Thursday, May 19, 2005

The Day on which the Godly truly rejoice: TRINITY SUNDAY [AND THE TRINITY SEASON]

One God – Yes: One God, One Person – No: One God, Three Persons – Yes: Three Persons, One God – Yes.
Glory be to the Father, and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost, now and for always even unto ages of ages.
The Church in the West was very wise, and no doubt led by the Holy Ghost, to call the Sunday after Whitsuntide, by the name of Trinity Sunday, in order that the focus of worship and devotion be most particularly on that day the Triune LORD God himself – the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, Three Persons One God, a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity.

The major festivals of the Christian Year before Trinity Sunday focus on
  • (a) the Incarnation of the Second Person of the Trinity, his taking of our human nature and flesh as his own;
  • (b) the sacrificial, atoning death of the Second Person for our sins and his rising again from the dead for our justification;
  • (c) the ascending into heaven with his assumed and now glorified human nature of the Second Person to be the High Priest and King of his people; and
  • (d) his sending, together with the Father, of the Holy Ghost to the Church in order for the Third Person of the Trinity to be the Paraclete of the Incarnate Son, a Counselor and Comforter to his sanctified people.

In the great work of divine revelation and redemption, salvation and sanctification, the Holy Trinity is supremely and wholly involved, as the Father sends the Son into the world where he assumed human nature by the presence of the Holy Ghost, and where the Holy Ghost acts in the Name of the Son. So it is most fitting and most appropriate that after the sequence of the great festivals – Christmas & Epiphany, Easter, Ascension and Whitsuntide – there should be another festival pointing to the identity of the Lord our God, the God of revelation and redemption, by whom the divine reality of the great festivals is assured.


The Early Church gave a lot of time and effort to the stating in the best possible and available terms the doctrine of the Holy, Blessed and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and of the Holy Ghost. That is, the rendering of the dynamic and diverse biblical teaching and insights into clear propositional terms, using particular words in specific ways. This teaching is found in the Nicene Creed (written originally in Greek and immediately translated into Latin) and in the Athanasian Creed or Quicunque Vult (written originally in Latin and later translated into Greek).

Key words are substance (ousia in Greek) and Person (hypostasis in Greek). And the church teaching is that there is one ousia (Divinity, Godhead) and that each of the Three Persons possesses in whole this one, unique ousia. This one substance, Godhead, is not, as it were, shared and split into three. The Father is wholly God; the Son is wholly God and the Holy Ghost is wholly God. Thus the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are homoousios (of the same, identical substance, essence & being) with each other.

The Three Persons differ from one another not in Godhead for each one is wholly God; rather they differ in terms of their relations (not relationships!) one with another. The first Person is the Father of the Only-Begotten Son; the Son is the only-begotten Son of the Father; and the Holy Ghost proceeds from the Father and the Son. And, of course, in the divine work of creation, redemption, providence and judgment, each of the Three has a different but not an independent role.

It is this Mystery, God as the Holy Trinity, which Mother Church asks her members ( born from above by the Holy Ghost to be the adopted children of the Father) specifically to adore, praise and magnify on Trinity Sunday, and to do so with special effort, concentration and devotion.

Then for the rest of the Christian Year until Advent, as each Sunday in the traditional Anglican Calendar also bears the Name of the same Holy Trinity, Mother Church asks her members to hear and read the Gospel and the Epistle as the words of the same Triune God, even as She worships the Undivided and Blessed Trinity, bowing before the Father in the Name of the Son and with the presence and illumination of the Holy Ghost. It is only when we know God as the Triune Lord God experientially and mentally that we are aware of the need for careful terminology both to preserve sound doctrine and to honor God for who he is and what he has revealed unto us.


Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of the true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the divine Majesty to worship the Unity: We beseech thee, that thou wouldest keep us stedfast in this faith, and evermore defend us from all adversities, who livest and reignest, one God, world without end. Amen.


(See further Peter Toon, Our Triune God, Regent College Publishing, Vancouver, Canada)

Wednesday, May 18, 2005

Christian Community – an idol?

With Dr Philip Turner, a most able thinker and writer, I want to suggest that to call the church of God “a Christian community” is to erect an idol.

As far back as I can remember the word “community” referred to a specific people living in a specific area. Thus in an American city there would be a Jewish community in one neighborhood and a Polish in another. In the prayers of intercession in the parish church in England I vividly recall how that the priest and congregation prayed for the local community and its various leaders and needs.

In the decades since the 1960s, it has become more and more fashionable to speak of the church itself as the Christian community. The apparent reason for this usage is that community became in the 1960s the preferred word to speak of the coming together of individuals (= individual human persons). Here the logic was that individualism is supreme in western society; that each human being is an individual (an adjective become a noun); and that a collection of “individuals” for a common purpose is a community. (At the same time as this usage developed, the traditional Irish, Polish, Italian local communities in cities were breaking-up as their inhabitants moved to the suburbs).

In the book which introduced the 1979 Prayer Book (Introducing the Proposed Book, p.43), to the Episcopal Church, Charles P. Price singled out “Christian Community” as one of the major emphases of this innovatory Prayer Book. If the assurance of immortality was the need of people in the patristic era, and forgiveness the need in the sixteenth century, said Price, then community is the need in our time. And he saw it writ large in the structure and content of this new kind of Prayer Book (not by any means an edition of the classical Anglican Book of Common Prayer).

Most people bought this idea and freely used the expression “Christian community” and it is very much in vogue these says by all parties within the ECUSA. Yet an evangelical theologian, Philip Turner, then the Dean of Berkely Divinity School at Yale, took a very different position. “To turn the Church into a ‘Christian Community’ is unacceptable to God,” he said. And writing in The Anglican Digest (Michaelmas 1992) he explained:

What I have come to believe is that if Christians look to the Church in any of its manifestations or institutional forms to provide them with a community, they distort the nature of the Church and, more seriously, construct an idol that, like all idols, is but the mirror image of themselves. If, however, they learn, in coming to God through Christ, to long for and rejoice in the communion of the saints, they will find union with God and with the saints of God that both transcends and transfigures any community they have ever known or will know.

He describes how, in seeking to create “a community” everyone is expected to become like everyone else; but this is an impossible goal. So everyone has to become like the inner community which is seeking to impose its identifying features and ways upon everyone so that all may be a real community (just as a Polish community is all Poles and Jewish one, all Jews).

So he concludes his piece by stating that the extent that churches,

Are motivated by a search for “Christian community” they will most certainly prove inhospitable, oppressive and divisive. To the extent that they are motivated by a longing for communion with God and communion in Jesus Christ with people from very different communities, we may even as strangers, hope for hospitality, liberty, and unity with God and with one another.

The Church is a congregation of people from a variety of human communities, ethnic, political, social, who meet together for and in communion and fellowship (communion and koinonia) in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, in the presence of the Holy Ghost, in order to worship and serve the Father.

In the history of the Episcopal Church since the 1970s we have seen what this idol of community has allowed and fostered. Attendance is down, traditional Episcopalians are not welcome, new doctrine and morality are espoused and celebrated, new forms of worship with new ways of speaking to Deity are in place, and all in all the Church is in one big crisis and mess.

One sad feature of this story is that many who ought to know better have embraced this use of “Christian community” and in so doing have lost the biblical and dynamic sense of koinonia as a the biblical word for fellowship one with another in the Body of Christ under Christ the Head. Koinonia is NOT community but an anticipation of heaven on earth within the Household of God and Body of Christ!

Those who seek to be orthodox in the Anglican Way should, I suggest, try to go one week 1) without calling a human person an individual, 2) without using the word “community” of the local church congregation, and 3) without describing the holy relation to God brought about by the divine work of regeneration and sanctification as “a relationship”. There are so many good words and phrases in the Bible and holy tradition for the church and her members and how they relate to God.

The Revd Dr Peter Toon, May 18, 2005

(For a solid but readable critique of the structure, content and style of the 1979 Book see NEITHER ORTHODOXY NOR A FORMULARY by Lou Tarsitano and Peter Toon, available by calling 1-800-727-1928)

Monday, May 16, 2005

LEX ORANDI: LEX CREDENDI

A popular expression, much loved of those engaged in the study of liturgy in the modern Anglicanism of the West, is this: lex orandi: lex credendi. It is usually quoted in this Latin, which sounds more imposing and awesome than the English translation, "the law of praying: the law of believing." (Technically it may also be translated "the law of believing: the law of praying.")

The Preface to the BAS (1985) of the Canadian Church clearly reveals that the architects of this book (based on the USA 1979 prayer book) believed they were working according to this supposed hallowed principle. We read that,


It is precisely the intimate relationship of gospel, liturgy and service that stands behind the theological principle, lex orandi: lex credendi,- i. e., the law of prayer is the law of belief. This principle, particularly treasured by Anglicans, means that theology as the statement of the Church belief is drawn from the liturgy, i.e., from the point at which the gospel and the challenge of Christian life meet in prayer. The development of theology is not a legislative process which is imposed on liturgy; liturgy is a reflective process in which theology may be discovered. The Church must be open to liturgical change in order to maintain sensitivity to the impact of the gospel on the world and to permit the continuous development of a living theology.

This is a remarkable paragraph based as much on ignorance as prejudice. Similar statements both spoken and written abound and their abundance testifies to the move away from the classic Anglican Way by those who, for the most part, now effectively order and run the worship of Anglicans. The same type of claims were made by those who created the BCP (1979) of the ECUSA, although at first they pretended that they were merely updating the Common Prayer Tradition and keeping its doctrinal framework.

Wrong way round?

First of all, the claim "it is precisely..." supposes that the writers have done careful historical research and can document their case. Such a possibility is doubtful. In fact if the Pope, and particularly Pope Pius XII, is any guide, then this expression is not a safe or sure guide. In his famous encyclical letter, Mediator Dei (1947), this Pope referred to the error and fallacious reasoning of those who claim that the sacred Liturgy is a kind of proving?ground for the truths to be held by faith. Such is not what the Church teaches and enjoins, he maintained. The entire Liturgy ought to have the Catholic Faith for its content, inasmuch as the Liturgy bears witness to the Faith of the Church.

He certainly recognized that on occasions the content of the Liturgy has been examined as one way (alongside others) of gaining insight into a controversial or doubtful truth. Yet the Pope concluded: "If one desires to differentiate and describe the relation between Faith and the sacred Liturgy in absolute and general terms, it is perfectly correct to say: Lex credendi legem statuat supplicandi (let the rule of belief determine the rule of prayer)." We note that this is precisely the opposite of the way lex orandi: lex credendi is used today.

In fact the origin of the expression, lex orandi: lex credendi, seems to have been with Prosper, a disciple of the great St Augustine of Hippo. He did not actually use it but another similar one, which is the fore?runner of it: lex supplicandi statuat legem credendi (let the rule of prayer determine the rule of faith). Prosper was involved in a controversy [known as the Pelagian controversy] concerning the grace of God offered in Christ and the freedom of man to accept or reject it. Being a disciple of Augustine, he held that our wills are in a bondage to sin and until God releases them and gives them the freedom to choose Christ and to believe on His name then we are not able to do so. In order to show that this doctrine of God's sovereign grace was truly the faith of the Church, he appealed to the contents of the prayers offered by Christians. He believed that these assumed that without God we can do nothing for our salvation.

Therefore he could confidently say, in this specific context, that the rule of prayer tells us what is the rule of faith. Of course he and his master, Augustine, did not stop there; they also turned to the Scripture to study its message and to the Creeds of the Church to learn what they declared. In fact for the early fathers of the Church the lex credendi was to be found first of all in the Holy Scriptures and to this the Liturgy was to witness and had to conform. If it conformed then it could be said in a strictly limited way that the law of prayer is the law of faith -- e.g. it confirmed Prosper's point that we are dependent upon God's grace in order to choose Christ. But such a law was not then, and cannot be now, of total or universal application in all circumstances.

Lex & the Common Prayer

Certainly since the sixteenth century, Anglicans have believed that in the Book of Common Prayer (in which historically were bound also the Ordinal and the Thirty?Nine Articles) is the lex credendi. For where you have the commitment to the authority of the Scriptures (the written Word of God), and a further commitment both to the catholic Creeds, and alongside the Creeds to the Thirty?Nine Articles, then you certainly have a lex credendi -- which is more developed if you add the doctrines of the Ordinal concerning the Threefold Ministry. However, the lex is not primarily to be found in the whole Book but specifically in the doctrinal truth of the Scriptures and the dogma of the Creeds as summarizing the truth of Scripture. Thus to claim with the BAS (1985) that the lex orandi: lex credendi is a principle particularly treasured by Anglicans is true but only in a limited way. Further, it is true only of the classic Common Prayer Tradition in which the Canadian BAS (1985) and the American BCP (1979) hardly partake.

--Peter Toon

Friday, May 13, 2005

Who are we? And What is our Name?

For the consideration of Anglicans, Episcopalians and the like.

It is becoming difficult to know how to name and describe those who profess to live within and to maintain the Anglican Way, as a form of reformed Catholicism or authentic Protestantism, and who are outside the Episcopal Church.

Obviously members of The Episcopal Church of the U.S.A., whether they be progressives or traditionalists, high church or low church, are all Episcopalians, who may also in some circumstances decide to call themselves Anglicans. At least they all, conservatives and liberals alike, claim to belong to the international family of Anglican Churches.

If we use the term “extra-mural Anglicans” (or “extra-mural Episcopalians”) for those claiming to be of the Anglican Way, but outside of the Episcopal Church, then there are problems and some folks get upset. For example, some think that by this expression those outside are being declared to be inferior to those inside and, further, it is being suggested that the outsiders are dependent upon the institution of the Episcopal Church, even though outside its walls.

So “extra-mural” as an expression from the field of university education is suspect when used of those outside the walls of the Episcopal Church.

If we use (as “The Communion Network” seems to be doing) the term “diaspora” we also run into trouble. For, as is well known, the Jewish diaspora look to Jerusalem as the origin and center of their religious existence; but, those of the Anglican Way outside the Episcopal Church and its New York City offices, claim to look away from rather than towards this modern center!

So “diaspora” as an expression from Jewish history is suspect, when used of those who do not look to the National Church headquarters of the Episcopal Church.

What term or terms then can we use?

Those who left the Episcopal Church in the late 1970s called themselves “the Continuing” Church and so we have the expression “Continuing Anglicans” or “Continuing Episcopalians.” However, before this exodus took place there had been the exodus of both those who called themselves Reformed Episcopalians in the 19th century and various small groups in the 1950s and 1960s, who objected to the social changes in the [Protestant] Episcopal Church, due to such things as the impact of civil rights.

The Continuing Anglicans from the 1970s are now represented by several groups (e.g., the Anglican Province of Christ the King, the Anglican Catholic Church and the Anglican Church of America).

In the late 1990s they all were joined by those now known as the Anglican Mission in America, which is an evangelical (and sometimes charismatic) movement looking for guidance to Archbishops in S.E.Asia and Africa. More recently we have witnessed the adoption of individual parishes, which have left the Episcopal Church, by a growing number of overseas bishops from South America and Africa. Further, overseas bishops have authorized the forming of parishes of immigrants from their region (e.g., Nigerians & Indians) in the U.S.A. as missionary arms of the home dioceses. And, finally, congregations from a pentecostalist or evangelical background have been embracing the Anglican Way and forming their own jurisdictions (e.g. The Charismatic Episcopal Church).

So the picture of those who are Anglicans or Episcopalians is a varied and a changing one and shows little sign of being anything else but this for the immediate future.

Is there one word that covers the anglo-catholics, who are the majority amongst the Continuers, and the hearty evangelicals, who are the majority in the Anglican Mission in America, and the charismatics who are found in all the newer groups? Perhaps “Anglican” but then, when referring to any one congregation or any group, an adjective would be usually needed, and that is where feelings begin to be inflamed. Too many are too sensitive and thus, to in defending their own distinguishing marks, tend to major in minors.

The Latin name of the Church of England is Ecclesia Anglicana and so the use of the word Anglican is well-founded. As already noted it is the adjective or the phrase that is added to it which often raises the emotions.

The problem of name and title is seen not only in e-mail exchanges but also at every church notice-board be it erected outside the church building or in a web-site on the internet.

Does one write, “St. Mark’s Anglican Mission in America Church;” “Christ Reformed Episcopal Church;” and “St. Anne’s Anglican Church in America Church”? Or does not respect the integrity of the dedication of the building and write, “St. Mark’s Church, Anglican Mission in America;” “Christ Church, Reformed Episcopal Church;” and “St. Anne’s Church, Anglican Church in America”? In the latter case the place where the church is situated could then be the third line. So one could have, “Christ Church, Reformed Episcopal Diocese of the South, Austin, Texas.”

Perhaps one thing can be said. The fact of the variety and the fact of sensitivity over names and titles they do point to life! The Anglican Way is not yet dead!

--Peter Toon

Thursday, May 05, 2005

Christ has ASCENDED. Alleluia & Alleluia.

In words from the Collect for the Ascension Day: “we do believe thy only-begotten Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, to have ascended into the heavens.” And from the Preface for the Ascension Day: “in their sight he ascended up into heaven to prepare a place for us; that where he is, thither we might also ascend and reign with him in glory.” Finally from the Acts of the Apostles: “While they beheld, he was taken up and a cloud received him out of their sight.”

The only-begotten Son of the Father was made man in the womb of the Blessed Virgin Mary; there he took our flesh and nature so that he Who had been One Person with one nature, now became One Person made known in two natures, divine and human. He was born and named Jesus (The LORD is our salvation). As the new Israel and the new Adam, he lived for us; he taught us; he revealed the Kingdom of God to and for us; as our Representative and Substitute he died for us, was buried, was raised from the dead and ascended into heaven.

Apostles and disciples witnessed his crucifixion, death and burial. But no-one witnessed his bodily resurrection – except perhaps the angels. Yet many disciples with the apostles met the risen Lord Jesus in the forty days from Easter Day. They certainly knew that he was alive, yet alive in a new and exalted form.

Since no apostle or disciple would be able to see the Lord Jesus when he had ascended into heaven and when he was seated at the right hand of the Father in the glory of heaven, a select number were given the high privilege of seeing his Ascension -- of watching him, as far as the human eye would allow, ascend into heaven. On that hillside heaven was powerfully represented by the Shekinah, the cloud of glory, which the Israelites had known in the wilderness and Solomon had known at the dedication of the Temple. Further, two messengers from heaven, assuming a kind of human form, confirmed that Jesus had truly ascended and would come again at the end of the age to complete the Father’s will.

Let us be clear of mind. The Ascension of the Lord is the festival which places the crown on the previous festivals. The Lord who descended from heaven to perform his revealing and redeeming work has now ascended into heaven. The Lord, who did for us what we could never in millions of ages do for ourselves, has returned with his perfected huyman nature and body to the sphere from which he came. By his ascension the Lord shows that he is truly the resurrected One, truly the new Adam, truly the One Mediator between God and mankind.

Had there been no Ascension there would have always been the suspicion that though resurrected he was not exalted. Thus this Festival is one of great joy and encouragement and hope. No wonder the Church sings Psalm 24 on this day. The Lord of hosts, the King of glory, even the Lord Jesus Christ is not only risen but ascended and exalted. He has begun his session for us in heaven. He will send the Paraclete. Praise be unto him, the crucified, risen and glorified Son of the Father.

So as we proclaim the Ascension on this day we extinguish the Paschal Candle to signify that he is no longer visiting his disciples on earth but he is now at the right hand of the Father, our exalted Prophet, Priest and King, who through the Spirit is with and in all his faithful, baptized people, even as they are with him.

In liturgical time, we the people of God now wait ten days for the promise of the same Lord Jesus to be fulfilled, when he will send the Paraclete, the Spirit who comes in his name with his graces, virtues and gifts. We walk in faith, hope and charity, watching and praying, between The Feast of the Ascension and the Feast of Pentecost, Whit-Sunday.

--Peter Toon

Wednesday, May 04, 2005

Baptism but not Holy Baptism

Why do “the Orthodox” within ECUSA actively support Progressive Doctrine & Ideology?

There is a very clear connection and route from the content of the 1979 Prayer Book of the Episcopal Church to its major innovations in sexuality of 2003-5. And that connection is through the constant use of the text of the “Service of Holy Baptism” (pp.299ff.).

I recall vividly being present at a meeting of the Standing Liturgical Commission at the Convention of 2000, where I was giving evidence on behalf of the use of the classic BCP of 1928. It was agreed that with the local bishop’s permission and under certain conditions certain services of the 1928 BCP could be used. However, of one thing they were all clear, and the female priests there present most clear. This was that there was no substitute possible for the use of the Baptismal Service. For herein was contained what they obviously believed was an essential part of the progressive religion of the modernized Episcopal Church.

I also recall vividly watching the installation – by himself! – in the National Cathedral at Washington of Griswold as the Presiding Bishop. Here it was made very clear that in Baptism God sows the seed of all possible ministry and ministries in the Church, lay and ordained. Thus at any time a baptized person may be called to any ministry, whatever the person’s sex or “orientation.” So, once baptized, any person is a potential candidate for all ministries and the fact of having been baptized is always to be the primary consideration.

Turning to the Service itself, one reads with horror the first sentence of the introductory comments: “Holy Baptism is full initiation….” A word that belongs chiefly to the human sciences such as anthropology and culture-studies, and that was used rarely in the Early Church of Baptism but has been pushed by the liberal ecumenical movement, is here used as the primary word of description for what Baptism is all about. It is the ritual entrance into a community (a community in modern terms is the coming together of “individuals” for a common purpose).

But what kind of community? This is presented within what is called “The Baptismal Covenant”. Though there is promise to be committed to certain traditional things such as church attendance, resisting of evil and proclaiming the Gospel, the innovation is in the questions which require an affirmative reply: “Will you seek and serve Christ in all persons, loving your neighbor as yourself? And , Will you strive for justice and peace among all people and respect the dignity of every human being?”

The Passing of the Peace, which often includes much physical contact, and is used often and widely within ECUSA, is intimately related to these commitment as a kind of outward and visible form of creating a community of people who affirm one another.

Anyone who has followed the debates and resolutions of the General Convention from the 1960s through to 2003 will have no doubt of the great importance attached to these innovative commitments, which provided for not a few Conventions their titles and themes. What these commitments mean – if we listen to the General Convention and the Executive Council – is a virtually total dedication to the expanding agenda of civil and human rights and the support of all moves to affirm self-worth and human dignity. Thus anyone making these commitments within the context of the Episcopal Church is virtually committing himself/herself to all the innovations introduced by the General Convention since the 1960s, from the right to divorce and remarriage in church, through a variety of women’s and minority rights, to the rights of homosexual persons to be true to their orientation. That is a commitment to a community which is not only in the world and for the world but is also of the world, differing only from the world (enlightened culture) in using “God-language” for human ideas and activity.

In the traditional Services of Holy Baptism, the emphasis is upon regeneration, birth from above, and dying to sin and rising to new life in Christ, for membership of a heavenly communion (not an earthly, activist community) where life on earth is a pilgrimage and where as a soldier and servant of Christ one is at war with the world, the flesh and the devil in the service of the heavenly Father. Let my reader compare the content of the 1979 service with that in the BCP of 1662 or 1928 in order to get the complete contrast between the doctrine, style and emphases as well as the content of the two different forms of entrance into Christian Faith.

Of course, there is sufficient traditional material in the 1979 Baptismal Service to hide its real and true purpose, which is that of initiating people into an activist community which, in the name of God, and with some use of traditional language and means, is primarily committed to bringing or reflecting change in human society, so that in it equality, justice and peace are to be found, and war and discrimination against persons are no more.

So I am very surprised, indeed shocked, that those who claim to be “the orthodox remnant” within ECUSA use this service all the time and seem not to realize that by using it they are supporting the very agenda that they say they oppose! I am more shocked that AMiA clergy use it as well!

Let them instead use the classic Anglican Service and, if they insist that it be in so-called contemporary language, some of us will be happy to provide such a text for them immediately.

(For a reasoned critique of the 1979 Prayer Book from the vantage point of the classic Anglican Way, see Louis. R Tarsitano & Peter Toon, Neither Orthodoxy Nor A Formulary…. Available on line at www.anglicanmarketplace.com or by calling 1-800-727-1928)

May 4, 2005, Eve of the Feast of the Ascension of our Lord. The Revd Dr Peter Toon

Sunday, May 01, 2005

American Prayer Books – their similarities and differences

Is Rite I really the same as the BCP of 1928?

In the U.S.A. and in the previous colonies, four prayer books, bearing the title, The Book of Common Prayer, have been in official use in churches which are in communion with the see of Canterbury.

In the colonial period the edition of the BCP was the English of 1662, a book that has been translated into 150 languages. This edition is still the official Prayer Book of the Church of England and of Anglican Churches in the British Commonwealth of nations. After independence, a new edition of the BCP, specifically related to the situation of an autonomous Church in a new country, was produced and authorized in 1789. In the preface the unity with the BCP of 1662 and with the Worship, Doctrine and Discipline of the Church of England are clearly affirmed.

Minor editing was done of the 1789 BCP to produce the editions of 1892 and then of 1928. There is a very distinct and clear relation in content and style between these four editions of 1662, 1789, 1892 and 1928 and it is obvious they are editions of one book.

It was the intention of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA in the 1960s to produce another edition of the same book. However, as the project progressed and as a variety of factors and forces from outside and inside the Church made their impact, the original project of gentle, minimal editing, expanded into a major overhaul, and, this became a project of creating virtually a new book altogether. In other Churches of the Anglican family, similar work was going on, energized by such things as the reforms of Vatican II, the insights of the Liturgical Movement, the social and cultural revolution of the 1960s, the calls for peace and justice and the call for human rights. Yet other Churches decided to treat their new creations of services and prayers as alternatives to those of the BCP and to call their new books by such names as A Book of Alternative Services, or a Prayer Book for South Africa.

The Episcopal Church stood alone in the 1970s in calling its new prayer book,The Book of Common Prayer, when it was – by its purpose and content – very similar to the alternative prayer books in other parts of the world. Thus the Church of England had the BCP and the ASB (Alternative Service Book) while the Episcopal Church had only the one book, a book of varied services, and it chose to call this new type of book of 1976/9 by the ancient name of The BCP! Further, in adopting this new book, it declared that the previous BCP, the authentically Anglican BCP of 1928, should not any longer be in use and should cease to be the Formulary of the Episcopal Church. So adopting a new Prayer Book was also in the USA adopting a new Formulary, a new statement of what the Church believed, taught and confessed, and thus a new form of Anglicanism, set on the path of innovations as culture and society determined, was born.

So what are the chief differences between the authentic BCP of 1928 and the innovatory BCP of 1979, with its Rite I and Rite II parts?

  1. The 1928 is consistent in language and style, using the traditional second person singular for both God and the human person – “thou art.” In contrast, Rite I uses the traditional second person singular, as 1928, and Rite II uses the modern form of the second singular; however, not sufficient material is in the Rite I form for this to become a consistent style and content for worship on all occasions. Significantly, Baptism is only possible in modern language.
  2. The 1928 is consistent in doctrine, presenting patristic orthodoxy and a reformed Catholicism in all its services. In contrast, there is deliberate variety of doctrine in the 1979 book, ranging from reformed Catholicism to modern liberal Catholicism. Thus it presents no coherent system of worship and doctrine.
  3. The 1928 has one form of each type of service and thus truly presents common prayer, with congregations in a province all using the same basic text/liturgy. Of course, the readings from the OT & NT and the Psalms change each morning and evening and for each Sunday the Gospel and Epistle change, but there is in principle one basic form of each liturgy. In contrast, the 1979 presents the Holy Eucharist in both the Rite I and Rite II forms and within each there is a choice of the main ingredient, the Eucharistic prayer. Thus what the 1979 presents is varied prayer, not common prayer.
  4. The 1928 recognizes sin for what it is before God and thus places great emphasis on the need for recognizing human sinfulness, confessing one’s sins to God in a humble and penitent manner, turning from sin and looking to God for absolution and remission of sins. Further, the confession of sins before God is seen as a necessary part of the praise of Almighty God, for it is the recognition of his holiness, righteousness and mercy. In contrast, the 1979 places much less emphasis upon the sinfulness of sin and tends to see confession of sin as something to get done quickly so that the real part of worship – celebration – can begin.
  5. The shape or structure of the service of Holy Communion in 1928 is what may be called the Anglican shape, or the reformed catholic structure, that which is found in the editions of the BCP from the sixteenth century through to the twentieth. In the 1979 the shape for Rite I and II is deliberately different for it claims to be based on the shape found in the liturgies of the Early Church of the third century, with the “passing of the peace” at the center. (In the 1928 the peace of the Lord is communicated by the Sacrament and then verbally with the Blessing at the end … “The Peace of God which passeth all understanding…”
  6. The version of the Bible used in the Eucharistic Lectionary of 1928 is the KJV except for the Psalter where it is an updated version of the Coverdale translation. The translation of various canticles and of the Psalter in 1979 is dominated by the modern principle of dynamic equivalency and also of anti-sexism (so that “Blessed is the man…” becomes “Happy are they…”).
  7. The content of the Eucharistic Lectionary in 1928 is ancient, going back through the Middle Ages to the late patristic era and its arrangement conveys particular biblical doctrines. The modern ECUSA Eucharistic Lectionary is based on modern ecumenical projects from the 1970s and 1980s.
  8. The Calendar in 1928 represents that of reformed Catholicism whereas that in 1979 represents post-1960s ecumenical agreements. For example, in 1979 the whole period of 50 days from Easter Day until Pentecost Day (Whitsunday) is called Easter and the Sundays are numbered with Easter Day as Easter 1. In 1928 only Easter Day (and week) is Easter, with Sundays afterwards being named “Sundays after Easter” until the Feast of the Ascension, after which it is “the Sunday after the Ascension.”
  9. The construction of Collects in the 1928 is uniform, following the pattern of the Latin Collects from the fifth century. In the 1979 book various changes are made not only in the content but also in the grammar. The most obvious and important is the change from the relative clause to the declarative clause – that is, from e.g., “O God, who knowest what we need before we ask,…” to “God, you know what we need before we ask,…” This grammatical change suggests a change in attitude and piety before God.
  10. In the 1928 the services of ordination constitute a separate book, The Ordinal, bound for convenience with the BCP. In the 1979 the ordination services are made part of the Prayer Book as such and they are provided only in a modern language form.


In summary, the title of the 1928 BCP is a correct description of what is inside the covers, while the title of the 1979 is not so. It was act of piracy which took the title of one thing and made it the title of a different thing. It was an act of impiety which took away from Episcopalians a consistent form of prayer which has the purpose of guiding people into living a godly life as the congregation of Christ.

Peter Toon

TRINITY SUNDAY AND THE TRINITY SEASON

One God – Yes: One God, One Person – No: One God, Three Persons – Yes: Three Persons, One God – Yes.

The Church in the West was very wise, and no doubt led by then Holy Ghost, to call the Sunday after Whitsuntide, by the name of Trinity Sunday, in order that the focus of worship and devotion be most particularly on that day the Triune LORD God himself – the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, Three Persons One God, a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity.

The major festivals of the Christian Year before Trinity Sunday focus on (a) the Incarnation of the Second Person of the Trinity, his taking of our human nature and flesh as his own; (b) the sacrificial, atoning death of the Second Person for our sins and his rising again from the dead for our justification; (c) the ascending into heaven with his assumed and now glorified human nature of the Second Person to be the High Priest and King of his people; and (d) his sending, together with the Father, of the Holy Ghost to the Church in order for the Third Person of the Trinity to be the Paraclete of the Incarnate Son, a Counselor and Comforter to his sanctified people.

In the great work of divine revelation and redemption, salvation and sanctification, the Holy Trinity is wholly involved, as the Father sends the Son into the world where he assumed human nature by the presence of the Holy Ghost, and where the Holy Ghost acts in the Name of the Son. So it is most fitting and most appropriate that after the last of the great festivals -- Christmas & Epiphany, Easter, Ascension and Whitsuntide – there should be another festival pointing to the identity of the Lord our God, the God of revelation and redemption, by Whom the divine reality of the great festivals is assured.

The Early Church gave a lot of time and effort to the stating in the best possible and available terms the doctrine of the Holy, Blessed and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and of the Holy Ghost. That is, the rendering of the dynamic and diverse biblical teaching and insights into clear propositional terms, using particular words in specific ways. This teaching is found in the Nicene Creed (written originally in Greek and immediately translated into Latin) and in the Athanasian Creed or Quicunque Vult (written originally in Latin and later translated into Greek).

Key words are substance (ousia in Greek) and Person (hypostasis in Greek). And the church teaching is that there is one ousia (Divinity, Godhead) and that each of the Three Persons possesses in whole this one, unique ousia. This one substance, Godhead, is not, as it were, shared and split into three. The Father is wholly God; the Son is wholly God and the Holy Ghost is wholly God. Thus the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost are homoousios (of the same, identical substance, essence & being) with each other.

The Three Persons differ from one another not in Godhead for each one is wholly God; rather they differ in terms of their relations (not relationships!) one with another. The first Person is the Father of the Only-Begotten Son; the Son is the only-begotten Son of the Father; and the Holy Ghost proceeds from the Father and the Son. And, of course, in the divine work of creation, redemption, providence and judgment, each of the Three has a different but not an independent role.

It is this Mystery, God as the Holy Trinity, which Mother Church asks her members ( born from above by the Holy Ghost to be the adopted children of the Father) to adore, praise and magnify on Trinity Sunday, and to do so with special effort, concentration and devotion.

Then for the rest of the Christian Year, as each Sunday also bears the Name of the same Holy Trinity, Mother Church asks her members to hear and read the Gospel, the Epistle and the Old Testament as the words to the world and the church of the same Triune God, even as She worships the Undivided and Blessed Trinity, bowing before the Father in the Name of the Son and with the presence and illumination of the Holy Ghost.

Christians will probably begin to get their terminology concerning the Holy Trinity correct when their own worship, devotion and service is truly Trinitarian. When they worship the Father through the Lord Jesus Christ with the Holy Ghost, and as they offer their daily lives in the Spirit, and for the sake of the Lord Jesus, to the Father to glorify his name. It is only when we know God as the Triune Lord God experientially and mentally that we are aware of the need for careful terminology both to preserve sound doctrine and to honor God for who He is and what He has revealed unto us.

One common heresy uttered by people whose devotion is not truly Trinitarian is to treat God as One God who is One Person, which is Unitarianism. However, this is often given a kind of seemingly Trinitarian character by giving to this divine Person three primary Names (Father, Son and Holy Ghost). In this form the heresy is Modalism or Sabellianism, where the One Person of God is said to reveal himself in Three Modes of Being.

Amongst more liberal Christians, the most common heresy is to present the Trinity as if it were One Divine Community wherein there is perfect Diversity, and then to see human community (and even amongst Anglican to see the Anglican Communion of Churches!) in its unity and diversity called to reflect the divine model. This is an extreme form of the doctrine of the “social Trinity” and seems to be very popular in various forms in western churches as people aim to create community locally with “peace and justice” out of diverse human individual beings.

The traditional, orthodox, dogma of the Holy Trinity, upon which all orthodox Christian doctrine and practice is based and must harmonize, is well expressed in The Book of Common Prayer (1662, 1962 Canada and 1928 USA). Here for Trinity Sunday the Collect is unique in its address, for it is offered on this day and during the week following, to the Trinity as Trinity and as One God (not as usual to the Father through the Son and with the Spirit).

Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the
confession of the true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity,
and in the power of the divine Majesty to worship the Unity: We beseech thee,
that thou wouldest keep us stedfast in this faith, and evermore defend us from
all adversities, who livest and reignest, one God, world without end. Amen.


And let us add:

Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Ghost ; As it was in
the beginning, is now and ever shall be, world without end .
Amen.

Blessed be the kingdom of the Father and of the Son and of
the Holy Ghost; now and always, and unto ages of ages. Amen.


The Revd Dr Peter Toon May 2005

Saturday, April 30, 2005

WHEN DOES THE EASTER FESTIVAL END?

And do not forget the Festival of the Ascension!

Those Episcopalians and Anglicans (not to mention Roman Catholics and Lutherans) who note the use of prepositions in liturgy will have observed that the Church used to describe the Sundays following Easter Day as “Sundays” after Easter but now calls them Sundays of Easter.

Why?

In the 1970s there was a liturgical revolution which included changing the Calendar, and one result was that the Sundays after Easter (some six of them) became a part of Easter itself. According to the new theory, Easter stretched from ONE day into FIFTY days, the period in the Jewish Calendar from Passover to Pentecost. In fact, the chief liturgist in the Episcopal Church at that time declared that the key to understanding the content of the new Prayer Book of 1979 was the “recovery” of the “unitary festival” of Easter (which it was held was the norm and practice in the Church of the second to the fourth centuries). So it became common for many Episcopalians as they used the new Prayer Book of 1979 to speak of “the great fifty days”, to insist on standing throughout the whole Eucharistic Prayer and to omit public confession of sin (in order to emphasize the theme of celebration for the risen Christ) in these fifty days. Further, the Paschal Candle was kept alight until the day of Pentecost (old name – Whitsuntide) in order to underline the unity of the whole period of fifty days.

Obviously this new ethos of celebration did have some beneficial effects for some people since the proclamation of the Resurrection in clarity and power must be good. However, there were and there remain some serious problems with this way of treating the period from Easter Day till Whitsuntide (Passover to Pentecost).

Here are a few.

First of all, in the life of the Early Church the unitary nature of the fifty days was deepened and made more complex by the addition of the Festival of the Ascension in the fourth century, held forty days after the Day of Resurrection. Thus the FIFTY instantly became FORTY plus TEN and church liturgy, ceremonial and devotion changed with the change in the Calendar. The Liturgy of the West, including from 1549 the reformed catholic liturgy of the Anglican Way, reflected this forty plus ten arrangement from the fifth to the twentieth century (and still reflects it today where the 1970s revolution is not in place).

Secondly, the modern emphasis upon the unitary nature of the fifty days has led to a serious neglect of the fact and theology, not to mention the celebration, of the Ascension of our Lord (see Acts 1). The fact that he left the earth and took into heaven as his very own for all eternity his resurrected, immortalized and glorified human body and nature is of absolutely fundamental importance for Christian Faith & Hope. Now believers approach the Father through, in and with this Lord Jesus Christ who is Man as they are but is also God as is the Father, and yet He is One Person – One Person made known in two natures, divine and human. There is no doubt but that the Festival of the Ascension has been neglected in modern times and that this is a most serious loss to the piety of the Church.

Thirdly, the keeping of the Paschal Candle alight for fifty instead of forty days has led to confusion concerning what the Candle represents and how long Jesus met with his apostles and disciples before He parted from them (see Acts 1). It should be extinguished after the reading of the account of the Ascension on the fortieth day after Easter Day in order to signify that Jesus has ascended into heaven and that the period of ten days of awaiting His Paraclete, whom the Father will send in His name, has begun.

Fourthly, the omission of public confession of sin with absolution in these fifty days represents a wrong notion of celebration. In the Bible – see the Psalter for example – the genuine confession of sins is the praise of God, for it is the praise of His holiness, justice and mercy, for that He who hates and punishes sin also forgives sin in the humble and penitent. And was not Jesus raised, as St Paul says, for our justification before the Father, for the forgiveness of our sins and a right relation to God?

In summary, there is much to be remembered and then said in terms of the long tradition of worship, doctrine, ceremonial and piety for the FORTY plus TEN and for the wholehearted celebration of the Ascension on our Lord on the fortieth day (and if not on the Sunday following). However, in order to recover the old ways Episcopalians and Anglicans need to make use of the classic, historic Book of Common Prayer in the edition of 1662 in England, 1962 in Canada and 1928 in the USA. Modern prayer books remove this approach in favor of the Easter of 50 days.

Celebrate the Ascension on the day appointed for the Resurrected Lord did actually ascend into heaven, and is exalted to the right hand of the Father as the One Mediator between God and Man, as our exalted Prophet, Priest and King!

The Revd Dr Peter Toon April 30 2005

Friday, April 29, 2005

Are the Revisionists & Progressives of ECUSA the consistent ones?

A discussion starter

Since World War II there have been many changes or developments within the Anglican Way. In the West, and particularly in North America, these have been continuous and consistent. A decision was made, or a route was adopted, at the beginning of the second half of the twentieth century by the Episcopal Church in the U.S.A. to become relevant within and acceptable to the changing culture and “the spirit of the 1960s”. From this move, which was as much being caught up in the wind of change as making a decision to take a new path, has come a whole series of innovations and changes in the worship, doctrine, discipline and polity of the Episcopal Church. Protests have been made from time to time by the would-be faithful before, during and after each innovation; but usually the protestors have eventually accepted the latest innovation and prepared themselves to resist the next one, only to accept this in due time. Some people have voted with their feet and departed (so the membership of the Church has dropped by as much as 66 per cent since the 1960s).

Resistance to the sexual innovations of recent years seems to be rather more sustained and widespread than earlier resistance – but it may be the final kick as it were of the dying horse.

The progression of innovations, changes and revisions, is relatively simple to plot from the middle to the end of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first. From the changing emphases and curriculum in the seminaries which produced a new kind of priest, less the man of God and more the man of the world, through the acceptance of remarriage in church after divorce, the imposition of a new prayer book, the setting aside of the classic formularies, a new hymn-book with inclusive language, the advent of the “You-God”, the arrival of the feminist agenda with the ordination of women, the use of inclusive language for human beings and also for God, the mandating of the acceptance of women as priests, the acceptance of the human rights’ agenda, the granting of rights to actively homosexual persons, the blessing of same-sex unions, to the changed function of a Bishop as the CEO and Chief Liturgical Officer, and so on.

It is important to see the relations and connections between the various innovations. Without the acceptance of the human rights philosophy and agenda there would have been few innovations. And the same can be said of the influence of the influence of psychotherapy and the pursuit of self-worth and human dignity programs. Likewise of the peace and justice movement from the 1960s. Further, without the background of the arrival of the divorce culture in the ECUSA, there would have been little basis on which the LesBiGay agenda could be based. For, if the heterosexual persons have the right to fulfillment of their feelings and the right to be true to their orientation in serial monogamy blessed by ECUSA priests, why cannot the homosexual person have the same rights and opportunities to experience his own orientation?

The protest today by those who call themselves “orthodox” against the progressives (or “revisionists”) may be said to have little credibility because the “orthodox” themselves accept in practice if not in theory not a few of the innovations of the second half of the twentieth century – e.g., the new formularies of 1979, ordination of women and the remarriage of divorcees in church (with few questions asked). And, let it be noted, the same type of exegesis and interpretation of sacred Scripture which makes it possible to claim that serial monogamy and the ordination of women is approved by God also can be put at the service of showing that long-term unions of same-sex couples is not contrary to Scripture and tradition.

Therefore, logic and justice would seem to be on the side of the progressives for they have been consistent since the 1950s in their adoption of modern ideologies and culture and the changing of Church doctrine and practice by their ethos and content.

For the “orthodox” to be consistent – and I really want them to be so -- they need to be prepared to go back, as it were, behind all the innovations, recapture the authority of Scripture and a right way of reading It, and also restore the Formularies as the guide to worship, doctrine and discipline. For as long as they challenge the progressives from within the actual innovations that they share in common, their credibility and voice are muted; and further, they stand on sinking ground.

The Revd Dr Peter Toon April 29 2005 petertoon@msn.com