Tuesday, October 04, 2005

The Orthodox – where are they?

O that all the “ orthodox” were truly Orthodox,
Even as all the “progressives” are really Liberal.

Since the 1960s the progressives within the Episcopal Church have clearly demonstrated their principles, which may generally be called liberal, even radically liberal.

Progressives have gradually adjusted the received doctrines of God, of the Lord Jesus Christ, of sin, of salvation, of the Last Things, of holiness, of morality and of sacraments in order to make them acceptable to contemporary social and cultural norms and values. And further they have adopted theories of translation from one language to another, of exegesis and interpretation of ancient texts, and of how the Deity reveals will and purpose, which make this large-scale task of changing the content of the Faith (while retaining much of its language) possible and even seem necessary and justified.

So the way God is named and addressed has changed and is changing – He is now also She or It and is always You. The way God is conceived has changed and is changing – Deity is now [a] Being that contains within itself (as a child in the womb) the cosmos and so there is a dynamic relation of interfacing between God and cosmos and cosmos and God. Jesus Christ was the human person whose whole being was in tune with Deity and whose Spirit lives on to bless and heal, to comfort and save. The Trinity is a model of fellowship and co-operation for human beings to follow. Women and men are in the evolutionary process but yet are unique in the cosmos; they are to be treated with dignity and respect and afforded all the rights that they desire and require for their happiness and self-esteem. The Church is the community of those who affirm one another and who see God present in their experience and as the One who accepts them just as they are. Talk of the Last Things is a way of encouraging right living and confidence in Deity as the Source of being and fulfillment and working hard for a better world. And so on.

In this progressivism and liberalism, it is required that the insights and developments of society and culture (which are seen as coming from God as Being) be adopted by the Church and adapted for its growth in maturity and understanding. So full rights for all types and kinds of people are absolutely required as being “divine law” ; and everything that stands in the way of this implementation (e.g., from received Prayer Book, Ordinal, Confession of faith, Canon Law, Tradition and stubborn traditionalists) must be removed (by the democratic process where at all possible). In this process, the acceptance of same-sex partnerships as blessed of God and holy before Him/Her/It is merely the most recent of the examples of the march of progressive liberalism.

The God who encloses the cosmos within its Being has yet more to reveal to those who pay attention and do homage. The ECUSA is not yet at the end of its liberal road. God in Experience has much to show and reveal.

The march of progressive liberalism since the 1960s has not occurred without resistance, often great resistance using millions of dollars. But most of the resisters eventually gave up and either left the Church (notice the tremendous drop in membership from the mid 1960s to the year 1980!) or they stayed on after the arrival of the new Prayer Book in 1979 and in so doing usually adjusted what they would accept and define as “orthodox” to what seemed possible in a situation where liberalism held sway. Thus we have arrived at the situation in 2005 when the working definition of “orthodox,” used both by informed commentators and also by those “conservatives” who use the name “orthodox” of themselves, is something like this: “those who accept the Bible, the Creeds, and the 1979 prayer book and also who believe that marriage is only between a man and a woman.” [There are a few congregations left in the ECUSA which have maintained the use of the classic Prayer Book in the edition of 1928. But even this tiny minority has been affected by the general ethos of the ECUSA for it is impossible not to share in some way in the general family likeness!]

What the march of liberalism means (for those with a historical overview) is that the “orthodox” of the ECUSA of 2005 are like the liberals of the late 1960s, for they accept serial monogamy even as they reject same-sex marriage, and they accept divorced and remarried clergy [male and female] even as they reject clergy living in same-sex unions. Further, they are like the liberals of 1980 for they accept the 1979 Prayer Book as THE “Book of Common Prayer” and THE Standard of Faith of the ECUSA. In so doing they accept the use of inclusive language for human beings and agree to translations of the Bible (e.g. the Psalter in the 1979 Prayer Book) which incorporate this inclusivism, and further they accept the “reduced” or “dumbed-down” doctrines of God, Christ and salvation written into the Rite II texts and the Catechism of this Book. Finally, they accept that the classic Anglican Formularies (the classic BCP, Ordinal & Articles, which define the Anglican Way) have no place or authority in the ECUSA for they are merely and only historical documents.

In short, the “Orthodox” is a relative term and the “Orthodox” of 2005 in the ECUSA are less liberal in practice than are the “Progressives” who run the Church. However, since the same-sex issue affects people at various levels of their being, from their guts to their ratiocination, it seems to be (and practically speaking is) the great issue, even the final issue and the basis of massive division, that makes the two sides to seem to be as different as chalk is from cheese. Yet in truth they use the same Prayer Book and its rites, they use the same modern versions of the Bible (all incorporating dynamic equivalency and inclusivism), they talk of personal relationships with Jesus who accepts us “just as I am” , and they belong to the same Institution with its many valued aspects (medical benefits, pensions and so on). The division is really between conservative progressives and liberal progressives! Finding genuine “Orthodox” in the ECUSA is like finding a needle in a haystack.

When will the “Orthodox” of ECUSA realize their true identity and seek really to become Orthodox and return to the fullness of the Anglican Way with its worship, doctrine and discipline, its heritage, style and ethos?

Leaving the ECUSA does not make anyone “Orthodox” for she or he departs as an Episcopalian! He and she must leave behind its formularies and ethos and seek to restore for themselves the classic Formularies, heritage and ethos of the Anglican Way. This is a painful and difficult vocation and many who exit seek to avoid it, thinking that ECUSA without its radical sexual innovations is really OK and so outside the ECUSA they carry on much as before, but with greater liberty – as for example appears to be the case with congregations in the AMiA and those individual congregations which have been “adopted” temporarily by foreign bishops !

Where there is a will there is a way! With God all things are possible – even to unify American Anglicans in truth with unity and unity in truth!

O that the “Orthodox” would really become Orthodox and that the Anglican Way of Reformed Catholicism would prosper again on American soil.

Peter Toon October 4, 2005

Finding Common Ground for the Distressed Anglican Way

A proposal to create discussion and prayerful investigation

Anglicans worldwide are finding that the so-called “Instruments of Unity” are not apparently much good at unifying. In the twenty-first century that have been seen to lack authority and efficacy to create spiritual, centripetal forces to overcome the powerful spiritual, centrifugal forces which presently are tearing the Anglican family apart.

Fine words and sentiments, even wise pronouncements and claims of bonds of affection from Lambeth Palace, the Primates’ Meeting, the Anglican Consultative Council and Bishops here and there (and from the last Lambeth Conference of 1998) do no seem to be having any positive effect towards unifying dysfunctional, even warring, family members in truth and love. It is clear that the “Instruments of Unity” are obviously not going to be the sole or even primary means of making the divided Anglican family into a genuine Communion of [autonomous] Churches. To those who think that they can and will be, the words of the psalmist speak to us: “Put not your trust in princes….”

What united Anglicans fifty years ago (and for centuries before then), and allowed there to be “bonds of affection”, was a deep sense of having something in common, something that was more than a shared history, heritage and hope. That something in common existed in the center, as it were, of the vital common heritage of devotion and piety, of church planting and growth, of the ordination of priests and consecration of bishops, and the creation of dioceses and provinces. It was a shared Liturgy, a profound yet simple Liturgy for daily prayer, Sunday worship, and for baptisms, confirmations, weddings, funerals and services of ordination.

It was Common Prayer, a set of texts/rites for the worship of the Church, and found in The Book of Common Prayer, first published as the expression of Reformed Catholicism for the Church of England in 1549. This Prayer Book easily fitted into the coat pocket of the man and the handbag of the woman, and its primary content was biblical citations and passages, woven together in a structured manner for the glory of God in worship and prayer.

The use of this Liturgy distinguished the Anglican from the Presbyterian, the Lutheran and the Roman Catholic and provided, when used with the Bible, a means of living before God in Christ Jesus in grace and holiness for 356 days a year for congregations, families and individual persons.

Naturally, its primary editions are in English, a fine yet understandable English from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, as may be seen in its most used edition, that of 1662, from the reign of Charles II. It is this edition which has been translated into over 150 languages since then, and it is this edition which the large Anglican Church of Nigeria has very recently in 2005 declared to be its standard for worship and doctrine, and also the means it will use for deciding with whom it is in Eucharistic communion! It is this edition which has also been gently edited in such English-speaking countries as Canada, South Africa and the USA to become the Prayer Book of the Anglican Churches in these lands (e.g., 1928 edition in the USA).

What has happened to this Liturgy? Why it is no longer the real basis of Anglican unity in truth?

For an answer we have to look back to the period after World War II, and to note the powerful cultural winds that blew most strongly in the 1960s and early 1970s and deeply affected the practice of Christianity in the West. These gale-force winds not only profoundly changed the R.C. Church; but, they also deeply disturbed and changed the Anglican Communion of Churches, especially in the West/North.

For example, the Lord our God, who had been addressed as “Thou art” for as long as English had been spoken, now became as one of us and was addressed as “You are”! New theories of translation led to the publication of new versions of the Bible and with these were produced new forms of worship. Soon, alongside the true Anglican Liturgy there appeared experimental forms of service, soon collected into “Books of Alterative Services.” And, such was the power of the cultural typhoon in the USA that the Name of the received Liturgy was actually – in an act of piracy by the General Convention of the Episcopal Church in 1976 – transferred to the new “Book of Varied and Alternative Services.” This was a clever move by progressive liberals for it took the Anglican Liturgy out of the official life of this Church.

With the arrival of new Bible translations/paraphrases and new forms of service, together with the arrival of new Morality, new forms of Ministry, new Dress-Codes, new Music, new roles for Bishops and new Architecture, the use of the Anglican Liturgy (with its tremendous heritage of music and art, devotion and piety) was declared by bishops and leaders to be out of date, irrelevant and too complicated for the Church in the modern era. Congregations were told it had to be replaced by exciting new forms to meet the needs of a new era, epoch and opportunity. How else could the young be recruited?

So the unity of the Anglican Way (a unity with comprehensiveness and local particularities), which had existed worldwide through one Liturgy was now in the West (but happily not in Africa and Asia) lost, even as that Liturgy was either banned or beaten down by many sincere but ill-informed clergy. And to fill the vacuum, the emphasis on “the Instruments of Unity” began in earnest. A family, which no longer had any common activity, speech and sentiments, and whose leaders extolled its great variety when meeting with its One LORD had to be kept together! And the way that emerged was an attempt at a weak form of hierarchy. The Archbishop of Canterbury could not be the Pope; the Lambeth Conference could not be an ecumenical council; the Anglican Consultative Council could not be a kind of Vatican Congregations, and the Primates’ Meeting could not be the Meeting of Cardinals with the Pope, but at least they could, as a minimal hierarchy, possibly hold the dysfunctional family together – especially if helped from time to time by Commissions chaired by an Irish Archbishop!

But the Instruments are not fulfilling the confidence placed in them! Yet they are here to stay, at least for a decade and more. So I am not suggesting that Anglicans abandon the Instruments of Unity; but, that they look to them with realism and not as the major means of salvation and unity in truth for the Anglican Family. The Instruments can surely help but only if there is a greater force for unity present and at work.

Therefore, what I suggest is that Anglicans at the grass roots dare to do what their leaders in the West would not have them do. I recommend that serious thought and diligent prayer be given to the possibility of the restoration of the One Liturgy as the basis [the standard Formulary] of the Anglican Way. After all, most of the African Provinces do not need any convincing for they are basically there already!

And as the Episcopal Church of the USA has been a cause of much of the present dysfunctional life of the Anglican family, perhaps the USA is the place from which to launch’ and then take to its practical outworking, this suggestion.

However, for this proposal for One Liturgy to have any opportunity to work I think that the way in which The Book of Common Prayer (1662) is now normally available (as a compact, small hardbound book in Roman type) has to be changed. That is, changed not in the actual content of the Liturgy but in the layout of the pages, the font, the type, and the binding.

Before Vatican II made possible the arrival of the Roman Mass in the vernacular, there were various Missals in which the Tridentine Latin text was on one side and a dignified translation into English, or French, or German or whatever on the other side. With this model in mind, I suggest that as a major means for the unifying of the Anglican Way, in the West as a starter, that there be a conscious recovery of the Anglican Liturgy in a new format which preserves the text of the 1662 edition on one side of the page and (to take account of what has happened to addressing God since the 1960s in the West/North) on the other side there be a parallel text in contemporary English, where God is addressed as “You”. In this arrangement, the classic text would be the standard of doctrine (Formulary) but either text could be used for public worship. Further, the accompanying ceremonial, music and prayers for local persons and needs would be determined locally for the aim is uniformity in formulary but comprehensiveness in use.

[Where there are differences between the 1662 edition and say the 1928 USA edition then options could be built in for the use of the latter where that was desired; however, in order to have a universal standard, the 1662 edition would need to be seen as the primary edition and that by which the Anglican Way is first identified and defined.]

To make sense of this One Anglican Liturgy, the use of any other types of liturgy would truly have to return (as was intended when alternative services were first produced in the 1960s) to being seen as occasional alternatives to the use of the standard Anglican Liturgy and not as the primary liturgy itself. Further, they would be subject to the doctrine contained in the Formulary.

If the pioneer printing of this edition of 1662 with parallel texts does not contain the text of the Epistle and Gospel for each Sunday and Holy Day but simply states what are the passages to be read (and suggests the appropriate Versions to be used), then the book itself will not have too many pages. There will be need to bear in mind in the contemporary English part the possibility of canticles and versicles being chanted or sung and this will call for special care and expertise in preparation. Likewise the contemporary version of the Psalter will pose problems for chanting and will probably not be done initially as part of the pioneer edition of the parallel texts.

Thus it would appear that what needs to be done is for there to be the preparation by a small team of this edition of parallel texts based on the BCP 1662, then for this to be widely circulated in order for there to be opportunity for people all over the West, but especially in North America, to see what it looks like and feels like, and what are the possibilities of its use. Waiting for an international meeting to agree to all this and to appoint a committee to get on with it is not realistic. A start has to be made and if the product has worth it will gain acceptance and from the pioneer edition will develop a further edition which will then truly compete for its true position as the Anglican Liturgy by causing its competitors of recent vintage to step down from their high places. During this process, probably the weight of the Nigerian and Ugandan and other Churches will be added to the restoration of the One Anglican Liturgy as both the way of worship and the Formulary.

Of course ECUSA will not (unless a mighty wind from heaven blows through it) have any interest in this proposal, but surely those who see themselves as “the orthodox” within that Church, along with the Anglican Mission in America and other bodies of Anglicans outside of the ECUSA or at least not in harmony with its leadership, will see the restoration of the classic Anglican model of One Liturgy which is also One Formulary as at least a possible way forward as a way towards unity in truth both in North America and in the whole world. How can anyone who is truly Anglican, that is Reformed Catholic Christian in mind and heart, be opposed to this proposal if he or she desires to see the revival and unity of the Anglican Way?

(Please note that the Prayer Book Society of the USA has prepared a book of parallel texts for the Daily Office, the Order for Holy Communion, the Litany and the Collects, with the title, Worshipping in the Anglican Way [from www.anglicanmarketplace.com or by calling 1 800 727 1928]. This book is based on the BCP1928 not the 1662 and is not part of the above proposal, but is an experimental means of leading people through a contemporary text to the classic text.)

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)

Thursday, September 29, 2005

Confessing sins properly

Have we lost the art of confessing sins aright, whether we use a classic or a modern liturgy?

Modern liturgists have given the impression to many Anglicans that the content of the classic Book of Common Prayer [BCP] is far too much focused on sin and penitence for sin and not enough on what they call “Celebration.” If the righteous dead could speak to these creators of modern liturgy, they would say with one voice: “the humble confession of sin is the beginning of the praise of God because it praises his righteousness and holiness and looks to his mercy and grace; also confession of sin is truthfulness before the God of all truth; and, further, did not the only-begotten Son of God enter space and time, become man, in order to die for our sins and be raised for our justification before God the Father?”

Let us look at the beginning of Morning/Evening Prayer as we find them in the classic edition of the BCP, that of 1662.

The first thing to note is that the Penitential Introduction (Sentences, Exhortation, Confession of Sin & Absolution) was added in 1552. The first BCP of 1549 began at the Lord’s Prayer without this introduction. Since it was obvious that this service was to become a public service (an not merely an office to be used before Holy Communion), the authorities decided that it needed an introduction to prepare people both for the fullness of praise through Psalm and Canticle and for the hearing of the two Lessons from the Old and New Testaments.

The Sentences are presented as a Call from God to his people to assemble together before him, the Almighty Lord, and to recognize who and what they are in his presence. The Exhortation by the Minister continues the Call of God and specifically calls for confession of sins as the people assemble to praise and thank God and to hear his holy Word.

Then there is the Confession – a general confession, meaning a confession of many different sins rather than of one particular sin. The rubric before it (also found in the American BCP1928) states: “A general Confession to be said of the whole Congregation after the Minister, all kneeling.”

To the Anglican traditionalist this instruction may seem not to be abnormal. Does it not require all present, Minister and People, to say the Confession and do so kneeling rather than sitting or standing? And is not kneeling the normal and customary Anglican way to pray (unless infirmity of body prevents)? The answer to both questions is yes, but there is more here in this rubric than at first meets the eye.

The people are to say the confession after not with the Minister. That is, he is to read a portion and then they are to repeat it, and so on from beginning to end. In contrast, in other prayers, e.g., the Lord’s Prayer, Minister and People say it together, he with them and they with him! The places where the Minister is to stop are indicated by a Capital Letter (upper case) of the word beginning the next portion. Thus:

Almighty and most merciful Father [repeat], We have erred and strayed from they ways like lost sheep [repeat], We have followed too much the devices and desires of our own hearts[repeat], and so on.

Why this method? Not because the people in 1662 could not read and needed to be prompted! But in order to provide more time for self-examination, reflection and genuine involvement in confessing one’s sins to Almighty God, the Father, in genuine sorrow and with penitence. After this, the Absolution from God by the Priest, as he declares that those who truly believe and repent will be pardoned and absolved, truly sounds like music from heaven.

It would seem that the sixteenth century reformers in the ecclesia anglicana, the Church of England, both knew their Bibles and the hearts of men better than do we, and certainly better than those who claim to provide divine liturgy for our use, in the continual stream of new services for public use from liturgical commissions of the western provinces of the Anglican Communion.

These sincere male and female liturgists and all of us need to learn from the Psalmists and Prophets, from Jesus and his Apostles, and from Archbishop Cranmer and the standard divines of the Anglican Way, that the humble confession of sin before God is the beginning of the true praise of God, the Holy One.

“Let us confess our sins unto Almighty God….”

The Revd Dr Peter Toon Michaelmas 2005

Saturday, September 24, 2005

PRAYER. Does it matter HOW we address God in public prayer?

Peter Toon (September 24, 2005)

If we are to address God, the LORD, in praise, thanksgiving, confession, petition and intercession within public worship in the same way that we talk one to another over lunch or in the classroom or on the street, then there are in essence few rules to follow. We must be well-mannered, decent, amicable, clear and hearty – or something like this combination (depending on circumstances of course). Speaking to God within this frame of reference, means that we shall have little concern for the massive difference between us (i.e., between God and man) and great concern for avoiding formal, traditional, and liturgical forms and phrases, so that we can speak in familiar, relevant and reasonably simple terms to a God whom we believe is near us and likes familiarity. Here God is first the immanent One, alongside to help, before he is the transcendent Holy One.

However, if we are to address God in public worship in a similar way to how subjects address their Emperor, citizens their President, and soldiers their General, then there are specific rules to follow. First of all, there will be profound respect and reverence, shown in words, attitude, deportment and dress. Then the words themselves will contain phrases which make clear that it is the “inferior” addressing the “superior” and he is doing so to ask for gifts or favors from him, as well as to honor and thank him. Speaking to the Almighty Father, the LORD, within this frame of reference means that our whole form of address proceeds from and assumes that God is the Creator and we are the created, that God is the Judge and we are the condemned, that God is the Savior and we can be saved and that God is the Redeemer and we can be redeemed. Reverence, awe, respect, humility and submission together with adoring love are the primary affections of the soul in this relation to God. God is first the transcendent HOLY ONE before he is the ever-present Friend alongside his covenant people. He is not “a Father” but the “Holy Father.”

Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of the Father, made a distinction between, on the one hand, his own communion with the Father in prayer (e.g., see John 17) and, on the other hand, the prayer of his disciples, and prayer in the synagogue and temple. The intimacy of Jesus with the Father was a holy and reverential intimacy and it was Person to Person, not public prayer. The disciples were taught not to pray, “My Father, who art in heaven…” but “Our Father….” which is corporate prayer. And the Lord’s Prayer is certainly not the language of the street or as between friends. It is profoundly formal, reverential and petitionary, the way we address the truly Superior and Transcendent One – “hallowed be thy Name.”

In general terms, we may say that much – but not all -- of what is called “modern” or “contemporary” liturgy belongs to the “be familiar with God” type and often is characterized by “dumbing-down” so that it will appeal to the lowest common denominator. Music accompanying it and the way folks dress suggest that it is a kind of special leisure activity! The pursuit of excellence is regarded as not appropriate for it will cause a barrier to many people. In contrast, the traditional Book of Common Prayer presents a form of excellence both in language and in doctrine. Here the idea is to raise up people to where the Bible says they ought to be, reverent and submissive, joyful and committed before the Holy Lord.

Lessons from history

The famous evangelical churchman of the early 19th century, Charles Simeon, whose powerful preaching and pastoral care in Cambridge University for many years was a great stimulus to the missionary movement and to the reviving of the Church of England, preached a series of sermons that he afterwards published as, The Excellence of the Liturgy. The series was on the content of The Book of Common Prayer (1662) and he proclaimed that in its language and address to God it was most appropriate for guilty sinners and adopted children of God to use; and in its doctrine it was a perfect summary and proclamation of primary biblical revelation and teaching. What Simeon declared was echoed not only by evangelical leaders after him (e.g., J.C.Ryle) but had been proclaimed before him by the great Caroline divines of the C of E. in the 17th century. Further, leading high-churchman of the 19th century commended enthusiastically the evangelical and catholic qualities of The Book of Common Prayer. And so have many 20th century worthies, including C.S. Lewis and leading novelists.

How would these “fathers in the Faith” describe the post 1960s attempts to write liturgy. Would they use “excellence” of any of it? Do well-informed and sensitive persons of today pronounce modern liturgies – Roman or Anglican – to be “excellent”? The most common word uttered in charity is “acceptable”! Even those who write and commend and use the new forms of worship in the West and North do not even think that they are working to produce excellence. Often dumbing-down is part of their strategy and follows from information gained in opinion surveys. They produce for today only, for they expect to have something now to present tomorrow.

And all this at a time when the biggest of the African Churches are clearly stating their commitment to the Book of Common Prayer of 1662 (which of course is available in various African languages).

Now a final comment.

It is possible, I believe, to have excellence even when the traditional English language of prayer is not used (see further, Neither Archaic Nor Obsolete by Tarsitano & Toon from www.anglicanmarketplace.com for study of the genuine English language of common prayer). That is, it is possible to pursue excellence in a Liturgy that uses the vernacular of today (this is an aim that the present Pope has much in mind for current R C Liturgy). So there is no reason why there should not be, for example, in contemporary English the very same content, structure, doctrine and style as is found in The Book of Common Prayer (1662 and later editions). It is possible to do such a job that the result can be declared to be “in pursuit of excellence” because done for the totally excellent LORD JESUS CHRIST.” Such a Liturgy would be superior to the liturgies produced by liberal liturgists and found in the Canadian BAS and the American “BCP” of 1979 and Enriching our Worship of 1991.

The “orthodox” constituency of North America happily has the classic Liturgy of excellence in the 1928 USA and 1962 Canadian editions. It could have very soon a contemporary equivalent if there is the will to have such! Where there is a will there is a way.

[For frank details of the liberal characteristics of the 1979 Rite II services from an insider see: Urban T Holmes, “Education for Liturgy”, in WORSHIP POINTS THE WAY (ed. M.C.Burson) New York 1991. See also Neither Orthodoxy Nor a Formulary by Tarsitano & Toon, www.anglicanmarketplace.com

Friday, September 23, 2005

Episcopalianism in the USA – cause for optimism in next decade?

Are the centripetal forces going to overcome the centrifugal ones?

Apart from the endless variety of types of Baptists, probably no type of church exists in the USA is so many different forms and manifestations as the Episcopal or the Anglican. And this is the more remarkable since there are probably 20 million Baptists present in churches on Sundays whereas there is only about one million Anglicans!

Let us first consider the forces which prize apart Episcopalians/Anglicans in the USA and then turn to consider what forces do and can unite them. But first let us set the scene.

The Episcopal Church of the USA (ECUSA) is a divided house, where dioceses are not in communion with others dioceses, where parishes look for flying bishops rather than the local, canonical one, and where there is open warfare over doctrinal and ethical matters. Outside the ECUSA there are many different jurisdictions, affiliations and groups of churches. One goes back to the 19th century (the REC) and some go back to the civil rights struggle (e.g. SEC) while others go back to the walk-out of ECUSA in 1977 (e.g., the ACA, ACC, APCK). Then others are splits from the latter or new creations on similar principles to the latter. Yet others are evangelical and charismatic in style (e.g., AMiA, and those parishes which are independently linked to overseas bishops). Add to these groupings of Nigerian churches, Indian Churches and other ethnic associations, together with charismatic Episcopal churches that have arisen independently and you have a real assortment! And there are others also, a new one each month or so.

Here are some of the Centrifugal forces at work dividing those who inside or outside the ECUSA desire to be orthodox and genuinely Anglican as biblical, Reformed Catholics.
  1. The presence of real heresy and error within the Anglican Way in the USA.
  2. The tendency amongst too many to major on minors and to cherish minors so that the essentials are not in focus sufficiently.
  3. The tendency for certain human beings to want to run their own show and empire and thereby to cherish division for providing a source of empire. See for example, the vast amount of bishops, many of whom have flocks that are very small, but they seem to cherish titles and uniforms.
  4. The vastness and the culture of the USA which supports individualism, selfish autonomy, variety and competition, novelty and innovation, and so on.
  5. The problem that once an organization or jurisdiction has been set up then it has a life of its own and it is easier to keep it going then to shut it down or unite it with another or others.
  6. Major differences in style of worship, from 1950s anglo-catholicism with much ceremonial, to 1990s style generic charismatic expressions of music and dress.
  7. Use of different Rites for services, ranging from Rite II of the 1979 prayer book, via Indian and Nigerian prayer books, to the Anglican Missal, and with no agreement on what is the Formulary of the Anglican Way.
  8. Different attitudes as to the way to regard and treat the official ECUSA – is it to be treated as reformable or as apostate and lost?
  9. Different attitudes to the See of Canterbury and to the Anglican Communion and whether or not they are truly orthodox in faith and morals?
  10. Possible unity with Rome – parts of the Continuing Anglican movement (anglo-catholic) are seeking to be accepted under the pastoral direction of the Church of Rome while others see this as a betrayal of the whole Anglican Way.
  11. Different approaches to church discipline, especially to the marriage of divorcees in church and the ordaining & consecrating of divorcees, or those married to divorcees.
  12. Different views and doctrines of the ministry and deployment of women in the churches.
    Different canon law.
  13. Not a few believe that competition and variety is a good thing and that there is no problem for God or for man with a divided and confused Anglican phenomenon in the USA. It is truly Americanized by its division and competitive character!

AND SO ON!

Now here are some of the Centripetal forces present in the Anglican and Episcopalian phenomenon in the USA.

  1. All the participants speak and use English.
  2. All value in varying degrees the Anglican tradition of worship, doctrine and discipline.
  3. All seem pleased or grateful to be known as Anglican or Episcopalian in contrast to being Presbyterian or Lutheran or whatever.
  4. All recognize that the Anglican witness in the USA was in earlier times a united one, the PECUSA even survived the civil war.
  5. All believe that Jesus Christ prayed that his Church should be one (John 17) and that all the metaphors used by the apostles of the Church presuppose that it should be a unity.
  6. All agree that doctrinal and liturgical integrity are important.
  7. All accept that there has to be a basic moral code for the life of the churches, a code that is derived from Holy Scripture and one that points to maturity and holiness of faith.
  8. A few people here and there, a few organizations here and there, and a few churches here and there, are definitely taking every opportunity to unite in activity and discussion Episcopalians/Anglicans from different streams. They see themselves as doing what many more ought also to be doing now and also as the first-fruits of a harvest yet to be.


What is very obvious to the observer, as well as to the student of Anglican affairs, is that the centrifugal forces seem to be more powerful than the centripetal ones and that the tendency to pull apart is more evident that a tendency to pull together.

Conclusion

If one takes the New Testament seriously, one must believe that Christians are to be united in Word and Sacrament, in worship and fellowship, in doctrine and in morals. And especially if they are of the same “kith and kin” called “Anglican.” Therefore, one must believe that the Holy Spirit, “the Lord and Giver of Life,” is supportive of genuine centripetal forces that move to unite believers in the one Christ and one Faith.

What else can be done to assist, as it were, this work of the Holy Spirit, and for us all to be “co-workers together with God” in this enterprise of unity for Christ’s sake?

I suggest that it would be beneficial for all the forms of Anglicanism in the USA that claim to be orthodox to accept, as a discipline and as a sweet offering to the Lord our God for say a decade, the use of the historic Anglican Rites for worship – that is the Rites of the 1662 BCP (or its modern equivalents) and to use them either in the original traditional English or in a dignified form of contemporary English (yet to be produced). Of course there would be local ceremonial and local specialities and emphases in each parish (with music and vestments and the like) but this proposal to be effective requires all parishes to use this One Rite, or else its power to unite would not be available everywhere.

The Anglican Way from 1549 through to the 1970s was glued together in a unity with comprehensiveness of churchmanship by the use of the one BCP used in 150 or so local editions around the world. To recapture this unity through One Rite seems to be the only way immediately available of beginning to unite the schisms and divisiveness within the bruised Anglican Way in the USA.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)



Rite II of the 1979 Prayer Book. Is it really orthodox?

Thousands in the USA, who claim to be biblically-based and orthodox in their Episcopal Faith , use the Rite II form of the “Holy Eucharist” from the 1979 Prayer Book weekly. They address the “You-God” in language which is supposed to be how people talk one with another. Further, the two supposed “orthodox” seminaries of the ECUSA use it and teach that it is an OK Rite. And most of these people who use and teach it have no personal experience of the use of a classic Anglican Book of Common Prayer (e.g., the edition of 1662, 1928 [USA] or 1962 [Canada]). Thus their Anglican perspective is rather limited in depth and width.

I invite all users of Rite II to consider what I write below.

I wish to suggest that these two propositions are true:

  1. In and of itself, and by itself, and also within the covers of the 1979 Prayer Book & Formulary of the Episcopal Church of the USA, Rite II Eucharist exhibits serious dumbing-down together with doctrinal error.
  2. Interpreted by and in the context of the classic American BCP of 1928, the Formulary of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA, Rite II Eucharist can be understood by charitable supposition as a modern, temporary experiment in liturgy and thereby judged as favorable for short-term use only.


What a word or a phrase or a sentence means depends to a large degree on context. “Eye” for example has a different meaning in these two statements: “The eye of the storm is compact” and “the human eye is a marvelous organ.”

What a specific service/Rite for Holy Communion means can be decided by a careful examination of what it contains and a judgment as it were, at face value, can be made in terms of how it is constructed in terms of its shape, its content, its emphases and its conclusions.

The same Rite can be set in a larger context – e.g. in the Prayer Book in which it appears and its relation therein to a Catechism and other Rites – and its meaning decided not only on its particular shape and content but also on its relation to other liturgy and doctrine.

In and of itself


On its own the Rite II material for the Holy Eucharist reveals that it is a production that could only have occurred after the 1960s and before the 1980s. This judgment is based on where the developing and changing mindset of liberal liturgists was in the second half of the twentieth century. Its general structure and the “shape” of the Eucharistic Prayer belong to a period when Gregory Dix’s, Shape of the Liturgy was in vogue and when the liberating impact of post Vatican II changes within the R C Church was strong. Also, it belongs to the beginnings of the acceptance of the feminist agenda by liturgists but is not yet at the stage seen in later Liturgy (e.g. Enriching our Worship from the 1990s with its advance feminism). Further, it belongs to the period of the first impact of the employment of the dynamic equivalency theory of translation of ancient texts, a theory which allows an ancient text to speak as if it were written today. Then, its use of ecumenical agreed texts from supposedly international bodies (e.g. ICEL) for the major canticles and translations of the Creeds points to the acceptance of an ecumenical form of dumbing-down of meaning to make them generally acceptable in the whole of the English-speaking world. [historical note; most of these agreed texts have been updated and changed, sometimes substantially, since the 1970s]

Anyone who goes through Rite II now, and who is aware of where liturgists have moved, can see why there is a universal agreement amongst liturgists that the texts are out of date and a new Rite or set of Rites, incorporating new insights and texts, is urgently required. (This is why the C of E abandoned its 1980 ASB in favor of its 2000 Common Worship and why the ECUSA is now urgently preparing a wholly new set of forms of worship to replace the ones from the twentieth century.)

So Rite II is out of date by the judgment of its creators.

As Rite II stands now in terms of doctrine it is imprecise. That is, because of its dumbed-down English and use of dynamic equivalency and the liberalism if its creators, it contains weakened doctrines of virtually every fundamental doctrine of the Faith, from the Trinity, through the Person and Work of Christ, to Salvation, Sin and Judgment. And recalling that it was put together by liberal theologians and liturgists, who wished to remove much of the clarity of Reformed Catholic doctrine in the 1662 BCP & 1928 BCP, such an observation makes good sense. [Note, the point being made here may be missed by those who are not very familiar with the classic content of BCP of 1662 and its North American editions.]

In the context of the whole of the 1979 Book

If the Rite II is interpreted alongside the Psalter, the Baptismal Service, the Catechism and Rite I, then its character as described above is the more clear. It is to be seen as an attempt to incorporate into the worship of God and the doctrines of the Christian Religion various insights and emphases that came to the fore in the 1960s and became afterwards part of the permanent “faith” of progressive liberals – e.g., pursuit of justice and peace, God’s kingdom is realizable in this world, the Church is the “community of those whose priority is peace and justice on earth,” God is more immanent than transcendent and so on. Thus (as the history of the ECUSA from 1960s to 2005 shows) the Church is committed to the incorporation of the rights of the divorced to be remarried in church, of the full use of contraception in pursuit of self-gratification, to the full rights of women, minorities and homosexual persons, to the calling of evil good and the affirmation that sin is holiness, and so on. Rite II Eucharist was until the 1990s the major means of the advancement of this total agenda in the ECUSA. Then Enriching our Worship took over for the advanced guard! Rite II never has been and cannot by its nature be the godly means and vehicle of the maturing of the faithful and their growth in godliness and true piety.

In the context of the BCP of 1928

If the PECUSA (which became the ECUSA after World War II) had retained its historic and inherited Formularies (BCP, Ordinal & Articles) and had not abandoned them as it did in 1976/79, and had it set forth a Book of Alternative Services (ASB or BAS) in 1979, and had that book been like what is now wrongly called the BCP of 1979, then (and only then) the content of the 1979 book could have been interpreted generously and charitably through the prism of the doctrine of the received Formularies of the Anglican Way. Hence suspicions of error and of dumbing-down could have been seen as experimental and open to correction later. In other words, Rite II as it now is, could have been interpreted within a very large context, and benefits of the doubt applied widely and kindly. Regrettably this possibility is near impossible since Rite II is a major part – let us note this carefully – a major part of the Formulary of the ECUSA, providing form and substance for what it believes, teaches and confesses! No wonder ECUSA is built upon sand and it is a constantly experiencing big cracks and falling apart because of its foundations.

Conclusion.

In that the ECUSA knowingly and deliberately set aside its received, classical and historic Formularies and created new ones (all inside the 1979 Prayer Book) then Rite II has to be seen (a) within the limited context of the 1979 book and (b) the liturgical and theological context out of which it came and which it served. Much of that context is the progressively liberal Episcopal Church itself.

As such, the greatest amount of charitable supposition and the giving of the benefit of the doubt is needed to make Rite II texts speak biblical theology and Anglican Reformed Catholic doctrine. And this judgment would apply even if the texts addressed the “Thou-God”!

The time has surely come for the would-be orthodox of ECUSA to ask for a Rite that is within the genuine shape, content and doctrine of the Anglican Eucharist and Order of Holy Communion. As a starter, a truly contemporary version of the Service in the BCP 1662, 1928 and 1962 (Canada) is needed for those who desire to address the LORD as “you”! Then the One Rite would be available it is traditional and in its contemporary form and there would be the basis for biblical and Anglican orthodoxy and from this for growth in maturity and membership.

September 23, 2005 petertoon@msn.com

Thursday, September 22, 2005

On Recovering Anglican Identity

A real contest is necessary
Will David challenge Goliath again?


If ever the U.S.A. is to see again in this century a genuine expression of the Anglican Way that is culturally American (rather than Nigerian or Rwandan or Indian – via missions from these groups) then a battle must be fought at the liturgical and doctrinal level.

True enough, American Episcopalianism has had recently more than its fair share of controversy and dissension, but there is yet another contest to come, another war to be fought, and the sooner the better.

The historic Rites/Forms of Service contained in the classic editions (e.g., 1662, & 1928 [USA] & 1962 [Canada]) of The Book of Common Prayer (lst edition 1549) must rise up to do battle with the modern Rites/Forms of Service found in the 1979 Prayer Book (falsely called “The Book of Common Prayer”), the 1985 BAS of Canada and in the 1997 ECUSA book called “Enriching our Worship.”

It seems right now in 2005 that the battle has been fought and the modern Rites have won conclusively. Virtually all the churches of Episcopal Church and, amazingly, virtually all the churches who confess to being the “orthodox” minority in this Church (and who belong in most cases to “The Network” and the American Anglican Counci and Forward in Faith) use the modern Rites -- and more often than not, Rite II of the 1979 prayer book.

The number of parishes in the ECUSA that still use the classic Book of Common Prayer for all, or some of their services, is exceedingly small, probably not more than seventy. And even in the Anglican Mission in America, the use of the 1979 prayer book and Rite II dominate, with not more than one congregation in twenty using the authentic Book of Common Prayer.

So where is an authentic edition of the historic Book of Common Prayer currently widely used in America? The answer is in what are called The Continuing Anglican Churches and in the Reformed Episcopal Church. There are several hundreds of these but they are mostly small congregations.

One thing is clear, the use of Rite II for Daily Prayer and for Holy Communion, and the use of the Baptismal Service of the 1979 book (a service which is the source and guarantee of major innovations in the Episcopal Church via its “baptismal covenant”) do not provide America with an authentic form of the Anglican Way. They provide instead a kind of modern generic form of ecumenism, from which the teeth of the Gospel and the sword of the Word God have been all but removed. Of course, in good hands they can be used to achieve good things, but in essence they present a dumbed-down ecumenical liturgy, that was invented by progressive liberals for the cause of the abandonment of historic biblical and creedal orthodoxy! If the aim is to be relevant, accessible, acceptable and inoffensive to modern secular minds and ears, then Rite II works well, for it has a weak doctrine of sin and a weaker doctrine of the holiness and righteous judgment of Almighty God.

So why a contest?

In order to establish their character as truly of the Anglican Way, the Network and AMiA parishes must surely recover really and practically (and not merely nominally) the historic Liturgy of the classic Formularies of the Anglican Way, as the basis of their doctrine and of their worship. It may be noted that the historic, classic Book of Common Prayer can be recovered in two forms – obviously in its received form as Formulary and Liturgy (in the historic form of the English language of public prayer) & also in a strict equivalent form in contemporary English (so that the shape, content and doctrine of the original is wholly preserved). Then congregations will have the original as Formulary and available for use and also may use the contemporary version for worship if they choose to do so. (The full contemporary version does not yet exist but could be made available reasonably quickly, for where there is a will there is a way.)

The contest then would be between the present occupant of the Anglican ground, the 1979 prayer book with its assisting prayer books, and the occupier of part of the perimeter, the classic Book of Common Prayer (available in two complete versions, the traditional and contemporary forms).

This contest must be fought for the soul of the Anglican Way in North America and if the 1979 book (= 1985 in Canada) triumphs and retains its virtually total dominance, then what is called Episcopalianism will merely continue to strengthen in character (even as it diminishes in numbers) as an ecumenical, generic, liberal expression of modern liturgy and church polity (often with a charismatic overlay).

The contest has yet to begin for the leadership of the Network and the AMiA seem satisfied with the dominant use of the 1979 texts. Yet there is the beginnings of much stirring in the parishes and missions and from the battle has to start.

Will David arise to challenge Goliath? Will copies of the classic Book of Common Prayer in its original form and in a contemporary language form be made available, examined and put to real use in the parishes and missions this year?

The unity of the Anglican Way in America is only possible through a basic agreement on a common formulary and rites. Right now the Anglican or Episcopal Household in the USA is a much divided House (“by schism rent asunder, by heresies distressed”); and there must be a contest within this Household to decide whether or not it is to regain its authentic and original Name, Integrity and Faith. Unity will only come through a contest wherein the progressive liberalism of the 1979 prayer book is banished from the Anglican Household and Way and right order and doctrine and worship are restored!

[Visit http://www.anglicanmarketplace.com/ for details of books to give more information and perspective]

Peter Toon

Pax to all

THE PEACE - often chaotic and noisy in practice, but, when appreciated, most important for the salvation of our souls

Those who are old enough to remember public worship before the 1970s are able to recall how their own parish was introduced to the “Passing of the Peace”, what reasons were given by priests to justify the novelty, and how they felt about the innovation. To this day there is a minority who do their best to avoid this activity! Of course, where the Service is either the Tridentine Latin Rite or the Order for Holy Communion from the classic Book of Common Prayer then there is no such thing to” endure” or “enjoy”.

Let us note the basics of this innovation.

In the modern Roman Mass, after the Eucharistic Prayer and before the receiving of Communion, the Priest says:

Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum (The peace of the Lord be with you always.)

And the faithful respond:

Et cum spiritu tuo (And with your spirit – “And also with you”.)

Then the Priest says:

Offerte vobis pacem. (Let us offer [to each other the sign of] peace.)

And then either in an orderly way (from the ministers at the altar to the congregation row by row) or in a less orderly way (each moves about as he or she desires) people offer a sign (handshake, hug or whatever) of peace.

Not too long ago, the Pax Vobiscum was offered by the Priest but there was no actual invitation to the congregation to offer of a sign of peace, and people stayed on their knees.

Those who have visited a variety of R.C. churches in recent days report that the exchange of peace takes many forms and can take an extended time in some.

In the Anglican, Lutheran and Methodist Churches, which share a common shape to their modern Eucharistic Liturgy, the exchange of the sign of peace occurs in a different place to that of the Roman Church. It comes at the end of the Ministry of the Word & Prayer and before the beginning of the Eucharistic Prayer. However, though in a different place, the way it occurs in terms of handshakes and hugs is much the same as in the modern Roman Catholic parishes. It can devout and quiet or it can be a long, noisy and involved affair (including as I saw recently, drinking coffee and having a donut!)

Doctrinal Meaning

Its place in the Roman Rite is long-standing, going back to the late patristic period. The basic idea of it is that the peace (= the salvation and reconciling love) of God the Father through Jesus Christ and by the Holy Ghost made manifest in the Eucharist/Mass brings baptized believers together as one in Christ, and thus, as children of God and as brothers and sisters, the baptized share a sign of peace/salvation. They do not need to share a sign for the peace/reconciliation is given by God as a gift to all present, who are penitent and faithful; but the sign helps to make the gift of God real.

Its present place in the modern Liturgies of the Anglican Lutheran and Methodist Churches is based on what modern liturgists claim to find in the practice of the Church of the second and third centuries. Here (with women and men separated) there was, it is said, “a passing of the peace” and its purpose was to not only to accept God’s reconciling love offered in Christ and in the Eucharist, but also to provide opportunity for reconciliation between believers before the service moved along to the Communion.

So whether we take the meaning as from the early patristic era or from the medieval Latin Church, we have to admit that it is, in both cases, by no means at all a flippant matter; and it is certainly no occasion for idle conversation or silly remarks. It is an opportunity to receive the reconciling love of the Lord and to begin to know and feel what it is all about. Observation would seem to suggest that this activity called the passing of the peace though relatively new is already in need of reformation and renewal for it has become in so many places and ways a means for the expression of what we may call “the flesh” rather than of the humble and contrite spirit. Further, and this is worrying, for some people it assumes a position of primary importance in their experience of worship and they would find it hard to do without it. (Let us remember that the Church managed for most of her existence without a public “passing of the peace” and its revival between 1970s and 2005 has not universally been the means of reconciliation and salvation for congregations.)

Historical Note: In the C of E Order for Holy Communion from 1552, the Pax Vobiscum was removed but – and this is important – the Peace of the LORD was given to the people of God through the extension of the Blessing at the end of the whole Service. “The Peace of God, which passeth all understanding, keep your heart and mind in the knowledge and love of God and of his Son, Jesus Christ our Lord: And the Blessing…..” However, in the Canadian BCP of 1960/62 the actual Pax Vobiscum is found at the same place as in the Roman Mass but without any indication that there is to be the giving of a sign one to another.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)

Wednesday, September 21, 2005

Liturgical Variety – is variety the spice of congregational life?

Has the time arrived for variety to give way to uniformity? Please read on.

For eighteen or nineteen centuries the local congregations of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church worshipped the Father through the Son and with the Holy Ghost using basically One Rite, one basic form of the Eucharist. Of course, this Rite was regional and there were differences from one region to another and between jurisdictions (East and West, for example). However, each region or jurisdiction had its own basic Rite.

That is, the local priest did not have to decide before, or on each, Sunday which of several available Rites he would use. The shape and content of the Service were fixed for him as also were the Lectionary, Collects, Psalms and Canticles.

Let us ask the question. Was great harm done to the people of God in East and West, in North and South, because in the Orthodox Churches, the Roman Catholic Church and the Anglican Churches there was (until the 1970s) only one basic service, one form of the Eucharist, available in each region/nation/jurisdiction? They had no variety (except that the Collect and Lessons and Psalter changed each week). Were they spiritually starved without the opportunity to have a different Rite every week or month?

Anyone who argues that they were starved spiritually will have a hard time convincing anyone, for, it appears that the use of one excellent Rite certainly helped to form genuine piety with a Christian mind in millions of baptized believers. And what great examples of Christian writing, music and art were produced within this uniformity of excellence?

In the 1970s, after the Vatican Council of 1962-1965 and the tremendous social and cultural effects of the era of the 1960s, church leaders within the R C Church and the Anglican Churches (not to mention Lutheran & Methodist!) decided that variety is not only the spice of fleshly life in this evil age and sinful world, but is also necessary as preparation for eternal life in the kingdom of heaven. They decided that not only did the people of God need new forms, shapes and types of Liturgy but that within the new provisions there should be variety in terms of Rite. Thus in the Episcopal Church of the U.S.A. there are now multiple Rites approved (via 1979 prayer book and publications since) for the Eucharist, and in the RC Church its modern Sacramentary contains a dozen Rites for the Mass.

In 2005, despite the available variety of Rites, in practice most Episcopal congregations choose one or two, print them, and then use only these – simply because it is too much work and bother to keep on changing (as liturgists would like them to do). In practice also, most Roman Catholic priests generally use only two of the possibilities, the traditional Rite on formal occasions and a shorter one when they have limited time available to say Mass before hurrying off to another parish or engagement.

Perhaps it is politically incorrect to ask the question: Does the availability of multiple Rites with the accompanying lack of any basic uniformity actually militate against the formation of genuine piety, devotion, Christian mindset and sense of the unity of the Body of Christ? Nevertheless a case can be made for an affirmative answer to this question. Certainly there is little evidence in the West that the availability of New and Varied Rites has actually helped in the evangelization of the populace and the edification of baptized believers.

Perhaps, after nearly 40 years of experiment and confusion, it may be suggested that it is time to do a major U-turn. That is to return to the One Rite, the traditional Rite, of both the Roman and Anglican Churches, with its availability for Rome in Latin and English and for Anglicans in traditional and contemporary English.

Variety has not been the spice of congregational or eternal life; the time has arrived for uniformity of a comprehensive kind to be restored!

Let us dig again the wells of Abraham and be refreshed by the water of life.

Peter Toon September 21 2005

Tuesday, September 20, 2005

DUMBING DOWN by Episcopalians – and of the Central Dogma of the FAITH

A call to Trinitarian Orthodoxy

Do you realize that at every ordination of a bishop, priest and deacon in the Episcopal Church since the 1970s there has been a dumbing-down of the central dogma of the Christian religion at the very beginning of the services? (See 1979 prayer book, pages 512, 525, & 537)

Do you realize that at every baptism since the 1970s there has been also a dumbing down of the central dogma of the Christian religion at the beginning of the service? (See 1979 prayer book, page 299)

Do your realize that at every Rite II Eucharist (except during Lent & Easter season) there has been since the 1970s a dumbing-down of the central dogma of the Christian religion? (See page 355)

In 1967 someone on the Liturgical Commission came up with the idea of beginning the Eucharist with an Acclamation and produced one, based upon the Blessing given by the priest in the Orthodox Liturgy. Let us first of all note what is the original Blessing from the ancient Liturgy of St Chrysostom of the patristic period.

At the beginning of the “Liturgy of the Catechumens” within the Divine Liturgy, the priest, holding the Gospel Book, intones:

Blessed is the kingdom of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, now, and ever, and unto ages of ages.

This Blessing is Praise of God and secondly blessing of the congregation. It affirms that that there is one and one only divine kingdom, but that there are three divine Persons in the One Godhead. Thus the kingdom is the kingdom of each One and of all Three, evn as there is one Divine Nature and each Person possesses this wholly and completely. The whole liturgy celebrates the Kingdom and provides entrance to the heavenly banquet of the Kingdom through Communion.

Let us now note the abbreviated & dumbed-down version created by the Liturgical Commission in 1967 and used ever since, first in trial liturgies and then in the 1979 prayer book.

Celebrant: Blessed be God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
People: And blessed be his kingdom, now and for ever. Amen.

To the untrained ear this may sound fine. To the average priest, with little education in classic doctrine and dogma, this may sound fine. To the priest or layman who desires to think the best of his church then this form of words can be charitably reckoned to pronounce the Christian dogma of the Trinity. But at the level of straight, clear analysis of the form of words used, and the form of words compared with the original, this Acclamation is obviously a dumbing-down.

Why is it so?

It appears to be designed to obscure the clarity of the original Blessing that there are Three distinct Persons in the One Godhead. It does so by allowing the interpretation that there is One God who is One Person and who, as One Person, has three principal names – “Father, Son and Holy Spirit”. We all are perhaps aware that various alternatives to Trinitarian Theism were taught in the Episcopal Church (and liberal Churches) after World War II and that amongst these were forms of Unitarianism and Panentheism(= the world is in God). The force of the colon in the first line of this 1967 formula is to offer the possibility that “God” equals “Father, Son and Holy Spirit”. If the first line had been, “Blessed be God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit”, then the meaning would have been clearly Trinitarian Theism, but the progressive liberals were not happy with such clarity. They preferred to allow for a variety of possibilities for they saw the dogma of the Trinity from patristic times as a kind of hellenization and corruption of the simple Gospel of Jesus.

It is worthy of note that for the last decade and more many progressive liberal parishes in the ECUSA have changed line 1 to be, “Blessed be God: Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier,” which is clearly a form of Unitarianism.

It is also worthy of note that in the Catechism of the same prayer book (see page 852) the answer to the question,” What is the Trinity?” is as follows: “The Trinity is one God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.” Note again the use of the colon, suggesting that the one God has three Names or three Modes of being. The Commission could have given as the answer, “The Trinity is the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, one God.”

If there is one area of Christian use of words where great care and precision is necessary, it is surely the area of the way we speak of and address The Holy Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, Three Persons One Godhead! Here dumbing-down and carelessness are nearly unforgivable!

I suggest that those who must use the 1979 texts say: “Blessed be God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit” in order to make clear they do accept the teaching of the Bible and of the Dogma of the ecumenical councils of the Early Church.

The modern R C Mass begins, “In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit” making clear that there are Three Persons of the One Godhead. The people respond, “Amen.”

(For the history of and the doctrinal decrees of the Seven Ecumenical Councils, see Peter Toon, Yesterday, Today and Forever. Jesus Christ and the Holy Trinity in the Teaching of the Seven Ecumenical Councils, 1996, 224 pages paperback. Officially out of print but obtain a copy for $10.00 by e mailing, thomascranmer2000@yahoo.com )

September 20, 2005 Peter Toon