here is the right place to reflect for a moment on the word “Formulary”, which is not a word in common usage, but an important word, nevertheless, as it has been used in serious Anglican discourse consistently since the sixteenth century. The Latin word, formularius (liber) [=a book of formulae], on which it is based, pointed to a collection of set forms or instructions for the performance or direction of a ceremony or an official duty. Thus a “formulary’ within a national Church is a book which contains the set forms and rules of what the Church believes, teaches and confesses, the liturgy it uses, and the way it creates the ordained Ministry. In reforming itself in the sixteenth century, the Ecclesia Anglicana reformed its Formularies (those which had been in force in the medieval period) to create three new ones – The Book of Common Prayer, The Book of Ordination Services [Ordinal] and The Thirty-Nine Articles, along with a new edition of Canon Law. Under the authority of Scripture, these summed up and presented the standards, norms and means by which the reformed Church of England sought to be the national jurisdiction of the Catholic Church of God. These Formularies not only provided the way to worship and serve God daily but they also distinguished the Church of England from other jurisdictions in Scotland and Europe. Take away the Formularies and leave only the Bible and what you have is a Church without shape, form and substance for there are no common standards or guidelines to govern all the many parts and keep them together as one.
Until the 1960s Anglicans were usually well aware of the Formularies, for they used the Book of Common Prayer for worship daily, the Ordinal for all services of ordination to the diaconate, priesthood and episcopate, and the Thirty-Nine Articles for learning the doctrine of the Anglican Way (clergy used excellent, learned commentaries on the Articles as their text-books in doctrine – see the CD of twelve such texts from the Prayer Book Society, www.anglicanmarketplace.com ). Then with the advent of new translations of the Bible, new liturgies, the addressing God as “You” not “Thou” and the near obsession with relevance, credibility, and simplicity, Episcopalians and Anglicans in the West began to lose touch with their roots.
The Episcopal Church put much energy, money and propaganda into creating new services and then published them under the old name of that which was being rejected! The book of varied, modern services was called The Book of Common Prayer (1979) and this became (with its own services for ordination and its own new Catechism) the one and only Formulary of the Episcopal Church. The Formularies which had been in place until then were set aside and known as historical documents.
This being so evangelical Episcopalians (as also progressive liberal Episcopalians and anglo-catholic Episcopalians) in the ECUSA are committed by their ordination vows (unless they repudiate it) to the Formulary which is the 1979 Prayer Book, and there by are committed to the revised form, greatly changed form, of the Anglican Way that it represents. (In Canada, the new Book of Services was deliberately called, The Book of Alternative Services (1985) to distinguish it from the classic BCP which remains the Formulary of that Church.)
The presence of this new Formulary it must be said has been a major factor in allowing the General Convention to continue its revision of received doctrine, morality and discipline, for most of its innovations are in harmony with the form of doctrine in the 1979 Prayer Book.
Happily the Anglican Mission in America has restored the classic Formularies of the Anglican Way to its foundation, and is now involved in asking what this means for its present forms of worship, witness and mission. (Regrettably, in my view this is occurring too slowly but it is occurring!)
Unhappily, the Anglican Communion Network has not yet gone very far on the way to the adoption of the historic Formularies (as received by the Protestant Episcopal Church from 1789-1979), partly because the ECUSA affiliation of virtually all its membership makes this seemingly impossible, and partly that it is not yet convinced of the need for it in order to be truly Anglican (even though the Anglican Church of Nigeria has made a very clear statement of commitment to the classic BCP, Ordinal & Articles).
The fact remains that the Anglican Way is Reformed Catholicism and that as such it has its Formularies, and that without these as foundation and guide, it ceases to be a viable Jurisdiction of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. Precisely how this works out in the twenty-first century is a task which requires great knowledge, wisdom, discernment and sensitivity and, regrettably, it is a task from which Episcopalians and Anglicans have been diverted for too long!
petertoon@msn.com December 11, 2005
Saturday, December 10, 2005
Chicken or the Egg? Which came first, enlightenment from the Bible or from the culture?
Certainly the local church/congregation cannot avoid being in the world, situated in specific place at a given time, and this means it is within a given society and culture which in outreach it has seriously to take into account. Yet the church is not to be conformed to the world even as it seeks to be for the world – that is, for its conversion to God, for its spiritual and moral renovation and for its physical welfare.
When the surrounding society and culture is part of “Christendom” and is generally governed by Christian views of personal and family life, then the pressure on the Church to follow the world and be conformed to it is not usually towards the changing of the internal doctrine of the Church. Rather it is more towards a dull orthodoxy and nominal Christianity.
However, when the surrounding society and culture is rejecting Christendom and adopting secular principles and values, then the pressure on the Church to modify or change its doctrine, worship, moral teaching and discipline becomes intense. The members of the Church live in a society where new and exciting ideas are being propagated and where calls are being made for changes that seem to be just and reasonable. Such a situation was faced by the Churches in Europe and the USA from the time when the Enlightenment made its impact in the late 19th century and the intensity of this pressure reached its zenith in the period after World War II to the present time.
If we now look only at one denomination in the USA it will be the easier to face the question concerning the chicken and the egg. We know that the Episcopal Church made great changes or introduced major innovations from 1950 to 2005. Did these arise because this Church, as inspired or pressed by changes in society and culture, began to see truths in the Bible that she had previously missed? Or did these arise because she consciously or unconsciously followed or imitated society and then looked to the Bible for justification? Or did these arise partly through the reading of Scripture and partly through the imitation of secular trends?
The major innovations of this period adopted by the Church seem to be the following: the acceptance of artificial means of birth control, including abortion, in some cases, as morally acceptable; widespread marriage of divorcees in church as morally acceptable; full membership and rights for all ethnic and racial minorities; the ordination of women to the Three Orders of Ministry contrary to the long tradition of a male-only Ministry; the creation and adoption of a new Prayer Book (a Book of Varied Services) which was falsely called “the Book of Common Prayer” as if it were another edition of the classic Book of Common Prayer; the commitment to new language for God and human beings which recognizes that women are half the population; the acceptance that there is a minority in society who are “homosexual” in “orientation” and that as such they should be given full membership of the Church and full rights therein; and the emergence of the office of bishop as the Chief Executive Office and Chief Liturgical Officer of the diocese.
When we examine these innovations it is reasonably clear (and sociological studies are conforming this) that in most cases it was clearly a case of the Church following trends and changes in society and culture.
In the case of remarriage, there was a tremendous increase in divorce after World War II and the Church, it may be claimed, acted pastorally by first counseling and then blessing the marriages of many divorcees. What began as a pastoral emergency became the way things were and still are – with nearly half of the adult membership divorced and remarried. Re- marriage in church is now an established right. (In this general context, the purpose of marriage was redefined in terms of personal fulfillment and in this procreation became an option!)
In the case of the ordination of women, again it is clear that the powerful forces of secular feminism were felt within the Church and it was these which caused a majority to vote for the entry of women into the Ministry even as they were entering other “professions.” Again, in the case of active “homosexuals” being admitted to full membership including ordination, it is a clear case of the Church following what was occurring in society and culture.
Now in these three cases, the experiential context is that once you feel convinced that what is being done is right then you will look for ways to justify it or at least show it is not wrong from your sacred tradition, especially your holy Books. This led to new ways both of translating the Bible and of interpreting the Bible. Texts which previously said “No” now said “Yes”. These new ways are now thought of by many as the normal ways. But the use of the Bible was secondary to the influence of secular teachings.
If we think about the granting of full membership rights to ethnic minorities then we are perhaps in a different context. While the pressure came from society, it was pressure led in the main by persons who were acting out of Christian faith and morality (e.g. Dr Martin Luther King). So in this instance the Episcopal Church did what was right and what had been there for all to see in the Bible since the apostolic age – to make clear that in Baptism and church membership there is equality of races and the sexes.
The changing role of bishops to become CEOs is obviously imitative of the way business is supposedly run efficiently; and the training of clergy to be skilled in counseling and management (so as to manage well a congregation) reflects both the influence of theories from secular management and secular psychology. The latter have been tremendously influence on a whole range of doctrines and practices creating sometimes a therapeutical religion.
Finally, the readiness of the General Convention publicly to endorse a falsehood in the title of its new prayer book, points to the arrogance and self-confidence of a Church that believed that it is autonomous and that majority decisions made by it are the will of God!
The spirit of the 1960s had gone, as it were, to its head and it believed that the majority vote was the action of the Divine Spirit. The Episcopal Church still glories in its autonomy and that it abides by its rules meticulously in its innovating!
What is abundantly clear is that the Episcopal Church has in terms of its worship, doctrine, discipline, language used to address God, and polity changed dramatically – even as it has diminished in membership and influence – since World War II, and especially from the late 1960s. It is also very clear that it has been secular forces which have supplied the major energy and ideology to cause this dramatic change, and to set in motion an avalanche that is apparently impossible to stop.
The amazing thing is that in a few dioceses, and in parishes in other dioceses, there has been a remnant which has not been taken in by the whole of the innovations, but which has managed to keep at bay some of them, and thus by God’s favor maintain a semblance if not an example of godly worship, order and piety! Whether the remnant can and will hold out remains an open question!
petertoon@msn.com December 10, 2005