Adelphoi,
(in part answer to queries!)
A discussion starter.
It is claimed by some that the question as to whether or not the church should bless same-sex partnerships belongs to the sphere of morality (i.e., what is right and wrong) rather than to doctrine (i.e., church teaching). It is also claimed that the question as to whether the church ordains women as presbyters or not belongs to the sphere of discipline (i.e., what a national church is free under God to do for edification of the whole - see Article XXXIV of the Thirty Nine Articles) rather than to doctrine.
In other words there is no primary doctrinal question involved in either of these modern innovations that the ECUSA and other parts of the Anglican Communion are embracing.
I suggest that underlying both these questions as far as the Church is concerned there is a major doctrinal issue which contains both the doctrine of the Holy Trinity and the doctrine of man.
Man is made in the image and after the likeness of God, and further man is made of two sexes, male and female. How male and female relate to each other in the church and how they are ordered one to the other in marriage is meant to reflect (in a dim human way, but a real way nevertheless) the Unity in Trinity and the Trinity in Unity (of the Father, together with his only-begotten Son and with his Holy Spirit, who proceeds from the Father through the Son).
Each of the Three Persons is equal to the Others in Godhead and Majesty; and likewise male and female persons are equal in worth and dignity. The Three Persons are in an eternal, dynamically fixed order of relation - first the Father, secondly the Son and thirdly, the Holy Ghost. This is the internal reality of God as God is unto himself and how God reveals his identity and relations to us. Likewise male and female are ordered in such a way that the male is first and the woman is second (and children third).
In practice reflecting God's plan this means that in the Church & Household of God men and women are equal before God as his children and they each have eternal worth; but, that there are ordered in such a manner that the male is first, which means that he alone (not all males but the one called) has the headship (thus is pastor of all). In human relations male and female are ordered towards each other in a divine complementarity of equality and in this relation, the male is first in order either in matrimony or in the congregation of Christ's flock. How this is worked out (discipline) will differ from place to place but the doctrinal basis is that of Order.
Because of this divine ordering, sexual relations between persons of the same sex, or between persons of opposite sexes outside of a God-given relation, are against divine Order and thus wrong in nature and in grace. Nevertheless, because of sin in the world and because of imperfections in human nature and persons, it may seem at times as though what is unnatural is acceptable and even commendable. In fact, disorder may be claimed as an aspect of order in a fallen world! The presence of aberrations from the norm, however, does not disturb the reality of divine ordering, although it does and should much affect the way the Church evangelises, teaches and exercises pastoral care.
So the doctrine of Divine Order is primary for God is the Creator, Redeemer, Judge and Lord of all. We are to reflect his order rather than seek to make him the author of our disorder. And we are to ensure that the Church's morality and discipline in all sexual relations is to flow from Order and be motivated by Love.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Friday, July 04, 2003
Is Jesus "The Son of the Carpenter & Mary", or is he, "The Carpenter, the Son of Mary"?
The Gospel in the Common Lectionary for next Sunday (Trinity III) in the Church of England is Mark 6:1-13.
In Mark 6:3 there is an important question from the crowd in Nazareth, but in different manuscripts of the Gospel it occurs in two forms:
The form which could cause offence is: "Is not this the carpenter the son of Mary.?" And the form which causes no particular offence is: "Is not this the son of the carpenter and of Mary.?"
Most English translations follow the first of these possibilities as being used by the more important collection of manuscripts.
However, the well known Church Father, Origen, in his treatise "Against Celsus" VI.36, strongly asserts that in none of the Gospels is Jesus called a carpenter. Thus the copies of the Gospels which he had contained only the second of the possibilities, that Jesus is the son of a Carpenter and also of Mary.
The parallel text of Matthew 13:55 provides the question in this form: "Is not this the carpenter's son? Is not his mother called Mary?." Here there is neither an assertion or denial that Jesus was a carpenter; and significantly Jesus is not called "son of Mary."
To call Jesus "son of Mary" is very strange in a Jewish context where a boy was said to be the son of his father. It is possible that the designation as "son of Mary" is an indication that there was rumour or knowledge in Nazareth that Joseph was not the biological father of Jesus. In other words this is an indirect reference to the virginal conception of Jesus by Mary.
Further, in the ancient world to describe someone as a carpenter, a manual worker, was to confine them to the lower orders of society, from where great teachers, prophets and leaders did not arise. To be the son of and to rise above the station of manual worker was fine, but to be a manual work was not fine.
It seems highly probable that what Mark originally wrote was "carpenter, son of Mary" for this was the truth of the matter. Jesus did have a manual trade and he did not have a biological human father. It also seems that Matthew - aware of the feelings in Judaism and the Gentile world - softened the original Marcan words to make them more palatable. Further, it seems that some copyists of Mark's Gospel adjusted the original Marcan words to conform to what was in Matthew.
To assert that Jesus had not been trained in the rabbinic schools but had worked as a carpenter is to take him off the map of respectability!
To assert that he had no biological human father is to raise all kinds of suspicions about his identity!
But if it be true that Jesus was a manual worker and that he had no biological father then these facts must be asserted as part of the doctrine of the Incarnation, wherein the Son of God not only took human nature but also became a servant , for us and for our salvation.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
In Mark 6:3 there is an important question from the crowd in Nazareth, but in different manuscripts of the Gospel it occurs in two forms:
The form which could cause offence is: "Is not this the carpenter the son of Mary.?" And the form which causes no particular offence is: "Is not this the son of the carpenter and of Mary.?"
Most English translations follow the first of these possibilities as being used by the more important collection of manuscripts.
However, the well known Church Father, Origen, in his treatise "Against Celsus" VI.36, strongly asserts that in none of the Gospels is Jesus called a carpenter. Thus the copies of the Gospels which he had contained only the second of the possibilities, that Jesus is the son of a Carpenter and also of Mary.
The parallel text of Matthew 13:55 provides the question in this form: "Is not this the carpenter's son? Is not his mother called Mary?." Here there is neither an assertion or denial that Jesus was a carpenter; and significantly Jesus is not called "son of Mary."
To call Jesus "son of Mary" is very strange in a Jewish context where a boy was said to be the son of his father. It is possible that the designation as "son of Mary" is an indication that there was rumour or knowledge in Nazareth that Joseph was not the biological father of Jesus. In other words this is an indirect reference to the virginal conception of Jesus by Mary.
Further, in the ancient world to describe someone as a carpenter, a manual worker, was to confine them to the lower orders of society, from where great teachers, prophets and leaders did not arise. To be the son of and to rise above the station of manual worker was fine, but to be a manual work was not fine.
It seems highly probable that what Mark originally wrote was "carpenter, son of Mary" for this was the truth of the matter. Jesus did have a manual trade and he did not have a biological human father. It also seems that Matthew - aware of the feelings in Judaism and the Gentile world - softened the original Marcan words to make them more palatable. Further, it seems that some copyists of Mark's Gospel adjusted the original Marcan words to conform to what was in Matthew.
To assert that Jesus had not been trained in the rabbinic schools but had worked as a carpenter is to take him off the map of respectability!
To assert that he had no biological human father is to raise all kinds of suspicions about his identity!
But if it be true that Jesus was a manual worker and that he had no biological father then these facts must be asserted as part of the doctrine of the Incarnation, wherein the Son of God not only took human nature but also became a servant , for us and for our salvation.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Wednesday, July 02, 2003
Three innovations together
In answer to questions, I offer the following as a further discussion starter:
Why THREE modern innovations, though different, belong together.
It should not really surprise us that three innovations in modern church life have occurred within the same time period and are interlocked and interweaved in various ways. These are the ordination of women to the presbyterate, the blessing of marriages involving a divorced person, and the blessing of partnerships of "gay" couples.
The causes of the introduction of these innovations into the "liberal" Churches in the latter part of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st are many and varied. Chief amongst them are the human rights movement of the 20th century moving into the church from secular society and the abandonment within the Church of the doctrine of Order.
By the human rights movement, energy and reasons have been supplied to women and to men who support them to press for the inclusion of women within the ordained Ministry of the Church. It has been argued that women are the equal of men, that the professions are now opened up to women, and that before God all people are equal and should be treated justly. From this standpoint the Bible has been re-interpreted so as to support this innovation.
Also, through the human rights movement, energy and reasons have been given to divorced persons and those who support them to press for the Church to change her received doctrine and discipline concerning those who may be married in church and receive God's blessing. It has been argued that divorced persons deserve a second chance at happiness in a blessed "relationship" and that the teaching of Jesus does not forbid such marriages.
Finally, because of their use of the human rights movement and its success in changing attitudes and practices in modern society, those who wish to establish the rights of "gay" and "lesbian" persons to live together in same-sex partnerships with the approval of the State and to be blessed by the Church therein have been very successful. This success has also been because they have successfully conveyed the message that some persons have an inbuilt orientation towards the same sex and that provision should be made for the exercise and practice of this in faithful partnerships.
It does not really matter for our purposes here just how each movement has used and benefited from the strong human rights movement of modern times. The fact is that they have done so and done so very successfully that anyone who questions their achievements runs the risk of being dubbed a bigot or homophobic or prejudiced.
However, it was not enough in the churches for the human rights movement to blow away the cobwebs and change the ethos and atmosphere. The Christian doctrine of sexual relations, inherited from the Old and New Testaments and enshrined in patristic teaching and ancient canon law, had to be abandoned - or more subtly had to be reworked and re-interpreted to make it speak with a new voice in support on the innovations.
The Christian doctrine is that of Order - the ordering according to a divine plan of the relations of male and female persons both in nature (creation) and in the new covenant established by the sacrifice of Christ on the Cross. This Order is a pale but real reflection in human relations of the Ordered Eternal Relations that constitute the Three Persons of the LORD God, who is a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity, and who always exists as Three but in this order - first the Father, second the Only-Begotten Son and third the Holy Ghost who proceeds from the Father and the Son. While all the Three Persons are equal in Godhead and Majesty, they are different in Order, with the Father eternally the First.
Man (mankind/humankind) is made in the image of God and after his likeness. This includes his being created with and in Order. God created man, male and female created he them. Though man and women, male and female, are equal in worth and dignity and have a God-given, designed complementarity and are ordered towards each other for procreation and companionship, they are not equal in order, for it is the male first and the female second. This does not mean that the female is inferior to the male but that in the divine ordering she is second in order, even as the Son is subordinate - second in order - to the Father.
By this doctrine women are not called to be bishops/pastors because they are second in order and by this doctrine same-sex relations are contrary to nature and order. And by the doctrine of one flesh in the union of the male and female the remarriage of divorced persons is prohibited (as it was in canon law of the C of E until 2003).
In the modern Church, we have re-written the dogma of the Holy Trinity and departed from the doctrine of Order and thus we have allowed ourselves to be dominated in our thinking and decisions by the secular human rights movement (which though it has much importance in the modern world in certain spheres is not to be the basis of Church doctrine). There is no way of holding back innovations if we are basically dominated by human rights principles and we have little or no theological dogma.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Why THREE modern innovations, though different, belong together.
It should not really surprise us that three innovations in modern church life have occurred within the same time period and are interlocked and interweaved in various ways. These are the ordination of women to the presbyterate, the blessing of marriages involving a divorced person, and the blessing of partnerships of "gay" couples.
The causes of the introduction of these innovations into the "liberal" Churches in the latter part of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st are many and varied. Chief amongst them are the human rights movement of the 20th century moving into the church from secular society and the abandonment within the Church of the doctrine of Order.
By the human rights movement, energy and reasons have been supplied to women and to men who support them to press for the inclusion of women within the ordained Ministry of the Church. It has been argued that women are the equal of men, that the professions are now opened up to women, and that before God all people are equal and should be treated justly. From this standpoint the Bible has been re-interpreted so as to support this innovation.
Also, through the human rights movement, energy and reasons have been given to divorced persons and those who support them to press for the Church to change her received doctrine and discipline concerning those who may be married in church and receive God's blessing. It has been argued that divorced persons deserve a second chance at happiness in a blessed "relationship" and that the teaching of Jesus does not forbid such marriages.
Finally, because of their use of the human rights movement and its success in changing attitudes and practices in modern society, those who wish to establish the rights of "gay" and "lesbian" persons to live together in same-sex partnerships with the approval of the State and to be blessed by the Church therein have been very successful. This success has also been because they have successfully conveyed the message that some persons have an inbuilt orientation towards the same sex and that provision should be made for the exercise and practice of this in faithful partnerships.
It does not really matter for our purposes here just how each movement has used and benefited from the strong human rights movement of modern times. The fact is that they have done so and done so very successfully that anyone who questions their achievements runs the risk of being dubbed a bigot or homophobic or prejudiced.
However, it was not enough in the churches for the human rights movement to blow away the cobwebs and change the ethos and atmosphere. The Christian doctrine of sexual relations, inherited from the Old and New Testaments and enshrined in patristic teaching and ancient canon law, had to be abandoned - or more subtly had to be reworked and re-interpreted to make it speak with a new voice in support on the innovations.
The Christian doctrine is that of Order - the ordering according to a divine plan of the relations of male and female persons both in nature (creation) and in the new covenant established by the sacrifice of Christ on the Cross. This Order is a pale but real reflection in human relations of the Ordered Eternal Relations that constitute the Three Persons of the LORD God, who is a Trinity in Unity and a Unity in Trinity, and who always exists as Three but in this order - first the Father, second the Only-Begotten Son and third the Holy Ghost who proceeds from the Father and the Son. While all the Three Persons are equal in Godhead and Majesty, they are different in Order, with the Father eternally the First.
Man (mankind/humankind) is made in the image of God and after his likeness. This includes his being created with and in Order. God created man, male and female created he them. Though man and women, male and female, are equal in worth and dignity and have a God-given, designed complementarity and are ordered towards each other for procreation and companionship, they are not equal in order, for it is the male first and the female second. This does not mean that the female is inferior to the male but that in the divine ordering she is second in order, even as the Son is subordinate - second in order - to the Father.
By this doctrine women are not called to be bishops/pastors because they are second in order and by this doctrine same-sex relations are contrary to nature and order. And by the doctrine of one flesh in the union of the male and female the remarriage of divorced persons is prohibited (as it was in canon law of the C of E until 2003).
In the modern Church, we have re-written the dogma of the Holy Trinity and departed from the doctrine of Order and thus we have allowed ourselves to be dominated in our thinking and decisions by the secular human rights movement (which though it has much importance in the modern world in certain spheres is not to be the basis of Church doctrine). There is no way of holding back innovations if we are basically dominated by human rights principles and we have little or no theological dogma.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
A WORD FROM THE BISHOP of ALBANY NY State of the election of a Gay Bishop
(he is one of the few bishops who seeks to be biblically based)
It is with deep sadness that I write to the people and clergy of the diocese. No doubt most of you have heard that the Diocese of New Hampshire has elected a person who is an openly professed, practicing homosexual to become their bishop. Of course, Episcopal elections that occur within 120 days of a General Convention must be ratified by a majority vote of the House of Deputies and the House of Bishops.
I do not know the Bishop-elect, the Reverend Canon Gene Robinson and therefore have no feelings about him personally. What I do know is public knowledge; that he was married with two children, divorced, and subsequently entered an openly homosexual relationship with another man. If his election is ratified by the General Convention it means that the Episcopal Church is clearly approving the kind of relationship of which Gene Robinson is a part. Such approval would have a significant impact on the Convention's consideration of the blessing of same sex unions which is a major issue already on the agenda.
It is my hope that the General Convention will not ratify this election and I will join with those who oppose it, not because of the individual or the process but because it represents a radical departure from the clear teaching of the Holy Scriptures, the doctrine and tradition of the Episcopal Church, the resolution of the 1998 Lambeth Conference of Anglican Bishops, countless resolutions of the General Convention and the expressed will of the Anglican Primates at their recent meeting in Brazil. The approval of this election will have serious consequences in our relationship with the rest of the Anglican Communion as well as in our own National Church.
Certainly all Christians are called to stand up for justice and civil rights, for non-discrimination against any persons or people; to love and care for all people as children of God. But Christians are not called to uphold or even tolerate all behavior. The approval and blessing of sexual intimacy, heterosexual or homosexual, outside of traditional marriage of one man and one woman is not a question of justice or civil rights, it is a question of morality. And morality cannot be decided by a majority vote of any group or body, including the General Convention. In all fairness, I must acknowledge that many of those who want to change the teaching of the church on human sexuality are people of faith. In an effort to recognize this and prevent a disastrous decision at the General Convention, the House of Bishops of the Fourth Province, following the lead of the Theology Committee of the National House of Bishops, unanimously approved affirmations which say essentially that there is no consensus on this issue and we should not try to resolve it by legislation. These affirmations, which will be sent to the General Convention as a resolution, were endorsed by the Fourth Province Synod which consists of the Lay and Clergy Deputies to General Convention and the Bishops of the twenty dioceses of the province. Originally crafted by bishops on both sides of the issue, I believe they are a way forward without dividing the church, defeating our evangelistic efforts and fracturing our relationship with the rest of the Anglican Communion.
After having said all that, and there is obviously much more that could be said, I am still saddened by this turn of events but I am not discouraged or dismayed. God is faithful and our ultimate trust is in God, not in the institutional church. The church is not infallible =96 she can and has made mistakes. But the church is indefectible; that is, her purposes will not ultimately be thwarted, God will prevail. That means that God will win in the end and our job is to be faithful in the meantime. I am calling the faithful to be faithful; to stand firm in the faith of our mothers and fathers, the authority of the Holy Scriptures and the historic teaching and tradition once delivered to us by the saints. We have a goodly heritage in this diocese and an unlimited potential. Let us not grow weary in well doing; let us continue our works of mercy and evangelism. Let us press on toward the heavenly prize by working and praying harder, by giving more liberally of ourselves and our resources and remembering, that neither death nor life nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 8:38-39)
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
It is with deep sadness that I write to the people and clergy of the diocese. No doubt most of you have heard that the Diocese of New Hampshire has elected a person who is an openly professed, practicing homosexual to become their bishop. Of course, Episcopal elections that occur within 120 days of a General Convention must be ratified by a majority vote of the House of Deputies and the House of Bishops.
I do not know the Bishop-elect, the Reverend Canon Gene Robinson and therefore have no feelings about him personally. What I do know is public knowledge; that he was married with two children, divorced, and subsequently entered an openly homosexual relationship with another man. If his election is ratified by the General Convention it means that the Episcopal Church is clearly approving the kind of relationship of which Gene Robinson is a part. Such approval would have a significant impact on the Convention's consideration of the blessing of same sex unions which is a major issue already on the agenda.
It is my hope that the General Convention will not ratify this election and I will join with those who oppose it, not because of the individual or the process but because it represents a radical departure from the clear teaching of the Holy Scriptures, the doctrine and tradition of the Episcopal Church, the resolution of the 1998 Lambeth Conference of Anglican Bishops, countless resolutions of the General Convention and the expressed will of the Anglican Primates at their recent meeting in Brazil. The approval of this election will have serious consequences in our relationship with the rest of the Anglican Communion as well as in our own National Church.
Certainly all Christians are called to stand up for justice and civil rights, for non-discrimination against any persons or people; to love and care for all people as children of God. But Christians are not called to uphold or even tolerate all behavior. The approval and blessing of sexual intimacy, heterosexual or homosexual, outside of traditional marriage of one man and one woman is not a question of justice or civil rights, it is a question of morality. And morality cannot be decided by a majority vote of any group or body, including the General Convention. In all fairness, I must acknowledge that many of those who want to change the teaching of the church on human sexuality are people of faith. In an effort to recognize this and prevent a disastrous decision at the General Convention, the House of Bishops of the Fourth Province, following the lead of the Theology Committee of the National House of Bishops, unanimously approved affirmations which say essentially that there is no consensus on this issue and we should not try to resolve it by legislation. These affirmations, which will be sent to the General Convention as a resolution, were endorsed by the Fourth Province Synod which consists of the Lay and Clergy Deputies to General Convention and the Bishops of the twenty dioceses of the province. Originally crafted by bishops on both sides of the issue, I believe they are a way forward without dividing the church, defeating our evangelistic efforts and fracturing our relationship with the rest of the Anglican Communion.
After having said all that, and there is obviously much more that could be said, I am still saddened by this turn of events but I am not discouraged or dismayed. God is faithful and our ultimate trust is in God, not in the institutional church. The church is not infallible =96 she can and has made mistakes. But the church is indefectible; that is, her purposes will not ultimately be thwarted, God will prevail. That means that God will win in the end and our job is to be faithful in the meantime. I am calling the faithful to be faithful; to stand firm in the faith of our mothers and fathers, the authority of the Holy Scriptures and the historic teaching and tradition once delivered to us by the saints. We have a goodly heritage in this diocese and an unlimited potential. Let us not grow weary in well doing; let us continue our works of mercy and evangelism. Let us press on toward the heavenly prize by working and praying harder, by giving more liberally of ourselves and our resources and remembering, that neither death nor life nor angels, nor principalities, nor things present, nor things to come, nor powers, nor height, nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 8:38-39)
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Monday, June 30, 2003
Was Jesus really silent on homosexuality?
Adelphoi,
I make a resolution to write not more on this topic that is in the British papers daily and then I get a flood of correspondence and in it are new questions and points to ponder. Thus...
Was Jesus really and truly silent on homosexuality?
The Bishop of Oxford and other supporters of the Christian Lesbigay agenda say that Jesus was silent on homosexuality. Some of us have agreed with them but then we have attempted to show that the mind of Jesus is the same as that of the Old Testament and his apostles on this matter.
But maybe Jesus was not wholly silent on this subject and did say something about homosexuality; and perhaps he did so not directly but by implicit reference, for those with ears to hear and eyes to see.
Consider this possibility which has been put to me by a learned friend.
In Matthew 10 and Mark 6, where the twelve disciples receive their first commission for evangelization, Jesus gives them instructions as to what to do if they and their message are rejected. "And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, as ye go forth thence, shake off the dust that is under your feet for a testimony against them. Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgment, than for that city." (Matthew 10:14-15)
Now let us recall that modern apologists for homosexual conduct frequently allege that the sin of Sodom and Gomorrah is not that of homosexual conduct but rather that of non-hospitality, or of homosexual rape or something else. Further, the view (adopted by the apostolic church and church fathers) that it is homosexual conduct which is the sin is alleged by the same apologists to be false and to have originated in a corrupt Pharisaic rabbinical interpretation, which was received by Sts. Paul, Peter and Jude (Cf. Rom. 9:29, II Pet. 2:6, and Jude 7.) .
These same apologists further employ an argument from silence -- that if Jesus did not explicitly condemn something, then he was not against it, and thus implicitly accepted it.
The fatal flaw in the argument based on the supposed rabbinical teaching is that this alleged corrupt interpretation was already in place at the time of Jesus (since St. Paul was taught it). Jesus could have condemned this argument (as he condemned the corrupt Pharisaic traditions regarding divorce) but he was silent. And, further, and most significantly, in positively citing Sodom and Gomorrah, Jesus accepted this [alleged corrupt] interpretation. He made it his own. Therefore, Jesus did condemn homosexual conduct per se as sinful, and the writings of Sts. Peter and Paul on the subject reflect the mind of Christ here also, not an alleged corrupt tradition in opposition to Jesus.
If this is so, then the only avenue left open to the apologists for the homosexual position is to drop their claim that Jesus did not condemn homosexual conduct per se, and to fall back on the position that the modern Church can set aside His teachings here, just as it has on divorce. Of course, they then abandon any claim that their position is founded on Christ's teachings and reflects a proper Christian understanding of "love" [agape]. They accept that it is based on a modern foundation only.
And this journey of thought takes us back to the point that I have been making a lot recently. That the basic Christian position - based on the identity of God as the Lord God, the God of Order, the Blessed Trinity (Three Persons in holy Order) and upon His revelation to us - is that this God of Order created man and woman in order, man the first woman the second. He so made them as to order them toward each other. Any other kind of ordering is thus against divine Order and revelation.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
I make a resolution to write not more on this topic that is in the British papers daily and then I get a flood of correspondence and in it are new questions and points to ponder. Thus...
Was Jesus really and truly silent on homosexuality?
The Bishop of Oxford and other supporters of the Christian Lesbigay agenda say that Jesus was silent on homosexuality. Some of us have agreed with them but then we have attempted to show that the mind of Jesus is the same as that of the Old Testament and his apostles on this matter.
But maybe Jesus was not wholly silent on this subject and did say something about homosexuality; and perhaps he did so not directly but by implicit reference, for those with ears to hear and eyes to see.
Consider this possibility which has been put to me by a learned friend.
In Matthew 10 and Mark 6, where the twelve disciples receive their first commission for evangelization, Jesus gives them instructions as to what to do if they and their message are rejected. "And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, as ye go forth thence, shake off the dust that is under your feet for a testimony against them. Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgment, than for that city." (Matthew 10:14-15)
Now let us recall that modern apologists for homosexual conduct frequently allege that the sin of Sodom and Gomorrah is not that of homosexual conduct but rather that of non-hospitality, or of homosexual rape or something else. Further, the view (adopted by the apostolic church and church fathers) that it is homosexual conduct which is the sin is alleged by the same apologists to be false and to have originated in a corrupt Pharisaic rabbinical interpretation, which was received by Sts. Paul, Peter and Jude (Cf. Rom. 9:29, II Pet. 2:6, and Jude 7.) .
These same apologists further employ an argument from silence -- that if Jesus did not explicitly condemn something, then he was not against it, and thus implicitly accepted it.
The fatal flaw in the argument based on the supposed rabbinical teaching is that this alleged corrupt interpretation was already in place at the time of Jesus (since St. Paul was taught it). Jesus could have condemned this argument (as he condemned the corrupt Pharisaic traditions regarding divorce) but he was silent. And, further, and most significantly, in positively citing Sodom and Gomorrah, Jesus accepted this [alleged corrupt] interpretation. He made it his own. Therefore, Jesus did condemn homosexual conduct per se as sinful, and the writings of Sts. Peter and Paul on the subject reflect the mind of Christ here also, not an alleged corrupt tradition in opposition to Jesus.
If this is so, then the only avenue left open to the apologists for the homosexual position is to drop their claim that Jesus did not condemn homosexual conduct per se, and to fall back on the position that the modern Church can set aside His teachings here, just as it has on divorce. Of course, they then abandon any claim that their position is founded on Christ's teachings and reflects a proper Christian understanding of "love" [agape]. They accept that it is based on a modern foundation only.
And this journey of thought takes us back to the point that I have been making a lot recently. That the basic Christian position - based on the identity of God as the Lord God, the God of Order, the Blessed Trinity (Three Persons in holy Order) and upon His revelation to us - is that this God of Order created man and woman in order, man the first woman the second. He so made them as to order them toward each other. Any other kind of ordering is thus against divine Order and revelation.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Bishop of Oxford: "Gay love's fine, its all in the Bible"
Controversy has the effect usually of pushing its participants deeper into their foundational principles.
This is the case with Bishop Richard Harries who has been defending his appointment of "a gay priest" to the suffragan bishopric of Reading. Here is part of what he wrote for The Sunday Times of London, 29th June, in his piece "Gay love's fine, it's all in the Bible" (sect/4.p.7).
Those who have listened to the arguments of the lesbigay lobby in the Episcopal Church and have also read the few writings on the doctrine of reception [with respect to women's ordination but easily transferred to lesbigay concerns] will be familiar with this argumentation, which is bold even if not sound.
Now he makes these arguments even though he insists earlier in the article that Dr John is no longer in an active sexual relationship with his male partner of many years. He even suggests that Dr John has brought all this to his Confessor and Spiritual Director and thus all is fine. However, he does accept and approve the fact that Dr John intends to work for the acceptance and blessing of same-sex couples who intend to live in stable relationships.
If the Bishop of Oxford is right in his arguments then the moral teaching of the Church through the centuries has been profoundly misguided and the position adopted by the Vatican recently is also deeply wrong. A few considerations..
As a minimum the C of E will soon accept, as a minority position but one described as one based on "conscience", the right of priests to live in same-sex relationships/partnerships and to be accorded full acceptance as such. Even leading evangelical Bishops appear to conceded this.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
This is the case with Bishop Richard Harries who has been defending his appointment of "a gay priest" to the suffragan bishopric of Reading. Here is part of what he wrote for The Sunday Times of London, 29th June, in his piece "Gay love's fine, it's all in the Bible" (sect/4.p.7).
"The crucial decision made by the first Christians was that the Gentiles could become Christians without being circumcised or obeying other aspects of Jewish law. Some, like Peter, found this very difficult. Then he had a dream in which he saw the Gentiles could be accepted fully. Perhaps like Peter, those opposed to this appointment will dream about people of the same sex loving one another through life and Jesus saying: 'This rejoices my heart; may it rejoice yours too'. Jesus said nothing about homosexuality. He did say something very fierce against divorce. The church, however, has made provision for divorced people to be married.
Gay and lesbian people find themselves with God-give affections for people of the same sex. If celibacy is not the chosen path, then, John [the 'gay' man appointed to be bishop] has urged the right course is a relationship of life-time love. Divorced people who remarry and gay and lesbian people who enter into such relationships are in a similar position. God takes them and their love, as it is, and blesses it."
Those who have listened to the arguments of the lesbigay lobby in the Episcopal Church and have also read the few writings on the doctrine of reception [with respect to women's ordination but easily transferred to lesbigay concerns] will be familiar with this argumentation, which is bold even if not sound.
1. The inclusion of "gay" and "lesbian" people in the church today is of similar importance to the inclusion of Gentiles, alongside the Jews, in the apostolic era.
2. Jesus rejoices to see two persons of the same sex living together in a partnership, which will include sexual acts.
3. Jesus said nothing about homosexuality [therefore he is not against it].
4. Jesus spoke against divorce [and thus remarriage] but the Church of England has in 2003 begun to allow the marriage of divorced persons [after centuries of forbidding it].
5. Persons who define themselves as "gay" or "lesbian" are made that way by God and thus they are to be accepted as such - with a permanent and God-given orientation.
6. "Gay" and "lesbian" persons should be given the same kind of rights in the Church as are given to divorced persons.
Now he makes these arguments even though he insists earlier in the article that Dr John is no longer in an active sexual relationship with his male partner of many years. He even suggests that Dr John has brought all this to his Confessor and Spiritual Director and thus all is fine. However, he does accept and approve the fact that Dr John intends to work for the acceptance and blessing of same-sex couples who intend to live in stable relationships.
If the Bishop of Oxford is right in his arguments then the moral teaching of the Church through the centuries has been profoundly misguided and the position adopted by the Vatican recently is also deeply wrong. A few considerations..
1. The admission of believing Gentiles into the [then] wholly Jewish Church was truly a momentous moment. It opened a door which is still wide open. To equate the inclusion of "gay" and "lesbian" people, who claim that they have an inbuilt orientation towards the same sex and who intend to fulfil this in practice, with the Gentiles is daring but preposterous. Such a claim can only stand if one previously has accepted a whole set of propositions about humanity, God, the church and so on.
2. To make the audacious claim that the heart of Jesus is made glad when he sees two persons of the same-sex in an intended life-long partnership is totally off mark. A bishop should not make such claims for he has no way whatsoever of showing it to be true or even possibly true from either Scripture of Tradition. He has to call in "experience" (a favourite source of revelation for such as Dr Harries) and this is a very shaky foundation indeed.
3. Certainly Jesus is not recorded as speaking about homosexuality. But he is recorded as saying much about the nature of man, of the relation of man and woman and so on. Jesus accepted the authority of the Hebrew Scriptures which he fulfilled in his Person and in his Teaching and in his Saving Work. The inference to draw from his not being recorded as addressing the topic of homosexuality is that he accepted the moral law as received by the Jews on this, and that his mind is further reflected in what his apostles said about it.
4. The Bishop has a point in what he says about divorce and remarriage. Once the Church gives up her received morality and makes adjustments to suit the pressures of the times then she is vulnerable on other fronts. Open one door and there is banging on the other door to be opened (as the history of the ECUSA in recent times abundantly shows).
5. In modern society, where the right to divorce and remarriage by the State is long established, and where now the rights of "gay" and "lesbian" couples to various rights (especially health and death benefits) are being quickly accepted, the church needs to keep all doors closed if she is to keep any closed! The fact that the Church of England has open one big door means that she will very soon open another and afterwards even more.
As a minimum the C of E will soon accept, as a minority position but one described as one based on "conscience", the right of priests to live in same-sex relationships/partnerships and to be accorded full acceptance as such. Even leading evangelical Bishops appear to conceded this.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Leader of the Kirk welcomes gay clergy
(from English Daily Telegraph, Monday 30th June)
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Leader of the Kirk welcomes gay clergy
By Tom Peterkin
(Filed: 30/06/2003)
The leader of the Church of Scotland has said for the first time that he has no objection to openly homosexual ministers being ordained in the Kirk.
The new Moderator of the Church of Scotland, the Rt Rev Prof Iain Torrance, has become the first leader to welcome the idea of homosexual ministers in the Kirk's 500-year history.
Prof Torrance said he was "utterly untroubled" by the ordination of homosexuals provided that they proved "disciplined and effective" ministers.
His remarks represent a major shift in the Church's view and are likely to be met with fierce opposition from traditionalists. Prof Torrance was speaking at the weekend following the controversy in the Church of England surrounding the appointment of Jeffrey John, a homosexual, as the Bishop of Reading.
Prof Torrance's comments in an interview with the Sunday Times are likely to provoke a similar row north of the border.
The Moderator said sexuality should not act as an impediment to those wanting to join the ministry and promised that homosexual ministers who encountered prejudice from congregations would be given help to move to another parish. Harry Reid, the author of the book Outside Verdict, which examined the issues facing the Church, said: "The Moderator's comments will take the debate much further on. But it will also bring what has been a festering issue for some time into the open.
"As a result, there could be a schism within the Church. There is undoubtedly a very significant minority in the Kirk, particularly north of Inverness, who will be appalled by the thought of the Church having a number of openly homosexual clergy."
Prof Torrance's views on the matter have changed since 1994 when he was one of six ministers to oppose a report to the General Assembly that recognised homosexuality and sex outside marriage for the first time.
Now he said he was prepared to cite the report to justify the appointment of the Kirk's first openly homosexual minister.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Sunday, June 29, 2003
The Bishop of Liverpool on the bishopric of Reading.
There was a live interview this morning (29th June) by the BBC of the Bishop of Liverpool on the controversy surrounding the recent appointment of Dr John to the suffragan bishopric of Reading in the diocese of Oxford. (Today also there is an interview in the London Sunday Times with the Bishop of Oxford, where he defends his appointment of Dr John.)
The Bp of Liverpool is an attractive evangelical spokesman who does not support the ordination of active homosexual persons because he accepts a traditional sexual ethic. However, his way to solve this controversy will open the door for the acceptance as a norm of such persons into the ordained Ministry.
First of all, he wants the Church to go back as it were to a point before the appointment of Dr John (i.e., he wants a way to be found to cancel this appointment) and then he wants there to be a full debate in the C of E leading to a vote in the General Synod about this matter.
The model he offers is significantly that of the process the C of E went through over the ordination of women. There was debate; there was a vote in favour; and importantly there was provision for people who in good conscience could not accept the innovation. In the latter case the provision was of "flying Bishops".
The fact that he insists that the informed consciences of church members should be respected and honoured means that, as in the debate over women and ordination, there will be the majority and the minority (and people caught in the middle not knowing what to think). If the majority is in favour of accepting the rights of those who wish to be active homosexual persons, then suitable provisions will have to be made for the evangelicals, anglo-catholics and traditionalists whose consciences tell them that all forms of active homosexuality are wrong before God. If the majority is in the other direction then likewise there will need to be provisions for the rights of those who wish to be active homosexual persons in the church.
By using the model of the process to resolution of the question of women's ordination, the Bishop has ensured that the Lesbigay lobby has already achieved one of its major goals in the Church of England - and done so in the thinking of evangelical bishops - that of the acceptance of the claims of active homosexual persons to be doing what is within the sexual morality of the Church. In fact, while he holds to the authority of Scripture, he has conceded that for practical purposes the morality approved by the Church of England has to be based on modern theories of human rights!
In contrast, the Roman Catholic Church through the Vatican is in the process of putting in place rules which will make it extremely difficult for a person who says he is homosexually inclined to be ordained in the future.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
The Bp of Liverpool is an attractive evangelical spokesman who does not support the ordination of active homosexual persons because he accepts a traditional sexual ethic. However, his way to solve this controversy will open the door for the acceptance as a norm of such persons into the ordained Ministry.
First of all, he wants the Church to go back as it were to a point before the appointment of Dr John (i.e., he wants a way to be found to cancel this appointment) and then he wants there to be a full debate in the C of E leading to a vote in the General Synod about this matter.
The model he offers is significantly that of the process the C of E went through over the ordination of women. There was debate; there was a vote in favour; and importantly there was provision for people who in good conscience could not accept the innovation. In the latter case the provision was of "flying Bishops".
The fact that he insists that the informed consciences of church members should be respected and honoured means that, as in the debate over women and ordination, there will be the majority and the minority (and people caught in the middle not knowing what to think). If the majority is in favour of accepting the rights of those who wish to be active homosexual persons, then suitable provisions will have to be made for the evangelicals, anglo-catholics and traditionalists whose consciences tell them that all forms of active homosexuality are wrong before God. If the majority is in the other direction then likewise there will need to be provisions for the rights of those who wish to be active homosexual persons in the church.
By using the model of the process to resolution of the question of women's ordination, the Bishop has ensured that the Lesbigay lobby has already achieved one of its major goals in the Church of England - and done so in the thinking of evangelical bishops - that of the acceptance of the claims of active homosexual persons to be doing what is within the sexual morality of the Church. In fact, while he holds to the authority of Scripture, he has conceded that for practical purposes the morality approved by the Church of England has to be based on modern theories of human rights!
In contrast, the Roman Catholic Church through the Vatican is in the process of putting in place rules which will make it extremely difficult for a person who says he is homosexually inclined to be ordained in the future.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Saturday, June 28, 2003
Two unlikely partners
Adelphoi,
A discussion starter
Not a few people write to me to express their viewpoint that it is most regrettable that women's ordination is discussed alongside or together with the ordination of persons who openly state that they are "gay" and in a stable partnership, a relationship which they say should be blessed by the Church. The reason for this regret or even anger and pain is, I think, reasonably obvious in most cases. Most of the opposition to the ordination of women has been and remains intellectual [theological], with some emotional blow-ups here and there. Many church members cannot see the reasons for opposing the progress of women to leadership roles when they have moved ahead elsewhere. However, the resistance to "gay ordinations & partnerships" is in large part "aesthetic," in the sense that any kind of homosexual activity that is open and obvious affronts middle-class sensibilities. Thus the latter cause is likely to be resisted more and longer than the former in most of the churches.
The obvious reason why the two are linked together - and in this sense cannot be prized apart practically - is that in the second half of the 20th century (from the 1960s in particular) both innovations in the Church have gained their primary support from the powerful human rights movement (which has included many other rights in the civil sphere). Were it not for their skilful use of and immersion in the human rights movement, it is highly unlikely whether either would have gained the substantial victories that they have in the State and in the churches. We need to be wholly aware that since for practical purposes the language and content of modern morality in the West is dominated by human rights, once any group within society is able to demonstrate that its agenda and pleas are really all about human rights it is usually on a winning run for it has an acceptable moral foundation & case.
But of course more is needed that the context, ethos and principles of human rights for an agenda to become a church agenda. In the case of women being admitted to the role of pastors in the churches the Bible was brought in to assist the case for equality and dignity already made by human rights principles. And with spectacles created in the factory of human works the Bible was seen in new perspective and light. A whole industry of scholarship arose to present the meaning of the Bible in a different way than it had been read for centuries. Behind its obvious perceived patriarchalism and sexism, principles of equality were seen and these were harnessed for the cause. Thus a continuing favourite verse has been Galatians 3:28: "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus." Some advocates of women's ordination within the churches even went so far as to claim that their case was wholly Biblical (for they were not fully aware of how a cultural context, ethos & zeitgeist affect one 's reading of the Bible).
Likewise with the blessing of same-sex partnerships and the ordaining of "gay" persons (male & female). In the powerful context of human rights & convinced by experience, reason and some selected scientific studies that what they had and enjoyed in their intimate same-sex partnerships was of God, religiously inclined "gay" persons and their supporters in the churches looked at the Bible in new light. What they saw was certainly God's condemnation of a variety of same-sex activities based on wild passion, prostitution, violence, child abuse and the like. But what they did not see or find - and this is hugely significant - was the condemnation of faithful, loving same-sex partnerships (simply because the ancient world did not encourage or know such relationships). Further, they made a lot of the fact that in the recorded teaching of Jesus there is no specific condemnation of same-sex relations. Thus they declared that the Bible does not address and therefore does not condemn faithful, monogamous, covenantal same-sex partnerships. And since their experience of them brought them blessings, they can be/even must be "of God". Thus they had the right to be blessed by the church in their partnerships.
So it has been the case that two different causes, both originating and energized by the human rights movement, have since the 1960s entered the church (where they were welcomed by some members and leaders) and have skilfully used the language of religion, the contents of the Bible and pre-eminently the name of "God" (which they have nearly successfully changed the grammatical gender of - from masculine to neither) to establish their innovations as not merely plausible but credible. In the one case, the ordination of women the work seems to be well on its way to being completed in the West/North in the Protestant Churches (with a minority still against it on theological grounds) and, in the other case, the acceptance of "gay partnerships", it is a work in progress but making major headway, even though still met by middle-class emotional opposition as well as (minority) intellectual/theological arguments. 2003 may the year for major steps forward being achieved by those pressing for full rights for "gay" persons in the churches.
It is true that a particular context or issue or scientific development within general culture can cause the Church to look into the Scriptures and see there teaching that previously had been missed or not taken seriously. This is hardly the case with respect to the ordination of women and of "gay" persons. Since the 1960s what has been seen in Scripture has generally speaking been found there to support a case that already is believed or assumed on the basis of secular culture, in particular human rights' claims.
The patristic argument against both women's ordination and all forms of sexual relations outside of marriage was based on Order - that is, within the creation of the cosmos and of human beings and also within the old and new covenants of grace there is a divine revealed Order and this exists to reflect the Holy Order that is the Holy Trinity (where the Father is first in Order, the Son second and the Holy Ghost, third in order). This Order is reflected in the word "God created man: male and female created he them" - i.e. created in an ordered relation and thus the man is first in order and the women second and this order applies in the sexual relation of holy matrimony and in the ordering of the Church.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
A discussion starter
Not a few people write to me to express their viewpoint that it is most regrettable that women's ordination is discussed alongside or together with the ordination of persons who openly state that they are "gay" and in a stable partnership, a relationship which they say should be blessed by the Church. The reason for this regret or even anger and pain is, I think, reasonably obvious in most cases. Most of the opposition to the ordination of women has been and remains intellectual [theological], with some emotional blow-ups here and there. Many church members cannot see the reasons for opposing the progress of women to leadership roles when they have moved ahead elsewhere. However, the resistance to "gay ordinations & partnerships" is in large part "aesthetic," in the sense that any kind of homosexual activity that is open and obvious affronts middle-class sensibilities. Thus the latter cause is likely to be resisted more and longer than the former in most of the churches.
The obvious reason why the two are linked together - and in this sense cannot be prized apart practically - is that in the second half of the 20th century (from the 1960s in particular) both innovations in the Church have gained their primary support from the powerful human rights movement (which has included many other rights in the civil sphere). Were it not for their skilful use of and immersion in the human rights movement, it is highly unlikely whether either would have gained the substantial victories that they have in the State and in the churches. We need to be wholly aware that since for practical purposes the language and content of modern morality in the West is dominated by human rights, once any group within society is able to demonstrate that its agenda and pleas are really all about human rights it is usually on a winning run for it has an acceptable moral foundation & case.
But of course more is needed that the context, ethos and principles of human rights for an agenda to become a church agenda. In the case of women being admitted to the role of pastors in the churches the Bible was brought in to assist the case for equality and dignity already made by human rights principles. And with spectacles created in the factory of human works the Bible was seen in new perspective and light. A whole industry of scholarship arose to present the meaning of the Bible in a different way than it had been read for centuries. Behind its obvious perceived patriarchalism and sexism, principles of equality were seen and these were harnessed for the cause. Thus a continuing favourite verse has been Galatians 3:28: "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus." Some advocates of women's ordination within the churches even went so far as to claim that their case was wholly Biblical (for they were not fully aware of how a cultural context, ethos & zeitgeist affect one 's reading of the Bible).
Likewise with the blessing of same-sex partnerships and the ordaining of "gay" persons (male & female). In the powerful context of human rights & convinced by experience, reason and some selected scientific studies that what they had and enjoyed in their intimate same-sex partnerships was of God, religiously inclined "gay" persons and their supporters in the churches looked at the Bible in new light. What they saw was certainly God's condemnation of a variety of same-sex activities based on wild passion, prostitution, violence, child abuse and the like. But what they did not see or find - and this is hugely significant - was the condemnation of faithful, loving same-sex partnerships (simply because the ancient world did not encourage or know such relationships). Further, they made a lot of the fact that in the recorded teaching of Jesus there is no specific condemnation of same-sex relations. Thus they declared that the Bible does not address and therefore does not condemn faithful, monogamous, covenantal same-sex partnerships. And since their experience of them brought them blessings, they can be/even must be "of God". Thus they had the right to be blessed by the church in their partnerships.
So it has been the case that two different causes, both originating and energized by the human rights movement, have since the 1960s entered the church (where they were welcomed by some members and leaders) and have skilfully used the language of religion, the contents of the Bible and pre-eminently the name of "God" (which they have nearly successfully changed the grammatical gender of - from masculine to neither) to establish their innovations as not merely plausible but credible. In the one case, the ordination of women the work seems to be well on its way to being completed in the West/North in the Protestant Churches (with a minority still against it on theological grounds) and, in the other case, the acceptance of "gay partnerships", it is a work in progress but making major headway, even though still met by middle-class emotional opposition as well as (minority) intellectual/theological arguments. 2003 may the year for major steps forward being achieved by those pressing for full rights for "gay" persons in the churches.
It is true that a particular context or issue or scientific development within general culture can cause the Church to look into the Scriptures and see there teaching that previously had been missed or not taken seriously. This is hardly the case with respect to the ordination of women and of "gay" persons. Since the 1960s what has been seen in Scripture has generally speaking been found there to support a case that already is believed or assumed on the basis of secular culture, in particular human rights' claims.
The patristic argument against both women's ordination and all forms of sexual relations outside of marriage was based on Order - that is, within the creation of the cosmos and of human beings and also within the old and new covenants of grace there is a divine revealed Order and this exists to reflect the Holy Order that is the Holy Trinity (where the Father is first in Order, the Son second and the Holy Ghost, third in order). This Order is reflected in the word "God created man: male and female created he them" - i.e. created in an ordered relation and thus the man is first in order and the women second and this order applies in the sexual relation of holy matrimony and in the ordering of the Church.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Masterpieces of Vatican Museums Now on Internet
Virtual Galleries Included Those Now Closed to the Public
VATICAN CITY, JUNE 24, 2003 (Zenit.org).- An ambitious multimedia project has made it possible for Internet users to get a glimpse at the Sistine Chapel and other immortal works of Vatican art.
The novelty, offered on the Holy See's Web page (www.vatican.va) in the Vatican Museums section, took five years to complete. It was presented to the press today in the Vatican.
The most important works of Renaissance artists Michelangelo, Raphael, Leonardo da Vinci, and galleries of Egyptian and Classic Greco-Roman art are presented, with technical explanations given by experts who catalogue and conserve them.
Cardinal Edmund Szoka, president of the Governorate of Vatican City State, observed that the new site "further enriches the Holy See's Web site, created years ago and in continual and progressive expansion."
"For some time, the Church has paid great attention to the means of social communication, in order to more efficaciously perform her universal mission," the Michigan-born cardinal said. "The Internet, with its enormous potential, allows us to approach an ever greater number of people and to spread throughout the world our message of evangelization."
Archbishop Claudio Maria Celli, secretary of the administration of the patrimony of the Apostolic See, which oversees the Vatican's Internet Office, noted the imposing work carried out by Vatican computer technicians to block viruses or cybernetic attacks.
Francesco Buranelli, director of the museums of Vatican City State, explained that the site "will allow the public to access the inestimable artistic heritage that these museums have preserved and protected for centuries," and highlighted the "effort to make it possible in five languages: Italian, French, English, Spanish and German."
Thanks to this new site, the Ethnological Missionary Museum can be visited. This museum has been inaccessible to the public for some time because it is being restructured.
The digitalization and presentation of the Sistine Chapel and the Raphael Rooms makes it possible for browsers to amplify aspects of the paintings.
Pictorial explanations have been prepared by directors of various sections of the museums. The sources of biblical texts that inspired the artists are also indicated.
Vatican spokesman JoaquĆn Navarro-Valls noted two aspects of the project: "the possibility of the virtual visit for people who live outside from Rome, and the possibility to personally choose the itinerary that will be followed in a real visit to the museums."
Nicola Aliperti, a representative of Hewlett-Packard Italy, the company that gave technical assistance in the project, remarked that "in the future the patrimony presented in the Vatican Museums, which UNESCO defined as 'the patrimony of mankind,' will be accessible through the wireless means of palm pilots."
Internet users cannot download the pictures on the Web page. If an attempt is made, the images will disappear automatically. ZE03062406
VATICAN CITY, JUNE 24, 2003 (Zenit.org).- An ambitious multimedia project has made it possible for Internet users to get a glimpse at the Sistine Chapel and other immortal works of Vatican art.
The novelty, offered on the Holy See's Web page (www.vatican.va) in the Vatican Museums section, took five years to complete. It was presented to the press today in the Vatican.
The most important works of Renaissance artists Michelangelo, Raphael, Leonardo da Vinci, and galleries of Egyptian and Classic Greco-Roman art are presented, with technical explanations given by experts who catalogue and conserve them.
Cardinal Edmund Szoka, president of the Governorate of Vatican City State, observed that the new site "further enriches the Holy See's Web site, created years ago and in continual and progressive expansion."
"For some time, the Church has paid great attention to the means of social communication, in order to more efficaciously perform her universal mission," the Michigan-born cardinal said. "The Internet, with its enormous potential, allows us to approach an ever greater number of people and to spread throughout the world our message of evangelization."
Archbishop Claudio Maria Celli, secretary of the administration of the patrimony of the Apostolic See, which oversees the Vatican's Internet Office, noted the imposing work carried out by Vatican computer technicians to block viruses or cybernetic attacks.
Francesco Buranelli, director of the museums of Vatican City State, explained that the site "will allow the public to access the inestimable artistic heritage that these museums have preserved and protected for centuries," and highlighted the "effort to make it possible in five languages: Italian, French, English, Spanish and German."
Thanks to this new site, the Ethnological Missionary Museum can be visited. This museum has been inaccessible to the public for some time because it is being restructured.
The digitalization and presentation of the Sistine Chapel and the Raphael Rooms makes it possible for browsers to amplify aspects of the paintings.
Pictorial explanations have been prepared by directors of various sections of the museums. The sources of biblical texts that inspired the artists are also indicated.
Vatican spokesman JoaquĆn Navarro-Valls noted two aspects of the project: "the possibility of the virtual visit for people who live outside from Rome, and the possibility to personally choose the itinerary that will be followed in a real visit to the museums."
Nicola Aliperti, a representative of Hewlett-Packard Italy, the company that gave technical assistance in the project, remarked that "in the future the patrimony presented in the Vatican Museums, which UNESCO defined as 'the patrimony of mankind,' will be accessible through the wireless means of palm pilots."
Internet users cannot download the pictures on the Web page. If an attempt is made, the images will disappear automatically. ZE03062406
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)