A discussion starter from Peter Toon
In choosing whether or not to enter into marriage, we often hear it said today that "modern people want a relationship not an institution."
Throughout human history marriage between a man and a woman (or sometimes, several women) has been regarded as an institution. That is, as an established organization with a social, economic and religious purpose. Marriage has been seen as a means of creating, safeguarding and cementing important social, economic, political and family ties. Thus the choice of a wife or husband for a son or daughter was very much in the control of the parents and their advisors. When married, the couple learned to respect and care for each other, guided by their families and friends.
The ideal of a man and woman getting married primarily because they are "in love" is western and hardly more than 150 years old. And it was only in the latter part of the twentieth century that it became the dominant view of the reason for getting married. Naturally this ideal of self-fulfillment in love was expressed through a word never before used of marriage or betrothal, the word, "relationship."
Is there a mid-point between seeing "marriage" as an institution and as a relationship?
It may be suggested that one such mid-point was seriously attempted in the 1950s, when marriage was extremely popular and most people aspired to be married by the time they were in their early twenties. The ideal was of the man as the breadwinner and of the wife as the homemaker and the one who took care of the (at least) two children. Pundits and preachers worked from this model and encouraged/commanded people to make it work and work well. Preachers even claimed that this was the biblical model!
However, this 1950s experiment soon began to disintegrate as the model of "relationships" came to dominate thinking and practice.
If we look back over the 150 years (1850-2000), in which the ideal of marrying for [romantic] love has been gaining ground and achieving virtual total success in the West, we see five major obstacles that had to be overcome in order to give people the personal autonomy and sexual freedom necessary for this ideal to prevail fully and completely.
The first obstacle was the inherited view that there are major, innate differences between men and women with regard to their sexual desires and drives. Only in the 1920s was it generally conceded that sexual satisfaction for women was as important as for men, and that they deserved equal consideration.
The second obstacle was the power and ability of families, neighbors, employers, churches and governments to regulate personal behavior and even penalize aberrations! This gradually collapsed as major changes in the culture and economic and social life occurred and greater degrees of personal freedom and personal anonymity developed.
The third obstacle to be removed was unreliable means of birth control. Only in the 1960s did means of birth control become reliable enough that fear of pregnancy was removed and women were "liberated" to choose when "to have sex" and with whom.
A fourth obstacle was the harsh penalties for illegitimacy both socially and legally in force. By the 1970s the legal category of illegitimacy was removed and it became widely accepted that it was wrong to penalize a child for the actions of its biological parents.
The final obstacle was the dependence of women on men both economically and legally. This broke down gradually and was pretty much gone by the 1980s. During much the same time-frame, the production of a host of labor-saving goods, from clothing that did not need ironing to automatic this-and-that, undercut men's dependence on women as housekeepers. So each sex became free of the other and able to be self-sufficient to a degree. Also a man and a woman each had the freedom to choose or not to choose marriage and to choose this or that partner for cohabitation or for marriage.
Some of the results of this REVOLUTION in the understanding and practice of marriage and sexual relations we know well. When romantic love and personal autonomy are dominant then there will be many marriages but also many divorces; divorced persons will re-marry; couples will enter a first marriage much later than previous generations did; couples will live together as partners in co-habitation without marriage; children will know step-parents as well as parents; birth certificates will have two different surnames as the parents; homosexual persons will claim the same rights as heterosexual persons, and so on.
There is a real sense of inevitability to the fall out from this REVOLUTION wherein marriage ceases to be an institution and becomes "a relationship." Yet, there are still some happy marriages which last, but these are a minority of "partnerships" in the modern West.
How does the Church pastorally deal with all this?
According to its inherited teaching, the Church has a very high view of marriage as the union of a man and woman as one flesh until the death of one of them. The model set forth is the mystical marriage of Christ, the Bridegroom, and his Church, the Bride.
In practice, the Church has accommodated to reality by finding ways to justify the use of artificial birth control, to bless the marriages of those who have been cohabiting and those who marry for the second or third time, to welcome to the Lord's Table those who (by previous standards) are guilty of fornication, to allow clergy who divorce and remarry to continue without discipline as pastors, and so on.
Of course, resistance to the new REALITY is strong in some places and weak in others, but virtually all types of modern denominations have accommodated by compromises to the REVOLUTION that has occurred. Usually this has been done out of pastoral care, of wanting to meet people where they are and being caring towards them. For example, the R C Church has greatly increased the number of annulments it has given to members who are divorced by law and the Episcopal Church has allowed its clergy to bless many "unions" of "gay" people.
One good thing that perhaps can be said is this. Where there is a good marriage today it is usually a truly good one, for the persons involved have had to work hard and make sacrifices to achieve their mutuality and happiness. In many ways they have had to work against the odds, against the culture and against the trends. Perhaps the Church can put more energy into encouraging good marriages and enabling the wife and husband to exert the necessary discipline and graciousness to achieve this end -- by the grace of God. To do this, her Ministers will need to be both chaste and wise, patient and caring, filled with the Spirit and his gifts!
June 7, 2005 The Revd Dr Peter Toon petertoon@msn.com
Wednesday, June 08, 2005
Friday, June 03, 2005
Is there a place for patriotism and/or nationalism in Common Prayer?
Citizenship of the heavenly Jerusalem & the Holy Eucharist
A discussion starter!
Let me begin by talking about Britain, which I know well.
In the Church of England, which is an established Church, there is in all the Sunday services the possibility of appropriate prayer [and in the classic BCP it is a requirement] for the Monarch [Queen Elizabeth II) and the royal family. The reason for this inclusion is that the Monarch not only rules the nation as Queen in Parliament but that in England alone she is also the Supreme Governor of the National Church. All Bishops are appointed by her, on the advice of the Prime Minister (who himself is advised by a commission of the General Synod of the Church), and any major changes in the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Church have also to be accepted by her.
In the [Anglican] Church in Wales and the Episcopal Church of Scotland there is also the possibility of prayer for the Queen who rules in and through Parliament. However, this prayer is not for her as Supreme Governor, for she does not have this position in these Churches.
Though there is prayer for the Queen, the government and nation in the intercessions of “The Order for Holy Communion” of the Book of Common Prayer (1662) in the Church of England, it is not usual, for there to be any obvious patriotism or nationalism displayed in this traditional service. For example, the singing of the National Anthem or any patriotic type of hymn is extremely rare within this service. This is how it ought to be, I think.
However, with public services of Morning and Evening Prayer the case can be different. Here patriotism (not nationalism or racism) is displayed from time to time as when the flags and banners of organizations are taken in procession through the church and when the National Anthem is sung at civic services, as when the dead of the World Wars are remembered on November 11.
Why do I suggest that anywhere in the world the celebration of the Eucharist should never include the expression of patriotism? Here is the beginning of an answer.
Wherever one is in God’s world, the celebration of the Holy Eucharist, by the means of any orthodox rite/service, is a celebration of the heavenly Jerusalem, beyond space and time, not of an earthly city of kingdom. Those present lift up their hearts and, by the Holy Ghost, they are lifted up into the heavenly place, where they feast at the Messianic Banquet on the Body and Blood of the once crucified and now exalted Lord Jesus. They are in communion with the Father through the Son and with the Holy Ghost. There is absolutely no place for patriotism or nationalism or racism here in this holy and rarified ethos. The family of God is from every tribe and every tongue and the heavenly Lord is lord of all peoples, races and nations. So those celebrating the Eucharist in Australia or in Bolivia or in Estonia or in New York City are all lifted up to the same Place and are present there are citizens of heaven, as fellow members of the Body of Christ and of the Household of God. In terms of their relation to earth and nations there, they are sojourners and pilgrims, for their true home is in the heavenly paradise, redeemed by the blood of the Lamb.
If we have a right view of what the Order for Holy Communion/ the Mass/ the Eucharist is all about, then we surely know that in its celebration we leave behind all nationalisms, patriotisms, racisms, ethnicities and whatever else. For only in so doing by God’s help and grace can we become that which God actually reckons us to be in Christ – that is, his adopted children, citizens of heaven and dwellers in the heavenly Jerusalem, who have been made clean by the blood of the Lamb. The experience of the Eucharist is for pilgrims & sojourners on earth a foretaste of heaven, the first-fruits of the heavenly life and the anticipation of what shall be for ever!
This being so, I suggest, the place (church building or anywhere else) where the Christian assembly for Eucharist takes place ought not to display obvious signs of patriotism, let alone of nationalism, or racism, and there should not be the singing as solos or as congregational hymns patriotic songs. There is plenty of space and time for healthy patriotism outside the sacred hour of the Eucharist. This hour belongs to the patriotism of heaven, of the heavenly Jerusalem, and of the new heavens and the new earth.
I fear that I may be seen as attacking the practice of “conservative” and “traditional” parishes in the USA where there is obvious patriotism [proudly] displayed at the Eucharist. Let me say that I am all for healthy patriotism (but not for nationalism and racism) but that the Eucharist is the one place where this conviction and expression is not appropriate!
The Revd Dr Peter Toon June 4, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
A discussion starter!
Let me begin by talking about Britain, which I know well.
In the Church of England, which is an established Church, there is in all the Sunday services the possibility of appropriate prayer [and in the classic BCP it is a requirement] for the Monarch [Queen Elizabeth II) and the royal family. The reason for this inclusion is that the Monarch not only rules the nation as Queen in Parliament but that in England alone she is also the Supreme Governor of the National Church. All Bishops are appointed by her, on the advice of the Prime Minister (who himself is advised by a commission of the General Synod of the Church), and any major changes in the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Church have also to be accepted by her.
In the [Anglican] Church in Wales and the Episcopal Church of Scotland there is also the possibility of prayer for the Queen who rules in and through Parliament. However, this prayer is not for her as Supreme Governor, for she does not have this position in these Churches.
Though there is prayer for the Queen, the government and nation in the intercessions of “The Order for Holy Communion” of the Book of Common Prayer (1662) in the Church of England, it is not usual, for there to be any obvious patriotism or nationalism displayed in this traditional service. For example, the singing of the National Anthem or any patriotic type of hymn is extremely rare within this service. This is how it ought to be, I think.
However, with public services of Morning and Evening Prayer the case can be different. Here patriotism (not nationalism or racism) is displayed from time to time as when the flags and banners of organizations are taken in procession through the church and when the National Anthem is sung at civic services, as when the dead of the World Wars are remembered on November 11.
Why do I suggest that anywhere in the world the celebration of the Eucharist should never include the expression of patriotism? Here is the beginning of an answer.
Wherever one is in God’s world, the celebration of the Holy Eucharist, by the means of any orthodox rite/service, is a celebration of the heavenly Jerusalem, beyond space and time, not of an earthly city of kingdom. Those present lift up their hearts and, by the Holy Ghost, they are lifted up into the heavenly place, where they feast at the Messianic Banquet on the Body and Blood of the once crucified and now exalted Lord Jesus. They are in communion with the Father through the Son and with the Holy Ghost. There is absolutely no place for patriotism or nationalism or racism here in this holy and rarified ethos. The family of God is from every tribe and every tongue and the heavenly Lord is lord of all peoples, races and nations. So those celebrating the Eucharist in Australia or in Bolivia or in Estonia or in New York City are all lifted up to the same Place and are present there are citizens of heaven, as fellow members of the Body of Christ and of the Household of God. In terms of their relation to earth and nations there, they are sojourners and pilgrims, for their true home is in the heavenly paradise, redeemed by the blood of the Lamb.
If we have a right view of what the Order for Holy Communion/ the Mass/ the Eucharist is all about, then we surely know that in its celebration we leave behind all nationalisms, patriotisms, racisms, ethnicities and whatever else. For only in so doing by God’s help and grace can we become that which God actually reckons us to be in Christ – that is, his adopted children, citizens of heaven and dwellers in the heavenly Jerusalem, who have been made clean by the blood of the Lamb. The experience of the Eucharist is for pilgrims & sojourners on earth a foretaste of heaven, the first-fruits of the heavenly life and the anticipation of what shall be for ever!
This being so, I suggest, the place (church building or anywhere else) where the Christian assembly for Eucharist takes place ought not to display obvious signs of patriotism, let alone of nationalism, or racism, and there should not be the singing as solos or as congregational hymns patriotic songs. There is plenty of space and time for healthy patriotism outside the sacred hour of the Eucharist. This hour belongs to the patriotism of heaven, of the heavenly Jerusalem, and of the new heavens and the new earth.
I fear that I may be seen as attacking the practice of “conservative” and “traditional” parishes in the USA where there is obvious patriotism [proudly] displayed at the Eucharist. Let me say that I am all for healthy patriotism (but not for nationalism and racism) but that the Eucharist is the one place where this conviction and expression is not appropriate!
The Revd Dr Peter Toon June 4, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Thursday, June 02, 2005
Kyriakon & Ecclesia; & Ecclesia Anglicana
Most of us are so busy with the life and work of the parish or group to which we belong, that do not take or make time to reflect upon its name and that of the larger unit to which it belongs. And, in the vast supermarket of American religions, we get so used to the peculiarity of our own name and association, even though it may seem odd to outsiders, that just live with it.
When we do reflect, or when someone asks a pointed question, perhaps we notice that we use both the word “church” and “Anglican [and/or Episcopalian]” in different ways and with different meanings. Perhaps we do not realize that this is confusing to outsiders and may also reflect the lack of witness in American “Anglicanism” to the confession in the Creed – one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.
Let us begin with the word “church.” When we use it of the consecrated building or temple, such as St Mark’s Church, do we realize that the underlying word here is KYRIAKON which literally means “thing belonging to the Lord.” This being so, do we also observe how odd it is to insert into the name of this building further words, such as “St Mark’s Anglican Church” or “St Mark’s Reformed Episcopal Church” or “St Mark’s Anglican Mission in America Church” ? Here is a building consecrated in the name of an evangelist for the worship of the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost. Why complicate and distort this most important and beautiful fact by adding more nouns or adjectives? Why not simply have the correct name on line 1 and then on line 2 add any further information as to its identity (e.g., name of jurisdiction to which those who use the building belong)?
When we use the word “Church” in the Creed – one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church – we refer to the people of God, the household of God, the Body of Christ living through space and time and in heaven. The underlying word is ECCLESIA which literally means in the New Testament and in regular Greek, “assembly of people.” This people is governed by holy Order under the Lord Jesus Christ and it may possess holy buildings and other property, but “Church” here is people who are being saved from sin by divine grace and mercy. The local assembly of this universal people is also “church” and should be a kind of microcosm of the whole. Again the local assembly may have a KYRIAKON.
Regrettably the One Church of God is divided into many parts, several very large and many small. Thus for the purpose of identification of the parts we have to use adjectives to indicate what part (jurisdiction, branch, denomination etc.) is intended. So we speak of the “Orthodox” Churches and of the “Roman Catholic” Church. However, when we come to the use of “Anglican” or “Episcopal” we cannot any longer simply say “the Anglican Church” or “the Episcopal Church.”
Certainly there was once the one Ecclesia Anglicana in England and from this sister churches were founded in the British Empire and Commonwealth. But now, in North America, there is out there a growing list of the bits and pieces Anglicanism, testifying to the powerful centrifugal forces of modern American culture and religion, which caused them to be separate and keeps them so. There are over forty “jurisdictions” bearing the “Anglican brand name” in the American supermarket of religious denominations – everything from e.g., the Episcopal Church of the U.S.A. through the Christian Episcopal Church, the Episcopal Missionary Church, the Charismatic Episcopal Church, the Reformed Episcopal Church, the Anglican Catholic Church, the Anglican Orthodox Church, the Anglican Church of America, the Anglican Mission in America, the Anglican Province of Christ the King, to Anglican missions belonging to Anglican Provinces in Africa and South America. And many more! In each one there are “saints of God.”
From within this situation, Anglicans and Episcopalians may care to ask:
What are we doing to try to allow the centripetal powers of unifying grace to heal divisions and bridge chasms and reconcile the divided?
Do we think that this powerful statement of disunity honors the Lord or helps the propagation of the Gospel and the engagement in pure worship?
At least, should not all those who think that ECUSA is apostate at its center and who think that there is such a thing as the orthodox Anglican Way be seeking to find ways of being together in the name of Christ in real cooperation and practice?
Further, should not those who really want to unite their “Anglican” jurisdiction or group with Rome or the Orthodox or the conservative Lutherans or Presbyterians get on with doing this, so that those who really want to be Anglican Christians and who remain can attempt to unite in meaningful ways? [It is possible that those groups who are looking for unions outside of the Anglican Way are hindering the work of uniting the genuinely Anglican groups by raising unnecessary questions and creating unsolvable problems.]
---------------------------------
Additional Note. There is a further use of the word “Church” in the ECUSA and this is really neither from KYRIAKON or EKKLESIA! The commonly-used description of the Offices and Administration of the Episcopal Church in NYC as “the National Church” seems to equate “Church” with the office of the Presiding Bishop and the Executive Council of the General Convention.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon June 2, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
When we do reflect, or when someone asks a pointed question, perhaps we notice that we use both the word “church” and “Anglican [and/or Episcopalian]” in different ways and with different meanings. Perhaps we do not realize that this is confusing to outsiders and may also reflect the lack of witness in American “Anglicanism” to the confession in the Creed – one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.
Let us begin with the word “church.” When we use it of the consecrated building or temple, such as St Mark’s Church, do we realize that the underlying word here is KYRIAKON which literally means “thing belonging to the Lord.” This being so, do we also observe how odd it is to insert into the name of this building further words, such as “St Mark’s Anglican Church” or “St Mark’s Reformed Episcopal Church” or “St Mark’s Anglican Mission in America Church” ? Here is a building consecrated in the name of an evangelist for the worship of the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost. Why complicate and distort this most important and beautiful fact by adding more nouns or adjectives? Why not simply have the correct name on line 1 and then on line 2 add any further information as to its identity (e.g., name of jurisdiction to which those who use the building belong)?
When we use the word “Church” in the Creed – one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church – we refer to the people of God, the household of God, the Body of Christ living through space and time and in heaven. The underlying word is ECCLESIA which literally means in the New Testament and in regular Greek, “assembly of people.” This people is governed by holy Order under the Lord Jesus Christ and it may possess holy buildings and other property, but “Church” here is people who are being saved from sin by divine grace and mercy. The local assembly of this universal people is also “church” and should be a kind of microcosm of the whole. Again the local assembly may have a KYRIAKON.
Regrettably the One Church of God is divided into many parts, several very large and many small. Thus for the purpose of identification of the parts we have to use adjectives to indicate what part (jurisdiction, branch, denomination etc.) is intended. So we speak of the “Orthodox” Churches and of the “Roman Catholic” Church. However, when we come to the use of “Anglican” or “Episcopal” we cannot any longer simply say “the Anglican Church” or “the Episcopal Church.”
Certainly there was once the one Ecclesia Anglicana in England and from this sister churches were founded in the British Empire and Commonwealth. But now, in North America, there is out there a growing list of the bits and pieces Anglicanism, testifying to the powerful centrifugal forces of modern American culture and religion, which caused them to be separate and keeps them so. There are over forty “jurisdictions” bearing the “Anglican brand name” in the American supermarket of religious denominations – everything from e.g., the Episcopal Church of the U.S.A. through the Christian Episcopal Church, the Episcopal Missionary Church, the Charismatic Episcopal Church, the Reformed Episcopal Church, the Anglican Catholic Church, the Anglican Orthodox Church, the Anglican Church of America, the Anglican Mission in America, the Anglican Province of Christ the King, to Anglican missions belonging to Anglican Provinces in Africa and South America. And many more! In each one there are “saints of God.”
From within this situation, Anglicans and Episcopalians may care to ask:
What are we doing to try to allow the centripetal powers of unifying grace to heal divisions and bridge chasms and reconcile the divided?
Do we think that this powerful statement of disunity honors the Lord or helps the propagation of the Gospel and the engagement in pure worship?
At least, should not all those who think that ECUSA is apostate at its center and who think that there is such a thing as the orthodox Anglican Way be seeking to find ways of being together in the name of Christ in real cooperation and practice?
Further, should not those who really want to unite their “Anglican” jurisdiction or group with Rome or the Orthodox or the conservative Lutherans or Presbyterians get on with doing this, so that those who really want to be Anglican Christians and who remain can attempt to unite in meaningful ways? [It is possible that those groups who are looking for unions outside of the Anglican Way are hindering the work of uniting the genuinely Anglican groups by raising unnecessary questions and creating unsolvable problems.]
---------------------------------
Additional Note. There is a further use of the word “Church” in the ECUSA and this is really neither from KYRIAKON or EKKLESIA! The commonly-used description of the Offices and Administration of the Episcopal Church in NYC as “the National Church” seems to equate “Church” with the office of the Presiding Bishop and the Executive Council of the General Convention.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon June 2, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Tuesday, May 31, 2005
Conscience, God, ECUSA, stay or leave?
A discussion and Prayer starter…
Here is a question that we cannot avoid asking:
How is it that faced with the same REALITY (ECUSA in 2005) clergy & laity, claiming guidance by two UNIQUE REALITIES (God & Conscience), do not all go in the same direction (to stay within or to leave ECUSA, and if the latter, do not choose the same option)?
To help to answer it, here are some considerations:
While the progressivism and revisionism are very strong at the center of ECUSA, they are weak in some dioceses and strong in others. The experience of the new agenda, doctrines and commitments of the new religion of the ECUSA is not uniform, for it differs widely across the country. Therefore, practically speaking, people are facing different but related phenomena in various places, and so they have to respond to and make judgments about different pressures and circumstances. After all Fort Worth and New Jersey dioceses are different in terms of experiencing the new religion.
Individual conscience is unique for no two persons have identical consciences. Each conscience is informed by the mind and is really the mind making moral judgments, and saying strongly, “you ought to do this” or “you ought not to do that.” The moral imperative of conscience is not to be equated with having a person opinion about this or that. Conscience does not process opinions but moral judgments. For a variety of reasons, Christian people do not always obey their conscience, or they obey in part. Further, what their conscience proclaims on a given question may change as they grow in maturity in faith, hope and love.
While all Christians have the same relation by grace to God through Christ and by the Holy Ghost, the strength and maturity of this relation differs from baptized believer to baptized believer. Seeking guidance from God in a complex issue, such as deciding to leave one church and join another, is not a straightforward matter. Maturity in the walk with God will play a part in how the question is asked, how an answer is processed, and how it is acted upon.
Many people are influenced by others, especially those whom they look up to and respect. So we should expect most members of a congregation to follow the example and advice of respected pastors and leaders. At the same time we would expect the independent-minded not to follow easily or quickly.
The departing from ECUSA by a priest whose stipend, medical cover and pension are all tied up with this Church, and who has no independent means, is a more difficult and complex decision than that of a layperson who will experience no financial loss.
The departing from ECUSA of a family with special ties to the building and with family memorials therein is a more difficult decision than the departing of a family with no special ties to a sacred place and temple.
One could continue with other considerations. However, it is reasonably clear, I think, that each of us is an unique person with an unique conscience. When faced with a major decision, it is not surprising that each of us, as an imperfect, forgiven sinner weighs the matter similarly but differently to the next person, and that the difference in judgment may be small but can be, and is often, great. Thus some choose to depart and some to remain, and those who depart go in different directions.
As Anglicans we are to pray one for another and love one another. To criticize a person for making a different decision than our own is not wise! In the complexity of North American Anglicanism, we need to be charitable, very charitable and find ways to work together to revive the Anglican Way of Christianity.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon. May 31, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Here is a question that we cannot avoid asking:
How is it that faced with the same REALITY (ECUSA in 2005) clergy & laity, claiming guidance by two UNIQUE REALITIES (God & Conscience), do not all go in the same direction (to stay within or to leave ECUSA, and if the latter, do not choose the same option)?
To help to answer it, here are some considerations:
While the progressivism and revisionism are very strong at the center of ECUSA, they are weak in some dioceses and strong in others. The experience of the new agenda, doctrines and commitments of the new religion of the ECUSA is not uniform, for it differs widely across the country. Therefore, practically speaking, people are facing different but related phenomena in various places, and so they have to respond to and make judgments about different pressures and circumstances. After all Fort Worth and New Jersey dioceses are different in terms of experiencing the new religion.
Individual conscience is unique for no two persons have identical consciences. Each conscience is informed by the mind and is really the mind making moral judgments, and saying strongly, “you ought to do this” or “you ought not to do that.” The moral imperative of conscience is not to be equated with having a person opinion about this or that. Conscience does not process opinions but moral judgments. For a variety of reasons, Christian people do not always obey their conscience, or they obey in part. Further, what their conscience proclaims on a given question may change as they grow in maturity in faith, hope and love.
While all Christians have the same relation by grace to God through Christ and by the Holy Ghost, the strength and maturity of this relation differs from baptized believer to baptized believer. Seeking guidance from God in a complex issue, such as deciding to leave one church and join another, is not a straightforward matter. Maturity in the walk with God will play a part in how the question is asked, how an answer is processed, and how it is acted upon.
Many people are influenced by others, especially those whom they look up to and respect. So we should expect most members of a congregation to follow the example and advice of respected pastors and leaders. At the same time we would expect the independent-minded not to follow easily or quickly.
The departing from ECUSA by a priest whose stipend, medical cover and pension are all tied up with this Church, and who has no independent means, is a more difficult and complex decision than that of a layperson who will experience no financial loss.
The departing from ECUSA of a family with special ties to the building and with family memorials therein is a more difficult decision than the departing of a family with no special ties to a sacred place and temple.
One could continue with other considerations. However, it is reasonably clear, I think, that each of us is an unique person with an unique conscience. When faced with a major decision, it is not surprising that each of us, as an imperfect, forgiven sinner weighs the matter similarly but differently to the next person, and that the difference in judgment may be small but can be, and is often, great. Thus some choose to depart and some to remain, and those who depart go in different directions.
As Anglicans we are to pray one for another and love one another. To criticize a person for making a different decision than our own is not wise! In the complexity of North American Anglicanism, we need to be charitable, very charitable and find ways to work together to revive the Anglican Way of Christianity.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon. May 31, 2005 petertoon@msn.com
Friday, May 27, 2005
Comments on a piece written by Dr Eprhaim Radner
Dear Father Kim,
Thank you for circulating the clearly written piece by Dr Ephraim Radner on the theme that those going off to the Ang Con. Council in England from the ECUSA are most unlikely to represent the true position of the ECUSA, as stated in the official reports of her Conventions, Theological Commissions and the like.
To use the expression of Dr Radner’s friend, Philip Turner, it is the “practical theology” (or “the tradition of the [progressive] elders of the ECUSA ) rampant within the ECUSA, rather than its official agreements at Convention and elsewhere, which the group will represent. This “progressive, practical theology” justifies, blesses and commends “faithful” homosexual partnerships as the dynamic equivalent of holy matrimony -- and also justifies & teaches other immoral or erroneous things as well!.
I would invite Dr Radner and his readers to reflect further on what it means for the leaders and official representatives of a Church (ECUSA) to be so confident in and committed to their “practical theology, ” that they are not careful to explain what the actual official statements declare. It suggests, I think, that they are spiritually blinded by their agenda (and by the “god of this world”) and that for them in important ways the Zeitgeist is the Holy Ghost!
As Dr Radner probably knows, I hold the view that this habit within ECUSA of telling lies or half truths or covering up the truth in the name of innovation and progress (all of which is part of its ”practical theology”) received a very major platform and boost in the late 1970s when the ECUSA decided (against protests from devout and learned persons) to call its new “Book of Varied Services” by the name of “The Book of Common Prayer” and at the same time, and, most significantly, set aside the received Formularies of the Anglican Way that were printed in the previous official BCP, that of 1928. Had the ECUSA Gen. Conv. been humble of mind and in “fear and love of the LORD,” it would have done what the C of E and other provinces did -- retain its classic Formularies (BCP, Articles and Ordinal) and add a Book of Alternative Services under the doctrinal authority of the Formularies. As it was, by this act of piracy, the ECUSA since the 1970s has been living a lie, and good souls within the membership have been weeping and protesting, staying or leaving. Those who desire and seek to be godly and orthodox become a smaller remnant week by week, even as the progressives remain, get more power an use the financial resources of this old-line Church for their purposes.
I do not know whether the Lord Jesus Christ will visit this Church by the Holy Ghost to purify and revive it. Like Dr Radner I hope he will and if he does – watch out – we will all as Episcopalians and Anglicans get burned, even those of us who claim to be “orthodox.” We all have the cancerous disease and we all need to be cleansed and revived and set on a right course.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
petertoon@msn.com
Thank you for circulating the clearly written piece by Dr Ephraim Radner on the theme that those going off to the Ang Con. Council in England from the ECUSA are most unlikely to represent the true position of the ECUSA, as stated in the official reports of her Conventions, Theological Commissions and the like.
To use the expression of Dr Radner’s friend, Philip Turner, it is the “practical theology” (or “the tradition of the [progressive] elders of the ECUSA ) rampant within the ECUSA, rather than its official agreements at Convention and elsewhere, which the group will represent. This “progressive, practical theology” justifies, blesses and commends “faithful” homosexual partnerships as the dynamic equivalent of holy matrimony -- and also justifies & teaches other immoral or erroneous things as well!.
I would invite Dr Radner and his readers to reflect further on what it means for the leaders and official representatives of a Church (ECUSA) to be so confident in and committed to their “practical theology, ” that they are not careful to explain what the actual official statements declare. It suggests, I think, that they are spiritually blinded by their agenda (and by the “god of this world”) and that for them in important ways the Zeitgeist is the Holy Ghost!
As Dr Radner probably knows, I hold the view that this habit within ECUSA of telling lies or half truths or covering up the truth in the name of innovation and progress (all of which is part of its ”practical theology”) received a very major platform and boost in the late 1970s when the ECUSA decided (against protests from devout and learned persons) to call its new “Book of Varied Services” by the name of “The Book of Common Prayer” and at the same time, and, most significantly, set aside the received Formularies of the Anglican Way that were printed in the previous official BCP, that of 1928. Had the ECUSA Gen. Conv. been humble of mind and in “fear and love of the LORD,” it would have done what the C of E and other provinces did -- retain its classic Formularies (BCP, Articles and Ordinal) and add a Book of Alternative Services under the doctrinal authority of the Formularies. As it was, by this act of piracy, the ECUSA since the 1970s has been living a lie, and good souls within the membership have been weeping and protesting, staying or leaving. Those who desire and seek to be godly and orthodox become a smaller remnant week by week, even as the progressives remain, get more power an use the financial resources of this old-line Church for their purposes.
I do not know whether the Lord Jesus Christ will visit this Church by the Holy Ghost to purify and revive it. Like Dr Radner I hope he will and if he does – watch out – we will all as Episcopalians and Anglicans get burned, even those of us who claim to be “orthodox.” We all have the cancerous disease and we all need to be cleansed and revived and set on a right course.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon MA., D.Phil (Oxford)
petertoon@msn.com
Early Church Piety & Spirituality
A perpetual fear and love of God’s holy Name
The Collect in the Gelasian Sacramentary (circa 500), used on the Sunday after the Ascension at the Eucharist, is, as most ancient collects, brief and profound. Through it, we gain an understanding of a major aspect of the Christian life and corporate worship as understood by the Fathers in the patristic era. In traditional English the prayer is as follows:
So how does the baptized believer make sure – as far as a human being can so do – that, as an adopted child of God, he is being piloted by God the Father through the problems and difficulties of life in this evil age? The answer is stated in the petition of this Collect: “to have concurrently a perpetual fear and love of the holy Name of God the Father.”
We note that what is required in not only a continuing fear of God but also a continuing love of God. Fear and love are two side of the same divine coin: they are two parallel affections of the soul: they are wedded to each other in the godly life. Fear of the LORD leads to love of the LORD and love of the LORD cannot exist without fear of the LORD.
An important point to bear in mind here is that both fearing and loving God are actually commanded by God. They are to be done in response to his authoritative word of command. This means that fearing and loving are not be seen as innate emotions of the soul that can be aroused by this or that circumstance or occasion. They are at least acts of the will to do something that God, the Sovereign Lord, commands.
Godly Fear, as an act of the will and a godly affection of the soul, is awe, reverence, even dread, before the Majesty of the Almighty God, who is not only Creator, but also Judge, not only Sustainer but also Saviour. A perpetual fear is this same awe, reverence and dread filling the believer’s soul each and every day, wherever he is, and causing him to think, determine and act in ways that are pleasing to the holy and righteous LORD God, whom he desires to please and not to offend – and from whose Spirit & Presence he can never escape.
Where there is such holy, profound respect for the LORD, there can be, and will be, genuine love of God. In fact, there can be no other for God, the LORD, as known in his attributes, perfections, ways and deeds by the reverent soul is supremely adorable and lovable. And, practically speaking love for the LORD means worshipping him, doing his will, obeying his commandments and walking in his ways.
Before the Name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, the Christian believer bows in humility and with reverence and awe, and, as he does so, he can do no other but love the LORD his God, with all his heart, soul, mind and strength, for the One before whom he bows is supremely lovable. The immediate fruit of this fear with love is obedience of the same LORD, the keeping of his commandments.
The joining together of fear and love is, of course, a biblical method, beginning most clearly in Deuteronomy (see 10:12-13) and reaching its climax in the Revelation of St. John (see 14:7; 15:5; 19:5). This couple is married on earth and the marriage remains in heaven.
In the composition of The Book of Common Prayer (first edition, 1549) of the ecclesia anglicana (Church of England) this ancient Collect was transferred to the Second Sunday after Trinity. In later editions of this Prayer Book, it was also expanded. The edition of 1662 contains it in this form:
The doctrine is found in the relative clause beginning, “who never failest…” It is that God is the Pilot through life of those whom he instructs and educates in steadfast fear and love of himself as the LORD, the Holy Trinity.
The petition begins with “Keep us…” and includes two requests. It is that we ask to be safely guided by God the Pilot through the complexities of life and that, as we are so guided, we both have and also maintain a perpetual fear and love of his holy Name.
Here again in this English Collect, fear and love necessarily belong together in the determinations of will and the godly affections of the children of God, who are disciples of Jesus, the Lord. This union of fearing and loving God as God’s command is Biblical doctrine; then also it is Patristic doctrine, as we have seen; further, it is both Reformation and Counter-Reformation Doctrine.
The questions arise (a) whether or not it is a doctrine and a petition which is found in modern liturgical books, and (b) whether or not it is within the practical theology as generally taught, commended and received in modern churches (be they “progressive” or “orthodox”)? Some observers of the contemporary church scene maintain that there has been such a sentimentalizing of love that the whole (biblical) concept of fear that leads to love, and love that requires fear as its context before God, is nearly impossible to conceive, let alone act upon.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon; petertoon@msn.com May 26, 2005
The Collect in the Gelasian Sacramentary (circa 500), used on the Sunday after the Ascension at the Eucharist, is, as most ancient collects, brief and profound. Through it, we gain an understanding of a major aspect of the Christian life and corporate worship as understood by the Fathers in the patristic era. In traditional English the prayer is as follows:
O Lord, make us to have concurrently (or, equally) a perpetual fear and love of thy holy name, because never dost thou leave destitute of thy pilotage, those whom thou dost institute [bring up] in the steadfastness of thy love. Though the Lord Jesus Christ….Here the basic doctrine is that God the Father pilots – and never fails to do so – through life all those whom he trains, rears, disciplines and educates in his steadfast love. And this doctrine presupposes that God’s love reaches out to the sinner in the Gospel and by it he is drawn into the family of God, there to live as a child of God within the steadfast, sure and certain continuing love of God.
So how does the baptized believer make sure – as far as a human being can so do – that, as an adopted child of God, he is being piloted by God the Father through the problems and difficulties of life in this evil age? The answer is stated in the petition of this Collect: “to have concurrently a perpetual fear and love of the holy Name of God the Father.”
We note that what is required in not only a continuing fear of God but also a continuing love of God. Fear and love are two side of the same divine coin: they are two parallel affections of the soul: they are wedded to each other in the godly life. Fear of the LORD leads to love of the LORD and love of the LORD cannot exist without fear of the LORD.
An important point to bear in mind here is that both fearing and loving God are actually commanded by God. They are to be done in response to his authoritative word of command. This means that fearing and loving are not be seen as innate emotions of the soul that can be aroused by this or that circumstance or occasion. They are at least acts of the will to do something that God, the Sovereign Lord, commands.
Godly Fear, as an act of the will and a godly affection of the soul, is awe, reverence, even dread, before the Majesty of the Almighty God, who is not only Creator, but also Judge, not only Sustainer but also Saviour. A perpetual fear is this same awe, reverence and dread filling the believer’s soul each and every day, wherever he is, and causing him to think, determine and act in ways that are pleasing to the holy and righteous LORD God, whom he desires to please and not to offend – and from whose Spirit & Presence he can never escape.
Where there is such holy, profound respect for the LORD, there can be, and will be, genuine love of God. In fact, there can be no other for God, the LORD, as known in his attributes, perfections, ways and deeds by the reverent soul is supremely adorable and lovable. And, practically speaking love for the LORD means worshipping him, doing his will, obeying his commandments and walking in his ways.
Before the Name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, the Christian believer bows in humility and with reverence and awe, and, as he does so, he can do no other but love the LORD his God, with all his heart, soul, mind and strength, for the One before whom he bows is supremely lovable. The immediate fruit of this fear with love is obedience of the same LORD, the keeping of his commandments.
The joining together of fear and love is, of course, a biblical method, beginning most clearly in Deuteronomy (see 10:12-13) and reaching its climax in the Revelation of St. John (see 14:7; 15:5; 19:5). This couple is married on earth and the marriage remains in heaven.
In the composition of The Book of Common Prayer (first edition, 1549) of the ecclesia anglicana (Church of England) this ancient Collect was transferred to the Second Sunday after Trinity. In later editions of this Prayer Book, it was also expanded. The edition of 1662 contains it in this form:
O Lord, who never failest to help and govern them whom thou dost bring up in thy steadfast fear and love; keep us, we beseech thee, under the protection of thy good providence, and make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy Name; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.Here the doctrine and petition are similar to those of the ancient Gelasian Collect, but not identical.
The doctrine is found in the relative clause beginning, “who never failest…” It is that God is the Pilot through life of those whom he instructs and educates in steadfast fear and love of himself as the LORD, the Holy Trinity.
The petition begins with “Keep us…” and includes two requests. It is that we ask to be safely guided by God the Pilot through the complexities of life and that, as we are so guided, we both have and also maintain a perpetual fear and love of his holy Name.
Here again in this English Collect, fear and love necessarily belong together in the determinations of will and the godly affections of the children of God, who are disciples of Jesus, the Lord. This union of fearing and loving God as God’s command is Biblical doctrine; then also it is Patristic doctrine, as we have seen; further, it is both Reformation and Counter-Reformation Doctrine.
The questions arise (a) whether or not it is a doctrine and a petition which is found in modern liturgical books, and (b) whether or not it is within the practical theology as generally taught, commended and received in modern churches (be they “progressive” or “orthodox”)? Some observers of the contemporary church scene maintain that there has been such a sentimentalizing of love that the whole (biblical) concept of fear that leads to love, and love that requires fear as its context before God, is nearly impossible to conceive, let alone act upon.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon; petertoon@msn.com May 26, 2005
Thursday, May 26, 2005
The Fear of God, why is it as necessary today under the New Covenant as it was under the Old Covenant centuries ago?
If you desire to love God both now and tomorrow, then it is impossible to do so unless you first fear him, and then continue to fear him, even as you love him!
Let us begin our reflection at the beginning – conversion to Jesus Christ. In response to the Gospel (the Good News from the Father concerning his Son, the Lord Jesus Christ) we are commanded to repent of sin, to believe the promises of God the Father, to be baptized, and follow the Lord Jesus Christ wherever he leads. In so doing, we are by grace through the merits of the Lord Jesus Christ, born from above and adopted by the Father as his children, in order to live in spiritual union with him, and in fellowship with fellow disciples in the household of God. As his children, we are to love him with all our being and to love our neighbors as ourselves.
Where then does “the fear of God” fit into this account of regeneration and conversion?
First of all, we need to recall that we who hear the Gospel of God hear it as Good News from not any kind of Deity, but from our Creator and our Judge. He is the One, true and living God, who chooses also by the promises of the Gospel through Jesus Christ to become our Redeemer and Savior. Then, secondly, we need to bear in mind most seriously the identity and character of this LORD God. In his existence and being the LORD is more than eternal and infinite, more than majestically transcendent and glorious, more than supremely holy and pure, and more than exceedingly righteous and just. He is completely and totally above and beyond us in his pure glory. There is no comparison between his existence and being and ours. In fact, there is no comparison between his existence and being and that of the most glorious of the angel hierarchy of heaven. Before him, we are as nothing, for we are so weak and small and he is so almighty and great. (See Isaiah’s vision in chapter 6.)
Thus merely to think of his amazing greatness and majesty is to be humbled of mind; merely to contemplate him is to tremble with much amazement; merely to be aware of falling short of his perfection is to collapse prostrate and in great sorrow and pain before his Majesty; and merely to meditate upon the multitude of his attributes and perfections is to be filled with overwhelming awe. Then, also, to recognize that he is the Judge of all and that in his judgment he takes into account all human thoughts, attitudes and deeds is surely to be before him in great, awful dread.
So the Gospel itself, and the background teaching and doctrine concerning the nature and character of God that it is built upon and presupposes, creates “fear of the Lord;” and “the fear of the Lord is the beginning not only of wisdom [to hear the Gospel fully and see in it the wisdom of God]” but also of “knowledge” [of God and of ourselves before him so that we can repent and believe].
How can a soul truly be repentant for sin and for offending his Creator unless there is the fear of the Lord in his heart and mind? How can a soul truly believe the promises of the Gospel unto salvation, unless he is filled with awe and reverence before the very LORD God who makes the promises? How can a soul truly love the LORD our God with all his being, unless he is at least dimly aware of who God really is, and unless, before his majestic holiness and glorious righteousness, he is filled with awesome dread?
In the soul that is born from above of the Holy Ghost, and that looks to the Father through the Son for salvation and life, there must be both fear of the LORD and love of the LORD. For the love which God expects and deserves as LORD is holy, pure, love and adoration, and such is only possible when the soul trembles in awe, reverence, amazement, dread and fear before the LORD. Certainly the angelic host in heaven is continuously filled with both the fear and the love of the Lord God, the Holy Trinity. And, the Lord Jesus Christ, our great High Priest, in his sacred manhood, as our Representative and as the New Adam, offers worship to the Father with holy fear and pure love.
Perhaps – and I do say perhaps – many of the claimed conversions and experiences of new birth and conversion today are not really the same as those which the Acts of the Apostles describes and which the Epistles provide doctrinal descriptions of. That is, the claimed “personal relationship” with God made by so many today is a different kind of experience and commitment. The reason for making this tentative and alarming observation is simple. It is that the “fear of the Lord” seems to be absent from, or minimal within, much modern evangelism and worship, which often not only are “dumbed-down” but also lacking in holy awe and reverence! Without the presence of fear in the soul, the quality of the believing, trusting and obeying as well as worshipping and celebrating will be minimized.
One way to begin to restore “the fear of the Lord” is surely to spend more time describing the very LORD God, whose Gospel is proclaimed, and doing so in such a way as to create the possibility for awe, reverence, dread and fear of him in all present. Another is to conduct “worship services” as unto not only the God who is LOVE but also the God, who in his majestic transcendence commands and deserves our FEAR.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon May 26, 2005.
petertoon@msn.com
Let us begin our reflection at the beginning – conversion to Jesus Christ. In response to the Gospel (the Good News from the Father concerning his Son, the Lord Jesus Christ) we are commanded to repent of sin, to believe the promises of God the Father, to be baptized, and follow the Lord Jesus Christ wherever he leads. In so doing, we are by grace through the merits of the Lord Jesus Christ, born from above and adopted by the Father as his children, in order to live in spiritual union with him, and in fellowship with fellow disciples in the household of God. As his children, we are to love him with all our being and to love our neighbors as ourselves.
Where then does “the fear of God” fit into this account of regeneration and conversion?
First of all, we need to recall that we who hear the Gospel of God hear it as Good News from not any kind of Deity, but from our Creator and our Judge. He is the One, true and living God, who chooses also by the promises of the Gospel through Jesus Christ to become our Redeemer and Savior. Then, secondly, we need to bear in mind most seriously the identity and character of this LORD God. In his existence and being the LORD is more than eternal and infinite, more than majestically transcendent and glorious, more than supremely holy and pure, and more than exceedingly righteous and just. He is completely and totally above and beyond us in his pure glory. There is no comparison between his existence and being and ours. In fact, there is no comparison between his existence and being and that of the most glorious of the angel hierarchy of heaven. Before him, we are as nothing, for we are so weak and small and he is so almighty and great. (See Isaiah’s vision in chapter 6.)
Thus merely to think of his amazing greatness and majesty is to be humbled of mind; merely to contemplate him is to tremble with much amazement; merely to be aware of falling short of his perfection is to collapse prostrate and in great sorrow and pain before his Majesty; and merely to meditate upon the multitude of his attributes and perfections is to be filled with overwhelming awe. Then, also, to recognize that he is the Judge of all and that in his judgment he takes into account all human thoughts, attitudes and deeds is surely to be before him in great, awful dread.
So the Gospel itself, and the background teaching and doctrine concerning the nature and character of God that it is built upon and presupposes, creates “fear of the Lord;” and “the fear of the Lord is the beginning not only of wisdom [to hear the Gospel fully and see in it the wisdom of God]” but also of “knowledge” [of God and of ourselves before him so that we can repent and believe].
How can a soul truly be repentant for sin and for offending his Creator unless there is the fear of the Lord in his heart and mind? How can a soul truly believe the promises of the Gospel unto salvation, unless he is filled with awe and reverence before the very LORD God who makes the promises? How can a soul truly love the LORD our God with all his being, unless he is at least dimly aware of who God really is, and unless, before his majestic holiness and glorious righteousness, he is filled with awesome dread?
In the soul that is born from above of the Holy Ghost, and that looks to the Father through the Son for salvation and life, there must be both fear of the LORD and love of the LORD. For the love which God expects and deserves as LORD is holy, pure, love and adoration, and such is only possible when the soul trembles in awe, reverence, amazement, dread and fear before the LORD. Certainly the angelic host in heaven is continuously filled with both the fear and the love of the Lord God, the Holy Trinity. And, the Lord Jesus Christ, our great High Priest, in his sacred manhood, as our Representative and as the New Adam, offers worship to the Father with holy fear and pure love.
Perhaps – and I do say perhaps – many of the claimed conversions and experiences of new birth and conversion today are not really the same as those which the Acts of the Apostles describes and which the Epistles provide doctrinal descriptions of. That is, the claimed “personal relationship” with God made by so many today is a different kind of experience and commitment. The reason for making this tentative and alarming observation is simple. It is that the “fear of the Lord” seems to be absent from, or minimal within, much modern evangelism and worship, which often not only are “dumbed-down” but also lacking in holy awe and reverence! Without the presence of fear in the soul, the quality of the believing, trusting and obeying as well as worshipping and celebrating will be minimized.
One way to begin to restore “the fear of the Lord” is surely to spend more time describing the very LORD God, whose Gospel is proclaimed, and doing so in such a way as to create the possibility for awe, reverence, dread and fear of him in all present. Another is to conduct “worship services” as unto not only the God who is LOVE but also the God, who in his majestic transcendence commands and deserves our FEAR.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon May 26, 2005.
petertoon@msn.com
Wednesday, May 25, 2005
On Philip Turner's "An Unworkable Theology"
Dear Fr Dick,
Thank you very much for circulating the essay, “An unworkable theology,” by Philip Turner, from First Things. It is an excellent description of the “working theology” of radical inclusivism practiced by the leadership of the ECUSA. Dr Turner is a very careful observer of this Church and he brings to that observation not only a fine mind but a deep love of our Lord and of the Anglican Way. I do hope that many people read and study this essay. I shall urge them to do so.
I agree with all of it except part of a paragraph right at the end. Here is the paragraph:
The first sentence may well be true, but if the C of E can stay on course, even as battered by a mighty wind, then I think the communion of churches, even if reduced to 36 or even 30, will remain.
My disagreement with Dr Turner is with the content of the fourth sentence, which contains the reference to the BCP of the ECUSA and the inference that it contains orthodox theology.
I would contend that the 1979 Prayer Book (“BCP”) of the ECUSA reflects in parts the very theology that Turner describes as causing the apostasy of the ECUSA. While the working theology of the leadership of ECUSA is as he describes it (radical inclusivism based on “love”) , seeds for this, and theological justification for it, are found in the 1979 Liturgy, and even more so, in the official liturgies that have been approved since 1979 by the General Convention.
Does Dr Turner not see that the Baptismal Covenant, so called, of the 1979 Prayer Book, with its commitment to peace and justice runs parallel to and justifies “the working theology”? It has certainly been so used for the last thirty or so years. Does he not see that the use of dynamic equivalency in translating Scripture ( see the Psalter of the 1979 Book and some of its canticles) and the entrance of the feminist agenda into the translation also provide a base for “the working theology”? When “Blessed is the Man…” [the Lord Jesus Christ]” of Psalm 1 becomes “Happy are they…” then a massive step has been taken to eliminate Jesus from the Church’s ancient prayer book. And I could go on with examples, especially from the Catechism which is a summary of the theology of the Rite II texts in the Book. (see for details Neither Orthodox Nor a Formulary, by the late Dr Tarsitano, with Peter Toon, from the PBS – call 1-800-727-1928 or visit www.anglicanmarketplace.com)
The point is that a Church which knowingly and deliberately set aside in the 1970s its received Formularies and imposed a new Formulary in the form of a new kind of Prayer Book, with a new catechism and ordinal, had set itself on a road which provided a basis (or at least no criticism) for its working theology, which was already in place in the 1970s, but since than has become more bold and explicit.
What I continue to fail to understand is why the Communion Institute, of which Dr Turner is a leading member, does not come out clearly and state that the ECUSA made a major mistake in setting aside in the 1970s its historic and classic Formularies and adopting new Ones (in the 1979 Book) which reflected, in seed if not in flower, the very things that have become the causes of its apostasy in the last two decades. To keep on calling the 1979 book “The BCP”, and importantly, giving it the role of Formulary seems to me to be like describing a sinking ship, the ECUSA, whilst one stays on deck commending its fine design!
Let the Institute, with its gifted members, work for the restoration of the classic Formularies, to calling the 1979 Book “The Alternative Service Book”, and to moving quickly to create another, much better and truly orthodox Book of Varied Services, to be alongside but under the authority of the doctrine of the classic Formularies. I do not want to stop people addressing the “You-God” but I heartily desire that they do so in fine language and sound doctrine and in an appropriate godly style.
--Peter Toon
Thank you very much for circulating the essay, “An unworkable theology,” by Philip Turner, from First Things. It is an excellent description of the “working theology” of radical inclusivism practiced by the leadership of the ECUSA. Dr Turner is a very careful observer of this Church and he brings to that observation not only a fine mind but a deep love of our Lord and of the Anglican Way. I do hope that many people read and study this essay. I shall urge them to do so.
I agree with all of it except part of a paragraph right at the end. Here is the paragraph:
“The future of Anglicanism as a communion of churches may depend upon the American Episcopal Church’s ability to find a way out of the terrible constraints forced upon it by its working theology. Much of the Anglican communion in Africa sees the problem. Can the Americans? It is not enough simply to refer to the Episcopal Church’s Book of Common Prayer and reply, “We are orthodox just like you: we affirm the two testaments as the word of God, we recite the classical creeds in our worship, we celebrate the dominical sacraments, and we hold to episcopal order.” The challenge now being put to the Episcopal Church in the United States (and, by implication, to all liberal Protestantism) is not about official documents. It is about the church’s working theology – one which most Anglicans in the rest of the world no longer recognize as Christian.”
The first sentence may well be true, but if the C of E can stay on course, even as battered by a mighty wind, then I think the communion of churches, even if reduced to 36 or even 30, will remain.
My disagreement with Dr Turner is with the content of the fourth sentence, which contains the reference to the BCP of the ECUSA and the inference that it contains orthodox theology.
I would contend that the 1979 Prayer Book (“BCP”) of the ECUSA reflects in parts the very theology that Turner describes as causing the apostasy of the ECUSA. While the working theology of the leadership of ECUSA is as he describes it (radical inclusivism based on “love”) , seeds for this, and theological justification for it, are found in the 1979 Liturgy, and even more so, in the official liturgies that have been approved since 1979 by the General Convention.
Does Dr Turner not see that the Baptismal Covenant, so called, of the 1979 Prayer Book, with its commitment to peace and justice runs parallel to and justifies “the working theology”? It has certainly been so used for the last thirty or so years. Does he not see that the use of dynamic equivalency in translating Scripture ( see the Psalter of the 1979 Book and some of its canticles) and the entrance of the feminist agenda into the translation also provide a base for “the working theology”? When “Blessed is the Man…” [the Lord Jesus Christ]” of Psalm 1 becomes “Happy are they…” then a massive step has been taken to eliminate Jesus from the Church’s ancient prayer book. And I could go on with examples, especially from the Catechism which is a summary of the theology of the Rite II texts in the Book. (see for details Neither Orthodox Nor a Formulary, by the late Dr Tarsitano, with Peter Toon, from the PBS – call 1-800-727-1928 or visit www.anglicanmarketplace.com)
The point is that a Church which knowingly and deliberately set aside in the 1970s its received Formularies and imposed a new Formulary in the form of a new kind of Prayer Book, with a new catechism and ordinal, had set itself on a road which provided a basis (or at least no criticism) for its working theology, which was already in place in the 1970s, but since than has become more bold and explicit.
What I continue to fail to understand is why the Communion Institute, of which Dr Turner is a leading member, does not come out clearly and state that the ECUSA made a major mistake in setting aside in the 1970s its historic and classic Formularies and adopting new Ones (in the 1979 Book) which reflected, in seed if not in flower, the very things that have become the causes of its apostasy in the last two decades. To keep on calling the 1979 book “The BCP”, and importantly, giving it the role of Formulary seems to me to be like describing a sinking ship, the ECUSA, whilst one stays on deck commending its fine design!
Let the Institute, with its gifted members, work for the restoration of the classic Formularies, to calling the 1979 Book “The Alternative Service Book”, and to moving quickly to create another, much better and truly orthodox Book of Varied Services, to be alongside but under the authority of the doctrine of the classic Formularies. I do not want to stop people addressing the “You-God” but I heartily desire that they do so in fine language and sound doctrine and in an appropriate godly style.
--Peter Toon
Tuesday, May 24, 2005
Dumbing-Down by the Orthodox!
Where are the “God-fearing”?
One important word much used in Christian discourse until the mid-20th century, but now virtually absent from it, is the expression “fear of God” or “fear of the Lord.” When did you last hear a sermon on this topic, and how often, if at all, does the expression, or ones synonymous with it, occur in modern liturgy and in modern ex tempore and charismatic services?
The way that the Bible has been understood over the centuries – until apparently recent times – is that it is impossible both to worship God and to love God, unless there is first the fear of God in the soul. For, as the Psalter and the Proverbs declare: “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom….and of knowledge.” Without experiencing the fear of the LORD, the one true and living God, it is impossible to know him, to worship him to love him and to keep his commandments.
The prophecy concerning the coming Messiah in Isaiah 11 declares: “The Spirit of the LORD shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and might, the spirit of knowledge and the fear of the LORD, and his delight shall be in the fear of the LORD.” The Messiah’s delight shall be in the fear of the LORD!
In the Letter to the Hebrews we read of Jesus the Messiah: “In the days of his flesh Jesus offered up prayers and supplications, with loud cries and tears, to him [the Father] who was able to save him from death, and he was heard for his godly fear” (Heb.5:7). Jesus was heard for his godly fear.
The Blessed Virgin Mary in her Magnificat declared of the LORD that “his mercy is on those who fear him from generation to generation” (Luke 1:50). God’s mercy rests on those who fear him.
In the Letters of St Paul the fear of the Lord is presented as a necessary component of the Christian walk with God. “Since we have these promises [from God], beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit, making holiness perfect in the fear of God” (II.Cor.7:1). Holiness is made perfect in the fear of God.
Addressing baptized Christians as exiled from their true home in heaven, St Peter urges them to “conduct yourselves with fear throughout the time of your exile” (1:17). Fear of the Lord is a necessary part of the life and attitude of pilgrims.
In the worship of heaven, the angels and archangels with redeemed humanity fear the LORD, the Holy Trinity. The angel with the eternal gospel cried with a loud voice, “Fear God and give him the glory….” (14:7); and singing the Song of the Lamb the heavenly choir say, “O king of the ages! Who shall not fear and glorify thy name?” (15:5), Further, the redeemed are identified as those who fear God, when they are urged by a voice from the throne, “Praise our God, all you his servants, you who fear him, small and great” (19:5). In heaven the fear of God is necessary and perfected.
So it would appear that all baptized Christians are called to be, and must be, if they are to worship, love and serve God the Father aright, “God-fearing persons.” This is truly a filial fear, the fear of both God’s adopted daughters and sons.
The fear of God obviously includes a dread of his wrath and judgment against sin. This basic fear can never be eliminated this side of the Great Judgment at the end of the age! Nor would the godly want it to be removed! But more often in the O.T. and the N.T. it refers to the sense of awe, reverence, amazement and abasement in the mind and heart as the forgiven sinner stands before the purity of holiness and righteousness of the Majesty of God the LORD. Only with this attitude governing his relation to the Father through the Son, will he be able – in biblical terms – truly to worship, truly to love and truly to obey the Lord, for the fear of the Lord is truly the beginning of wisdom (perceiving what God requires) and of knowledge (of who is God and what he has revealed). If we know God we must know him in the matchless glory of his transcendent majesty, and the only appropriate posture for us before him is prostration before him in awe, reverence and humble adoration, for his Name is glorious and fearful (Deut. 28:58).
Certainly “perfect love casts out fear” (1 John 4:18) but this kind of fear is not the fear of the Lord but fear of torment, and such fear is removed by the indwelling presence of the Holy Ghost.
One obvious reason why the genuine fear of God is missing in modern piety and devotion is that God has been, as it were, domesticated. He is seen more as the everywhere-present “Father-God” and “Loving God” whose presence his children may always feel. He has been brought down from the Throne of His Majesty to dwell most of his time on earth. So the fear of the Lord has been replaced by “feeling good” and “being affirmed” and knowing one’s “self-worth and dignity” through “self-realization.” The Rite II liturgies, and their successors in the ECUSA, are such that their effect, in the context of the general lack of a sense of the transcendent glory of the LORD, is to eliminate “the fear of the Lord” as a necessary affection of the soul. Thus the “the fear of God” is rarely to be seen in contemporary piety, be it that of the “progressives” or the “orthodox.” Instead, “celebration” has become the key aspect.
In general, it would seem, modern Christians have so engaged in dumbing-down of doctrine and piety, devotion and liturgy, that they have lost that necessary ingredient of pure religion which is “the fear of the LORD.” True saints on earth love and fear God and they do not cease when they are promoted to the heavenly Jersualem, for there also Jesus in his sacred, perfect humanity, leads the heavenly host in the fear, worship and love of the Father, by the Holy Ghost!
--Peter Toon
One important word much used in Christian discourse until the mid-20th century, but now virtually absent from it, is the expression “fear of God” or “fear of the Lord.” When did you last hear a sermon on this topic, and how often, if at all, does the expression, or ones synonymous with it, occur in modern liturgy and in modern ex tempore and charismatic services?
The way that the Bible has been understood over the centuries – until apparently recent times – is that it is impossible both to worship God and to love God, unless there is first the fear of God in the soul. For, as the Psalter and the Proverbs declare: “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom….and of knowledge.” Without experiencing the fear of the LORD, the one true and living God, it is impossible to know him, to worship him to love him and to keep his commandments.
The prophecy concerning the coming Messiah in Isaiah 11 declares: “The Spirit of the LORD shall rest upon him, the spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and might, the spirit of knowledge and the fear of the LORD, and his delight shall be in the fear of the LORD.” The Messiah’s delight shall be in the fear of the LORD!
In the Letter to the Hebrews we read of Jesus the Messiah: “In the days of his flesh Jesus offered up prayers and supplications, with loud cries and tears, to him [the Father] who was able to save him from death, and he was heard for his godly fear” (Heb.5:7). Jesus was heard for his godly fear.
The Blessed Virgin Mary in her Magnificat declared of the LORD that “his mercy is on those who fear him from generation to generation” (Luke 1:50). God’s mercy rests on those who fear him.
In the Letters of St Paul the fear of the Lord is presented as a necessary component of the Christian walk with God. “Since we have these promises [from God], beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from every defilement of body and spirit, making holiness perfect in the fear of God” (II.Cor.7:1). Holiness is made perfect in the fear of God.
Addressing baptized Christians as exiled from their true home in heaven, St Peter urges them to “conduct yourselves with fear throughout the time of your exile” (1:17). Fear of the Lord is a necessary part of the life and attitude of pilgrims.
In the worship of heaven, the angels and archangels with redeemed humanity fear the LORD, the Holy Trinity. The angel with the eternal gospel cried with a loud voice, “Fear God and give him the glory….” (14:7); and singing the Song of the Lamb the heavenly choir say, “O king of the ages! Who shall not fear and glorify thy name?” (15:5), Further, the redeemed are identified as those who fear God, when they are urged by a voice from the throne, “Praise our God, all you his servants, you who fear him, small and great” (19:5). In heaven the fear of God is necessary and perfected.
So it would appear that all baptized Christians are called to be, and must be, if they are to worship, love and serve God the Father aright, “God-fearing persons.” This is truly a filial fear, the fear of both God’s adopted daughters and sons.
The fear of God obviously includes a dread of his wrath and judgment against sin. This basic fear can never be eliminated this side of the Great Judgment at the end of the age! Nor would the godly want it to be removed! But more often in the O.T. and the N.T. it refers to the sense of awe, reverence, amazement and abasement in the mind and heart as the forgiven sinner stands before the purity of holiness and righteousness of the Majesty of God the LORD. Only with this attitude governing his relation to the Father through the Son, will he be able – in biblical terms – truly to worship, truly to love and truly to obey the Lord, for the fear of the Lord is truly the beginning of wisdom (perceiving what God requires) and of knowledge (of who is God and what he has revealed). If we know God we must know him in the matchless glory of his transcendent majesty, and the only appropriate posture for us before him is prostration before him in awe, reverence and humble adoration, for his Name is glorious and fearful (Deut. 28:58).
Certainly “perfect love casts out fear” (1 John 4:18) but this kind of fear is not the fear of the Lord but fear of torment, and such fear is removed by the indwelling presence of the Holy Ghost.
One obvious reason why the genuine fear of God is missing in modern piety and devotion is that God has been, as it were, domesticated. He is seen more as the everywhere-present “Father-God” and “Loving God” whose presence his children may always feel. He has been brought down from the Throne of His Majesty to dwell most of his time on earth. So the fear of the Lord has been replaced by “feeling good” and “being affirmed” and knowing one’s “self-worth and dignity” through “self-realization.” The Rite II liturgies, and their successors in the ECUSA, are such that their effect, in the context of the general lack of a sense of the transcendent glory of the LORD, is to eliminate “the fear of the Lord” as a necessary affection of the soul. Thus the “the fear of God” is rarely to be seen in contemporary piety, be it that of the “progressives” or the “orthodox.” Instead, “celebration” has become the key aspect.
In general, it would seem, modern Christians have so engaged in dumbing-down of doctrine and piety, devotion and liturgy, that they have lost that necessary ingredient of pure religion which is “the fear of the LORD.” True saints on earth love and fear God and they do not cease when they are promoted to the heavenly Jersualem, for there also Jesus in his sacred, perfect humanity, leads the heavenly host in the fear, worship and love of the Father, by the Holy Ghost!
--Peter Toon
Monday, May 23, 2005
Anglican Foundations – have we forgotten them?
A discussion Starter
Until fifty or so years ago, virtually all informed Anglican bishops or leaders, be they high or low church, would agree with the statement of Bishop Lancelot Andrewes (d.1626) concerning the foundations of the Faith, Worship, Doctrine, Ministry and Discipline of the Church of England:
One Canon [Of Scripture], reduced to writing by God himself, two Testaments, Three Creeds [Apostles’, Nicene & Athanasian], four General Councils [Nicea 325, Constantinople 381, Ephesus 431 & Chalcedon 451], five centuries and the series of Fathers [bishops and respected teachers] in the period – the three centuries, that is, before Constantine, and the two centuries after, determine the boundary of our [Anglican] Faith. (Opusc.Posthuma, p.91)
Here we have a commitment to 1) the authority and inspiration of the Scriptures, whose Canon was fixed by the Early Church; 2) this Canon contains Two Testaments; 3) the truths set forth in Three Creeds; 4) the authority of the first four Ecumenical Councils, which provided the Church with the dogma of the Trinity and the Person of Christ, and confirmed other doctrines such as the Threefold Ministry, Liturgical Worship and the principle of Canon Law; and 5) the providential way that Christ the Lord had guided his Church in space and time in its formative period of five centuries.
Of course, later councils, theologians and saints were not discounted, in terms of the input, example and experience, but the first centuries were seen as unique in that they were first, and thus unique, and they constituted the formative period for the Church. So while there is great respect for Anselm and Thomas Aquinas and for St. Francis and St. Elizabeth of Hungary shown by the Anglican Way, at the same time, there has not been acceptance of the claims of the See of Rome to universal rule, since this was clearly not the case in the first five centuries of the Early Church.
Bishop Andrewes, with other standard divines, saw the Church of England Formularies (the Articles of Religion, the Book of Common Prayer & the Ordinal) as resting upon, and interpreting, this biblical and patristic foundation for the reformed catholic Church of England, and thus for the Anglican Way. Naturally, they accepted that, for each generation and in each culture, there had to be explanation and teaching not only of the contents of the Bible but also of the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Anglican Way. There also had to be application to changing circumstances and new challenges. Thus we may see the Chicago-Lambeth Quadrilateral at the end of the nineteenth century as an application of the principles of the Anglican Way to ecumenical discussion and union. In this document the minimum required for unity with other Churches was stated in terms of four principles, Scripture, Creeds, Sacraments & Ministry.
What Anglicans/Episcopalians witnessed in the late 1960s and especially in the 1970s was a move away from the 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 explained above towards a fascination with and concentration upon the liturgies and statements of faith from the Church of the third century, especially from Hippolytus of Rome. That is, for the period before Constantine the Great and before the developments in dogma, liturgy and the Calendar that occurred during and after his reign. On the basis of this commitment to the liturgy and faith of the third century, liturgists created new services with a new shape and different content, claiming that their model was an authentic model, being nearer to apostolic times and before the secularization and hellenization of Christianity in the Roman Empire which begun with Constantine.
So it is obvious that the classic Formularies, wherein is a commitment to Scripture and to the clear guidance of the first five centuries are in tension with, even at war with, what one has in the new liturgies, which according to their creators, is commitment to the doctrine and liturgy of the third century (when, it is said, the church was pure and placed in a multi-religious and multi-cultural society, similar to our own). Massey H. Shepherd, the primary liturgist in the commission, which produced the 1979 Prayer Book for the ECUSA, was very clear that his/their primary motivation was this desire to create a contemporary, dynamic equivalent of the liturgy & doctrine of the third century (of which our knowledge is much more limited than for that of the fourth and fifth centuries). Did they not often claim that “the law of praying is the law of believing”?
Those traditionalists who in 1977 left the ECUSA, in part because of the new liturgies and in part because of the ordaining of women, and gathered in St Louis to form the Continuing Anglican Church, accepted the position of Lancelot Andrewes, but only as a starter. They expanded his position, and that of the standard divines of the Anglican Way, by making the summary to read: One Canon, Two Testaments, Two or Three Creeds [Athanasian optional], Seven Councils and at least Seven Centuries. That is, they made acceptance of the fifth, sixth and seventh councils part of their confession of faith, something that had never been done before by a province or synod of the Anglican Way. Certainly, individual divines had stated their acceptance of the dogma of one, two, or all three of these later Councils, but not so Anglican, provincial synods.
Now it may be reasonably claimed that the fifth and sixth simply expand what is taught by the fourth in terms of the Person of Jesus Christ, made known in two natures, human and divine. But the seventh, which authorizes the use of icons of Jesus, Mary and the saints has never gained general acceptance in the Anglican Way. It has however been accepted by anglo-catholic divines since the mid-19th century.
The point being made here is not that the seventh council is wrong in its teaching, but that it is NOT the Anglican method to make its dogma of reverencing of icons compulsory. It is best to leave it optional.
It would seem that on the right and on the left, as it were, Anglicans have forgotten exactly what are their foundations. Regrettably, also, “the Network” as the reforming movement within the ECUSA, seems not yet to have been able to express its doctrinal basis without wanting to place the 1979 Prayer Book (with its novel commitment to the 3rd century!) a part of that basis. This is hard to understand for the 1979 Book is after all only in reality a Book of Varied Services and not a genuine edition of the classic Book of Common Prayer. In contrast, the AMiA and the REC and some other small jurisdictions have a clearer sense of the historic and classic Anglican Foundations.
If I were asked for a biblical text to set forth what I desire to say, I would choose the word of the Lord through the prophet, Jeremiah. "Stand ye in the ways, and see, and ask for the old paths, where is the good way, and walk therein, and ye shall find rest for your souls" (6:16). I invite my readers to choose the old way, not to bury their heads in the sands of the past, but with the intention of working to see its perfection for the Anglican Way for today and tomorrow.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon May 22, 2005
Until fifty or so years ago, virtually all informed Anglican bishops or leaders, be they high or low church, would agree with the statement of Bishop Lancelot Andrewes (d.1626) concerning the foundations of the Faith, Worship, Doctrine, Ministry and Discipline of the Church of England:
One Canon [Of Scripture], reduced to writing by God himself, two Testaments, Three Creeds [Apostles’, Nicene & Athanasian], four General Councils [Nicea 325, Constantinople 381, Ephesus 431 & Chalcedon 451], five centuries and the series of Fathers [bishops and respected teachers] in the period – the three centuries, that is, before Constantine, and the two centuries after, determine the boundary of our [Anglican] Faith. (Opusc.Posthuma, p.91)
Here we have a commitment to 1) the authority and inspiration of the Scriptures, whose Canon was fixed by the Early Church; 2) this Canon contains Two Testaments; 3) the truths set forth in Three Creeds; 4) the authority of the first four Ecumenical Councils, which provided the Church with the dogma of the Trinity and the Person of Christ, and confirmed other doctrines such as the Threefold Ministry, Liturgical Worship and the principle of Canon Law; and 5) the providential way that Christ the Lord had guided his Church in space and time in its formative period of five centuries.
Of course, later councils, theologians and saints were not discounted, in terms of the input, example and experience, but the first centuries were seen as unique in that they were first, and thus unique, and they constituted the formative period for the Church. So while there is great respect for Anselm and Thomas Aquinas and for St. Francis and St. Elizabeth of Hungary shown by the Anglican Way, at the same time, there has not been acceptance of the claims of the See of Rome to universal rule, since this was clearly not the case in the first five centuries of the Early Church.
Bishop Andrewes, with other standard divines, saw the Church of England Formularies (the Articles of Religion, the Book of Common Prayer & the Ordinal) as resting upon, and interpreting, this biblical and patristic foundation for the reformed catholic Church of England, and thus for the Anglican Way. Naturally, they accepted that, for each generation and in each culture, there had to be explanation and teaching not only of the contents of the Bible but also of the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Anglican Way. There also had to be application to changing circumstances and new challenges. Thus we may see the Chicago-Lambeth Quadrilateral at the end of the nineteenth century as an application of the principles of the Anglican Way to ecumenical discussion and union. In this document the minimum required for unity with other Churches was stated in terms of four principles, Scripture, Creeds, Sacraments & Ministry.
What Anglicans/Episcopalians witnessed in the late 1960s and especially in the 1970s was a move away from the 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 explained above towards a fascination with and concentration upon the liturgies and statements of faith from the Church of the third century, especially from Hippolytus of Rome. That is, for the period before Constantine the Great and before the developments in dogma, liturgy and the Calendar that occurred during and after his reign. On the basis of this commitment to the liturgy and faith of the third century, liturgists created new services with a new shape and different content, claiming that their model was an authentic model, being nearer to apostolic times and before the secularization and hellenization of Christianity in the Roman Empire which begun with Constantine.
So it is obvious that the classic Formularies, wherein is a commitment to Scripture and to the clear guidance of the first five centuries are in tension with, even at war with, what one has in the new liturgies, which according to their creators, is commitment to the doctrine and liturgy of the third century (when, it is said, the church was pure and placed in a multi-religious and multi-cultural society, similar to our own). Massey H. Shepherd, the primary liturgist in the commission, which produced the 1979 Prayer Book for the ECUSA, was very clear that his/their primary motivation was this desire to create a contemporary, dynamic equivalent of the liturgy & doctrine of the third century (of which our knowledge is much more limited than for that of the fourth and fifth centuries). Did they not often claim that “the law of praying is the law of believing”?
Those traditionalists who in 1977 left the ECUSA, in part because of the new liturgies and in part because of the ordaining of women, and gathered in St Louis to form the Continuing Anglican Church, accepted the position of Lancelot Andrewes, but only as a starter. They expanded his position, and that of the standard divines of the Anglican Way, by making the summary to read: One Canon, Two Testaments, Two or Three Creeds [Athanasian optional], Seven Councils and at least Seven Centuries. That is, they made acceptance of the fifth, sixth and seventh councils part of their confession of faith, something that had never been done before by a province or synod of the Anglican Way. Certainly, individual divines had stated their acceptance of the dogma of one, two, or all three of these later Councils, but not so Anglican, provincial synods.
Now it may be reasonably claimed that the fifth and sixth simply expand what is taught by the fourth in terms of the Person of Jesus Christ, made known in two natures, human and divine. But the seventh, which authorizes the use of icons of Jesus, Mary and the saints has never gained general acceptance in the Anglican Way. It has however been accepted by anglo-catholic divines since the mid-19th century.
The point being made here is not that the seventh council is wrong in its teaching, but that it is NOT the Anglican method to make its dogma of reverencing of icons compulsory. It is best to leave it optional.
It would seem that on the right and on the left, as it were, Anglicans have forgotten exactly what are their foundations. Regrettably, also, “the Network” as the reforming movement within the ECUSA, seems not yet to have been able to express its doctrinal basis without wanting to place the 1979 Prayer Book (with its novel commitment to the 3rd century!) a part of that basis. This is hard to understand for the 1979 Book is after all only in reality a Book of Varied Services and not a genuine edition of the classic Book of Common Prayer. In contrast, the AMiA and the REC and some other small jurisdictions have a clearer sense of the historic and classic Anglican Foundations.
If I were asked for a biblical text to set forth what I desire to say, I would choose the word of the Lord through the prophet, Jeremiah. "Stand ye in the ways, and see, and ask for the old paths, where is the good way, and walk therein, and ye shall find rest for your souls" (6:16). I invite my readers to choose the old way, not to bury their heads in the sands of the past, but with the intention of working to see its perfection for the Anglican Way for today and tomorrow.
The Revd Dr Peter Toon May 22, 2005
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)