Tuesday, November 08, 2005
Commitment to Christianity Depends On How It Is Measured
(Ventura, CA) – Four out of every five adults in the United States consider themselves to be Christian. How committed are they to the Christian faith? It depends on how you measure commitment. That’s the conclusion of a new report from The Barna Group, based on nationwide surveys with a random sample of 4015 people conducted this year. The research explored eight different measures of people’s commitment to their faith and found that the outcomes ranged from a low of 16% to a high of 72%.
Eight Measures of Commitment
The indicators of commitment that showed the broadest attachment were those that assessed people’s psychological commitment to their chosen faith. Those types of measures included the following:
· “Have you ever made a personal commitment to Jesus Christ that is still important in your life today?” (72% said “yes”)
· “Your religious faith is very important in your life today.” (71% strongly agreed)
· “Would you describe yourself as deeply spiritual?” (60% said “yes”)
The research found that more demanding involvement in practical forms of Christianity generated lower scores. Those measures included the following:
· “The single, most important purpose of your life is to love God with all your heart, mind, strength and soul.” (62% strongly agreed)
· “Would you describe yourself as a full-time servant of God?” (53% said “yes”)
· “How committed are you to the Christian faith?” (42% said they are “absolutely committed”)
The lowest scores were recorded for the pair of indicators that required the most intense level of participation in the Christian faith.
· 29% had attended a church service, prayed to God and read from the Bible during the past week.
· 16% said the highest priority in their life was their faith.
Who’s Most Committed?
A demographic analysis of the eight measures of commitment showed highly consistent trends in relation to gender, age, region, ethnicity and faith subgroups.
Women were more likely than men to express a higher level of commitment to the Christian faith for all eight of the factors studied. On average, women were 36% more likely to register commitment regarding the factor in question. A majority of women expressed commitment in relation to six of the eight factors; in comparison, a majority of men noted personal investment in their faith in relation to just three of the eight measures.
Adults who were 40 or younger – i.e., those in the Baby Bust or Mosaic generations – were less likely than older adults to indicate commitment to their faith in relation to each of the eight measures. In addition, the survey found that the older a person was, the more likely they were to be committed to the Christian faith in connection with six out of the eight measures tested.
Residents of the South were the most likely to express significant commitment on seven of the eight measures. Adults residing in the Northeast and West were the lowest on the commitment scale for seven of the eight measures.
Blacks emerged as the ethnic group most likely to be committed to Christianity. They had the highest score of any of the four major ethnic groups in relation to seven of the eight measures tested. On average, Blacks were 39% more likely to register commitment than were whites, and 53% more likely than Hispanics. Asians were lowest on the commitment continuum in relation to seven of the eight measures. In fact, there was only one measure for which a majority of Asians exhibited commitment: 52% said their religious faith is very important to them, lagging the 68% among whites, 72% among Hispanics, and 89% among African-Americans.
Out of more than sixty subgroups studied in this research, evangelical Christians were the top-ranked people group for each of the eight measures of faith commitment. The most dramatic differences were found in relation to making their faith the highest priority in their life (55% of evangelicals claimed to do so, versus 16% of the population at-large) and demonstrating an active faith (73% had attended church, read the Bible and prayed during the preceding week, compared to 29% nationally).
Protestant adults had higher scores than did Catholics on all eight measures of commitment. On average, Protestants were 66% more likely than Catholics to say they were committed to their faith in the manner posed by the survey question.
Interpreting the Findings
George Barna, whose company conducted the research, believes that the findings reveal several insights about America’s faith. “For starters, it appears that most Americans like the security and the identity of the label ‘Christian’ but resist the biblical responsibilities that are associated with that identification. For most Americans, being a Christian is more about image than action. Further,” he continued, “researchers and those who use research data must be careful how they portray people’s spiritual commitment. Such descriptions are greatly affected by the way in which commitment is measured.”
Barna also encouraged Christian leaders to reflect on the implications of the relative lack of commitment among young adults and key ethnic groups. “Hispanics and Asians are the fastest growing ethnic groups in the country, but they are also substantially less committed to Christianity than are Caucasians relative to six of the eight measures tested. Add to that the widespread complacency toward Christianity among people under 40 and we have what amounts to a crisis of commitment facing the Church of the future.”
Source of This Information
The data reported in this summary are based upon telephone interviews with a nationwide random sample of 4015 adults conducted in 2005. The maximum margin of sampling error associated with the aggregate sample in each of these surveys is ±1.5 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. All non-institutionalized adults in the 48 contiguous states were eligible to be interviewed and the distribution of respondents in the survey sample corresponds to the geographic dispersion of the U.S. adult population. The data were subjected to slight statistical weighting procedures to calibrate the survey base to national demographic proportions. Households selected for inclusion in the survey sample received multiple callbacks to increase the probability of obtaining a representative distribution of adults.
“Evangelicals” are a subset of born again Christians in Barna surveys. In addition to meeting the born again criteria, in which people say they have made “a personal commitment to Jesus Christ that is still important in their life today” and who also indicated they believe that when they die they will go to Heaven because they had confessed their sins and had accepted Jesus Christ as their savior, evangelicals also meet seven other conditions. Those include saying their faith is very important in their life today; contending that they have a personal responsibility to share their religious beliefs about Christ with non-Christians; stating that Satan exists; maintaining that eternal salvation is possible only through grace, not works; asserting that Jesus Christ lived a sinless life on earth; saying that the Bible is totally accurate in all it teaches; and describing God as the all-knowing, all-powerful, perfect deity who created the universe and still rules it today. Further, respondents were not asked to describe themselves as “evangelical.” Being classified as “evangelical” is not dependent upon any church or denominational affiliation or involvement. Evangelicals represent 7% of the adult population.
The “Baby Bust” refers to the generation of people born from 1965 through 1983. The “Mosaic” generation includes all people born from 1984 through 2002. In this study, only those Mosaics born from 1984 through 1987 were included – that is, those who were 18 or older.
The Barna Group, Ltd. (which includes its research division, The Barna Research Group) is a privately held, for-profit corporation that conducts primary research, produces audio, visual and print media, and facilitates the healthy spiritual development of leaders, children, families and Christian ministries. Located in Ventura, California, Barna has been conducting and analyzing primary research to understand cultural trends related to values, beliefs, attitudes and behaviors since 1984. If you would like to receive free e-mail notification of the release of each new, bi-weekly update on the latest research findings from The Barna Group, you may subscribe to this free service at the Barna web site (www.barna.org). © The Barna Group, Ltd, 2005.
Monday, November 07, 2005
A Treasure in Modern Format – with extras!
This is the classic edition of the Anglican Prayer Book and has been translated into over 150 languages.
Within the covers of this new edition is also an Introduction by Professor Diarmaid MacCulloch, the leading authority on Archbishop Cranmer and his biographer.
Also there are in Appendices significant portions of the first edition of the Prayer Book, that of 1549, along with other notable historical Commemorations.
The Prayer Book Society has obtained a limited number of copies of this book. Please note that they cannot be bought on the web at www.anglicanmarketplace.com but must be ordered directly by sending a check for $20.00 (plus $2.50 for post) to
The Prayer Book Society (attention Mrs D Remenyi)
100 East Avon Road,
Parkside
PA. 19015-3306.
THERE ARE SIX COPIES LEFT AS OF November 7, 2005
TO RESERVE ONE CALL 1 800 727 1928 and speak to Debbie BEFORE POSTING A CHECK.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Revolution is occurring, says George Barna
To understand what he has found and what he supports, it is important that we recognize what he means by “church/Church.” He states: “I use the words church (small c) and Church (capital C) in very different ways. The distinction is critical. The small c church refers to the congregation-based faith experience, which involves a formal structure, a hierarchy of leadership, and a specific group of believers. The term Church, on the other hand, refers to all believers in Jesus Christ, comprising the population of heaven-bound individuals who are connected by their faith in Christ, regardless of their local church connections or involvement. Some hail this as the Church universal, as opposed to the church local. As you will see, the Revolution is designed to advance the Church and to redefine the church” (page x).
The revolutionaries are usually people who are dissatisfied with the local church or with local churches because they cannot find in them, however hard they try, an authentic pursuit of and commitment to a genuine Christianity, wherein there is a vital relationship with God through Jesus, and a consecrated life of obedience and holiness. They find in Scripture descriptions of the Church and of Christian living that cause them to look for and desire much more than the restrictions of the local church allow. And they are obsessed with the idea of being much better and more useful to God than they are now.
So mini-movements have been generated of people seeking to find alternative ways of serving God then in the local church with its limited and restricting agenda and activity. Thus there are cells, home fellowships, cyberspace meetings and the like, as well as “groups” within the local church, wherein serious people seek to become better Christian disciples of Jesus the really true “Revolutionary.”
So the Revolution has begun and, Barna predicts, will intensify, affecting America from the bottom up, as it were, as local groups function as “the salt of the earth” and “the light of the world” in their own communities. The number of committed Christians will grow but the number and size of local churches (of the old kind) will diminish, for the vital Christians will be in all kinds of loose organizations and groupings. Yet the moral and spiritual health of the nation will improve through their presence. Further, this Revolution will qualify as one of the great spiritual “awakenings” within the USA.
Comment.
I do not know how seriously to take the contents of this book. This is because so much of it is Barna the preacher and advocate commending his view of “church/Church”, and, in proportion, so little is actually basic research material/facts that the reader can consider in their own right.
His use of the New Testament to describe the Church seems to be limited virtually to the early chapters of the Acts of the Apostles. But are not the teachings of Paul, James and John in their epistles also important for understanding what is the local church and what is the universal Church?
His confidence in human nature within the revolutionaries seems to be much higher than history and experience would recommend. Even the committed revolutionaries suffer from original sin, from the temptations to individualism and idiosyncrasies, from the possibility of many sins of omission and commission, and so on. How can Barna be sure that they will not simple add to the vastness of competitive Christian groups within the present supermarket of religions in the USA? How does he know their energy will go into the pursuit of holiness and the service of man in the name of Jesus?
And what about the connection or relation of these emerging mini-movements of revolutionaries to the variety of groups, house-churches, cells and the like which already exist and are associated with, for example, the “generous orthodoxy” movement (which seeks a kind of non-denominational form of Christianity that is missional locally, seeking to show practical love, especially to the poor).
Overall, my judgment tends to be that Dr Barna has gone much too far in his claim that there really is a Revolution, and in his predictions of what this Revolution will soon become and achieve. Let us remember that there have always been those, whom we may call the remnant, within the existing churches or synagogues who have longed for a deeper, richer and more substantial expression of Christian faith within themselves as persons and within the larger structure of the churches. He has discerned such within the American evangelical churches and appears to have made too much of his discovery because of what is his own personal desire for Christian growth in the USA.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
Sexuality: Where should the line be drawn?
Few would disagree with the observation that the Church in the West in this post-modern culture has a very different estimate of what are right goals and necessary principles of sexuality than did the Church in former times, especially the patristic era, but even the Victorian era.
Few also would disagree with the observation that the approach to sexuality in today’s Church is profoundly affected by the therapeutic culture which is now endemic in western thought and feeling. For most of us a primary purpose of life is to be happy. Happiness is an end in itself, rather than a product of something else (e.g., of doing what is right, or good, or one’s duty and vocation). Self-fulfillment and self-realization are seen as important ends in connection with happiness.
The Early Church and Sex
Few also would disagree with the point that the ideal in the Early Church was that of chastity, and thus the virgin (female and male) was the symbol of purity. People today find it hard to understand why married love was not the symbol for the Early Church. Their difficulty is in part because they live in a therapeutic culture.
The only sure way that the Church in a self-indulgent, immoral society could present the Christian sexual ethic to itself and to the world in a positive and dynamic way was to emphasize, as the ideal of what the Lord loved to see, the way of purity, chastity and virginity. This kept the mind and vision focused and gave moral energy to the resisting of temptation. It did not mean that marriage was sinful but it did mean that those who by grace were enabled to do so should be virgins and be united as it were to the Lord in purity and service. By this ideal and with this standard, the Church could declare with integrity that fornication, sodomy and adultery were sins, which if not repented of, would keep even baptized persons out of the kingdom of heaven. Further, the Church was able to make Christian marriage sacramental as a one flesh union of a man and woman until that union was broken by death. Further, the purpose of holy matrimony was mutual comfort and procreation, as well as the avoiding of fornication.
Of course, there were many failures and there were multiple scandals and there was hypocrisy, for human beings are not only sinners but sinful; BUT there was also the divine offer of forgiveness to those who were penitent. Importantly, forgiveness did not reduce standards but it lifted up those who had fallen. And there was a penitential system in place to deal with this pastoral problem of the weak and the fallen in a way which did not compromise the ideal.
So there was no compromise. The Church preached and asked for the highest of standards and believed the grace of God sufficient to help people reach them. In this context, it made sense to proclaim that adultery, fornication and sodomy were sinful and to deal with them as such in the penitential system.
Contemporary Liberal Denominations
Today, the Church, especially the main-line liberal denominations like the Episcopal, asks for the lowest standards and expects even less then these! Deeply affected by the therapeutic culture, the Church accepts in practice if not in doctrine all sexual unions which claim to be seeking self-fulfillment and based on “love” and “faithfulness’ – e.g., in serial monogamy, opposite sex and same-sex partnerships. The ideal now is not virginity and chastity but rather self-realization, self-fulfillment and happiness therein. Any “love” that leads in this direction is acceptable for is not God as God “Love”? What is wrong and sinful today is “loveless” sexual intimacy and relationships!
The Evangelical Stance
However, there are those within the liberal denominations (e.g., the Network in the ECUSA) who believe that a line can be drawn and maintained in the contemporary churches at homosexual practice (not homosexual orientation as such).
That is, the Church proclaims the ideal of marriage between a woman and a man as a life-long partnership and teaches that all other forms of sexual intimacy are wrong. However, this ideal is not taught as a divine command or real standard but as that to which the faithful should strive and if they reach it, then congratulation! If they fail there is divorce and remarriage, even serial monogamy, for their right to fulfillment of their sexual drive and desires is paramount in a therapeutic culture.
In this system, wherein there is not any kind of penitential system or the hope of one, but only local therapeutic “counseling”, the inevitable result is that it is very difficult to teach against and prevent the widespread living together of men and women in short-term or long –term partnerships either before marriage or as a substitute for marriage. After all, they only seek personal fulfillment and happiness in a loving relationship. It is less difficult to argue against same-sex partnerships for they appear to be contrary to nature and to gut feelings of what is decent and right, not to mention biblical commands. Yet as same-sex unions are increasingly recognized by law and by culture, opposing them, specially when nice people are involved, gets more difficult day by day for the conservative Christian to do.
Conclusion
It would appear that only the Church which has the ideal of Virginity, together with a penitential [not a counseling] system, has any hope in the therapeutic culture of the West of maintaining a Christian doctrine and practice of biblical sexuality and sexual relations! A modern denomination, or part thereof, which has lowered the bar to lifelong marriage as an ideal (but has not made the ideal a true standard and divine requirement) and works with counseling will, like the city of New Orleans, see its walls continually broken by the floodtide of the modern sexual culture.
November 7, 2005 The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Saturday, November 05, 2005
What the Prayer Book Society Is
THE PRAYER BOOK SOCIETY OF THE U.S.A.
P.O. Box 35220, Philadelphia, PA 19128-0220
1-800-727-1928 & www.episcopalian.org/pbs1928
- ACCEPTS that there is one Book of Common Prayer which has appeared in many editions, of which the first was in 1549.
- SEEKS to keep in print the latest American edition of this Book, the edition of 1928.
- ENCOURAGES the use with understanding not only of the American edition, but also of the Canadian (1962) and the English (1662).
- RECOGNIZES that some recent Prayer Books which bear the title of “Common Prayer” are not editions of the authentic, one Book of Common Prayer, but are in fact Books of varied services and thus have the wrong title.
- BELIEVES that the Formularies of the Anglican Way are the authentic Book of Common Prayer, the Ordinal and the Articles.
- PRODUCES books, booklets, and CDs to educate people in the nature and content of Common Prayer ( www.anglicanmarketplace.com).
- PUBLISHES in fine leather the Altar Edition of the American edition of The Book of Common Prayer (1928).[call 1-800-727-1928 for information]
- COMMUNICATES with its members and friends bi-monthly through its magazine, Mandate (call 1-800-727-1928 for a copy).
- WORKS both within the Anglican Communion and also amongst Anglicans outside it.
- COOPERATES with similar Societies in Canada, Great Britain and Australia.
- INVITES people who care for the integrity of the Anglican Way to join the Society and thereby seek to keep Anglican Churches worshipping the Lord our God in the beauty of holiness, in spirit and in truth.
Escaping from the Three B’s
Do the people within them need to escape from the throttle of the Three B’s?
If you are interested in the answer, please read on!
By the kindness of the Rector of St Luke’s Seattle, I attended a Conference on “Generous Orthodoxy” in Seattle in the first week of November 2005. About 400 people were there and they were mostly from non-denominational groups. In fact many of them had apparently left denominational churches (from Catholic to Pentecostal) in order to discover who is Jesus and to practice what Christianity and the local church (meaning people rather than building) are really and truly all about. Their focus appears to be on Jesus, on a simple spirituality to know God through Jesus, and on loving the neighbor through local community outreach. Their creed is what they have come to call “generous orthodoxy” which is nothing to do with the dogma of the Early Church! Rather, it is a readiness to embrace insights and practices from the wide variety of Christian traditions of devotion and spirituality that have existed and still exist in the USA. To affirm all rather than to defend one and to be generous to one another and especially to the needy and disadvantaged locally. The expression “generous orthodoxy” is from the title of a recent book by Brian MacLaren, who is a key person/mentor in this movement.
One female minister (who with her husband pastors one of these local non-denominational churches that does not own property) described her “journey” from the stress of the three B’s to the liberation of the three C’s. In her denominational church where she was a clergy-person she had to think continually about the BUDGET (and the weekly collection and covenants), the BUILDING PROGRAM (whether new facilities or maintaining the existing ones) and BUTTS on seats (how many people attended?). On Sunday evening and Monday morning she was regularly “stressed out.” Instead of looking to Jesus and loving God and the neighbor, she was bound to the Three B’s and their out-workings and this was bondage.
Now that she has left this bondage she is able to focus on and count other things such as Connections, Collaboration and Conversation. Now the church is people who are connected to the neighborhood where they meet, who are able to collaborate with any others in specific projects long or short term, and engage in dialogue and conversation with people of all kinds about God and love and anything else, without the pressure to seek to make them disciples and church members right away!
The point about this “generous orthodoxy movement” is that it seeks to be non-judgmental, to be practical rather than cerebral, to emphasize actions more than words, and thus to be a very mixed bag in terms of the great variety of local experiments at being “the real church” of people who love Jesus. Right now it seems to be generating a lot of interest amongst younger, caring Christians.
Running parallel to this “generous orthodoxy” movement is another which has been very recently described by George Barna in his book, Revolution (Tyndale House), He describes a related but different phenomenon of a small but growing number of evangelicals who are not satisfied with the quality of Christian vision, character and vision being taught and commended in the majority of the evangelical churches (congregations with hold buildings). They are desirous of a fuller and deeper Christian life and consecration and they are forming a variety of kinds of associations, groupings and fellowships to foster this. And most of them are under 45 and are devoted family people.
Both movements are found either outside or only very loosely attached to the many evangelical denominations and institutions of the USA. And there is obviously some overlap between them for neither is organized from a center and thus at the local level one group may easily see itself as belonging to both, indeed of seeing the two as but one general phenomenon. Both seem to have consciously recognized the power of post-modernity and the culture it creates, with the intention to work creatively within it. However, those described by Barna seem to be more specifically committed to biblical themes of personal holiness and consecration at home and work than those embracing “generous orthodoxy.” At the same time, the latter seem more specifically committed to practical action on behalf of the poor and disadvantaged, not abroad, but in their patch.
Whether either or both movements will be around in a decade is a question I cannot answer. However, my suspicion is that the high day of the evangelical church growth movement is ended and this movement is slowing down. It is slowing down because there is a significant, growing yearning for growth in maturity of faith, hope and love rather than a one-sided emphasis on growth in numbers (Butts in seats!). The small “church” of 100 members even 50 members or less is becoming attractive again – a fellowship which has a definite mission within the locality wherein it is placed, a mission more than evangelism, a mission of service to and within the local communities, especially to the needy therein.
We know that the average size of Anglican/Episcopal churches in the USA is well below a hundred. Regrettably so often these churches are so overcome by two of the B’s – the Budget and the Building – that they do not have sufficient energy left to go after more Butts for seats. [And those evangelicals which do go after more Butts tend to make the entry of converts into the church rather easy, if for no other reason than that the internal standards are not high to start with!]
Maybe these liturgical congregations with buildings can learn from the two movements described above without actually joining them! That is, to place growth in maturity in Christ and love of the neighbor in local practical ways as high priorities and thereby embrace the C’s – to make new connections in the neighborhood and community, to collaborate with people of like mind, and to have wider and deeper conversation with a widening circle. Certainly they must avoid being tired and stressed out by the B’s.
November 4, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Thursday, November 03, 2005
Too short? A consideration of Dr. Paul Zahl as systematic theologian.
Usually a book with the title, “Systematic Theology,” has many pages and sometimes comes in several volumes. Yet Dr Paul F.M. Zahl, now Dean of Trinity School for Ministry in PA, published a few years ago a book entitled, A Short Systematic Theology (Wm. B. Eerdmans). The text does not take up more than 100 pages! And in his preface he argues that there is real merit in such a short book (which I guess is about 40,000 words)- after all is not the New Testament itself a short book.
I ask myself after reading it:
Does his brevity prevent him from doing justice to his subject? I think so.
Does his brevity open him up to the charge of denying Articles I,II, & V of The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion and thus of advocating error or heresy? I think so.
I think so, but I am not sure on both counts.
The impression he makes is of a dynamic Protestant theologian who is committed to the heart of the Lutheran Reformation (justification by faith alone), to the Protestant doctrine of penal substitution in the death of Jesus on the Cross, and to the insistence that true saving faith issues in works of love, and a life of true moral and spiritual freedom. At the same time, he causes one to think that he has doubts as to the veracity and usefulness of the Church dogma of the Holy Trinity and the Person of Christ as also of the need for carefully defined doctrines of the place of the Church and Sacraments in the economy of salvation.
Now to the content of his case, which is attractively presented.
Zahl insists that theology must begin from the bottom as it were and work upwards. He does not mean from contemporary human experience (like the Presiding Bishop of ECUSA and his advisers), but from the accounts of the historical Jesus found in the Four Gospels. So he starts with Jesus and notes wherein he is unique within Judaism. Then he focuses on his passion and crucifixion, which he shows provides the full and universal Atonement for human sins and sinfulness.
Further, and importantly, he interprets the death of Jesus on the Cross as penal, substitutionary Atonement, even as the Protestant Reformers explained and preached this doctrine. Yet the way he writes of this is not in sixteenth-century style but as one who has learnt much from his recent periods of study in Germany.
Then he proceeds by accepting the apostolic claim that Jesus was raised from the dead and ascended into heaven; and, on this basis, proceeds to ask how the same Jesus, now exalted, is present with us (“Lo I am with you always, even unto the end of the age”) when in fact he is actually absent from us as the historical Jesus. His answer is perhaps surprising – not in sacraments, not in preaching of the Word, not in church fellowship, not in the gifts of the Spirit etc., but he is found in “works of love”. Here he connects with the Protestant emphasis on justification by faith expressed practically in deeds of love. “I would not work my soul to save/ for that my Lord has done./ But I would work like any slave/ for love of God’s dear Son.”
It is only when he has presented all this that he suggests that it is appropriate to consider the full identity of Jesus, the crucified and ascended One. The identity of Jesus appears from what he achieves. And this is presented very briefly. For him, the church dogma of the Incarnation (Jesus is One Person made known in two natures, divine and human) is apparently useful but not necessary for it is too speculative.
With regard to the Church doctrine of the Trinity, he seems to be skeptical as to both its truth and its usefulness. For he says it is speculation based upon speculation (i.e., it is built upon the dogma of the Person of Christ). However, in his brief treatment he does not distinguish between the dynamic, biblically-based “economic” Trinity and the ”ontological” Trinity of church dogma (God as God is in and unto himself as Three Persons, One Godhead, in his own infinity and eternity) The biblical portrayal of the Father sending the Son into space and time to be incarnate by the action of the Holy Spirit, and then of the movement in the Spirit, through the Son to the Father in the sacrifice of prayer and good works of the disciples of Jesus, would seem to be a major theme of the New Testament. Is it not the case that for the New Testament there is the double “flow”: (a) from the Father through the Son and by the Spirit come creation, revelation, salvation and redemption and (b) to the Father through the Son and with the Spirit flow worship and service, prayer and good works?
What Protestant Reformers learned after their discovery of “justification by faith alone” was that the church dogma of the Trinity and Person of Christ (for this see the decrees of the first four Ecumenical Councils) in the pious, devout mind provides a paradigm which profoundly assists in the understanding and interpreting of Scripture unto holiness and salvation. In this realization, they joined Fathers such as Augustine and Bernard, Thomas Aquinas and Anselm.
Dr Zahl also reveals his departure from the full Protestant and classical Anglican tradition by his embracing and defending of the doctrine of God as passible, the God who in his deity, is subject to change of feelings and moods. It is one thing, we may recall, to attribute to the human nature of the Lord Jesus changing moods and feelings; it is yet another thing to deny the long-held doctrine of the impassibility of God the Father (see Article I).
Much more could be said about this little book for it does have the merit of being both readable and gently provocative of serious thought. At the same time, it is impossible to tell from It what value for salvation Dr Zahl places upon the historic Liturgy of the Church (wherein church dogma most carefully influences the content and style of prayers), the recital of the ecumenical Creed, the visible Church wherein are preached the Word and the Sacraments administered, and, as an Anglican, the classic Anglican Formularies (the authentic BCP, Ordinal and Articles). Would he agree that you cannot have God as your Father and the Lord Jesus Christ as your Saviour without having the Church as your mother?
A final thought. In the “old days” at least in England, the fact of being the author of this book would disqualify him from teaching doctrine in one of the conservative evangelical theological Colleges in the Church of England (e.g., Oak Hill College, London) or being on the Board of the Church Society or the Church Pastoral Aid Society. I say “old days” for things have changed a lot in England as in the USA since the 1970s within “evangelical Anglicanism.” It is not clear to me now what in fact “evangelicals” actually believe for usually they do not accept or even study the Thirty-Nine Articles as a source of Anglican doctrine and also sit lightly upon the classical dogma of the first four ecumenical Councils.
November 3, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Tuesday, November 01, 2005
Ordinal – woman bishop?
The Ordinal, usually bound together with The Book of Common Prayer and The Articles of Religion as one book, is a Formulary of the Church of England and of the Anglican Way. It sets forth the form of doctrine of the Ministry of the Church, which is Threefold, that of Deacon, Priest [Presbyter] and Bishop.
When the Ordinal of the Church of England was created in 1550, as a book written in English and based upon Scripture and medieval Latin texts, there was never any intention that a women could be or would be admitted to any of the three Offices. However, social conditions change, the mind of [parts of] the Church of God change, and thus, in the twenty-first century, women have been ordained as Deacons and Priests in the Church of England (and also in other provinces of the Anglican Communion).
However, with the real possibility that women priests may be consecrated as bishops, even archbishops, in the next decade, there are some persons who, having either supported or not being opposed to the ordination of women as priests, now have grave doubts about their possible consecration as bishops. Reasons for this concern vary – from a strong biblical doctrine of the “headship of the male”, through the traditional catholic teaching of the Bishop as a successor of the apostles and an icon of Christ Jesus, to the practical question of whether it will really work in terms of loyalty and obedience to a female bishop.
The Forward in Faith Movement is totally opposed to the consecrating of a women as a bishop and has proposed and provided the basic legislation for a third province in the Church of England, wherein are no female clergy at all. And the evangelical Church Society has given general support to this proposal.
But what about those who do still use The Book of Common Prayer and take seriously its position (with the Ordinal and Articles) as Formulary of the Church of England? How should they think and act?
Here I want to suggest that to be committed to the Formularies and interpreting them in the most generous way does not allow one to support the consecration of a woman as a bishop, even it if allows one to support the ordination of a woman as a deacon and priest.
What do I mean? Here I must invite my reader to read carefully first of all the text entitled, “The Form and Manner of Ordering of Priests.” In reading this I also invite you to follow the old convention that “he” can stand for “he or she”. As you read through you will notice that the candidates for the Order of Priesthood are first of all called “persons”, then “servants” and then “brethren”(which can mean brothers and sisters”). In the address by the Bishop they are also called “messengers, watchmen and stewards of the Lord”. In the questions from the Bishop there is one which may be taken as being addressed only to man, for it may be taken as presupposing he is head of a family; but in different social conditions today the question also makes sense as addressed to a woman (“to frame a family according to the doctrine of Christ”).Then in the Prayer before Ordination and the words of ordination the text nowhere specifically states (even if it originally assumed) that it is a man that is being ordained.
So one may claim that, in and of itself and by itself, the Ordinal does not specifically state that the Order of Priesthood is solely and only for male candidates. While it may assume such, it does not clearly declare such. So in this sense a generous benefit of doubt may be allowed.
Now let us turn to “The Form of Ordaining or Consecrating of an Archbishop or Bishop.” Is this service like the previous one in that while it assumes that the Bishop will be a man it never specifically states this to be required?
The answer in this case is NO.
If we allow the convention that “he” may be “she or he” then we conclude that much of the text appears to be of the same kind as for the ordaining of priests. Yet there are a few features of the service that appear to require that the candidate be a man.
First of all, the Epistle is from 1 Timothy 3:1ff, where the text reads: “If a man desire the office of Bishop…. A Bishop must be the husband of one wife…” Then, secondly, in the presentation of the candidate to the Archbishop the words are: “we present unto you this godly and well-learned man to be ordained and consecrated Bishop.” In the Litany are inserted these words: “That it may please thee to bless this our Brother elected…” In the questions from the Archbishop the candidate is addressed as , “Brother…”
So, it would appear that it is impossible to deduce from the Ordinal, even on a generous interpretation, that a woman (even if she is legitimately a priest) can be elevated to the office of bishop. Now, a canon could be passed by the General Synod to add to canon law which would effectively state, “notwithstanding the natural and literal interpretation of the Ordinal, a woman may be a candidate for the office of bishop.” However, for those who have a high view of the Ordinal as Formulary (and containing both the teaching of Scripture and the witness of Tradition) such a change would not be convincing or acceptable.
Thus I conclude that the leadership of Prayer Book Societies are bound by their commitment to the Formularies to oppose the ordination and consecration of women as bishops; and, as a corollary of this, to support ways for faithful churchmen to remain in good faith in the Church, if and when the innovation is implemented. In England this may mean giving support to the proposal for a Third Province.
November 1, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
No need to dumb down because we start from a low point
Is it a simple matter of fact that most western Christians, be they progressive liberals or “orthodox” conservatives, are very much “conformed to this world” (Romans) and further even “love the world” (I John) – even though they are clearly commanded by Christ’s apostles not to be and do so?
To say this of the progressive liberals may please the orthodox conservatives, for the latter claim that liberals take their agenda and principles from the enlightened world around them and simple give “God” and “Christ” and “biblical” names to these worldly ideals.
Further, to say this of the orthodox conservatives may please the progressive liberals, for the latter claim that the conservatives are conformed to and love a world of their imagination, a world of patriarchy and sexism, which they find in the Bible through their out-of –date exegesis and interpretation.
The “world” for both St Paul and St John could be the cosmos for “God so loved the world that He have his only begotten Son…” But in moral contexts the “world”, for the apostles, is the presence of evil and sin within human society, organizations, culture and ethos. It is a disordered world where instead of existing for the glory of God, people and institutions support and encourage evil. Of course, human beings are made in the image of God and have the potential to do good and to please their Creator, but their souls are infected with sin and they do not naturally fulfill their potential and purpose.
Let us now reflect upon the situation of the “orthodox” conservatives who are seen as “the righteous remnant” in the old, main-line denominations of the USA.
Is it reasonable or just to say of them (and I place myself within their company) that though they protest on behalf of authentic Christianity, they are in so many ways “conformed to this world” and in “love with the world”? My reply is that with regret I do think it is both reasonable and just even though one can find individual cases of saintliness and heroism that seem to point in the other direction.
Here in a kind of theological shorthand are some ways in which some of the churches within the “remnant” are conformed to this world:
- In dress. They treat worship on the Lord’s Day as a kind of special, recreational, leisure activity and this is demonstrated by the way they dress and their general deportment. They do not give the impression that they come to meet the King of kings. Rather, they come casually to meet a “great friend” who says to them “just be yourselves.” Cf. LET God be GOD the LORD!
- In style of worship. There is little evidence of the pursuit of excellence in order to magnify the LORD but in general, the average, the normal, the ordinary in terms of the quality of assembling, singing, and form of language used, are seen as appropriate and good enough. Likewise the content of preaching and teaching does not give the strong impression that they are words about the glorious GOD and the amazing Incarnation of the Son of God. Cf. WORSHIP THE LORD IN THE BEAUTY OF HOLINESS.
- In reducing the holiness of the Sacrament. The Eucharist is the heavenly meal with the Lord Jesus at his Messianic Banquet and to be there the people must be raised in the Spirit. But how can they when the Eucharist is treated casually and without awe and reverence as it were only holy fast food. Cf. THIS IS MY BODY AND THIS IS MY BLOOD!
- In demands made on converts. While there is emphasis on evangelization and church growth, there is minimal emphasis upon the fullness of the transformed life to which Christ calls his own. This is because the congregation itself is too conformed to the world and its standards and cannot ask the new members to aim too high or else they will cause embarrassment. Cf. BE YE HOLY FOR I AM HOLY SAITH THE LORD.
- In advertising and publicity. So often the techniques of the communication industry are used without asking first the question whether the Christian Gospel truly can fit into the models which this industry supplies without losing its character as “not of this world.” Cf. WE PROCLAIM CHRIST AND HIM CRUCIFIED – foolishness to the Greeks!
- In pastoral care. By adopting uncritically so many of the themes and phraseology of the therapism and the human rights movements and not taking sufficiently seriously the biblical presentation of the human soul and its concupiscence and sinfulness. Thus there is little or no genuine moral and spiritual direction and much counseling and the latter sometimes owes more to the wisdom of this world than the leading of the Holy Spirit. Further clergy are often presented as first of all managers and counselors and then secondly as preachers and teachers and pastors. Cf. THE FEAR OF THE LORD IS THE BEGINNING OF WISDOM AND OF KNOWLEDGE.
- In fixation on relevance and meeting stated needs of people. What people are invited to believe, understand, meditate upon, live out in life, and to be and to do as a Christian in the world is so often reduced to “simple” terms which can be received by all without effort, for the idea is that relevance goes with simplicity. This is what is usually called “dumbing down.” Cf. STRIVE FOR THE HIGHEST.
No doubt some will judge me as being harsh. But I invite all to take a look at the very recently published book, REVOLUTION by George Barna of the Barna Group, a research organization based in California. (Tyndale House Publishers of Illinois)
What is the Revolution? It is that evangelical people up and down the USA are realizing that in most of the evangelical churches and congregations they are not truly and really meeting “the real and true Church of God”. Thus they are looking to other ways of seeking to be genuine Christians, wholly consecrated and committed to the Lord Jesus Christ. Local churches are becoming therefore less relevant and many will have to close as people seek the real Church, the people of God united to the Father through the Son from all over the world. Returning are small group meetings and the like for people of like mind and like aspirations.
Barna claims that what he says is wholly based on sound research and he is so committed to what his team has found that he has joined what he calls the Revolution, a dramatic change going on all over the USA in people in order to seek to become and be genuine Christians who truly serve the Lord in this world.
In Anglican terms: Are the AMiA and the Network and the FinFNA in the USA and the Essentials of Canada partaking of the Revolution, or are they the very groups from which the genuine Revolutionaries for Christ are departing? This is an important question!
October 31, 2005 All Hallows Eve. petertoon@msn.com
Monday, October 31, 2005
The Third Anglican Global South to South Encounter
ACNS 4061 MIDDLE EAST 31 OCTOBER 2005
The Third Anglican Global South to South Encounter
Red Sea (Egypt), 25-30 October 2005
The Third Anglican South-to-South Encounter has graphically demonstrated the coming of age of the Church of the Global South. We are poignantly aware that we must be faithful to God's vision of one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. We do not glory in our strengths but in God's strength. We do not shrink from our responsibility as God's people because of our weaknesses but we trust God to demonstrate His power through our weakness. We thank God for moving us forward to serve Him in such a time as this.
A. Preamble
1. A total of 103 delegates of 20 provinces in the Global South (comprising Africa, South and South East Asia, West Indies and South America), representing approximately two-thirds of the Anglican Communion, met for the 3rd Global South to South Encounter from 25-30 October 2005 at Ain El-Sukhna by the Red Sea in Egypt. The theme of the Encounter was "One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church: Being A Faithful Church For Such A Time As This".
2. We deeply appreciated the Archbishop of Canterbury for the time he spent with us, his listening ear and encouraging words. We took to heart his insight that the four marks of the Church are not attributes we possess as our own right, nor goals to attain by human endeavour, but they are expressed in us as we deeply focus on Jesus Christ, who is the Source of them all (John 17:17-21).
3. We were really warmed by the welcome that we received here by the President, the government and the people of Egypt. We valued the great efforts made by the state security personnel who are making the land of Egypt a secure and safe place to all her visitors. We were touched by the warm hospitality of the Diocese of Egypt.
4. We have witnessed in Egypt a wonderful model for warm relations between Christians and Muslims. We admire the constructive dialogue that is happening between the two faiths. We appreciated the attendance of the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, Dr Mohammed Said Tantawi, the representative of Pope Shenouda III and other religious leaders at the State Reception to launch our Encounter. We were encouraged by their wise contributions.
B. We Gathered
5. We gathered to seek the face of God, to hear His Word afresh and to be renewed by His Spirit for total obedience to Christ who is Lord of the Church. That is why the gathering was called an "Encounter" rather than a conference. The vital question we addressed was: What does it mean to be one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church in the midst of all the challenges facing the world and the Church?
6. The world of the Global South is riddled with the pain of political conflict, tribal warfare and bloodshed. The moral and ethical foundations of several of our societies are being shaken. Many of our nations are beset by problems of poverty, ignorance and sickness, particularly the HIV and AIDS that threaten millions, especially in Africa. In addition to that, thousands of people have suffered from severe drought in Africa, earthquakes in South Asia, and hurricanes in the Americas - we offer our support and prayers to them.
7. Apart from the world condition, our own Anglican Communion sadly continues to be weakened by unchecked revisionist teaching and practices which undermine the divine authority of the Holy Scripture. The Anglican Communion is severely wounded by the witness of errant principles of faith and practice which in many parts of our Communion have adversely affected our efforts to take the Gospel to those in need of God's redeeming and saving love.
8. Notwithstanding these difficult circumstances, several parts of our Communion in the Global South are witnessing the transforming power of the Gospel and the growth of the Church. The urgency of reaching vast multitudes in our nations for Christ is pressing at our door and the
fields are ready for harvest.
9. Surrounded by these challenges and seeking to discover afresh our identity we decided to dig deeper into God's Word and into the tradition of the Church to learn how to be faithful to God's gift and call to be His one, holy, catholic and apostolic people. We deliberately chose to meet in Egypt for two reasons:
a. Biblically, Egypt features prominently in the formative period of the calling of God's people (Exodus 19). Moreover, Egypt was part of the cradle that bore the entry of the Savior into the world (Hosea 11:1; Matthew 2:13-15).
b. Meeting by the Red Sea, we could not help but be inspired by the historic crossing of God's people into the realm where He purposed to make them a "light to the nations" (Isaiah 42:6). Part of that blessing was fulfilled when Alexandria became a center of early Christianity, where church fathers formulated and held on to the
Christian faith through the early centuries.
C. We Discovered Afresh
10. We discovered afresh the depth and richness of our roots in the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church. Carefully researched papers were presented at the Encounter in the context of worship, prayer, Bible Study and mutual sharing. We recognize the dynamic way in which the four marks of the Church are inextricably interwoven. The salient truths we encountered inspired us and provided a basis for knowing what God requires of us.
The Church is One
11. The Church is called to be one. Our unity is willed by our Lord Jesus Christ Himself, who prayed that we "all might be one." (John 17:20-21) A great deal of confusion has arisen out of misunderstanding that prayer and the concept of unity. For centuries, the Church has found unity in the Person and teaching of Jesus Christ, as recorded in Scripture. We are one in Him, and that binds us together. The foundation and expression of our unity is found in Jesus Christ as Saviour and Lord.
12. While our unity may be expressed in institutional life, our unity is grounded in our living relationship with the Christ of Scripture. Unity is ever so much more than sharing institutionally. When we are "in Christ," we find that we are in fellowship with others who are also in Him. The fruit of that unity is that we faithfully manifest the life and love of Christ to a hurting and groaning world (Romans 8:18-22).
13. Christian unity is premised on truth and expressed in love. Both truth and love compel us to guard the Gospel and stand on the supreme authority of the whole Word of God. The boundary of family identity ends within the boundary of the authentic Word of God.
The Church is Holy
14. The Church of Jesus Christ is called to be holy. All Christians are to participate in the sanctification of their lives through submission, obedience and cooperation with the Holy Spirit. Through repentance the Church can regain her rightful position of being holy before God. We believe concurrently that holiness is imparted to us through the life, ministry, death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ (Heb 10:21-23). He shares His holiness with us and invites us to be conformed to His likeness.
15. A holy Church is prepared to be a "martyr" Church. Witness unto death is how the Early Church articulated holiness in its fullest sense (Acts 22:20; Rev 2:13, 12:11).
The Church is Catholic
16. The Catholic faith is the universal faith that was "once for all" entrusted to the apostles and handed down subsequently from generation to generation (Jude 3). Therefore every proposed innovation must be measured against the plumb line of Scripture and the historic teaching of the Church.
17. Catholicity carries with it the notion of completeness and wholeness. Thus in the church catholic "when one part suffers, every part suffers with it" (1 Cor 12:26). The local church expresses its catholicity by its devotion to apostolic teaching, its attention to prayer and the sacrament, its warm and caring fellowship and its growth through evangelism and mission (Acts 2:42-47).
The Church is Apostolic
18. The Church is apostolic in its doctrine and teaching. The apostolic interpretation of God's salvation plan effected in Christ Jesus is binding on the Church. God established the Church on the "foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ Jesus Himself as the chief cornerstone" (Eph 2:20).
19. The Church is apostolic in its mission and service. "As the Father has sent Me, so I send you." (John 20:21) In each generation He calls bishops in apostolic succession (Eph 4:11-12) to lead the Church out into mission, to teach the truth and to defend the faith. Accountability to God, to those God places over us and to the flock is an integral part of church leadership.
D. We Commit
20. As a result of our Encounter, we emerge with a clearer vision of what the Church is called to be and to do, with a renewed strength to pursue that vision. Specifically, we made commitments in the following areas.
The Authority of the Word of God
21. Scripture demands, and Christian history has traditionally held, that the standard of life, belief, doctrine, and conduct is the Holy Scripture. To depart from apostolic teaching is to tamper with the foundation and to undermine the basis of our unity in Christ. We express full confidence in the supremacy and clarity of Scripture, and pledge full obedience to the whole counsel of God's Word.
22. We in the Global South endorse the concept of an Anglican Covenant (rooted in the Windsor Report) and commit ourselves as full partners in the process of its formulation. We are seeking a Covenant that is rooted in historic faith and formularies, and that provides a biblical foundation for our life, ministry and mission as a Communion. It is envisaged that once the Covenant is approved by the Communion, provinces that enter into the Covenant shall be mutually accountable, thereby providing an authentic fellowship within the Communion.
23. Anglicans of the Global South have discovered a vibrant spiritual life based on Scripture and empowered by the Spirit that is transforming cultures and communities in many of our provinces. It is to this life that we seek to be formed and found fully faithful. We reject the expectation that our lives in Christ should conform to the misguided theological, cultural and sociological norms associated with sections of the West.
Mission and Ministry
24. Churches in the Global South commit to pursue networking with one another to add strength to our mission and ministry. We will continue to explore appropriate structures to facilitate and support this.
25. Shared theological foundations are crucial to authentic fellowship and partnership in mission and ministry. In that light, we welcome the initiative to form the Council of Anglican Provinces of the Americas and the Caribbean (CAPAC). It is envisaged that CAPAC will not only provide a foundation on the historic formularies of Anglican faith but also provide a structure with which member churches can carry out formal ministry partnerships with confidence.
26. Global South is committed to provide our recognition, energy, prayers and experience to the Networks in the USA and Canada, the Convocation of Nigerian Anglicans in the USA, those who make Common Cause and the Missionary District that is gathering congregations that circumstances have pressed out of ECUSA. We are heartened by the bold witness of their people. We are grateful that the Archbishop of Canterbury publicly recognized the Anglican Communion Network in the USA and the Anglican Network in Canada as faithful members of the Anglican Communion.
27. As for the other provinces and dioceses around the world who remain steadfastly committed to this faith, we look forward to further opportunities to partner with them in the propagation of the Gospel. We will also support those orthodox dioceses and congregations which are under difficult circumstances because of their faithfulness to the Word.
We appreciate the recent action of the Primate of the Southern Cone who acted to stabilize the volatile situation in Recife, Brazil.
In this regard, we take this opportunity to acknowledge the immense contribution of the Primate of South East Asia to the development of the Global South and to the preservation of orthodoxy across the worldwide Anglican Communion.
Theological Education
28. In order to provide teaching that preserves the faith and fits our context, it is crucial to update the curricula of our theological institutions in the Global South to reflect our theological perspective and mission priorities. We note from the All Africa Bishops Conference their concern that far too many Western theological education institutions have become compromised and are no longer suitable for training leaders for our provinces. We call for the re-alignment of our priorities in such a way as to hasten the full establishment of adequate theological education institutions across the Global South so that our leaders can be appropriately trained and equipped in our own context.
We aim to develop our leaders in biblical and theological training, and seek to nurture indigenous theologians. We will provide information on institutions in the Global South, and we will encourage these institutions to explore ways to provide bursaries and scholarships.
The Current Crisis provoked by North American Intransigence
29. The unscriptural innovations of North American and some western provinces on issues of human sexuality undermine the basic message of redemption and the power of the Cross to transform lives. These departures are a symptom of a deeper problem, which is the diminution of the authority of Holy Scripture. The leaders of these provinces disregard the plain teaching of Scripture and reject the traditional interpretation of tenets in the historical Creeds.
30. This Encounter endorses the perspectives on communion life found in sections A & B of the Windsor Report, and encourages all Provinces to comply with the request from the Primates' Communiqué in February 2005 which states:
"We therefore request all provinces to consider whether they are willing to be committed to the inter-dependent life of the Anglican Communion understood in the terms set out in these sections of the report."31. The Windsor Report rightly points out that the path to restoring order requires that either the innovating provinces/dioceses conform to historic teaching, or the offending provinces will by their actions be choosing to walk apart. Paragraph 12 of the Primates Communiqué says:
"Whilst there remains a very real question about whether the North American churches are willing to accept the same teaching on matters of sexual morality as is generally accepted elsewhere in the Communion, the underlying reality of our communion in God the Holy Trinity is obscured, and the effectiveness of our common mission severely hindered."32. Regrettably, even at the meeting of the Anglican Consultative Council (ACC) in Nottingham in 2005, we see no evidence that both ECUSA and the Anglican Church of Canada are willing to accept the generally accepted teaching, nor is there evidence that they are willing to turn back from their innovations.
33. Further, the struggles of the Communion have only been exacerbated by the lack of concrete progress in the implementation of the recommendations of the Windsor Report. The slow and inadequate response of the Panel of Reference has trivialized the solemn charge from the Primates and has allowed disorder to multiply unnecessarily. We recognize with regret the growing evidence that the Provinces which have taken action creating the current crisis in the Communion continue moving in a direction that will result in their "walking apart." We call for urgent and serious implementation of the recommendations of the Windsor Report.
Unscriptural and unilateral decisions, especially on moral issues, tear the fabric of our Communion and require appropriate discipline at every level to maintain our unity. While the Global South calls for the errant provinces to be disciplined, we will continue to pray for all who embrace these erroneous teachings that they will be led to repentance and restoration.
Spiritual Leadership
34. Our on-going participation in ministry and mission requires godly and able spiritual leadership at all times. We are encouraged that many inspirational leaders in our midst bear witness to the Scriptures and are effectively bringing the Gospel to surrounding cultures. We commit ourselves to identify the next generation of leaders and will seek to equip and deploy them wherever they are needed.
35. We need inspirational leaders and accountability structures. These mechanisms which we are looking into must ensure that leaders are accountable to God, to those over us in the Lord, to the flock and to one another in accordance to the Scriptures. This last aspect is in keeping with the principle of bishops and leaders acting in council. In this way, leaders become the role models that are so needed for the flock.
Youth
36. The Global South emphasizes the involvement and development of youth in the life of the Church. The youth delegates encouraged the whole gathering by the following collective statement during the Encounter:
"Many youths in the Global South are taking up the challenge of living in moral purity in the face of the rising influence of immoral values and practice, and the widening epidemic of HIV and AIDS. Young people will be ready to give their lives to the ministry of the Church if she gives them exemplary spiritual leadership and a purpose to live for. Please pray that we will continue to be faithful as the Church of 'today and tomorrow'. It is also our heart's cry that the communion will remain faithful to the Gospel."Poverty
37. As the church catholic we share a common concern for the universal problem of debt and poverty. The inequity that exists between the rich and the poor widens as vast sums borrowed by previous governments were not used for the intended purposes. Requiring succeeding generations of people who never benefited from the loans and resources to repay them will impose a crushing and likely insurmountable burden. We welcome and appreciate the international efforts of debt reduction and cancellation, for example, the steps recently carried out by G8 leaders.
38. A dimension of responsible stewardship and accountability is the clear call to be financially self-sustaining. We commend the new initiative for financial self-sufficiency and development being studied by the Council of Anglican Provinces of Africa (CAPA). This is not only necessary because of the demands of human dignity; it is the only way to have sustainable economic stability.
HIV and AIDS
39. A holy Church combines purity and compassion in its witness and service. The population of the world is under assault by the HIV and AIDS pandemic, but the people of much of the Global South are hit particularly hard because of poverty, lifestyle habits, lack of teaching and the paucity of appropriate medication. Inspired by the significant success of the Church in Uganda in tackling HIV and AIDS, all our provinces commit to learn and apply similar intentional programmes which emphasize abstinence and faithfulness in marriage. We call on governments to ensure that they are providing adequate medication and treatment for those infected.
Corruption
40. The holy Church will "show forth fruits that befit repentance" (Matt 3:8). Many of us live in regions that have been deeply wounded by corruption. Not only do we have a responsibility to live transparent lives of utmost honesty in the Church, we are called to challenge the culture in which we live (Micah 6:8). Corruption consumes the soul of society and must be challenged at all costs. Transparency and accountability are key elements that we must manifest in bearing witness to the cultures in which we live.
Violent Conflict
41. Many of us from across the Global South live juxtaposed with violent conflict, most egregiously manifest in violence against innocents. In spite of the fact that the conflicts which grip many of our provinces have resulted in many lives being lost, we are not defeated. We find hope in the midst of our pain and inspiration from the martyrs who have shed their blood. Their sacrifice calls us to faithfulness. Their witness provokes us to pursue holiness. We commit ourselves to grow to become faithful witnesses who "do not love their lives even unto death"
(Rev 12:11).
E. We Press On
42. We emerge from the Encounter strengthened to uphold the supreme authority of the Word of God and the doctrinal formularies that have undergirded the Anglican Communion for over four and a half centuries. Communion requires alignment with the will of God first and foremost, which establishes our commonality with one another. Such expressions of the will of God which Anglicans should hold in common are: one Lord, one faith, one baptism; Holy Scripture; apostolic teaching and practice; the historic Creeds of the Christian Church; the Articles of Religion and the doctrinal tenets as contained in the 1662 Book of Common Prayer. Holding truth and grace together by the power of the Holy Spirit, we go forward as those entrusted "with the faith once delivered" (Jude 3).
43. By the Red Sea, God led us to renew our covenant with Him. We have committed ourselves to obey Him fully, to love Him wholly, and to serve Him in the world as a "kingdom of priests and a holy nation" (Exodus 19:6). God has also helped us to renew our bonds of fellowship with one another, that we may "stand firm in one spirit, contending as one man in the faith of the Gospel" (Phil 1:27).
44. We offer to God this growing and deepening fellowship among the Global South churches that we might be a servant-body to the larger Church and to the world. We see ourselves as a unifying body, moving forward collectively as servants of Christ to do what He is calling us to do both locally in our provinces and globally as the "scattered people of God throughout the world" (1 Peter 1:1).
45. Jesus Christ, "that Great Shepherd of the sheep" (Heb 13:20, Micah 5:4), is caring for His flock worldwide, and He is gathering into His one fold lost sheep from every tribe and nation. We continue to depend on God's grace to enable us to participate with greater vigour in Christ's great enterprise of saving love (1 Peter 2:25, John 10:14-16).
We shall press on to glorify the Father in the power of the Spirit until Christ comes again. Even so, come Lord Jesus.
The Third Anglican Global South to South Encounter
Red Sea, Egypt, 25-30 October 2005
ACNSlist, published by Anglican Communion News Service, London