Wednesday, September 17, 2003

ACNS 3579: Anglican Communion / Al Azhar meeting postponed

ACNS 3579 | ENGLAND | 17 SEPTEMBER 2003

[ACNS source: NIFCON] The 3rd meeting of the Anglican Communion / Al Azhar Joint Dialogue Commission was scheduled to be held in New York on 10-11 September 2003, the second anniversary of 9/11. Al Azhar is the ancient mosque/university in Cairo, which has a critical and authoritative position throughout the Sunni Muslim world. This year the dialogue was being administered by NIFCON, the Anglican Communion Network for Inter Faith Concerns. The Episcopal Diocese of New York was hosting the event.

Unfortunately at the last minute the Dialogue was postponed. The Muslim representatives cited unease in Egypt about the election of Canon Gene Robinson as Bishop of New Hampshire. The Diocese of New York has expressed regret at not being able to assist in an important venture in Christian-Muslim understanding.

ACNS 3577: Bishop Griswold meets with bishops about General Convention reactions

ACNS 3577 | USA | 16 SEPTEMBER 2003

by Jan Nunley

[ACNS source: Episcopal News Service] A group of 10 Episcopal bishops from across the spectrum of views on human sexuality met with Presiding Bishop Frank T. Griswold in New York, September 10-11, to discuss local reaction to General Convention's decisions about the election of an openly gay bishop and the blessing of same-gender relationships.

The meeting was an attempt to explore what Bishop Griswold called "the very deep question of how we can live with disagreement, given our very divergent points of view around the issues of sexuality." In his letter of invitation, sent August 25, Bishop Griswold asked the bishops to "address together how we might find, in our current circumstances, a deeper invitation to reconciliation."

The bishops issued a brief statement following the meeting:

"The Presiding Bishop called together ten of your fellow bishops to be in a conversation about General Convention and, more particularly, about issues resulting from the consent to the election of the Bishop Coadjutor of New Hampshire and resolution C-051 [concerning a rite for blessing same-gender unions]. Our dialogue was candid, honest and respectful as we considered the seriousness of those decisions that were reached and the possible consequences of them for the continued faithful unity of the Church. We found the discussion to be helpful to each of us personally, and we hope it is helpful to the Presiding Bishop in his continuing leadership and ministry."

The statement was signed by Bishops Keith Ackerman of Quincy, Edwin Gulick of Kentucky, John Howe of Central Florida, Robert Ihloff of Maryland, Don Johnson of West Tennessee, John Lipscomb of Southwest Florida, Edward Little of Northern Indiana, Stacy Sauls of Lexington, Mark Sisk of New York, and Geralyn Wolf of Rhode Island.

In a September 12 letter to members of the House of Bishops, Bishop Griswold indicated, as he has in the past, the discomfort he and other bishops have felt at submitting decisions about matters related to human sexuality to a legislative process. "Regardless of our points of view, all of us recognized the polarization that was caused by our having to make an either/or decision with no possibility of any other mode of response," he wrote. "This has clearly caused pain, confusion and disbelief in many parts of the church, and a sense of rightness in other parts."

Bishop Griswold continued, "Our meeting was very helpful to me in thinking about how we can assist our church in living through this time in faithfulness.... I left the meeting extremely grateful for the candor and grace of the participants, their deep care and affection for one another, and their commitment to the wellbeing of their dioceses, and our church. It is my sense that their spirit is representative of us all."

The bishops also decided more such gatherings are needed in anticipation of the spring meeting of the full House of Bishops.

[The Revd Jan Nunley is deputy director of Episcopal News Service]

Tuesday, September 16, 2003

Sexuality and Renewal of the Anglican Way in the Fall of 2003 in the ECUSA

Before responding below to a variety of letters, comments and questions on the relation of modern expressions of sexuality to the desired spiritual and moral reformation & renewal in the ECUSA in late 2003, I wish to make the following two statements concerning the general approach to divorce & remarriage amongst American Anglican evangelicals and charismatics.

(a) I think that many biblically-minded evangelicals and charismatics make wrong or imbalanced judgments in this area because they tend to take & make the very limited possibility of divorce with a second marriage in the tradition (as set out by Erasmus and followed by Beza & the Reformed tradition and seen in the Westminster Confession 1648) into a kind of general permission so that, as it were, the one case in a hundred envisaged in the 16th & 17th century by the Protestant divines has now become, as it were, 90 cases out of a hundred in the ECUSA, even amongst conservatives.

(b) I note that lifelong, one-flesh marriage is often and generally described in evangelical and charismatic circles as an ideal rather than as a privilege, command and duty required by God. The logic of this word “ideal” in practical terms means that life-long wedlock is something to aim for; but, if it is not attained, a second or third try is acceptable if one is sincere. So the use of this word can be and often is most supportive of the divorce culture and serial monogamy. There is a big difference between an ideal to aim for and a command to obey.


Now I wish to state what I see as the general mindset & state of affairs in virtually all ECUSA dioceses and parishes with respect to divorce & remarriage.

1. In general, no bishops place any obstacles before a person, whose original spouse is alive, being married a second time in church.

2. In general, few bishops object to a third marriage if a suitable explanation for it is offered.

3. Around 40 percent of Episcopalians are divorced, or divorced and remarried (at least once). This deeply affects the mindset of a parish and congregation, making it difficult therein to preach the whole counsel of God.

4. At least 20 per cent of clergy (female and male) are divorced, or divorced and remarried and this fact does not seem to affect their continuance and promotion in ordained Ministry or stand in the way of job prospects, including being made bishop.

5.Virtually all Episcopalians give general support to the marriage of divorcees in church whether they themselves are divorced or not. The divorce culture, so called, is part of the Episcopal mindset and this is so whether we speak of conservatives or liberals.

6. Much energy, money, skill & time is spent on counseling in order to make the divorce culture work and cause minimal casualties in the congregations.

7. To find a clergyman and/or a parish which seeks to uphold the traditional, biblical and western canon law standards for holy matrimony is very difficult. Those who wish to do so find themselves overwhelmed by the culture. (Even in the Continuing Churches, where one would expect to find this standard upheld, it is often negated through the use of the bishop’s supposed power to annul a marriage and therefore treat it as if it never existed.)


If we take all these statements together and then place alongside them the further fact that many dioceses are now authorizing the blessing of same-sex couples, we can so easily see that we are dealing with a general failure in the ECUSA to stand on the biblical rock of the Word which is the Lord Jesus Christ who said, “those whom God hath joined let no man put asunder”. In fact, the ECUSA is allowing all kinds of other sexual relations/deviations to exist on the shifting sands of modern doctrines of freedom, personal autonomy, personal fulfillment, and human rights. These modern doctrines have all been absorbed to some degree or another in the Church by liberals and conservatives alike and thus the mindset is created which is favorable to these innovations in sexuality.

So a new beginning, a reformation, a revival, a renewal of the Anglican Way in 2003 MUST surely include [how can it exclude?] a getting to grips with the terrifying phenomenon of the demise of biblically-based marriage along with the triumph of the ecclesiastical expressions of the divorce and lesbigay cultures.

We have to take up our cross in order to follow the Lord Jesus. Here without pain there can be no gain for the kingdom of God. And all of us are affected whether in a primary or secondary way.

Again I commend the study of the Preface to the Service of Holy Matrimony in The Book of Common Prayer of 1662 as a pointer to the biblical teaching.

Dearly beloved, we are gathered together here in the sight of God, and in the face of this congregation, to join together this man and this woman in holy Matrimony; which is an honorable estate, instituted of God in the time of man’s innocency, signifying unto us the mystical union that is betwixt Christ and his Church; which holy estate Christ adorned and beautified with his presence, and first miracle that he wrought, in Cana of Galilee: and is commended of Saint Paul to be honorable among all men: and therefore is not by any to be enterprized, nor take in hand, inadvisedly, lightly or wantonly, to satisfy man’s carnal lusts and appetites, like brute beasts that have no understanding; but reverently, discreetly, advisedly, soberly, and in the fear of God; duly considering the causes for which Matrimony was ordained.

First, it was ordained for the procreation of children, to be brought up in the fear and nurture of the Lord, and to the praise of his holy Name.

Secondly, it was ordained for a remedy against sin, and to avoid fornication; that such persons as have not the gift of continency might marry, and keep themselves undefiled members of Christ’s body.

Thirdly, it was ordained for the mutual society, help, and comfort, that the one ought to have of the other, both in prosperity and adversity. Into which holy estate these two persons present come now to be joined.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Monday, September 15, 2003

Step by step or all together?

In response to my several little pieces/tracts on the present Crisis in ECUSA as a God-given opportunity to engage in a full reform and renewal of the Anglican Way, several thinking persons have written to tell me that a jurisdiction of the Church of God can only be cleansed step by step, one thing at a time. Thus they say: "Let us, as biblically-minded Episcopalians, get rid of the gay bishop elect and dispel from our midst all talk and practice of blessing same-sex unions as a starter and be concerned about other things later."

There appears to be sense in such a plan of action. It is practical; It can be done with pressure from overseas and internal campaigning; and from a propaganda and communications angle; It is easy to sell and easy to grasp.

But God's truth and God's ways are not simplistic.

The problem with this approach is that the matter of "gay unions" is not an isolated subject that has no relation to the religious context of the present ECUSA and of the social, cultural context of the western world in which we all live. Gay sex cannot be prized apart from other forms of modern, sexual relations for they All belong together within the modern revolution in sexual ethics, the revolution that entered the western world with the general availability of contraception and has been sustained by the emphasis on human autonomy, human fulfillment, human rights, and abortion.

So in context the "rights" of "lesbians" and "gays" to equal treatment and in dignity are all part of the general "rights" claimed by heterosexual persons engaged in temporary or long term partnerships, by married persons to get a quick divorce, and of divorced persons to get married again and be socially acceptable as such.

Now the Episcopal Church at the local level in many parishes has for several decades tolerated and treated as normal the partnerships of heterosexuals, the marriage of divorced persons, and also but quietly same-sex partnerships. What has been declared by government departments, big business and prestigious universities to be acceptable sexual ethics has become the norm for many Episcopalians, even if they do not like all of this agenda and everything that is happening. (And there has been a tremendous effort in terms of counseling and therapy in parishes to keep all this under control and outwardly healthy.)

Over and over again it has been said within the parishes and at diocesan meetings:

"We Episcopalians no longer keep to the biblical rules about divorce and remarriage; we reject the idea that a faithful sexual partnership of a man and woman is fornication; and we reject the teaching that by remarrying while the first spouse is alive a person commits adultery. It is not that we have abandoned the Bible; rather it is that we have learned to read the Bible in a sophisticated way and not be tied down to old ideas by recognizing the presence in the Bible of patriarchalism, androcentricism and sexism. We have freed the Word of God from its cultural and social context and so can hear It afresh and know what It really is all about. Did we not also apply this most successfully over the innovation of the ordination of women, as we interpreted the Bible in a new way so that we found that it actually agreed with what we had learned from the world around us about the development of civil and human rights and the emphasis upon human dignity & worth?"

It would appear that in terms of sexual ethics the real difference between the average conservative Episcopalian (e.g. who is heading for the Plano/Dallas Congress on October 7) and the average liberal Episcopalian (who voted for Gene Robinson's confirmation as bishop) is that, for the former, the sexual revolution does not include the blessing of faithful homosexual unions from the churches but pretty much tolerates the rest. Thus what separates conservative & liberal is a difference of degree of commitment to the new sexual order rather than a difference over the acceptance of the new sexual ethics. Even so this difference has the power to unlock powerful emotions and to empty deep pockets and fat wallets on both sides!

So I conclude that if there is to be reform & renewal, it has to be of the whole of sexual relations and sexual ethics and this includes doctrine, discipline and pastoral practice. Simply chasing away the homosexual problem will only be a temporary expedient for it will be back quickly unless there is no base left upon which it can set up its tent and make its claims to "we have the same rights as the heterosexuals".

In fact, what a sober examination of this whole topic reveals is that we conservatives need to look again at their Bible - the translation we use, our dependence on modern exegesis for acceptance of such topics as the ordaining of women, our apparent lack of acquaintance with classical exegesis and interpretation as it is found in standard historical sources like Liturgy, Confessions of Faith, Canon Law, Formularies and Commentaries by the Fathers.

This Crisis is surely God-sent to call us back to a whole-hearted and whole-minded commitment to the Holy Trinity and His will and purposes as these have been known and can be known in the Anglican Way as a jurisdiction of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

On Reformation, Renewal & Reaction in late 2003 in the ECUSA

Ladies & Gentlemen,

I offer these five statements for serious consideration. They reflect what I see and thus are limited by my creaturelines and weaknesses.

1. If the present Dallas-headed (October 7) movement of 5000 plus has basically the same mindset as pre-August 2003 conservative Episcopalianism together with an added, committed opposition to the innovation of the blessing of "gay" partnerships, then it is NOT likely to see or experience any reform or renewal that are worth the names or is especially blessed by heaven, and this will be so even if a viable, working federation of dioceses separate from the "national church" is formed with the approval of some primates on or after October 7.

2. Genuine Reform & Renewal of the Church have both inward and outwards aspects (two sides of the divine coin, as it were). (a) The reformers are those who earnestly seek God until they find him, constantly knock at the door of heaven until it is opened, and continually ask/petition until their requests are granted. They open their hearts and lives to the searching light of the Word of the Lord and the Spirit of the Lord. They are penitent, repentant and yet filled with faith, hope and love. They are prepared to give up anything and everything for the Lord Jesus whose love and grace they experience. (b) The reformers know that the Word of God written must be central to their whole activity and commitment. They realize that they must use English translations that are true to its literal rather than supposed dynamic sense; further, to interpret that Word they need the best help of the long tradition of the Church in reading and meditating upon the Bible - thus the importance of Creeds, Formularies, classic Commentaries, the underlying doctrines of ancient canon law and so on. What they have to avoid at all costs is insulated private judgment, following only modern exegetes and allowing dominant themes of modern life (human rights for example) to guide their interpreting of the Bible. Thus they need in place the classic Creeds (three) and the Anglican Formularies from the 16th Century - the latter as a signpost to where reformed catholic doctrine is to be found & what it is, and the former as a guide to the central verities of the Bible.

3. A time of Crisis (which seems to be the case now for many Anglicans) is a unique opportunity not to fire darts at the enemy (lesbigay movement and supporting bishops) but rather to examine ourselves, our tradition and our position and to seek under God's guidance to plot a way forward that is true to HIM, to HIS WORD and to the best Anglican Forms of Worship, Doctrine & Discipline.

4. This time is most certainly a time (as the Psalms often tell us) not to put our trust in princes or the sons of men - i.e., in Primates or in local bishops or in organizations. It is pre-eminently a time truly and really, fully and clearly, to trust in the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. If He uses Primates to help the ECUSA or its remnant then that it is His choice.

5. There is much to learn by studying the origins of the Continuing Anglican Church movement from the late 1970s and its history to the present - its aims and hopes, it successes and failures, its attempts to shake off its back and out of its bloodstream the ECUSA it left behind, its internal divisions and the cause of them, and so on.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Primate Griswold - post General Convention

(from Episcopal Life, ECUSA national newspaper. I print the article and then
comment on it)



UPON REFLECTION / Presiding Bishop Frank T. Griswold

Claiming our Anglican charism
A both/and consciousness in an either/or world


DURING OUR GENERAL Convention in Minneapolis, media observers frequently noted that the Episcopal Church set an example in dealing with highly contentious issues. One newspaper editorial noted our "thoughtfulness and mutual respect for one another." Our "civility" was frequently remarked on, and our ability to articulate and hold very different points of view in a way that respected one another was applauded.

Though it was named "civility," I believe what they actually saw was our Anglican charism at work. They were witnessing our reluctance, because of our deep sense of belonging together as limbs and members of Christ's body, to say to those of a differing point of view: "I have no need of you."

Since then, I have found myself reflecting upon our Anglican charism and how we have come to be the way we are. How has our history as Anglican Christians formed our consciousness and provided us with a way of coming at things that we might be able to see as God's gift to us?

To an extent that sets us apart from many other Christian bodies, our liturgy is the ground of our being. Liturgy, through which we confess our faith and encounter Christ in word and sacrament, is the source of our identity. By examining our liturgy and observing its development, we learn about ourselves as Anglicans.

Not long ago, I opened a volume containing the first two books of Common Prayer. The first, published in 1549, sought to offer worshippers a sense of continuity with their Catholic past while incorporating a number of Reformation emphases. For example, when the priest administered Communion to the people, he was directed to say words that were a translation of the traditional sentence of administration in the pre-Reformation liturgy: "The body of our Lord Jesus Christ which was given for thee, preserve thy body and soul unto everlasting life."

In the next prayer book, published in 1552, the Reformation themes are much more pronounced. The priest administering Communion was directed to say: "Take and eat this, in remembrance that Christ died for thee, and feed on him in thy heart by faith, with thanksgiving."

In the first prayer book, one can see the continuation of the Catholic understanding of Christ's real presence in the Eucharist, whereas in the second prayer book the emphasis is placed on the Protestant notion of commemorating what Christ did. In the third prayer book, issued in 1559 under Queen Elizabeth I, the two sentences of administration have been joined together with a colon. One is not preferred over the other. Each supports a particular theological perspective and amplifies the other. The solution was to set them side by side, avoiding an either/or solution in favor of a more expansive both/and.

In the tumultuous theological climate of the 16th century, reforming zeal frequently clashed with Catholic continuity, and a person's theology could be considered grounds for treason. The both/and way that characterized the Church of England made it possible for those of various perspectives to recognize one another as true members of Christ's risen body and to make common cause in the service of the gospel.

In our own country, in the wake of the Civil War, the ability of the Episcopal Church to remain united while many other denominations split in two is another example of our graced capacity to contain difference within the context of common prayer.

Over the years, issues have changed and other matters have presented their own challenges and excited people's emotions. During the churchmanship battles, which have now largely passed from our consciousness, the vastly different ways in which the liturgy was celebrated made some wonder if we were all members of the same church. However, once again a both/and consciousness carried the day. The understatement of Protestant simplicity and the fulsomeness of Catholic ritual both were embraced as part of our common life, which expanded our ability to meet Christ in word and sacrament.

I believe that in these examples of both/and consciousness we see the essential character of Anglicanism and that this gift will serve us very well in our own day. Issues change, and divergent points of view continue to address one another, often with a great deal of passion. Certainly this was true at our General Convention. It will continue to be true in the months ahead, as we sort and sift decisions we have made and consider their consequences for our common life and mission.

Over these past days, I have wondered if the media fascination with our way of coming at things doesn't reveal a deep hunger for this Anglican charism. As your presiding bishop, it is my firm belief that what has shaped and formed us in the past is very much needed now. Our gift is needed not only in our church but also in the world around us, where points of view seem so often to be polarized and no common ground can be found.

More than ever, we must now claim our Anglican way of coming at things from a both/and perspective rooted in common prayer. As we are able so to do, we will be witnesses to the world of Christ's power to reconcile all things, including divergent points of view, and we will be able -- evermore -- to see difference as a gift.



Here is an attempt to create something positive out of what was basically negative publicity for the ECUSA in the USA and around the world. I was in the press room and did not get the impression that there was a great fascination with the civility shown. To lift the civility out of a secular value into a spiritual virtue and make it a charism is an effort to make a bad story into a good one! It will convince only the few that the path taken by the General Convention in August 2003 was the right one.

It is true that the C of E in the 16th century took the path of Reformed Catholicism and that since that time has sought to be comprehensive -- a common center with variety in the spokes and especially at the circumference. But this does not mean that the Anglican Way in Britain or elsewhere has never said no to innovations & to sin. There has always been a recognition that the Anglican Via Media has internal limits in terms of worship, doctrine and discipline. For example, consenting homosexual behavior has never been seen as within the morality of Christian sexuality.

Without mentioning the innovations [read blessing of disorder or sin] introduced by the ECUSA in recent times the Presiding Bishop writes as though the ECUSA is a pioneering Body that is setting an example to the world and to the Anglican Communion. It is certainly setting an example but a bad one! Yet in terms of the values of the world and the present western understanding of individual autonomy, human rights and self-expression & self-realization the ECUSA is a pioneering and innovative religious body with its own unique offerings in the massive American supermarket of religions (yet not all its "shops" sell the new products!).

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Saturday, September 13, 2003

A Prayer for the Anglican Primates

If you need a Collect for Sunday worship or in the intercessions in the daily office, you may care to use this:

"O Gracious Father, we humbly beseech thee for thy holy Catholic Church and in particular for that jurisdiction of the same known as the Anglican Communion; that thou wouldest be pleased to fill it with all truth, in all peace. Where it is corrupt, purify it; where it is in error, direct it; where in any thing it is amiss, reform it. Where it is right, establish it; where it is in want, provide for it; where it is divided, reunite it. When its Primates meet on October 15-16 in London bless, direct and unite them in thy love, for the sake of him who died and rose again, and ever liveth to make intercession for us, Jesus Christ, thy Son our Lord. Amen."

(adapted from a prayer of Archbishop Laud)

The original Prayer from the Works of Laud I used as the dedication of my new, Sept 2003, book COMMON WORSHIP CONSIDERED (www.edgewaysbooks.com)

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

ECUSA, Evangelicals & Charismatics, Holy Scripture & Consonance

In late 2003 a minority within the ECUSA is regretting that this Church's teaching and practice are not consonant with Scripture, and they have in mind particularly the area of sexual ethics.

To be consonant with Scripture has always been the aim/claim of the Church in her desire to be orthodox. And, surprisingly, it has also been the claim of those who have in sincerity introduced innovations into the Anglican Way since World War II - e.g., marriage of divorcees in church, new styles of liturgy, new language of prayer, the ordination of women, the blessing of "gay" couples & so on.

How can there be this unanimous commitment to CONSONANCE with sacred Scripture but yielding very different results? The answer is relatively simple - it all depends on the premises underlying the claim of consonance (i.e. that which underlies that teaching & doctrine which is said to be in agreement or harmony with the intent and doctrinal content of the Bible).

Let us note that whether we make the traditional conservative claim that the Scriptures are inerrant and infallible as God's Word written in their original autographs, or we make the modern claim that the books of the Bible witness in some way to the Word of God, we have still the task of interpreting the Bible to find the Word of God.

While the classic Anglican approach to interpretation of the Bible has allowed for the function of sanctified reason & careful exegesis, it has set this in the context of bringing to the Bible a Christian mindset that is formed through commitment to the major aspects of Tradition created in the Early Church (the Creeds, the Dogma of the first ecumenical councils, the way the Bible is used in Daily offices & Public Liturgy etc.) and at the Reformation (e.g., the principle of justification by faith & the Reformation Formularies). Further it has said that there is One Canon of Scripture wherein are Two Testaments and thus the unity of Scripture is very important as a principle in terms of interpreting both Testaments and using Scripture in Liturgy and preaching.

When this mindset reads Scripture and applies what it finds to the contemporary church it is very unlikely to desire to introduce any major innovations. Its sense is always to look up to the exalted Lord and in so doing also to look back to the foundational documents and their use in the past. Thus it seeks to find ways of making what is received from the past into living reality in the present and for the future. To introduce anything for which there are no strong hints and a sound basis in the past, would be seen as not being consonant with Scripture as received.

In contrast, if the approach to the Bible is dominated by what we may called "critical theory", if the search is always for what it meant to those who originally wrote it and received it, if all kinds of critical questions preface any claim of unity between the OT & NT, and if the doctrinal understanding of the Bible in Tradition is discounted or is sidelined as being too culturally conditioned to be taken seriously into account, then obviously what the Bible is said to teach and what is applicable to the present are very open questions. So it is possible to claim that the real, inner message of the Bible is this or that theme or position and on this new basis justify innovations in the Church's doctrine and practice (e.g., import into the church as innovations that which in secular society is regarded as good and right).

The big questions for Evangelical & Charismatic Episcopalians in this time of crisis in the ECUSA and in world Anglicanism are how they actually view the Scriptures, how they interpret them and how they apply the results of that study to the burning questions of the day. For they need to remember that it is much the same type of reading and interpreting of the Bible that has justified the innovation of same-sex blessing that also has justified and continues to support women's ordination and the blessing of serial monogamy by the church. And the use of Scripture in modern Lectionaries and Liturgy is very different from that usage in the older Lectionaries and Liturgies. So to use the latter is to imbibe the "modern" outlook even if without intending to do so.

In this complex situation which version of the Bible is regularly used tells one a lot about where a given person or group really is! If one uses a Bible which translates Psalm 1 as "Happy are they" or "Happy is the one", for example, then the unity of Scripture is basically lost for Jesus Christ, the new Adam, has been taken out of the Psalter! And if out of the Psalter then out of the basic prayer of the Church. In the unity of Scripture the Psalter is the Prayer of Christ in, with and through His Church and the prayer of the Church in with and through Him! Finally, the classic Christian doctrine of sexuality (which forbids all "gay" sex as all fornication & adultery) wholly depends upon the unity of the two Testaments
in One Canon.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Friday, September 12, 2003

The See of Canterbury & the ECUSA

The occupant of the See of Canterbury, the Primate of all England, the Archbishop of Canterbury, is the President of the Lambeth Conference (which he calls every ten years), the President of the Anglican Consultative Council (whose creation gained the approval of all the Provinces in 1968) and the President of the Primates' Meeting (created 1978).

Yet each of the Thirty-Eight Provinces is autonomous in that the Primate of all England, like any other of the 37 Primates in the Anglican Family, can only enter other provinces than his own by invitation. There are no rights of entry.

Thus the Archbishop of Canterbury only enters a diocese of the ECUSA by invitation.

Not all Primates are welcomed in all Provinces. Since the introduction of the ordination of women as presbyters and then as bishops, there has been an impaired communion between certain provinces and thus, for example, Primates who have ordained women have not been invited to provinces where this innovation is seen as wrong.

It is also the case that autonomous provinces and indeed individual dioceses can declare themselves in impaired or wholly broken communion with other provinces and/or dioceses because of the perceived error, heresy,& condoning of immorality in the other provinces or dioceses. This is happening in 2003 over the matter of sexual practices approved in the ECUSA and deemed immoral by other provinces/dioceses. As yet none has declared itself out of communion with the Province of all England.

Thus there is between the 38 provinces something short of a rightly ordered federation, let alone a genuine Communion of Churches. This situation of impairment and division may become more obvious and pronounced after the regional meeting of evangelical bishops in Kenya later in September 2003.

However, all the Provinces without exception look to the See of Canterbury as the focus of unity and see their bishops in communion with the Archbishop thereof. Thus the Anglican Communion of 38 provinces remains intact even if it merely now just a loose federation.

None of the Primates has refused to attend that special Primates' Meeting in London on October 15-16 (but perhaps illness may keep several away). There will be pressure there, especially from the African lobby, upon the Archbishop of Canterbury to act in a way which only he can uniquely act - that is to tell the ECUSA that he is not prepared to invite its bishops to the next Lambeth Conference of Bishops unless its General Convention in 2006 reverses its decisions on sexuality & other matters. If he so acts the ECUSA will be disciplined in a way that has never occurred before in the history of the Communion. It will be on notice to reform or to be dismissed.

We need to be clear that no majority vote in the Anglican Consultative Council and certainly no majority vote in the Primates Meeting can discipline or expel the ECUSA. It is simply and only the Primate of all England (Canterbury), advised by the Primate of England (York), and such others as he cares to consult, who determines the membership of the Anglican Communion.

We do not know the full mind of the present Archbishop of the See of Canterbury on these matters; but, we do know that he knows that he has tremendous responsibility which must be hard to bear. He has told us that he is also very concerned about the evangelical intention in Sydney to use Lay Celebrants for Holy Communion. So if he decides to give warning to the ECUSA he may also do the same to Sydney, and in both cases, many will judge, he would be justified in terms of the central doctrines and traditions of the Anglican Way and the departure of Sydney & ECUSA from them.

Let us pray daily for ROWAN that wisdom, charity, insight and strength will be given unto him abundantly from the Father through the Son and by the Holy Spirit so that he truly acts not only as the Primate of all England but as the President of the Primates of the Anglican Family of 38 Churches.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Thursday, September 11, 2003

Beware of "the bondage of the will"

What we often fail to take into account in our explaining of why people hold on to what they know to be wrong beliefs or bad habits is what used to be called "the bondage of the will". [Remember that Luther wrote a book with this title!]

We are all familiar with the inability of people to give up smoking or hard drugs or alcohol, even when they really want to do so. They seem permanently wedded to the drug and are its slaves even at the same time as they can tell you how bad it is for them and that they ought to give it up.

Likewise we are familiar with the apparent inability of people to give up bad habits that they know are wrong and their desperate desire to change - e.g., gambling, compulsive sex, excessive eating, gossiping, bat temper, over-use of credit cards and so on.

In some cases it is possible that the cause of the bondage to drugs & compulsions can be traced to chemical reactions in the blood and the brain and thus special medical help along with spiritual medicine are needed.

However, there are many cases - most cases - where the reason that we do not act according to our informed consciences, best reasoning and rational mind is what we have called "the bondage of the will". St Paul has something profound to say about this in Romans 7. St Augustine has described the condition in detail in his writings and in his autobiography. We can experience the inner voice saying, " I ought to be this or that" or "I ought to do this or that", and we can be persuaded that what should be achieved or done by us is wholly right, and still we can fail to go ahead. The commitment of the mind does not get into the will and into action. Indeed, we can feel paralyzed and unable to do what we know absolutely is right. There is a blockage in the will. Thus we do not have the peace that passes understanding in our souls.

When we are in such circumstances it is obvious that we need to give ourselves with fresh commitment to prayer asking for help from above and claiming the promises that those who call upon the Lord for help will be heard. It may be necessary also to talk to a godly friend to ask for help & prayer from him.

This bondage of the will is also often found in respectable people (Christian leaders for example) -- a kind of stubbornness & refusal to accept that we are wrong, or that we must go in a different direction, or that we have to adopt a different creed. When it is to our (worldly) advantage to stay with this or that way, this or that form, our wills can and do become exceedingly defensive to protect the ego and the advantage to self, and this is so even when we are convinced in our minds that we should actually change our way or form or behavior to obey the Lord.

And this moral and spiritual bondage where people are socially joined - in a ethnic neighborhood, or in a local church, or in a denomination -- can take on a corporate dimension so that there it is as if a group of people are glued together in a bondage of the will, not prepared to change even when they know in their minds and hearts that they ought to do so for the lasting good of their group and in love of their neighbor. In fact this protection of the status quo and the refusal to be led by enlightened conscience is a major expression of sinfulness in churches and Christian societies for it produces both sins of commission and sins of omission.

Further, this bondage can affect the best of us (that is, the most religious of us) as our Lord's descriptions of and words to the Pharisees & Scribes well illustrate. In their case there was a corporate bondage within their party/movement and there was an individual bondage in each soul and it was all totally abhorrent to the Lord Jesus.

Let us relate this to where we are in the ECUSA now.

What I fear will prevent any God-directed renewal and reformation within conservative Episcopalianism at this period of crisis in the Episcopal Church in the Fall of 2003 is "the bondage of the will", both in its personal and in its corporate aspects. Too many of us seemingly want to hold on to what we have believed to be fine in the last decade or more, even though now we hear the informed reason telling us that it was below par and not genuinely of the Anglican Way, and even though we feel the alert conscience saying loudly and clearly within, "I ought to change and embrace the right way, this is my clear duty."

We shall never escape some bondage of the will as long as we live in mortal bodies, but let us seek by the mercies of God to break as free as is possible from that bondage now, individually & corporately, so that we do experience that gift of the Holy Spirit which is freedom from the rule of original and actual sin.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)