Wednesday, October 01, 2003

RECEPTIONISM, WOMEN IN ORDERS & "GAY" PARTNERSHIPS

(suggestions for consideration by those involved in the crisis in the ECUSA)
In the ECUSA, we are seeing increasingly both liberal bishops in their diocesan messages and advocates of the LesBiGay lobby in their writings and speeches using the Anglican doctrine of reception with respect to the blessing by the church of same-sex couples. This Anglican doctrine was created (from other forms of the doctrine of reception in the ecumenical movement and with respect to the history of doctrine) in 1988 in order to deal with the reality of divisions within the Anglican Communion over the ordination of women.

What the doctrine teaches is that after a synod or convention passes the necessary legislation to allow women to be ordained, then that doctrine and practice is in the process of reception - of testing and discernment - until such time as there is consensus about it, one way or the other. However, women in orders are to be treated as if they are truly and fully ordained even though their orders and position are being tested and discerned. Respect, good will and kindness are to be shown by all to all.

Applied to the "gay" issue by people in the ECUSA, the doctrine of reception teaches that after the General Convention of the ECUSA has passed the legislation allowing the blessing of "gay" couples (with local bishop's approval) and has confirmed the election of a priest (in a "gay" union) to be a bishop, then this doctrine and practice is in the process of reception, that is being tested. Discernment is being applied. As this goes on, those in such unions are to be treated as in legitimate and wholesome partnerships. All in the church are to be respectful and kind one to another so that there are no outcasts.

So it is that, whether we like it or not, the ordaining of women and the blessing of same-sex partnerships have been brought together and placed, as it were, under the same umbrella. This way of thinking is gaining ground in the ECUSA and also in Canada and Great Britain.

But is there a deeper more profound relation between the ordination of women and the blessing of "gay" couples? Yes, there is, and it is a connection which few in the conservative or the liberal camps of the Church appear to wish to think about or to acknowledge.

This relation and connection is NOT that of immorality - that both these church rites break the moral law of God. Obviously, "gay" sex is contrary to the law of God concerning sexual relations and it is described in the NT as a sin which, if not repented of, bars a person from the kingdom of God. Virtually all say that a woman who is ordained is not guilty of breaking that which we normally think of as the moral law of God - the second part of the table of the Ten Commandments. If anyone is guilty of breaking any law, be it of the first or second part of the table of the Commandments, it is the bishop who ordains her.

What does unite these two rites is that each is a setting aside, or a breaking, or a disregarding, of the Order that God in his wisdom has placed within the natural creation and in the kingdom of God, as we know them. Obviously "gay" sex is unnatural -- contrary to the Order within creation wherein male and female are equal but different, complementary, and ordered one to another for the purpose of procreation and personal fulfillment. Thus "gay" sex is both immoral and disordered - BUT yet it can be forgiven and those involved in it helped and healed.

However, women's ordination (which elevates the women to pastoral oversight) though not immoral is also unnatural, contrary to God's order for the relation of the two sexes and for the ordering of His Church. Male and female are certainly equal in dignity, worth and ability; but, they are also distinct in order, even as the Three Persons of the Holy Trinity are equal in their Personhood and their Divinity/Godhead but in an ordered relation one to another - the Father together with His Son and with His Spirit. The Father is first in order, the Son second and the Holy Ghost, third: in the human race the male is first in order and the woman second in order (see Genesis 1: 27 & St Paul's teaching on headship). To break this order is to interfere with what God has blessed.

Thus it is that when the Church, even with good intentions and according to the best secular wisdom of the day, introduces innovations that are contrary to known divine Order, then the result is disorder in terms of the kingdom of God, and, immediately a window or door is opened through which further forces to cause disorientation and disorder enter. This has been the case so clearly in the Provinces of the Anglican Communion in the West (North) and may be the cause of the collapse of this Family of Churches as we have know it.

So the relation between women's ordination and the blessing of "gay" couples is that they are both examples of disorder and a breaking of the command to love God with heart, soul, mind and strength. In each, however, those who do the ordaining or give the blessing are more guilty than those who are ordained and blessed.


P.S. One could add that the blessing of serial monogamy by the clergy in the ECUSA is another example of disorder, which also opens windows and doors wide to allow secular forces to enter the church and change her mindset and practice and make her weak in moral theology and vigor.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

American Anglican Council and Christ Church announce soaring registration numbers for "A Place to Stand" gathering

ACNS 3594 | USA | 29 SEPTEMBER 2003

[ACNS source: American Anglican Council] The American Anglican Council (AAC) and Christ Church of Plano, Texas, have announced that registrations for the "A Place to Stand: Declaring, Preparing" gathering have topped 2200. To date, "A Place to Stand" has drawn participants from all 50 states representing at least 95 Episcopal dioceses (out of 110). The participant list already includes 40 bishops, 729 priests, 43 deacons, 91 seminary students and 1,219 lay members of Episcopal churches across the nation. International and ecumenical representatives have also registered for the event. Over 75 media credentials have been approved.

"The extraordinary conference registration numbers show that mainstream Anglicans in the Episcopal Church are mobilized and determined to find a way to remain within the Anglican family," said the Revd Canon David C. Anderson, AAC President and CEO. "As we have said all along, we're not leaving. It is the Episcopal Church that has departed from the historic teachings of the Christian church and separated itself from the Anglican Communion."

"We are seeing an incredible response for 'A Place to Stand,'" said the Revd David Roseberry, Rector of Christ Church, Plano. "The number of priests who have registered is equivalent to roughly 10 per cent of all active clergy in ECUSA and the overall number of registrants is larger than the number of ECUSA deputies and bishops who attended General Convention."

The gathering will be held at the Wyndham Anatole Hotel in Dallas, Texas, from noon October 7 through noon October 9, 2003.

For more information or to register for "A Place to Stand: Declaring, Preparing", visit the AAC web site at www.americananglican.org or the Christ Church website at www.christchurchplano.org

All participants are required to register online. All media interested in attending must apply for media credentials.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

What Price Unity? Archbishop Robin Eames examines questions facing the Anglican Communion

ACNS 3593 | IRELAND | 26 SEPTEMBER 2003

[ACNS source: Church of Ireland Gazette] The Archbishop of Armagh and Senior Primate of the Anglican Communion, the Most Revd Robin Eames, examines some of the questions currently facing the world-wide Anglican Communion prior to the forthcoming special meeting of Primates at Lambeth Palace:

"The decision of the Episcopal Church of the United States to endorse the appointment of Canon Gene Robinson as bishop of the diocese of New Hampshire has provoked a crisis for the Anglican Communion. Irrespective of individual or collective opinions on the election of a practising homosexual to be an Anglican bishop this event has once more brought
into question the nature of unity and relationships of the diverse Provinces which make up the Communion to which the Church of Ireland belongs by bringing to light very deep divisions on this question which have existed within Anglicanism and beyond. Those sharp divisions of opinion currently obvious within individual Provinces and between Provinces, the expressions of strong opinions by clergy and laity and the widespread media speculation in advance of the forthcoming special meeting of Primates at Lambeth Palace compel a careful examination of the nature of the Anglican Communion and its structures. The demand by some for the expulsion of ECUSA from the Anglican Communion raises the
question: What does expulsion mean and how if at all could it take place?

"In any relationship corporate or individual it is often the case that only when a crisis arises is the structure or meaning of that relationship examined in any depth. So it is with the Anglican Communion. The ordination of women to the priesthood and episcopate
forced such an examination before, during and following the Lambeth Conference 1988. The media even forecast the end of the Anglican Communion. Questions were raised then about the same structures where fundamental differences of opinion existed across Anglicanism and I was privileged to chair the international Commission set up by the late
Robert Runcie, Archbishop of Canterbury. That Commission produced pastoral guidelines which were geared to encourage the 'highest degree of communion' between differing Provinces, guidelines which may well be appropriate at this time. My experience then and since has convinced me that the fundamental issue for our Communion is: How do we live together with differing opinions, differing cultures but maintain some semblance
of active communion? I believe Anglicanism will survive this current controversy. The question is: in what form?

"The truth is that the Anglican Communion has lived through generations without basic regulations, rules or legal structures. Anglicanism has consistently rejected any move to create a curia such as we see in the Roman Catholic tradition. This desire has manifested itself time and again at Lambeth Conferences, Primates Meetings and gatherings of the
Anglican Consultative Council. I have witnessed consistent rejection of such a move. The autonomy of individual Provinces has been jealously guarded. Provincial government usually through synodical structures and the exercise of episcopacy has enshrined this degree of individuality. Provincial contributions have centred on the aspirations and historical developments of individual Provinces or Churches. The common tie has
been 'communion with the See of Canterbury' and 'communion with other Churches maintaining the same ethos.' But I am unaware of any agreed rules governing such relationships beyond the desire to be 'in communion'. Therefore when we talk of expulsion the question arises - expulsion from what?

"In the blitz of opinion and counter argument over the election to New Hampshire I believe we need to be clear what we are talking about.

"This election undoubtedly challenges the Resolution 1.10 of the last Lambeth Conference. It is clearly in breach of the majority opinion of the bishops in 1998. It is clearly contrary to the view of a large number of Anglicans. But the question still remains: Is there a tangible
manner within the structures of our Communion as present constituted to do more than express concern and criticism and adopt attitudes within our own Provinces towards those others with whom we disagree?

"To put it plainly - if no constitutional or legal rules exist for what constitutes membership of the Anglican Communion there are no rules for expulsion of a member Church.

"The focus must therefore turn to the practices and customs which do exist.

"The Archbishop of Canterbury is primus inter pares at any meeting of Primates. As 'first among equals' he calls and normally presides at such gatherings. Equally it is at his invitation that bishops attend the Lambeth Conference. In theory there is nothing to prevent disapproval on any issue being expressed at a meeting of Primates. It is also open to the Archbishop of Canterbury to withhold invitations should he so wish to either a Primates Meeting or to the Lambeth Conference itself. But the fact remains that no constitutional basis exists for the expulsion of any Province from the Anglican Communion. Given that the traditional 'instruments of unity' of Anglicanism are the See of Canterbury, the Lambeth Conference, the Primates Meeting and the Anglican Consultative Council, our Communion has existed as a 'communion of like-minded Provinces' where provincial autonomy is preserved. It is that 'communion' which has been questioned and challenged by the recent events in the United States.

"On the other hand Anglicans refer to the historic Lambeth Quadrilateral which addresses the concept of Communion even more directly than the Instruments of Unity. We have traditionally placed a high value on the ordering, the forms and the expressions of worship. In this we have expressed doctrine in a more explicit manner than doctrinal statements.
Here in the Church of Ireland it is the way we worship and pray that shapes our identity. Soon we will celebrate the launch of a new Prayer Book. Such is for us a standard of doctrine as much as a basis for worship. This standard expressed through the Book of Common Prayer has been recognised by successive Lambeth Conferences as being grounded in Scripture, the Catholic Creeds, the Sacraments of Baptism and Eucharist
and the historic Ministry of Bishop, Priest and Deacon.

"A Church which describes itself along these lines does not seek to define more of its ethos than is absolutely necessary. Provincial autonomy permits different attitudes to discipline and to ways of presenting the Gospel. Anglicans seek to preserve the identity or
communion of a world family. This does not prevent disagreements between members of the family on what Scripture says - but it is far from saying we do not care about the primacy of Scripture. We can disagree about the frequency of the celebration of the Sacraments - but we cannot discard the Sacraments. As we have seen Anglicans can differ on the ordination of women to the priesthood or episcopate but we do not deny there should be priests and bishops if we wish to remain Anglicans. The Creeds may be
only an outline of the faith but we cannot reject them and remain part of the Catholic Church.

"Such are just some of the ingredients and dilemmas of 'communion' as we have sought to be a world Church family.

"As the Archbishop of Dublin and I stressed in our recent statement the Church of Ireland addresses that communion in the Declaration: 'The Church of Ireland will maintain Communion with the sister Church of England and with all other Christian Churches agreeing in the principles of this Declaration.'

"Laws apart, opinions apart and sensitivities apart diversity of culture, practice and life-styles have been and will most likely continue to be the experience of a world family such as the Anglican Communion. Perhaps the main question arising for us at this time is
simply: How do we live with and how do we understand difference?

"What price unity?"

Monday, September 29, 2003

PRIORITIZATION OF THE "GAY" ISSUE

Thought to provoke better thoughts

The expression "the prioritization of the homosexual issue" has been used by a few conservative Episcopalians, including myself. It assumes that there are other very important issues and that a choice is being made by the majority (or by the leadership of the American Anglican Council and Bishops in a few dioceses heading this majority) to place blessing "gay" partnerships either first on the list, or even as the only item on the list, of concerns about the Episcopal Church of the USA.

To open up this discussion leads us to the heart of a major disagreement within conservative Episcopalians, and thus amongst those who will gather at Plano/Dallas on the 7th October. The disagreement is whether the homosexual issue is THE real and true problem in the ECUSA or rather a most serious PRESENTING problem behind which are other, even more important, problems.

But let us be honest. In terms of communication, political strategy and simplicity, to focus on one clear message - e.g., it is wrong that the Church consecrate a man who is living in an openly "gay" union - is a winner amongst many social conservatives be they churchmen or not. Here the ECUSA leadership is the "bad guy" and those who oppose this wrong are the "good guy". (A danger here, of course, is of self-righteousness by those who do the condemning.)

Let us agree that those who claim that the homosexual issue is THE primary issue (and not merely a very serious presenting issue) have to go on to affirm that if this is put right then the ECUSA will be generally OK. That is, the major decisions to innovate taken by the General Convention since the 1960s are within the acceptable standards of the kingdom of God and within the principles of historic Anglicanism. Thus, for example, ECUSA's rejection of the classic formularies and its adoption of new ones in 1976/79; the approval of the ordination of women in 1976 and the making of this doctrine part of the received Creed in 2000 for church officers; the acceptance of serial monogamy and the allowing of divorced and remarried persons to continue in and be promoted in ordained ministry and lay leadership since the 1960s -- all these are generally acceptable and cannot be either the real problem or a major problem at all. They can be safely discarded and we can all carry on much as before as long as we get rid of the "Lesbigay" presence.

Let us now look at this whole thing in a different light.

Let us suppose that the homosexual issue is only there prominently in the ECUSA in 2003 because of what already exists in ECUSA as well as what has been going on within ECUSA for fifty years or more - i.e., a way of worship, doctrine and discipline that owes more to modern views of human rights, personal fulfillment and autonomy and secular values than to the principles of holy Scripture & historic Anglicanism. This issue, as it were, sits on the back of other issues/facts and, to change the metaphor, is only the tip of the iceberg. And when something is a presenting problem it will remain there expressing itself in one or another forms for as long as the underlying causes and problems are left alone. (We know this from experience in many areas and walks of life.)

Thus those (at present the minority - even a small minority) who claim that the homosexual issue is an offence unto Almighty God, but only is occurring in intensity because the ECUSA has prepared for it by a series of acts of apostasy since the 1960s, have to say that in the present crisis, and in sending messages to the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Primates, conservative Episcopalians have to be honest before God, man and their own history.

That is, they accept that the homosexual issue can be prioritized IF AND ONLY IF it is clearly indicated (in the accompanying "annotations") that the "gay" issue is inextricably related to other foundational issues and that these must be dealt with as soon as possible so that a proper and right Anglican foundation is laid for any future reformed Anglican presence in the USA as part of the Anglican Communion. In other words, they say that unless the matter of the rejection of (a) the authentic formularies, (b) the doctrine and discipline of Holy Matrimony, and (c) proper ecclesiastical discipline by ECUSA is stated as needing urgent attention so that error, heresy, apostasy, and antinomianism can be dispelled. If this is not made clear, then to lead off on the homosexual issue (and stay with it alone) is a grave & fateful mistake, and the last state will be worse that the first.

Certainly this is all about recovering Biblical doctrine, but that means in practice recovering it wearing the right spectacles and using the right lens. ECUSA has been using the wrong spectacles and lens for thirty or more years. There needs to be recovered an orthodox way of reading and interpreting Scripture that is within the ongoing central Tradition of the Church of God.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Sunday, September 28, 2003

Diocesan Resolutions & Anglican Crisis

It is worthwhile in a calm and reflective mood to study the Resolutions produced in Special Conventions recently in conservative dioceses such as Pittsburgh & Fort Worth.

I offer the following observations as a call to self-examination and prayer as well as serious reflection & discussion.

While these Resolutions are very clear in their opposition to the innovation of the blessing of "gay" unions and of the consecration of "gay" bishops, and while they say they stand for the orthodox faith, there are some very important false assumptions & omissions (which the Church of yesterday, it if were consulted and had a vote, would certainly point out to these dioceses both very clearly and very firmly).

First of all, there is no sense in the Resolutions that being a part of the ECUSA and having shared in its common life for decades, even centuries, that these dioceses share the guilt, stain and cancer of the apostasy of the "national church". There is little or no sense of being causes of, and participants in, the growing apostasy, error and immorality, since all are part of the same ecclesial body and household (however dysfunctional it be). Where is the weeping for this long participation?

If the ECUSA as "national church" can be said to have no corporate memory beyond 1976, so likewise it appears can these dioceses. They appear to accept as good the major act of apostasy of 1976/79 when the classic Formularies of the Anglican Way were set aside and novel Formularies (the 1979 book of alternative services and it catechism) were put in their place. Only by the false decree of the General Convention is the 1979 prayer book "the book of common prayer" - for by literary and historical analysis it is a book of alternative services, which should stand alongside and under the authority of the classic Book of Common Prayer, Ordinal and Articles of Religion.

By agreeing to this massive change, by confirming its supposed correctness over the years since 1979 (and without reference to the Constitution of the PECUSA where the Prayer Book must be the classic BCP) and in words of these recent Resolutions -- as well as, apparently, by showing little or no remorse for their own share in the cancer within ECUSA -- the dioceses have simply, it would appear, prioritized the homosexual issue and not gone to the root and cause of the malady of ECUSA.

Why cannot both be dealt with for they hang together and are inextricably united! Why is their such attachment to the 1979 prayer book and such a widespread and open rejection of the classic Formularies in the evangelical/charismatic circles of the ECUSA? All the Continuing Anglican Churches and virtually all the newer non-ECUSA Anglican bodies accept the classic Formularies, even if they use modern liturgies. And of course such is the legal position of the Church of England & the Anglican Church of Canada.

If there is a public health emergency (with cases of a deadly disease here and there) we do not merely seek to help those afflicted; we also seek to get to the originating cause of the outbreak and emergency. What seems to be happening now is that evangelicals are seeking to deal enthusiastically with the local manifestations of the deadly disease but yet they are not keen on going to the source and not recognizing that their own (as it were) rejection of good health regulations is a major part of the emergency.

To say "we go back to the Bible" when we hold to false formularies (which help to fix how we read and receive the Bible's teaching) is not an answer or solution. It is an avoidance of the major crisis by denying its existence.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Sisk, Receptionism, Gay Unions.

Adelphoi,

Did you see this recent Statement ( below Sisk of NYC)? Look at it not only as a capitulation to error and immorality via the adoption of human rights and doctrines of personal self-fulfillment & autonomy, but also in another way, which has all kinds of implications for the Anglican Way.

Bishop Sisk uses the language of "discernment" in what amounts to the application of the Anglican doctrine of reception [adapted/invented in 1988 by the Lambeth Conference for the sole purpose of dealing with wide disagreement over women’s ordination] to homosexual acts.



The "conservative liberals" keep claiming that there is no connection between the ordination of women and the blessing of gay unions/sodomy, even as those pushing gay unions/sodomy increasingly invoke the language and methodology of the innovation of ordaining women. There is likely much trouble ahead on this score & connection! The ordination of women will come back as it were to haunt those who resolutely oppose the blessing of gay unions but favor women as bishops/presbyters.


See
http://www.dioceseny.org/index.cfm?Action=News.ViewAnnouncementDetails&NewsID


Bishop Sisk's Statement on the Blessing of Same-Sex Unions

STATEMENT ON THE BLESSING OF SAME-SEX UNIONS
The Rt. Rev. Mark S. Sisk
Bishop of New York

I first grappled with the question of blessing same-sex unions more than 30 years ago when I came to know a deeply committed lesbian couple in the congregation I then served. I found myself wondering what I would do if they asked me to bless their union. Although they never asked, I concluded that I would be willing to offer such prayers, although I knew such a blessing would lack the assent of the larger church. I came to that decision based upon my observation that this couple’s commitment to each other appeared to me to be integral to their lives as faithful followers of Christ.

If the question had been presented to me in the abstract, I doubt very much that I would have ever reached that conclusion. However, I found myself confronted not by a hypothetical question but by two people, alive in themselves and alive in the faith that so clearly nourished them and strengthened their witness. It was through their fidelity, and the obvious fruitfulness of their lives in Christ, that I was moved to a new place of understanding. I believe that it is through the lived experience of the presence of God’s Holy Spirit animating the lives of committed same-sex couples that the larger Church will eventually come to a new understanding of those relationships. I know that this process of thoughtful pastoral discernment, and the prayerful exploration of different modes of affirmation, is underway in many churches in the Episcopal Diocese of New York, and I am sympathetic to it.

However, it takes time for the Church as a whole to reach a common mind about any such new understanding. I do not believe that this process of discernment can or should be determined simply by an up or down vote of a legislative body. Parliamentary and legislative actions rarely resolve such fundamentally pastoral issues; any truly new understanding within the Church needs to grow out of the lived experience of the People of God.

I believe that we are in a transitional moment. We are at a time between times when numbers among us believe that God’s will in this matter clearly favors, even demands, such blessings, while others, perhaps the majority among us, most emphatically do not agree. As a bishop, I bear responsibility to both groups in my diocese, as well as all whose views are less strongly held. I am a pastor to all, and in that work I must be honest and forthcoming about my own views. However, it is not my vocation to substitute my own experience and convictions for those of the larger community of faith, or to deny to them the opportunity to clarify their understanding as they grapple with this question themselves. That opportunity is their right.

I have come to the conclusion that the best way for the Church to reach a common mind, the most promising way forward, is to recognize and accept the fact that we live in a time of deep disagreement. As we disagree, we must work hard to be respectful to opposing views. I am further convinced that we do not serve our Church well by attempting to force a resolution one way or the other. Instead, we must live within the tension of that disagreement, and allow time for the Spirit to work among us. We will best experience that working not in legislative action but in the halting, tentative, and yet ultimately decisive way we have experienced the Spirit working among us through the ages.



(note my booklet/essay THE DOCTRINE OF RECEPTION AND THE CONSECRATION OF WOMEN AS BISHOPS will be available soon from the Latimer House Trust in Great Britain)
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Marriage in the Ancient Eastern Church, Orthodoxy & ECUSA

When a Jurisdiction of the Church has in place a solid doctrine & discipline of marriage, then its Ministers can, when and where necessary, make specific dispensations to cover particular needs. However, when a Church (such as the Episcopal Church of the USA) has no solid doctrine or discipline in place then the general state of affairs is more like antinomianism than order.

Some people suggest that what goes on in the ECUSA is not too different from the basic law and tradition of Orthodoxy. This opinion in unfounded, I think.

The Orthodox doctrine of marriage as a sacrament is as high a statement as is possible on earth of the relation of man and wife as one flesh for life – and even for the life of the age to come! And, of course, such a marriage always begins in church in the context of the Eucharist.

In fact so high is this doctrine that the Rite is unrepeatable even for the widow(er) and certainly not for the divorced. Any second marriages of any kind cannot & do not have the sacramental meaning or context as does a genuine first marriage.

In the traditional canon law of the Orthodox Churches, where there is a second marriage of a divorced person that person is under discipline and is treated as if he were a catechumen or under penance for a year or more – that is, not allowed even to attend the Eucharist proper. This is because of the Lord’s teaching about the sin of adultery contracted in second marriages. Here the sin is forgiven but penance is necessary.

Also – and this still applies – a deacon or priest is only allowed to marry once and even if he is made a widower he is still not allowed to marry again. If he does then he is no longer able to function in the Ministry.

So, if the ECUSA (or any new federation of conservative episcopal dioceses & parishes) were to follow Orthodox practice rather than the strict, more legal, way of the Roman Church and the traditional Church of England, what would occur would be something like this:

--That all first marriages would be in the context of the Eucharist

--That there would be no divorced and remarried clergy at all

That where second marriages were performed in church they would not use the same service as that used for first marriages and that those in such marriages would be under discipline (restricted in holding church office and from the Lord’s table) for a stated period, say a year. Penance after forgiveness being in place.

That where a couple has been married according to the minimum laws of the State and in a ceremony that is entirely secular, that where there is a divorce and afterwards one of the parties is converted, baptized and made a church member then she or he may perhaps be allowed to marry in church as if there had been no previous marriage (in this case there would have to be most careful counseling and care for any children etc etc). And that also in extreme circumstances such a person could also become a candidate for the diaconate.

[See further John Meyendorff, Marriage an Orthodox Perspective, St Vladimir’s Seminary Press]

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),

Friday, September 26, 2003

Primates & Saints, October 15,16 & 17

According to the Calendar of the Church of England, the commemorations on the days of the Primates’ Conference in London are as follows:

October 15 Teresa of Avila

October 16 Nicolas Ridley and Hugh Latimer

October 17 Ignatius of Antioch

The classic Anglican style of Collect does not ask for the intercession of the saint/martyr but rather looks to virtues of the saint as examples to follow.

Teresa of Avila (1515-1582), Spanish Carmelite Nun and mystic is the teacher of the Path of Contemplative Prayer, the Way of Holiness, Sanctification and Perfection. By her example and teaching, the Primates are taught that “those who wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength”, that true ecstasy is in union with the Holy Trinity, that “without holiness no one shall see the Lord” and that “the will of God is your sanctification.”

Unless the Primates, led by Archbishop Rowan, are deep in meditative prayer & consecrated and sanctified to the service of the Gospel and to the Way of the Lord Jesus, their deliberations and decisions will be worth nothing in terms of the kingdom of God – however much interest Episcopalians show in them.

Ridley (1500-1555) and Latimer (1485-1555), burnt at the sake in Oxford on October 16, are examples of pastors and preachers who fearlessly proclaimed that salvation is wholly by the grace of God and is received by faith – a faith that is faithful and is expressed in love. Their reformed Catholic zeal and devotion and opposition to medieval errors present to the Primates the example of total dedication to the will of the Lord, whatever the cost, including being burnt at the sake.

Unless the Primates, led by Archbishop Rowan, are wholly dedicated to the Gospel and to the purity of life for which the Gospel calls, then their deliberations and decisions will be worth nothing in terms of the kingdom of God – however much interest the media shows in them.

Ignatius of Antioch (d.107) as the Bishop of Antioch presents to us an example of total dedication to his Lord, to the young Church of the Lord in Turkey & Rome, and to the privilege of martyrdom for the Lord in the Coliseum. Here is a saint of God whose passionate desire is to be with his Lord, even if by the powerful teeth and hunger of ravenous animals in Rome, and yet who cares for the flock of God at the same time.

Unless the Primates, led by Archbishop Rowan, are more concerned about the honor and name of the Lord Jesus, and of heaven as the true home of the faithful baptized, than they are about earth and human reputation, then their evaluation of the ECUSA & human sexuality on earth for disciples of Jesus will not be that which is held & approved in heaven!

“O Gracious Father, we humbly beseech thee for thy holy Catholic Church and particular for that jurisdiction of the same known as the Anglican Communion; that thou wouldest be pleased to fill it with all truth, in all peace. Where it is corrupt, purify it; where it is in error, direct it; where in any thing it is amiss, reform it. Where it is right, establish it; where it is in want, provide for it; where it is divided, reunite it. When its Primates meet on October 15-17 in London bless, direct and unite them in thy love, for the sake of him who died and rose again, and ever liveth to make intercession for us, Jesus Christ, thy Son our Lord. Amen.”


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Thursday, September 25, 2003

1976 - a watershed

In the September/October issue of the Mandate (on line at www.episcopalian.org/pbs1928 or obtain a copy from 1-800-PBS-1928) my editorial is on 1976 -- and the fact that the corporate memory of the ECUSA in Convention only seems to go back effectively to that date, and thus the vote & wisdom of the saints of God over the centuries is not counted when changes/innovations are introduced. A reader sent this Letter below, which contains something that he sees, and I see, as giving general support & larger context to what I argue in this Editorial. Further it makes us hesitant to receive anything that the ECUSA has given us since the 1970s - including of course not only gay blessings but also the Prayer Book and the Liturgies that have followed it.


Your reflections on 1976 were fascinating in the latest issue of Mandate.

Thank you! I humbly submit one more from "Against the World for the World, the Hartford Appeal and the Future of American Religion", by Peter Berger and Richard John Neuhaus, editors, Seabury Press 1976, ISBN: 0-8164-2121-8:

In 1975, eighteen prominent Christian thinkers issued "The Hartford Appeal for Theological Affirmation", a document which identified 13 "pervasive, false, and debilitating" themes in contemporary Christian thought...and called for a religious renewal in America.

The 8 writers are: Peter Berger, George Lindbeck, Avery Dulles, George Forell, Carl Peter, Richard Mouw, Alexander Schmemann, and Richard John Neuhaus.

Their 13 themes representing the final capitulation by the Church to modern thought are:

1. Modern thought is superior to all past forms of understanding reality, and is therefore normative for Christian faith and life
2. Religious statements are totally independent of reasonable discourse
3. Religious language refers to human experience and nothing else, God being humanity's noblest creation.
4. Jesus can only be understood in terms of contemporary models of humanity.
5. All religions are equally valid; the choice among them is not a matter of conviction about truth but only of personal preference or life style.
6. To realize one's potential and to be true to oneself is the whole meaning of life.
7. Since what is human is good, evil can adequately be understood as failure to realize potential.
8. The sole purpose of worship is to promote individual self-realization and human community.
9. Institutions and historical traditions are oppressive and inimical to our being truly human; liberation from them is required for authentic existence and authentic religion.
10. The world must set the agenda for the Church. Social, political, and economic programs to improve the quality of life are ultimately normative for the Church's mission in the world.
11. An emphasis on God's transcendence is at least a hindrance to, and perhaps incompatible with, Christian social concern and action.
12. The struggle for a better humanity will bring about the Kingdom of God.
13. The question of hope beyond death is irrelevant or at best marginal to the Christian understanding of human fulfillment.


The 18 signers of that Appeal were: Peter L. Berger, Elizabeth Ann Bettenhausen, William Sloan Coffin, Avery Dulles, Neal Fisher, George Forell, James N. Gettemy, Stanley Hauerwas, Thomas Hopko, George Lindbeck, Illeana Marculescu, Ralph McInerny, E. Kilmer Myers, Richard J. Mouw, Richard John Neuhaus, Randolph W. Nugent, Carl J. Peter, Alexander Schmemann, Gerard Sloyan, Lewis B. Smedes, George H. Tavard, Bruce Vawter, John D. Weaver, and Robert Wilken.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Wednesday, September 24, 2003

Archbishop Akinola attacks Archbishop Ndungane over "Gay Remarks"

ACNS 3591 | NIGERIA | 23 SEPTEMBER 2003

[ACNS source: All Africa News Agency] The Archbishop of the Church of Nigeria, the Most Revd Peter J. Akinola, has written a strong-worded letter to his southern Africa counterpart, Archbishop Winston Njongonkulu Ndungane of Cape Town, expressing deep criticism over the stand taken by Archbishop Ndungane on the controversial issue of gay ordination within the Anglican Church.

Responding to Archbishop Ndungane's recent sentiments published in a leading British newspaper, Archbishop Akinola has launched a scathing attack on his fellow churchman, telling him, "you got it all wrong".

Archbishop Ndungane had indicated in an interview that African clergymen, including Archbishop Akinola, who were expressing opposition to gay ordination were arrogant, intolerant and hypocritical.

Below is the full text of Archbishop Akinola's letter, released yesterday:


A MESSAGE TO ARCHBISHOP NDUNGANE

"My attention has just been drawn to a publication by a religious affairs correspondent in a British daily criticising the stand of a majority of Global South Primates and several other bishops around the world over the current departures arising from the ongoing controversies surrounding unscriptural revisionist innovations on human sexuality.

Your criticism is based on some unfortunate presuppositions. And coming at this time, it appears like an attempt to cause a possible diversion of focus amongst African and Global South Church leaders. But thank God these leaders have come of age, they are no longer to be pulled by the nose nor taken for granted. We are poised, using every gift of God available to us to defend orthodoxy, the integrity of the Church, and banish the erroneous teachings you plan to impose on us.

The criticism

1. How correct are you dear brother Archbishop Ndungane in judging the cloud of witnesses to biblical truth through the ages whose stand on biblical ethics is only being upheld by those of us who are now branded as arrogant and intolerant? Is there anything in our pronouncements that constitutes a departure from the standard of morality held out in the Bible?

Isn't it a paradox that the Archbishop of Southern Africa sees no arrogance in those whose flagrant disregard of the stand of the entire Anglican Communion has plunged us into this sad and avoidable controversy. They have refused to ensure strict compliance with resolutions duly passed at the Bishops' Lambeth Conference and the Primates' Meetings. To you that is alright. Should there not be a protest against such disrespect? When has the poor (as we in the Global South are often called) begun to be proud over and against the rich (the affluent West)?

2. How can you forget so soon the alert we sounded at the Anglican Consultative Council (ACC) in Hong Kong barely a year ago? It is worth repeating here:

"While I appreciate that the New Westminster diocese and the Church of Canada may not be, in numerical terms, especially large ecclesia bodies, we value them as dearly as we value all our partner Provinces. We have a growing fear for the sense of loss which sustained departure by them from our common path and mind must risk. We urge and pray that reflection will lead to reconsideration. It is hard indeed to see any action, which threatens our Communion to be justified as a 'local mission priority'"

3. Brother Ndungane, you got it all wrong. What you cited as top priorities are in this context clearly misplaced. I ask, are the issues of peace, hunger, sharia, and HIV/AIDS, serious and prevalent, as they are, more important to the Church than faithfulness to the plain truth of Scripture? We remind you dear brother of our Lord's response to a similar situation two thousand years ago as recorded in Luke 13:1-5.(Please take time to read it over and over again). His response was that, tragic as those situations were, the more important priority was repentance. He actually said, "Unless you repent, you too will all perish" It didn't mean that Christ was not compassionate. If anything He demonstrated compassion daily in His miracles and teachings. We are following His footsteps by doing all we can for those caught in these painful conditions as part of our holistic approach to ministry.

We place a high priority on caring. For sure, the Archbishop has not forgotten that 'man shall not live by bread alone but by every word that proceeds from God' (Dt. 8:3; Matt. 4:4; Lk. 4:4). Peace, hunger, sharia and HIV/AIDS are indeed major life and death issues, albeit, they are at the physical level. Unfaithfulness to Scripture is a more major life and death issue because it is spiritual. What shall it profit a man to feed well and live long here on earth only to lose his soul in hell? What then is the Church here for ?

4. On the question of integrity of ECUSA's decision, again we ask, can one eat his cake and still have it in his hands? And can two walk together unless they be agreed? (Amos 3:3). If the integrity of a part is so important, what will be said of the whole? And it must be said that this is not a matter of 'unity in diversity' for according to the rule: in the essentials, unity; in the non-essentials, freedom; in all things charity, the issue at stake falls within the orbit of the essentials and thus any deviation means alienation.

One suspects in your unguarded and scathing criticism a resurgence of a hitherto latent feeling of hurt since the Lambeth Conference Committee on human sexuality you chaired was overwhelmingly overruled by the so-called hard-liners who are not willing to compromise the precious heritage of scriptural truth.

5. The accusation of hypocrisy does not recognise the inherent difference between what the Church openly and officially sanctions and what it does not but exists. In the former, the Church stands responsible while in the latter, the burden of blame and guilt remains the private responsibility of those concerned with the accompanying room for repentance and forgiveness. This accusation carries with it an uncomfortable insinuation of double standards on the part of those opposed to homosexuality in the Church. However, it still does not square up as two wrongs do not add up to a right.

6. The unwarranted accusation that Africans do not know much about their sexuality portends a talking-down of Africans-a gnostic tendency that is capable of weakening the resolve of the African church leaders to be God's prophets in times like this. The biblical prophets resisted it and so must their contemporary counterparts.

I ask you dear brother to face issues and not fall into the temptation of "casting stones". Apparently you do not know everything I have said and done on every issue concerning Nigeria. That you have not heard any fuss from me in the foreign media about certain issues does not mean the Church which by the grace of God I lead is doing nothing. For instance, I deliberately included Zamfara State in the itinerary of the immediate past Archbishop of Canterbury to Nigeria and called the world's attention to the infringement on fundamental human rights that the imposition of the Islamic penal code portended for freedom-loving peoples. The Church in Nigeria has borne the most brunt of this unwarranted imposition. If you care to know, I urge you to refer to the volumes of published findings by Christian Solidarity Worldwide following their repeated visits to Nigeria, including my Office.

Conclusion

May I say as I conclude that your comments reveal a palpable failure to grasp the nature of the issues at stake. Your criticism is so burdened with such sad and most unfortunate presuppositions that see our stand from the point of arrogance and intolerance rather than a strong will to defend the 'faith that was once delivered to the saints.' When you accuse us of arrogance and intolerance, be courageous enough to direct the searchlight at yourself and those for whom you spoke.

What is at stake has to do not just with the identity of the Church universal and our historic faith but also how we treat God and his incarnate and written Word. Yes, we are a worldwide communion, but our church is only a part of the holy, catholic and apostolic Church. Where the autonomy of any part of our communion becomes a scandal in the entire Christian world, then we must be humble enough to accept rebuke and correction. There is still room for repentance. Amen."

The Most Revd Peter J Akinola
Archbishop, Metropolitan and Primate
The Church of Nigeria, Anglican Communion.