Wednesday, October 08, 2003

No welcome for observers at Texas meeting of conservatives

ACNS 3610 | USA | 7 OCTOBER 2003

by James Solheim

[ACNS source: Episcopal News Service] An attempt by Presiding Bishop Frank T Griswold and Dean George Werner, president of the House of Deputies, to send four observers to the American Anglican Council meeting in Texas has been rebuffed.

Bishop Griswold said that the four: Bishop Christopher Epting, deputy for ecumenical and interfaith relations; Bishop Stacy Sauls of Lexington; Dean Titus Presler of Seminary of the Southwest in Austin, Texas; and the Revd Brian Prior of Spokane, Washington; had been asked to "bring a greeting and to listen with care and the ear of the heart to the voices of those present. Their presence was to be a visible sign of the fact that, in the midst of disagreement, we are nonetheless fellow members of Christ's risen body and that we are called to bear one another's burdens and to acknowledge that when one member suffers the whole body must bear that suffering."

In a letter to Bishop Griswold, the Revd David Anderson, president of the AAC, said that there is no category for observers and that all must register as participants, signing the document, "A Place to Stand," that gives the AAC's theological perspective on the current state of the church. He said that those who are gathering for the meeting feel a
sense of betrayal and abandonment by the leadership of the Episcopal Church and feel that those who voted to confirm Gene Robinson's election as the church's first openly gay bishop have shattered and shipwrecked the church.

"When teachings and practices contrary to Scripture and to this orthodox Anglican perspective are permitted within the Church - or even authorized by the General Convention - in obedience to God we will disassociate ourselves from those specific teachings and practices and will resist them in every way possible," warns the "A Place to Stand" statement.

James Solheim is director of Episcopal News Service

Statement of His Eminence Cardinal Walter Kasper during the Archbishop of Canterbury's visit to Rome

ACNS 3610 | EUROPE | 7 OCTOBER 2003

[ACNS source: The Vatican] I would first of all wish to say that we rejoice in Archbishop Williams' visit to Rome and to the Holy See in his capacity as Archbishop of Canterbury. Such visits are a clear sign of the desire of the Anglican Communion and the Catholic Church to continue to work together towards full communion. I was honoured to be able to attend Archbishop Williams' enthronement in Canterbury last February, and am very happy to be able to welcome him here.

While the path to full communion has proved to be long and not without difficulties, the Catholic Church and the Anglican Communion continue to seek this goal, and remain committed firstly to the ongoing pursuit of doctrinal agreement through theological dialogue, and secondly, to incarnating as much as possible, in appropriate aspects of our ecclesial lives, the level of faith we already share. These complementary tasks are taken up most directly by our two international commissions, the Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission (ARCIC) and the newly formed International Anglican-Roman Catholic Commission for Unity and Mission (IARCCUM).

The theological dialogue, ARCIC, has produced a number of agreed statements over the past 33 years on doctrinal matters where Anglicans and Catholics have traditionally diverged. The most recent statement, The Gift of Authority (1999), builds on ARCIC's previous work on authority in the Church, and reveals significant progress towards a common understanding of the Petrine ministry. ARCIC will soon complete an agreed statement on the role of Mary in the life and doctrine of the Church. The Commission's aim has been to study the dogmas of the Assumption and the Immaculate Conception of Mary in the light of Scripture and our ancient common Tradition. It is hoped that significant progress will be recorded in the forthcoming agreed statement.

The second international commission (IARCCUM), constituted principally of bishops, builds on the historic meeting in May, 2000, of 13 Primates of Anglican Provinces with the heads of the Catholic Episcopal Conferences from the same countries, under the leadership of Cardinal Edward Cassidy and Archbishop George Carey. IARCCUM is intended to complement the work of ARCIC. It has taken up the threefold mandate given to it at the Mississauga meeting: the preparation of a text which would concisely articulate the degree of agreement in faith that exists between Anglicans and Catholics; reflection on ways in which the study and reception of the agreed statements of ARCIC could be fostered and promoted within the Anglican Communion and the Catholic Church; and identifying strategies which would translate the degree of spiritual communion that has been achieved into visible and practical outcomes.

As you know, there are currently tensions within the Anglican Communion over the teaching and practice concerning human sexuality. It is not my task to comment at length. In our private conversations, we have certainly discussed the recent decisions taken in two Anglican Provinces. Archbishop Williams knows that we are deeply concerned about this, and that depending on how the present situation is resolved, these decisions could cause new problems for our relations. Catholic teaching is very clear in this regard, and is concisely expressed in the Catechism of the Catholic Church (nn. 2357-59). Until recently, one could state with relative confidence that Catholics and Anglicans shared the same moral principles regarding human sexuality. We hope that it will remain so, for the world today needs our common witness. I hope and pray that the Anglican Communion will find a constructive solution to the present situation, both for the sake of the Anglican Communion itself and for the sake of our relations as well.

Our dialogue has produced many excellent results, and we look forward to working together to ensure that it continues to do so.

The American Anglican Council and Financial Backing

In the London Church Times of 3 October 2003 there is an article by Steve Levin, a staff writer on the Pittsburgh Post- Gazette (USA paper).

He calls the members and supporters of the American Anglican Council "US traditionalists" which is his way of contrasting them with the supporters of "gay rights" in the Episcopal Church USA.

He states that between 1997 & 2002 the AAC spent more than $3 million internally within the ECUSA seeking to promote its viewpoint. Its most generous donor is the Californian multi-millionaire Howard F Ahmanson Jr, who gives annually at least $200.000.00 to the AAC, to match money it first raises itself.

Closely allied with the AAC in activism within the ECUSA is the Institute on Religion and Democracy of Washington DC, which is well supported by charities and foundations connected with the Scaife family of Pittsburgh. Of interest is the fact that Mrs. Roberta Ahmanson, wife of Howard F., is on the Board of the Institute. It spent about $541.000.00 between 1997 & 2002 on programmes aimed at the Episcopal Church (and similar sums within Methodist and Presbyterian main-line churches).

Steve Levin did not know the context for which he was writing and so has probably given a wrong impression to the readers of the Church Times. In Britain and in the Church of England, for the supporters of the AAC & I R & D to be called "traditionalists", suggests that they hold to solid tradition - and thus use the traditional services of the classic BCP, read from the traditional Bible (KJV) and use language on the principle "We say 'Thou/Thee' to GOD and we say 'you' to man."

Of course, those living in the ECUSA know that the majority of support for these two organizations is from those who are better described as evangelical charismatics or charismatic evangelicals or just modern evangelicals. They are "traditionalists" only in the sense that they are deeply opposed to the gay agenda and are committed to the authority of Holy Scripture and the truth of the Creeds received and understood in the modern evangelical ethos. They use the NIV and the NRSV and Rite II from the 1979 Prayer Book (as at the Dallas Congress, 7-9 October) and call God "You".

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Anglican Communion Office responds to "leaked" document

ACNS 3608 | ACO | 7 OCTOBER 2003

On 30 September 2003, the Director of Communications for the Anglican Communion was contacted by a journalist in connection with a claim that Dr Paul Zahl, Dean of the Cathedral of the Advent, Birmingham, Alabama, had acquired details of the programme for the forthcoming Primates' Meeting to be held next week (15-16 October).

The Anglican Communion Office can confirm that Dr Zahl was briefly handed two documents in error at the recent meeting of the Inter-Anglican Theological Doctrinal Commission in Virginia Theological Seminary at the beginning of September.

Dr Zahl's comments on the nature and contents of these documents are misleading, and quotations that appeared in a recent newspaper report are incorrect. The documents were early draft versions of proposals being developed for a planning meeting in the ACO in preparation for the Primates' Meeting.

The Anglican Communion Office has an official role to advise on the structure of the Primates' Meetings in a way which will facilitate all primates to have an equal voice in all discussions.

Monday, October 06, 2003

The Seventeenth Sunday after Trinity

LORD, we pray thee that thy grace may always prevent and follow us, and make us continually to be given to all good works; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The Epistle: Ephesians 4.1-6 The Gospel: S. Luke 14.1-11

Here we address the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ as the LORD, in Hebrew YHWH, the revealed Name of God given to Moses at the burning bush in the wilderness (Exodus 3). He is “I AM WHO I AM” and “I AM WHO I SHALL BE” and “I AM & SHALL BE WHO I WAS”. And his Son, the One Mediator between God and Man, who also shares the name of “LORD” is “the same yesterday, today and for ever” (Hebrews 13:8).

To this eternally existing, infinite and ineffable God, who came to us in Jesus Christ, the Incarnate Son of the almighty Father, we are most highly privileged to be able to bring our petitions and to offer our praise and thanksgiving.

Here we use a verb “Prevent” whose meaning in this context is the old one -- to anticipate, to forestall, to be beforehand with. And we make two petitions which are connected to each other. First of all, we ask that the grace (the personal presence and unmerited mercy) of God (that is the Holy Ghost, the Paraclete, present in the world as the Spirit of Christ) may always both go before us and come behind us, so that we are always surrounded on all sides by the divine omnipresence and infinite care. In the second place, being thus placed within the gracious favour of God, we ask that we shall continually respond in faith and faithfulness to be and do that which is pleasing in his sight -- loving God with all our being & loving our neighbour as ourselves to the glory of God.

There is great strength in the word “always”. We need God’s personal presence and assistance not sometimes, not even often; but, rather, always. We may wish to compare this Collect for Trinity XVII with the Fourth Collect at the end of the Order for Holy Communion where we pray, “Prevent us, O Lord, in all our doings with thy most gracious favour…” That is, we ask God, as it were, to bring up the rear as his Church moves through space and time. The same Collect also asks, “Further us with thy continual help”. Here, we ask God to surround us and to go before us with his Presence.

Let us be clear that the LORD, the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost, is wholly desirous of being with his children in a complete and satisfying way for their salvation and their good. His promises of his presence and his help are many. What he looks for in us is faith and faithfulness so that we are truly and continually his people and he is known by us always as our covenant God.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Chastity - the old or the new kind?

The word "Chastity" is little used today in the Church, and even less in the world. This is a matter for regret!

What it used to mean - and still does mean - is a supreme God-pleasing standard for sexual relations. Regrettably, this standard seems to be universally regarded as too idealistic and/or not in touch with people's real lives and feelings.

Chastity (from the Latin "castitas", the quality or state of being chaste) has for centuries described the pure life, with particular reference to abstinence from unlawful, sexual intercourse. The unmarried and the married are both called to chastity. Thus fornication and adultery, and all forms of rape, are forbidden, being acts of impurity. Further, cohabitation and most forms of marriage after divorce fall within what Chastity has (traditionally) forbidden.

Using the modern expression of "orientation" it may be said that the call of chastity to those with a homosexual orientation is to an abstinence from "gay" sex.

The call to purity in general and sexual purity in particular is, of course, based upon many passages in the Gospels and Epistles where baptized Christians are called to purity of life in the church and in the world in imitation of Christ Jesus. And the purity that is being sought includes very definitely purity of mind and heart.

Let us hope and pray that this traditional Christian theme will influence the Primates in their discussions on October 15-16 and that they will not be too focused on one aspect of impurity, "gay" partnerships.

Today, there is a tendency amongst moral theologians to widen the meaning of Chastity and to free it from its traditional association with purity of sexual relations. Thus it is now said, "to be chaste is to be a person of integrity, true to self and to other persons, devoted to the love of God and neighbour in all things. The call to chastity is the call to receive, affirm, exercise and celebrate our ways of being human together, including sexual ways, so that respect, love, trust, mutuality and commitment towards ourselves and our neighbours will grow and abound in human community" (New Dictionary of Christian Ethics, IVP). There is nothing wrong with these sentiments, but if we go with this wide meaning we find that we do not have a word to replace "chastity" as a powerful, incisive word referring to sexual purity. Maybe this loss is what pleases many in the modern churches!

I vote to stay with the traditional meaning! I hope the Primates also do.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Reconciliation Ministry inaugurated by Episcopal Divinity School

(this should be worth perusing to gain a clearer understanding of a very liberal mindset) -- P.T.

ACNS 3605 | USA | 6 OCTOBER 2003

Reconciliation Ministry inaugurated by Episcopal Divinity School

Episcopal Divinity School announces the inauguration of a major new ministry for reconciliation within the church, "Good News: A Congregational Resource for Reconciliation." In the aftermath of controversy and confusion following the decision of the General Convention to endorse the election of the first openly gay bishop in the Anglican Communion, the seminary has responded with a program designed to bring people on "both sides of the argument" together in mutual respect with a shared hope for healing and peace.

"Good News" is a model for small group conversation within any parish built on the gospel of Jesus Christ. The content for the dialogues comes from the four gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. The process is simple and accessible. Guided by a covenant which honors persons of all opinions, "Good News" seeks to fulfill three goals: (a) to promote a fair and respectful dialogue among persons who hold different opinions, (be) to offer a context of reflection on the shared values of the gospel, and (co) to encourage a process of reconciliation within the life of the community.

Participants receive a booklet written by EDS's President and Dean, the Rat Red Steven Charleston, which guides them through a prayer-centered experience in how Christians can (and indeed must) stay together even when the differences between them seem irreconcilable. These booklets can be purchased from the seminary and then reproduced by the parish making the "Good News" ministry affordable for any congregation.

As Bishop Charleston writes in the introduction, "Good News" is not about trying to resolve the debates on human sexuality, but about helping the Christian community find reconciliation. "At the end of that path," he writes, "people may still disagree, but they will have found the peace of Christ which is at the heart of community.... To use Good News, no one is asked to give up his or her own opinions. They are only asked to enter into a shared journey with others to search for reconciliation...they are asked to take the path to peace, even if it means only taking a few steps at a time."

Those steps are built on the three central visions of the seminary's own mission: Justice, Compassion, and Reconciliation. "Good News" walks participants through these three viewpoints on the gospel, shifting the focus away from the usual repetitive cycle of arguments on fixed positions and placing it on the call to discipleship every Christian hears when Jesus says "come, follow me". "Good News" helps communities discover that they can find reconciliation without resolving all of their disagreements. Parishes can experience compassion rather than conflict. They can embrace the peace of Christ, calming fear with the forgiveness of Jesus.

While "Good News" may be especially timely and supportive for communities struggling with the issues surrounding the last general Convention, it is equally helpful for any congregational conflict. It is a flexible model that can be carried out over a one day retreat, or, divided into separate sessions over three days. It is intentionally created to be an adaptable, welcoming, and yet challenging resource for any congregation to use in its own ministry of healing and Christian education.

"In a time when people were being called to take sides," said Bishop Charleston, "EDS decided to stand with Christ in the crossfire. Our mission is one of reconciliation and that is what the church needs now more than partisan politics."

For further information, please contact:

Nancy Davidge
99 Brattle Street
Cambridge
MA 02138
USA

Tel: +1 617-868-3450 x 302
Email: ndavidge@episdivschool.edu
www.episdivschool.edu

Anglicans' Homosexual Priests Are Not Just Internal Problem, Says Cardinal

Warns That Such Ordinations Affect Relations With Catholic Church

VATICAN CITY, OCT. 3, 2003 (Zenit.org).- The Anglican Communion's ordination of practicing homosexuals is a problem affecting its relations with the Catholic Church, says a cardinal.

Cardinal Walter Kasper, president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, made his observation today, the first day of a visit to the Vatican by the Anglican archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams.

"We have . talked about the conflicts and tensions which have arisen in recent months within the Anglican Communion following the ordination of practicing homosexual priests," Cardinal Kasper said on Vatican Radio.

"I expressed my concern because it is not only an internal problem to the Anglican Communion, but also a problem that affects our relations," he added.

The Anglican primate held working meetings with Cardinal Kasper as well as with British Archbishop Michael Fitzgerald, president of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue.

This is Dr. Williams' first visit to the Vatican as archbishop of Canterbury. He was appointed to the post by Queen Elizabeth II and confirmed in it last year. John Paul II is scheduled to receive the Anglican archbishop in audience on Saturday.

At the end of a meeting, Cardinal Kasper disclosed that the Catholic Church and the Anglican Communion are completing the redaction of a joint document on the Virgin Mary.

Written by a commission of Catholic and Anglican theologians and pastors, the document will focus on the role of Mary in the life and doctrine of the Church.

The commission has considered the dogmas of the Assumption and the Immaculate Conception in the light of Scripture and of the ancient tradition common to both Anglicans and Catholics.

Regarding the ordination of practicing homosexuals, Cardinal Kasper said: "We have a clear position which is expressed in the Catechism of the Catholic Church; we also have a tradition, a common heritage on this point. We hope they will not abandon this common tradition."

"I expressed my desire, my wish that a solution will be found that is accepted by the Anglican Communion and that will not have repercussions on relations with our Church," he added.

The Anglican Communion will address the issue at a summit in London this month. It will study the appointment by its church in the United States -- the Episcopalian church -- of Gene Robinson, a divorced homosexual, as bishop of New Hampshire.

The Anglican Communion, present in 160 countries, has 70 million faithful, organized in 38 autonomous regional churches.

Anglican-Catholic theological dialogue takes place through two structures: the ARCIC (Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission), instituted in 1970, and the IARCCUM (International Roman Catholic Commission for Unity and Mission).

ARCIC concentrates its works on controversial theological themes between Catholics and Anglicans and has published documents on the Eucharist, ministry, authority, salvation, the Church and moral questions. These documents are submitted to both parties for review and debate. The most recent was the 1999 document "The Gift of Authority."

IARCCUM was instituted during a meeting in Canada in May 2000 and led by Cardinal Edward Cassidy, the then president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, and the then archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey. Thirteen primates of Anglican provinces and 13 presidents of Episcopal conferences in the United States participated in this meeting, as did representatives of the Catholic Church.

The duty of IARCCUM is to sustain and support the aims of ARCIC.

Archbishop of Canterbury arrives in Rome Friday

(To visit the Vatican before he hosts the 37 Primates of the Anglican Family
on Oct 15 seems a fine preparation by Archbishop Rowan!) --P.T.


VATICAN CITY - 3 October 2003 - 340 words

Archbishop of Canterbury arrives in Rome Friday

The Most Rev Rowan Williams, Archbishop of Canterbury and president [first Primate] of the Anglican Communion, arrives in Rome this evening for a three-day visit to the Vatican, including an audience with Pope John Paul (October 4).

He will be met at Rome airport by Cardinal Walter Kasper, president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and by other Vatican officials.

The archbishop, who will stay at the Venerable English College, will be accompanied by 13 people, including his wife, and representatives of the Anglican Communion. Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor, will arrive in Rome tomorrow to participate in the events surrounding the visit.

Today, Archbishop Williams will have talks with Cardinal Kasper and other members of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity as well as talks with Archbishop Michael Fitzgerald, president of the Pontifical Council for Inter-religious Dialogue. After lunch at the Anglican Centre at the Doria Pamphili Palace, there will be round table discussions with Catholic representatives. Cardinal Kasper will host a dinner at the Santa Martha Residence in the Vatican.

Saturday morning, Archbishop Williams will go to St Peter's Basilica to pray. At 11am he will be received in audience by the Holy Father. He will then visit the excavations under St Peter's and return to the English College for lunch. In the afternoon there will be a press conference at the college, vespers at Santa Maria Sopra Minerva and a ceremony for the official installation of the new director of the Anglican Centre in Rome. Following a reception in the archbishop's honour, a dinner will be offered by the ambassador of Great Britain to the Holy See, Kathryn Colvin.

On Sunday, Archbishop Williams will preside at a Eucharist at All Saints Anglican Church, before his departure for London.

Catholic diocese withdraws invitation to Episcopalians over gay issue

The Associated Press

ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. - The Catholic Diocese of St. Augustine withdrew its invitation Wednesday for the Episcopalian Diocese to use one of its churches for a ceremony because the pro-gay leader of the Episcopalian Church was slated to attend.

The local Catholic diocese rescinded the invitation after Frank Griswold, the presiding bishop of the Episcopal Church, defended in a news article the church's confirmation of a gay bishop and argued that the Bible does not condemn same-sex relationships.

Bishop Victor Galeone "felt a good number of his people would be offended to learn that an Episcopalian bishop, that holds a position that is radically opposed to what both the church and scripture teach about homosexuality, is using one of our facilities," Kathleen Bagg-Morgan, a spokeswoman for the local Catholic diocese said in a statement.

The Episcopalian Diocese, based in nearby Jacksonville, had planned to use St. Joseph's Roman Catholic Church for the installation ceremony of a new bishop, Samuel Howard, on Nov. 1. After learning of Griswold's comments and that he would be attending, Galeone "regrettably revoked" the invitation.

The Episcopal Diocese of Florida did not return telephone and e-mail messages Wednesday evening.

In a Monday interview with The Associated Press, Griswold defended his confirmation of Bishop-elect V. Gene Robinson, the church's first openly gay bishop, and defended homosexuality, saying it was not fully understood in Biblical times.

"Discreet acts of homosexuality" were condemned in the Bible because they were acts of lust instead of the "love, forgiveness, grace" of committed same-sex relationships, he said.

"Homosexuality, as we understand it as an orientation, is not mentioned in the Bible," Griswold said.

Griswold comments come at a time when the 2.3-million member Episcopal Church is in danger of being split over the decision to confirm Robinson. Next week, the conservative American Anglican Council will meet in Dallas to decide whether to break from the denomination.