Wednesday, September 24, 2003

Strict Canon Law ON MARRIAGE does not mean JUSTICE WITHOUT MERCY

(a discussion paper, following on from others on the relation of the divorce culture to the demands by "gay" persons for full recognition of their rights)

If the "antinomianism" of the present ECUSA marriage and "gay" policies is abandoned, there is no need to go into a form of legalism. However, there will need to be a major change in ECUSA canon law in order for there to be any real change in practice at the parish level. Caring and enlightened Bishops can do much by teaching and leadership to bring in the necessary changes that justice requires and that mercy should accompany.

THUS

Canon Law of a Church which is written in the light of the teaching of Jesus and his apostles will be "strict" in regard to ministers of the Church officiating at second marriages when a previous spouse is still alive.

Such Canon Law must regard divorce - for whatever reasons - as a breaking of that which is intended & commanded to be for life ("That which God hath joined together, let no man put asunder.")

Such Canon Law must regard the remarriage of a divorcee (except in rare circumstances) as contrary to the will of the Lord Jesus and thus not to be undertaken in church as if it were, or could be, wholly in accord with divine Order for Creation and the Church.

Canon Law has always made provision for separation of a man and wife where there is just cause for this separation - e.g., constant cruelty being shown, adultery etc.

Canon Law stands always for chastity in sexual relations.

Canon Law cannot prevent a baptized person (or anyone else) seeking divorce in the secular courts; but will itself continue to regard the first marriage as the one made in the Name and with the blessing of God, the Holy Trinity.

Canon Law (Anglican style) has always recognized the where a couple (a bachelor & a spinster) has been married according to the law of the state where they live then that is in God's sight a real marriage. Thus, if there is a divorce, and then one of the divorcees is converted to Jesus Christ, this conversion does not change the fact that this person is still a divorced person -- in this case a Christian who has been divorced. Thus this person has no automatic right to being re-married in church to another person as if he were marrying for the first time. (Open the door here and it will be soon opened very wide by all kinds of appeals for special cases!)

Any new expression of the ECUSA (e.g., dioceses supported by Primates abroad?) ought to revert to the Canon Law on marriage as it was previous to the 1960s and at the same time generously declare that all previous marriages conducted in the ECUSA in recent decades using the official service in the 79 prayer book shall stand as valid (even if by the new standards for post 2003 they ought not have taken place in church).

Giving of an Annulment by a Bishop should be avoided for it is open to grave scandal and to misuse (as in the Continuing Church movement now). Annulments should come if at all from the secular courts.

THIS SAID.. ALSO

The Church ought to be deeply involved in the care of persons affected by modern marital breakdown and separation, showing pity and mercy and offering help. But this help does not mean counseling that is based on modern ideas of rights, autonomy and self-realization/ self-fulfillment; rather, it means counseling to help to bring one's life under the sovereign grace of God and in receipt of that grace and mercy.

If a divorced person decides to remarry, that should take place at an office of the State and according to the laws of the State. It will then be open for the local church to offer, if asked, a service of prayer and dedication in which God will be asked to forgive what is past and graciously to help in the present and for the future. The admittance of such persons to the Lord's Table or to lay offices in the church should not be automatic but dependent upon pastoral judgment by the bishop.

BUT no clergyperson (deacon, presbyter or bishop) who is divorced ought in the new Order to remain in official ordained ministry if he/she remarries and has a previous spouse alive.

AND no person actively engaged in a homosexual partnership, long term or short term, ought to be ordained or remain in ministry if ordained in the new Order, unless there is a full repentance and change of life.

THE CHURCH CANNOT CHANGE THE WORLD IN TERMS OF THE NATURE AND MEANING OF MARRIAGE; BUT IT CAN CHANGE ITSELF AND REFLECT MUCH MORE THAN IT NOW DOES THE MIND AND WILL OF THE LORD JESUS FOR HOLY MATRIMONY AND SEXUAL RELATIONS. IN PARTICULAR IT CAN SEEK TO REVIVE TRUE CHASTITY.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

TRINITY XV, fervent prayer for ECUSA

Adelphoi,

The set prayer within the classic Book of Common Prayer(1662/1928) for the week of 28th September surely is a prayer for all who care for the ECUSA to use.

The Fifteenth Sunday after Trinity

"Keep, we beseech thee, O Lord, thy Church with thy perpetual mercy; and, because the frailty of man without thee cannot but fall, keep us every by thy help from all things hurtful, and lead us to all things profitable to our salvation; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen."

The Epistle: Galatians 6:11-18 The Gospel: St Matthew 6:24-34

This is a perfect Prayer to pray daily not only in the week of Trinity XV but right through to - and beyond - the Primates' Meeting in London, October 15-17.

Let us notice here in the first petition a strange, interesting and relevant fact. God the Father is implored to keep his Church (for which his Son shed his precious blood) not with his Fatherly Care, not with his Watchful Providence and not with the guardianship of his holy Archangels and angels [all of which he actually does], but with his Perpetual Mercy.

Perpetual Mercy -- If man (we, all of us) is to be saved and secured from major spiritual and moral injuries with which Satan, the world (zeitgeist) and the flesh threaten him, it can only be by the continual & perpetual exercise of the Father's mercy in the name, for the sake of his Beloved Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, in and by the Holy Ghost, the Counselor & Comforter. From that heavenly mercy proceed abundant blessings of many and varied kinds, descending upon those who seek the Lord and find him.

Certainly, being a member of the ECUSA at this time seems to bring an extra deluge of temptations, testings, problems and heart-aches for pilgrims who would walk on the narrow way that leads to life. We need mercy not only on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, but each and every day - and night! Perpetual and nothing less than continuing and continual! "Every hour I need thee!" The Bishops who call themselves orthodox especially need this Mercy so that they can be truly orthodox in worship, doctrine, and discipline and be true Shepherds.

Let us also recognize, as does the Collect, that considered as moral and spiritual beings who stand before God, the all-holy, the all- seeing and the all- knowing One, we are not only mortal but also frail, weak and sinful. We possess the ancient disease of inbred, original sin and because of it we cannot, in and of ourselves, truly help ourselves into the way and enjoyment of God's salvation. We have to be lifted by grace-filled hands into the Ark of Salvation. (This Collect stands as a defiant statement against Pelagianism, a doctrine loved and favored within the present ECUSA.)

To state this truth of original sin - so clear in the Bible and in the content of the classic editions of The Book of Common Prayer - and to confess it and its implications before God is wholly to depart from the mindset and spirituality of the present ECUSA, where man is hardly the guilty sinner upon whom the wrath of God falls. Rather he/she is usually the autonomous being engaged in self-fulfillment and asking God to accompany her/him on this journey!

Thus we pray again in this Prayer for help, the presence of the Holy Ghost indwelling our souls so that he elevates our affections, inspires our thinking and energizes our wills in order to guide us away from that which will harm us and towards that which will protect and bless us. Many things that exist will harm us, even things which in and of themselves may be good, but for you or for me they are the frequent cause of temptation and sin. Happily, there are many things in God's creation, and especially in the provisions of the new covenant/creation, that are for the cleansing, renewing, inspiring and saving of our souls and bodies.

Within the present life of the ECUSA in its "National Church" organization, its dioceses and parishes, there are many things that are hurtful in the sense that they have the potential to be the means of causing persons/souls to abandon the Faith and their Lord and to become apostate. Also, thanks be to God, there are - though in short supply - means of grace available (in persons and sacraments) to those who seek, knock and look for the healing and salvation of their souls.

This Prayer and all such fervent, effectual prayer is offered to the Father through the One Mediator, the Son, and with the Holy Ghost by the people of God, who know that the only merits that heaven knows are those of the Lord Jesus Christ.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Monday, September 22, 2003

Jensen & Toon, Travers & Hooker

The Dean of the Cathedral in Sydney, Phillip Jensen, has succinctly, passionately and carefully responded to my little tract on “Primates & Guarding the Faith” which was circulated by the Rev’d Fr. Dick Kim. He and his brother, the Archbishop of Sydney, are most capable and earnest men and I admire both of them. We disagree over the relation of the Scriptures to holy tradition and over the place and use of the Scriptures in the Anglican Way as a jurisdiction within the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church of God.

In his response he takes up a position which may be described as the twenty-first century equivalent of that of the “puritans” in the Church of England in the sixteenth and seventeenth century. In fact, if he and I were to debate it would be (yet without the great learning) in content like the famous debates between the Puritan/Presbyterian W. Travers and the Anglican divine, Richard Hooker.

Hooker’s Law of Ecclesiastical Polity is as it were my answer to the position taken by Dr Jensen, his brother (the Archbishop of Sydney), and others in the archdiocese of Sydney concerning the authority and use of Scripture in the Church.

Jensen wishes to set aside the position of the Church of England as it is defended by Bishop Jewel in his Apology and then by Hooker in his Polity and given clear expression in the Formularies of 1662 (BCP, Ordinal & Articles) and to seek to stand solely on what may be most clearly proved from the Scriptures by modern conservative exegesis, as well as by the exegesis of certain reformers of the 16th century.

Lay Celebrancy, favored and defended in Sydney, is wholly against the Order that the Church, which collected and approved the Canon of Scripture in the early centuries, actually believed was the will of God and required by Scripture. And the traditional Church of England position stated in the Elizabethan period with great clarity is – ONE Canon of Scripture, with TWO Testaments, whose content is summarized in THREE Creeds, and whose doctrine as dogma is set forth in FOUR Ecumenical Councils, and whose intent and provisions are seen in FIVE Centuries of developing evangelization, worship, doctrine, discipline and order. On this basis one accepts the Threefold Ministry as God’s Order in the church and as consonant with Scripture, but one does not have to believe in it to be saved by grace.

(The lecture that I gave in the University of Sydney against Lay Presidency I still have as a file and may be able it to send to any who wish to read it.)

Following response is from the Dean of Sydney, Phillip Jensen – to Dr Toon’s paper on the Primates as Guardians of the Faith as that is received in the Anglican Way

Dear Dick

I am happy that this be known to be written by me as the Dean of Sydney seeing that Peter has specified the diocese of Sydney as one that needs to be disciplined.

Peter's requirement that the Primates make statements consonant with scripture is a minimalist position. Rather we should require that they make statements which are the teaching of Scripture. However like all minimalist positions Peter's position is used to legalistically add to scripture – for it will be said that though scripture does not speak on an issue if it did it would say and therefore people should be excluded who do not agree.

Take the three issues that Peter wants clear immediate statements from the Primates on. The first sexual purity is clearly taught in scripture. The second lay administration of the Lord's supper is nowhere discussed in Scripture. The third the ordination of Women is not itself in scripture, as ordination is not explicitly in scripture, though the issue of women in authority is explicitly in scripture.

By introducing the two issues that are not explicitly addressed in scripture into the same category of discussion as the immorality that would exclude someone from the kingdom of God, Peter is confusing the issues, dividing the mainstream, and giving opportunity to the Primates to throw dust and confusion into the air.

Worse still than the bad politics and pragmatic considerations of his call, he is in error for he wishes to exclude God's people from fellowship because of a view of ordination that cannot be sustained from Scripture. Unless our fellowship is something more precious than salvation in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, Peter's call is contrary to Article 6 and is in danger of following the example of Diotrephes.

Because of scriptures' teaching I am opposed to sexual immorality in the laity let alone in the clergy. Because of Scriptures' teaching I am opposed to women exercising the same authority and teaching roles as men in the church and therefore in our heritage of ordaining them to the priesthood as the chief teaching ministry of the church. Please notice the difference in logic between these two positions.

But then try to think where the Bible teaches the ordination to a priesthood that has the sole authority to administer the Lord's Supper. It is not only totally absent from the teaching of Scripture but is against the tenor of the unique mediatorial work of the Lord Jesus Christ and the consequential priesthood of all believers.

Please understand the importance of Peter's call - for to exclude the archdiocese of Sydney will end my participation in a circle of friends such as this - is that what you want? You cannot call for our exclusion and remain in fellowship with us. That you wish to exclude unrepentant adulterers and the sexually immoral is one thing (they are excluded from the kingdom of God), but do you want to place those of us who are earnestly seeking to apply God's word to our church life in the same category of sinfulness? How quickly will godly discipline turn into human tyranny.

Phillip



The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),

Sexuality, God and Church

Adelphoi,

In response to requests for clarity... and in your kindness... Issues of God and sexuality are often very emotive and we think via our emotions...

I wish to make it clear that I have NEVER attacked divorced & remarried persons as such, only the church's allowance of second & third marriages (when first spouse is alive). And I have not attacked homosexual persons or called them by rude names. I have some relatives who are divorced and remarried and not a few friends who are such and as far as I know I treat them all the same way. What I write against is an apostate Church/bishops and their leading the sheep astray both in sexual matters and in others things and thus they lead them not into the kingdom of heaven but into the kingdom of darkness.

Here is what I have said in summary:

1.There is a large divorce culture both within American society and within the membership of the ECUSA. A large proportion of members and also priests/bishops is divorced and remarried.

2.The presence of this culture - with its dominant justification in terms of personal rights and individual autonomy & happiness - paved the way and set the scene for the carefully planned and executed call of the LesBiGay Lobby to gain a major hearing within the ECUSA. "If you have granted rights to the divorced against Scripture then you must also grant us rights even if you think they are against Scripture."

3.If one is to follow biblical ethics and plain common sense it is obvious that to oppose the "Gay" successes without also dealing with the root cause of them (and other things) - which is the abandonment of good Order - is neither to be just nor realistic.

4.To oppose the right of heterosexual persons to be married more than once in the church as well as to oppose the right of "gay" persons to be blessed in their partnerships is NOT to attack individual persons or couples it is to attack the false authority taken by the ECUSA to allow such things.

5.The real problem is not, therefore, the desires of people to seek their happiness in whatever ways the media and their friends and their (sinful) hearts suggest; but it is the Episcopate (and the General Convention) of the ECUSA, which has since the 1950s and especially since the 1970s forsaken the Lord and his righteous paths.

6.Thus the gay issue must not be prioritized in such a way that the impression is given that if the (reformed parts of) ECUSA gets rid of Gene Robinson as a bishop and gets some resolutions against gay blessings in the books then all shall be well.

7.The disease, the problem, the error & the apostasy would very much remain at the center and with each Bishop; THUS there must be a major U-turn back to the Bible, the Creeds, the Formularies, the Canon Law as it was before the 1970s, and to right Order. Only in this context can "gay" and divorce issues be addressed rightly with a sound mind.

8.What do to about all those in second and third marriages who have been blessed by the ECUSA? Make a clear statement and write in clearly into church law that ALL marriages solemnized and blessed until a specific date shall be treated as true marriages (because any error was primarily & basically on the part of the Church not on the part of those being married); and that from this date certain new rules shall apply to marriage in church and these shall be graciously, pastorally and yet firmly adhered to. The BCP (1662/1928) service of matrimony shall serve as the basic formulary for marriage and appropriate counseling should be put in place immediately.

9.The Primates' Meeting in October 2003 will fall very far short of its duty if it merely and only addresses "gay" issues for the reason that this would be like dealing with one child with food poisoning and not working out where the poison came into the food chain - at factory, distributor, supermarket or kitchen! The "gay" issue & the divorce/remarriage issue and the cohabitation issue are all parts of a manifestation of rebellion against God 's good Order for creation and the Church, and we need a call back to & a return unto that good Order.

10. The Church of England & its Episcopate are heading on the same direction (down into the valley of darkness) as the ECUSA has headed, but with a different kind of routing down the slope! In Britain a lot goes on behind closed doors [under trees in a thick wood as it were) and so one only finds out when it is out in the open!

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

The Prioritization of the homosexual issue

It is well known in conservative ECUSA circles that I have tried in the last month to make the homosexual issue surrounding Gene Robinson into a much larger issue of sexual ethics, and then to set this in the context of the major changes - of worship, doctrine, discipline & Order -- that have occurred in the ECUSA since the 1960s.

I have suggested that when the matter of gay sex is treated in and of itself then it runs the danger of being basically a cultural matter - whether in the USA or Africa.

Someone who has been reading my tracts and considerations wrote:

'The prioritization of the homosexual issue is not primarily doctrinal. The issue is most certainly very serious and must be addressed. Nevertheless, addressing homosexuality without first addressing the matters of authority and order is a waste of time, a mere Band-Aid on a system that will devour itself in the end. The real power driving the prioritization of dealing with the homosexualists is a middle-class sensibility, draped in religious trappings. The frequent surfacing of the terms "pervert" and "unnatural," while justified in some regards, still does not get to the heart of the matter--poor souls dying because of their disobedience to God's Word Written. But if the matter were put in these terms, then the liar, the thief, the multiply married, the ordainers and imposers of women ministers would have to look to their own souls, and being middle-class they do not wish to do so. The first and greatest middle-class doctrine is this: "We are, all in all, pretty good fellows".'

There is much worth taking to heart in this straight talk, which will be offensive, I know, to some.

Consider that in the USA -- where in living memory it once was embarrassing in public to be known as divorced - that being divorced and remarried once or twice is perfectly respectable in 90 per cent of the country and churches. Consider also that couples living together without being married is also respectable whereas 50 years ago it was deeply frowned upon and actively opposed. (Much the same of course in Great Britain and the western world.)

But there is a proportion especially of the middle classes that focuses upon homosexual practices as being special if not unique aberrations and offences against good taste. And they do so while regarding divorce and remarriage and co-habitation as normal.

Now in the Bible there is no doubt but that homosexual practice is a sin, but when it is stated as a sin, it does not appear as one sin set apart from other sins. Take a look at 1 Corinthians 6:9 (RSV):

"Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived; neither the immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor robbers, will inherit the kingdom of God."

How many candidates for bishop does this word from heaven exclude and ought to have excluded in the recent past? How many ordinands? How many S.S teachers? How many of us?

When we point at homosexual sin (ners) alone and do not see its presence (them) as part of a much larger and sinister reality of evil in practice then we are unlikely to be repentant and to look into our own souls in self-examination by the light of the Word of God. We are being religiously middle-class and self-sufficient.

I am NOT saying that the election of Canon Robinson was right or good. It was right to oppose it! What I am saying is that by the rule of the Word of God, read & understood in its common sense meaning all of us need to be careful in pointing the finger towards Gene R and the Lesbigay Lobby when the rest of the hand points back to ourselves and to our sins of equal seriousness to that of homosexual acts.

If the Primates on October 15-17 focus ONLY on this matter of homosexual sin and do not set it in a much larger context of severe failures by all of us in biblical family order/ethics and ecclesial order/ ethics then they willbe letting down the Anglican Communion in a disastrous way.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

The Inter-Anglican Theological and Doctrinal Commission

ACNS 3585 | COMMUNIQUÉ | 19 SEPTEMBER 2003

The Commission, now two-years into its study of the meaning and maintenance of 'Communion', met under the Chairmanship of the Rt Revd Professor S W Sykes from 4 - 9 September as guests of Virginia Theological Seminary. The work of the Commission is being pursued as an active conversation with member churches of the Anglican Communion, a process which was approved at the Anglican Consultative Council meeting in Hong Kong in 2002. Several hundred dioceses and theological centres, a number of parishes and individuals have participated in this dialogue by responding to the Four Key Questions and Six Propositions on ways in which Anglicans understand and experience koinonia.

Whenever the Commission has gathered it has been vividly aware of the need for the sort of trust and solidarity which Communion anticipates. The initial meeting of the Commission was disrupted by terrorist attacks on New York and Washington, and the next overshadowed by the mounting rhetoric which preceded the invasion of Iraq. On this occasion members were acutely conscious of the controversy surrounding the election of a non-abstinent homosexual priest as the next Bishop of New Hampshire. The circumstances of our meetings have demonstrated how urgent it is, within the church as much as throughout the wider human community, to encourage good argument on disputed matters so as to nurture the unity promised by the gospel in an increasingly polarised global context.

We have been made aware by our correspondents of the variety of threats to koinonia which they face, and also the high value which is placed on membership of a worldwide Communion of Anglican Churches, especially in situations where Christian discipleship can be a lonely, challenging and dangerous calling. The response which the Commission is making seeks to learn from that evidence. It is developing an argument which tries to discern how God addresses his creation and how his people receive and respond to his word; it is taking seriously the way the Gospel addresses theological and ethical disputes; and, in a world so challenged by global and local tensions, it is asking how recent developments in Anglican polity may impact on its developing understanding of Communion.

During its meeting the Commission also gave the document To Mend the Net further consideration, it discussed the papal encyclical, On the Eucharist and the Church, and began to explore ways in which theological education resources might be shared throughout the Communion, perhaps in concert with the Theological Education Initiative being commissioned by the Primates Meeting. The next phase of the Commission's work will be to integrate the three lines of its discussion - continuing reflection on the responses to the Six Propositions which have been received, developing a response to the document To Mend the Net, and working on the processes by which the Communion can sustain its life. Together it is hoped these will lead into the development of a dynamic description of how our life as a Communion can be carried forward.

The generous hospitality and resources of the Virginia Theological Seminary were again greatly appreciated by the Commission, which next year expects to meet in Kenya.

The Commission will report its proceedings as usual to the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Primates, and the Anglican Consultative Council. Compilations of replies received to the Six Propositions and other information about the study process will be posted to http://www.anglicancommunion.org/ecumenical/iatdc/index.html in the next few
days.

Stephen Sykes
Chairman


Enquiries on the work of the Commission may be addressed to:

Gregory Cameron
Secretary
Anglican Communion Office
Partnership House
157 Waterloo Road
London SE1 8UT
England
gregory.cameron@anglicancommunion.org

Philip Thomas
Assistant to the Chair
The Vicarage
Heighington
Co Durham
DL5 6PP
England
philip.thomas@durham.anglican.org


The members of the Commission are:

The Rt Revd Professor Stephen W Sykes (Chair)
The Revd Dr Philip H E Thomas (Assistant to the Chair)
The Revd Canon Gregory Cameron (Secretary)
The Revd Professor Kortright Davis
The Rt Revd J Mark Dyer
The Rt Revd Tan Sri Dr Lim Cheng Ean
The Revd Dr Katherine Grieb (Observer)
Dr Esther M Mombo
The Revd Canon Luke Pato
The Revd Dr Stephen Pickard
Dr Jenny Te Paa
The Rt Revd Paul Richardson
The Revd Dr Nicholas Sagovsky
Dr Eileen Scully
The Rt Revd Dr N Thomas Wright
The Very Revd Paul F M Zahl
The Rt Revd Tito Zavala

Not present on this occasion were:

The Revd Victor R Atta-Baffoe
The Rt Revd Dr Samuel R Cutting
The Revd Dr Bruce N Kaye
The Rt Revd Dr Matthew Oluremi Owadayo

Administrative staff:

Mrs Christine Codner
The Revd Terrie Robinson

Thursday, September 18, 2003

The CRISIS ZONE

a meditation to assist other meditations

It has become commonplace, since the close of the General Convention of the Episcopal Church of the USA in August 2003, to refer to the ECUSA and the Anglican Communion as being in crisis. However, the truth of the matter is that an already existing crisis in the Anglican Family has now been extended and deepened, with intense emotions being released at the present time.

In words written in 1990, Gillian Evans, a well-known Cambridge scholar & writer, offered this [correct] judgment: "But above all, it [the ordination of women as bishops] makes the Anglican Church not a single Communion seeking unity with others [e.g., Lutherans & Orthodox], but itself a crisis zone, in which the desire for unity struggles to hold together what structural anomalies pull apart. That must be frankly confessed." (Authority in the Church, p.80)

Let us frankly confess this truth with Ms Evans.

But what are the "structural anomalies"? They are two aspects of order in conflict - that which places the emphasis upon the local diocese/province as calling and appointing Ministers & that which sees Ministry as belonging to the universal Church and thus only authentic if acceptable to the whole Church. The Anglican Family of Churches has been experiencing for over a decade what is called "impaired communion" because what has been decided upon and done locally when a woman has been ordained has neither been accepted by the whole Anglican Family nor by major ecumenical partners.

The Anglican Communion [Family] of Churches became a crisis zone when local wishes were preferred to universal order, especially and directly so when the first women were consecrated. And that crisis zone becomes larger year by year as more women are ordained, and especially as more women are consecrated.

The crisis began because what had been previously been believed, taught and confessed as belonging to ordination was brought into question, doubted, and set aside. Ordination to the presbyterate [priesthood] or to the episcopate may be said to contain three elements - the gift of the Holy Spirit to the candidate from the Lord Christ for the office; the acceptance by the parish/diocese of the candidate; and the being placed in the universal order of the Church by the act of the laying on of hands by the bishop (s). In the case of women candidates none of these elements is either clear or sure for there are large parts of the visible Church that do not accept that the Spirit is given to women for priestly ministry, that oppose the ordination of women and that state that they are not placed in the universal order. (It may be recalled that the Anglican doctrine of reception was invented in 1988 in order to seek to deal with this real problem on the basis of charitable assumptions, testing and discernment and to maintain as high a level of impaired communion as is possible in the Anglican Family of Churches.)

It is generally accepted that at the very least UNITY, and the Episcopate as the sign of that unity, belong to the bene esse (and more likely the plene esse or even the esse) of the Church. In the Anglican Family the unity of the dioceses and of the Church has been seen as centered upon and in the Bishop on what may be described as three planes. In the diocese he is the chief Pastor, Teacher and Celebrant, and he shares these offices with his presbyters; he unites his diocese with other dioceses in province and worldwide by his sharing in the universal Episcopate; and he unites the church of today with the church of yesterday through his belonging to a historical line of Bishops, through time and across space. Now it is clear that a woman cannot fulfill these three relational aspects of the Episcopate simply because she is not accepted by all in her diocese, all in her province and all in the universal Church. The esse of the Church is shattered by the innovation of the ordination of women and especially by the consecration of women and so we talk of "impaired communion" as a nice way of handling it.

One major reason (not often realized) why the innovation of "gay" unions and ordinations is felt so intensely now is because within the Anglican Family of Churches it entered into an already existing crisis-zone, a zone which the leadership has attempted to avoid, play down and minimize. Whether the latest addition to the crisis can be permanently solved without solving the former is a major question.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Wednesday, September 17, 2003

RESTORE US, O God, Let thy FACE shine

In the appointed Psalms for Sept 16 in the classic editions of the BCP (1549-1662 -1928) is Psalm 80. Scholars tell us that it was probably composed in the last days of the northern kingdom, just before 721 BC. Today the Church prays this psalm with, in and through the Lord Jesus Christ and thus it becomes a prayer for restoration, renewal and revival of Christ’s cause.

Notice the repeated petition, “RESTORE US, O GOD; LET THY FACE SHINE, THAT WE MAY BE SAVED” (verses 4, 8, 15, 20).

Notice also that the intensity of the petition increases as the Name of God is developed and strengthened – “O God” (v.4); “O God of hosts” (vv.8 & 15) and “LORD God of hosts” (v.20).

We move from the general name of the God of Israel, to the heightened Name (The God of all the heavenly armies) to the unique, revealed Name ( LORD -- YHWH, HE WHO IS, HE WHO WAS & HE WHO SHALL BE).

And with the heightening and intensifying of the NAME of God so the petition becomes the more explicit and real. “Let thy face shine” is prayer for not only the divine light and divine favor to be known and felt amongst the Jews but also for there to be a vital sense of God’s presence with his covenant people. It is fervent request for YHWH (the LORD) to be unto them now and always their covenant God.

For the Church YHWH is the Blessed Holy and Undivided Trinity (“in the NAME of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost”) and only HE is able to revive his people and only HE can of his choosing cause his Spirit to fall upon them and his blessings to be as showers to cleanse and refresh them.

At the stage of composing this Psalm the northern kingdom knew that political alliances and human effort could not save it. Only intervention by the LORD could restore and save, only restorative rain could cause this vine to grow and bear fruit (vv.14-15).

Similarly, for American Episcopalians, who see the Judgment of God upon their province and who realize that political machination and ecclesiastical alliances do not have the power to save them from moral & spiritual disaster, this is a Prayer to address fervently and humbly to the Almighty Father, through the Incarnate Son and with the Holy Ghost: RESTORE US, O LORD GOD OF HOSTS, BLESSED TRINITY! LET THY FACE SHINE UPON US THAT WE MAY BE SAVED.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

The Anglican Communion & Moral Authority

"The positive nature of the authority which binds the Anglican Communion together is .seen to be moral and spiritual, resting on the truth of the Gospel, and on charity which is patient and willing to defer to the common mind" [Lambeth Conference, 1948, Report, p. 84]

The general style and tone of authorizing or exercising authority in the Anglican Communion is not in terms of "to forbid, to command or to require" but rather "to suggest, to commend and to urge". This approach can be seen throughout the Reports of the Lambeth Conferences from 1867 to the present day. It is an appropriate form of authority for what is, after all, a fellowship of Churches which are indeed "independent, but independent with the Christian freedom which recognizes the restraints of truth and of love" and thus the Churches are neither free to deny the truth nor free to ignore the fellowship.

Of course, we have learned in recent times that fellowship or communion can be a different levels - the basic fellowship due to a common baptism and common roots and relations (which is the sole tie that binds many now) and the deeper or higher communion that is also Eucharistic and which recognizes the Ministry of each and all (to which all aspire).

The moral authority that belongs to the Lambeth Conference is identical in nature to that which belongs to the Primates' Meeting. The latter is set up to exercise authority through moral persuasion, example and reason and so its words, even to an erring brother, can only be "we suggest, urge, beg & commend". However, such language can be persuasive where there is a readiness of the erring one to hear and where the Spirit of truth is present and active.

In contrast to the moral authority of the Lambeth Conference and the Primates' Meeting, the See of Canterbury has an authority that actually has in certain respects a judicial power. The occupant of this ancient See has the duty and the power to invite the bishops of provinces to attend the Lambeth Conference and he also has the power to withhold invitations to such bishops as he deems ought not to be present for their attendance would be to dishonor the Gospel or would not be for the common good.

Of all the "instruments of unity" of the Anglican Communion, the See of Canterbury is the first, and being first, it is both like and unlike the others in its possession and exercise of authority. For most of the time and for most occasions, the authority of the Archbishop of Canterbury is that of moral suasion, but in a very limited sphere it is judicial. A combination of both forms of authority is required to begin to address the current crisis in the Anglican Family of Churches.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

ACNS 3582: Preparations for CAPA Council in top gear

ACNS 3582 | KENYA | 17 SEPTEMBER 2003

[ACNS source: CAPA] The ninth session of the Council of the Anglican Provinces of Africa (CAPA) council meeting will be held in Nairobi from 24 - 26 September.

Over 50 representatives from all the Anglican Provinces in Africa, as well as partners, friends and observers, are expected to attend the meeting, which is the highest governing body for the Council. There are close to 40 million Anglican members in Africa.

The council meeting is held once every four years and charts the general direction for the Anglican coordinating body in the coming years.

Among the highlights of this year's meeting will be the official opening and dedication of CAPA House which was purchased last year with generous support from the United Thanks Offering and CAPA Provinces. CAPA House is now accommodating all the secretariat activities.

Since the last meeting in 1999, CAPA has expanded in order to respond effectively to the challenges facing Anglicans and communities in Africa. Communications and HIV/AIDS programmes have been set up to work with the national churches in Africa in addressing these key areas.

Other outstanding proceedings at the meeting will be the election of a new management team as the current chairman, the Most Revd Robert G A Okine of West Africa, retires.