23rd June 2003
Dear Brothers in Christ
None of us will need any persuading that the recent appointment of Canon Jeffrey John as Bishop of Reading has proved a controversial and challenging one. It has become a focus for a great deal of debate, in which differing views of the appointment and its significance have been widely aired, inside and outside the Church here, and indeed much further afield.
At this point in the debate - particularly since some of you have already voiced serious concerns - it is important that I try to clarify basic issues, in my capacity as Archbishop of Canterbury and Chairman of the House of Bishops.
First, about the appointment process. As you know, the appointment of a suffragan bishop is made by the Crown, on the advice of a diocesan as forwarded by the Archbishop of the province. And that is what has happened on this occasion. It is not for me to recount the diocesan process. But so far as my own involvement is concerned, you should know it is an appointment I have neither sought to promote nor to obstruct.
I was informed that Canon Jeffrey John was regarded as a highly gifted candidate, was acceptable to the diocese, that he had given explicit assurances on various matters, including his personal circumstances and his willingness to work loyally within the framework of doctrine and discipline as expressed in Issues in Human Sexuality. With these assurances, since repeated very publicly, and in keeping with the principle that the integrity of the process within the diocese should be respected, I raised no objection to forwarding his name.
Despite what some have claimed, I do not believe this overall process weakens the commitment of the House of Bishops to what we have declared as our common mind. Nor do I believe that Canon John's appointment either subverts current discipline or forecloses future discussion. It would certainly be deplorable if it were assumed that the existing approach has been abandoned by stealth, or that the forthcoming guide to the debate on sexuality that we have agreed to publish, was slanted towards a change in that policy. So, let us be clear: there can be no question of trying to pre-empt, undermine or short-circuit the reflection of the Church as a whole.
It is also important here, to stress to the wider Anglican Communion that we are not embarking on or colluding with any policy of unilateral local change, which I have more than once deplored elsewhere.
Two final and important points. The concerns of many in the diocese of Oxford are theologically serious, intelligible and by no means based on narrow party allegiance or on prejudice. They must be addressed and considered fully. Confidence in the ability of a new bishop to minister to those in his pastoral care is a centrally important matter, and it is clear that serious questions remain in the diocese. To consider these with prayerfulness and maturity needs time and a measure of calm. It is not for anyone outside the diocese to override or pre-empt what is obviously a painful and complex process, and I can only ask your prayers for the diocese as it struggles with this and tries to find a right discernment.
Finally, it would be a tragedy if these issues, in the Church of England and in the Communion, occupied so much energy that we lost our focus on the priorities of our mission, the priorities given us by Our Lord. What we say about sexuality (and not just on the same-sex question) is a necessary part of our faithfulness, but the concentration on this in recent weeks has had the effect of generating real incomprehension in much of our society, in a way that does nothing for our credibility. In the world where we are called to offer the Good News of Jesus, we need to reflect on this dimension of the situation - not to surrender to alien standards, but to keep our eyes on those central revealed truths without which other matters of behaviour and discipline will never make sense.
In a few weeks, I shall be making a pastoral visit to West Africa. Some of our local issues are there too, of course, but so are most of the greatest wounds of our age, afflicting millions - violent conflict, epidemic disease, instability and poverty. Faithful Christian witness shines through all this, and we are deeply thankful for it. It does us no harm to think about our own priorities against such a background, and perhaps to learn in some matters to give each other a little more time and space for thought as we try to find how we can walk in step as the Body of Christ - not falling over ourselves because of anxiety and suspicion.
+Rowan Cantuar
Lambeth Palace
23rd June 2003
Tuesday, June 24, 2003
Monday, June 23, 2003
The Second Sunday after Trinity
Adelphoi,
There is a profound petition in the Collect for the Second Sunday after Trinity. Please read on.
"O Lord, who never failest to help and govern them whom thou dost bring up in thy steadfast fear and love: Keep us, we beseech thee, under the protection of thy good providence, and make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy name; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen."
The Epistle: 1 John 4. 7-21 The Gospel: St Luke 14. 16-24
Previous to the 1662 edition of The Book of Common Prayer this Collect was similar but shorter:
"Lord, make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy name; for thou never failest to help and govern them whom thou dost bring up in thy steadfast love."
Let us focus on the petition in both these Collects.
As baptized Christians, members of the Household of God, we ask from God to have perpetually in our souls - minds, hearts and wills -two profound affections towards God the Father through Jesus Christ our Lord.
And, further, we ask that we may have these two affections in our souls concurrently, not one for a while and then the other for a while, but both there together and always. We ask both for a perpetual fear of God's holy Name and for a perpetual love of God's holy Name. In biblical terms, the Name of God stands for the revealed Character of God, thus for God himself, for God the Father or God the Father together with his only begotten Son and the Holy Ghost.
Most of us have no difficulty in thinking that we ought constantly to love God's holy Name for the first and great commandment is that we are to love God with all our heart and soul and mind and strength.
But perhaps some of us have real difficulty in thinking it a duty to fear God constantly. Does not perfect love cast out fear (see 1 John 4:18)? Yes it does, the fear of punishment by God the holy Judge, the fear of hell-fire and the fear of condemnation - for there is no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus.
But there is another meaning of fear in the Bible and it is a profound sense of awe, submission and reverence of the creature before the all-Holy, all-Majestic God, Creator & Judge of heaven & earth, the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity. This filial and godly fear in the soul of the child of God is the beginning of knowledge and wisdom in terms of God's ways, will and purposes - as the Psalmists testify. Even those who within the new covenant are brought near to God by the blood of Christ Jesus, and in whom the Spirit testifies to their spirits that they are the children of God the Father, ought never be other than filled with reverence and awe in their relation to God, who is always and ever the Infinite, Eternal Glorious and Holy One.
Love with filial fear is like a ship without ballast; it has no steadfastness and it is wavering, fluctuating, unstable and uncertain.
When we love God in reverence and filial fear, our love is not sentimental and sloppy but solid and secure.
When we fear God in love toward him, this fear is not fear of hell-fire or everlasting condemnation, but deep and profound humility & awe before his overwhelming greatness and holiness.
The more ardently we love God the more we fear him with filial reverence and
awe: and the more we ardently fear God the more we love him with all our being.
Thus let us pray all next week...
"Make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy Name."
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
There is a profound petition in the Collect for the Second Sunday after Trinity. Please read on.
"O Lord, who never failest to help and govern them whom thou dost bring up in thy steadfast fear and love: Keep us, we beseech thee, under the protection of thy good providence, and make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy name; through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen."
The Epistle: 1 John 4. 7-21 The Gospel: St Luke 14. 16-24
Previous to the 1662 edition of The Book of Common Prayer this Collect was similar but shorter:
"Lord, make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy name; for thou never failest to help and govern them whom thou dost bring up in thy steadfast love."
Let us focus on the petition in both these Collects.
As baptized Christians, members of the Household of God, we ask from God to have perpetually in our souls - minds, hearts and wills -two profound affections towards God the Father through Jesus Christ our Lord.
And, further, we ask that we may have these two affections in our souls concurrently, not one for a while and then the other for a while, but both there together and always. We ask both for a perpetual fear of God's holy Name and for a perpetual love of God's holy Name. In biblical terms, the Name of God stands for the revealed Character of God, thus for God himself, for God the Father or God the Father together with his only begotten Son and the Holy Ghost.
Most of us have no difficulty in thinking that we ought constantly to love God's holy Name for the first and great commandment is that we are to love God with all our heart and soul and mind and strength.
But perhaps some of us have real difficulty in thinking it a duty to fear God constantly. Does not perfect love cast out fear (see 1 John 4:18)? Yes it does, the fear of punishment by God the holy Judge, the fear of hell-fire and the fear of condemnation - for there is no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus.
But there is another meaning of fear in the Bible and it is a profound sense of awe, submission and reverence of the creature before the all-Holy, all-Majestic God, Creator & Judge of heaven & earth, the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity. This filial and godly fear in the soul of the child of God is the beginning of knowledge and wisdom in terms of God's ways, will and purposes - as the Psalmists testify. Even those who within the new covenant are brought near to God by the blood of Christ Jesus, and in whom the Spirit testifies to their spirits that they are the children of God the Father, ought never be other than filled with reverence and awe in their relation to God, who is always and ever the Infinite, Eternal Glorious and Holy One.
Love with filial fear is like a ship without ballast; it has no steadfastness and it is wavering, fluctuating, unstable and uncertain.
When we love God in reverence and filial fear, our love is not sentimental and sloppy but solid and secure.
When we fear God in love toward him, this fear is not fear of hell-fire or everlasting condemnation, but deep and profound humility & awe before his overwhelming greatness and holiness.
The more ardently we love God the more we fear him with filial reverence and
awe: and the more we ardently fear God the more we love him with all our being.
Thus let us pray all next week...
"Make us to have a perpetual fear and love of thy holy Name."
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Saturday, June 21, 2003
Reading the Bible With the Church Fathers
Interview With Historian Robert Louis Wilken
ROME, JUNE 19, 2003 (Zenit.org).- Interest in the wisdom and writings of the Church fathers has exploded recently among Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox Christians.
In an effort to describe the spiritual and theological vision of the fathers, University of Virginia Church-historian Robert Louis Wilken has published a new book, "The Spirit of Early Christian Thought: Seeking the Face of God" (Yale). He discussed his book with ZENIT while in Rome as a McCarthy lecturer at the Gregorian University.
Q: The title of your book brings to mind Étienne Gilson's book "The Spirit of Medieval Philosophy." Was this a conscious decision on your part?
Wilken: I would not want to compare myself with the great Catholic philosopher and historian of philosophy Étienne Gilson, but there was a sense in which I hoped to do for the world of the early Church what Gilson had done for medieval philosophy.
Of course there are large differences between early Christian thought and medieval thought. But Gilson hoped to give readers a feel for what animated the whole, hence the term "spirit" in the title.
Also, though he dealt with Christian thought in a particular historical period, the Middle Ages, he intended his book to say something about the ongoing significance of medieval philosophy....
My aim was to depict the pattern of Christian thinking as it took shape in the first centuries, how Christians thought about the things they believed. I try to see things whole, to present persons and ideas as part of a common tradition rooted in a specific historical period yet not bound to time. Though long dead, the Church fathers maintain their ground.
Q: It is apparent in your book how central the Bible was for the Church fathers. Why is this fact often obscured in the histories of the early Church?
Wilken: There has been a major shift in the study of the early Church in the last two generations. In the 1940s a group of French Jesuits, most notably Jean Danielou and Henri de Lubac, began to publish a series of early Christian texts entitled "Sources Chrétiennes," or Christian sources.
Danielou and de Lubac were reacting against the way theology was being taught in Catholic seminaries and schools of theology in the early part of the 20th century. They felt that theology had lost contact with the imaginative world of the Bible, a world of images and metaphors, of story and history, and believed that the way to recover this aspect of Christian thinking was to publish modern translations of classical Christian texts.
Today, "Sources Chrétiennes" is approaching 500 volumes and many are of works that had never been translated into a modern language. Some were biblical commentaries, for example, a large commentary on the Gospel of John by Origen of Alexandria, the first great Christian biblical scholar.
In the book I give many examples of how the Bible shaped Christian thinking, for example, the doctrine of the Trinity, the person of Christ, the moral life. Even a topic such as the freedom of the will, something that had long been discussed by Greek philosophers, became for Christians a discussion about the proper interpretation of key biblical texts.
As I tell my students, in reading the Church fathers one should always have a Bible open on one's desk.
Q: The title of your McCarthy lecture at the Gregorian was "The Inevitability of Allegory." Many people today believe that "allegory," giving a passage another sense than the plain sense, has no place in modern biblical interpretation. Isn't the historical approach to the Bible one of the most important developments in Catholic thinking in the 20th century?
Wilken: It is indeed. And again a little history might help clarify things. The same year that "Sources Chrétiennes" began publishing, 1943, Pope Pius XII issued the encyclical, "Divino Afflante Spiritu." This encyclical was the magna carta for Catholic biblical scholarship.
However, just at the moment that Catholic biblical scholars believed they had won the right to study the Bible historically, another group of Catholic scholars were urging a reappropriation of the classical Christian way of interpreting the Bible.
So there is some tension between how the Church fathers interpret and use the Bible and how modern historical scholarship views things. Yet I don't think that they are in fundamental conflict, and in many respects they complement one another.
Q: Could you give an example?
Wilken: You will remember the well-known passage in Romans 10 where St. Paul says it is not possible to believe unless one has heard, and one cannot hear without a preacher. Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the preaching of Christ. Then he quotes from Psalm 19, "Their voice has gone out to all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world."
In its original setting the first part of Psalm 19 -- Psalm 18 in the Vulgate -- celebrates the silent witness of the heavens to the majesty of God. "The heavens are telling the glory of God; and the firmament proclaims his handiwork. ... There is no speech, nor are there words; their voice is not heard."
Paul, however, interprets the text not in relation to the knowledge of God displayed in creation but as a psalm about the mission of the apostles. He understands the psalm in relation to the new thing that had happened, the coming of Christ and the preaching of the Gospel. In other words, he gives the passage another sense than its obvious or plain meaning.
Paul's interpretation of the psalm had large consequences, for it passed over into the Church's worship, most notably in daily prayer. Whenever we celebrate the feast of an apostle, one of the psalms appointed to be read in the office of readings is Psalm 19 whose words "their voice has gone out to the limits of the earth, their words to the end of the world" are used as the antiphon.
For those who pray with the Church the apostolic interpretation of Psalm 19 is as familiar and natural as the original or plain sense of the psalm.
This does not mean that the original meaning of the psalm is abandoned. It stands confidently as a testimony to the witness of creation to the mystery and majesty of God. At the same time the allegorical or spiritual interpretation became a precious and fixed part of the Church's life and worship. The two interpretations live comfortably side by side.
Q: It is interesting that the example you chose comes from the Church's prayer, from worship. What is the relation between liturgy and the interpretation of the Bible?
Wilken: The Church fathers were men of prayer and even when writing learned treatises in their studies they were never far from the Church's worship. In the liturgy they came to know Christ not so much as a historical figure from the past, but as a living person present in the Eucharist.
When they opened their Bibles they discovered this same Christ not only in the writings of the evangelists and St. Paul but also in the Old Testament. In the liturgy the words of the Scripture are alive and filled with the mystery of Christ.
For example, in the great Vigil of Easter in ancient times, when the newly baptized were preparing to receive communion for the first time, Psalm 42 was sung: "As the deer yearns for living waters, so longs my soul for you, O Lord."
The regular reading of the Scriptures in the liturgy and the recitation of the psalms in daily prayer worked powerfully on the minds of Christian interpreters. One might say that the Bible provided a lexicon of words for Christian speech and the liturgy a grammar of how they are to be used.
Q: What is the enduring significance of the early Christian understanding of the Bible?
Wilken: In spite of its many accomplishments, a strictly historical approach to the Bible can only give us a medley of documents from different times and places in the ancient world. It cannot give us the book of the Church, the Scriptures as heard by Christians for centuries, the psalms imprinted on the Church's soul, the words and images that bear witness to the Holy Trinity.
If we ignore the first readers of the Bible we are left with a collection of fragments, interesting in their own right, but lacking the unity that only the living Christ can give.
ZE03061926
ROME, JUNE 19, 2003 (Zenit.org).- Interest in the wisdom and writings of the Church fathers has exploded recently among Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox Christians.
In an effort to describe the spiritual and theological vision of the fathers, University of Virginia Church-historian Robert Louis Wilken has published a new book, "The Spirit of Early Christian Thought: Seeking the Face of God" (Yale). He discussed his book with ZENIT while in Rome as a McCarthy lecturer at the Gregorian University.
Q: The title of your book brings to mind Étienne Gilson's book "The Spirit of Medieval Philosophy." Was this a conscious decision on your part?
Wilken: I would not want to compare myself with the great Catholic philosopher and historian of philosophy Étienne Gilson, but there was a sense in which I hoped to do for the world of the early Church what Gilson had done for medieval philosophy.
Of course there are large differences between early Christian thought and medieval thought. But Gilson hoped to give readers a feel for what animated the whole, hence the term "spirit" in the title.
Also, though he dealt with Christian thought in a particular historical period, the Middle Ages, he intended his book to say something about the ongoing significance of medieval philosophy....
My aim was to depict the pattern of Christian thinking as it took shape in the first centuries, how Christians thought about the things they believed. I try to see things whole, to present persons and ideas as part of a common tradition rooted in a specific historical period yet not bound to time. Though long dead, the Church fathers maintain their ground.
Q: It is apparent in your book how central the Bible was for the Church fathers. Why is this fact often obscured in the histories of the early Church?
Wilken: There has been a major shift in the study of the early Church in the last two generations. In the 1940s a group of French Jesuits, most notably Jean Danielou and Henri de Lubac, began to publish a series of early Christian texts entitled "Sources Chrétiennes," or Christian sources.
Danielou and de Lubac were reacting against the way theology was being taught in Catholic seminaries and schools of theology in the early part of the 20th century. They felt that theology had lost contact with the imaginative world of the Bible, a world of images and metaphors, of story and history, and believed that the way to recover this aspect of Christian thinking was to publish modern translations of classical Christian texts.
Today, "Sources Chrétiennes" is approaching 500 volumes and many are of works that had never been translated into a modern language. Some were biblical commentaries, for example, a large commentary on the Gospel of John by Origen of Alexandria, the first great Christian biblical scholar.
In the book I give many examples of how the Bible shaped Christian thinking, for example, the doctrine of the Trinity, the person of Christ, the moral life. Even a topic such as the freedom of the will, something that had long been discussed by Greek philosophers, became for Christians a discussion about the proper interpretation of key biblical texts.
As I tell my students, in reading the Church fathers one should always have a Bible open on one's desk.
Q: The title of your McCarthy lecture at the Gregorian was "The Inevitability of Allegory." Many people today believe that "allegory," giving a passage another sense than the plain sense, has no place in modern biblical interpretation. Isn't the historical approach to the Bible one of the most important developments in Catholic thinking in the 20th century?
Wilken: It is indeed. And again a little history might help clarify things. The same year that "Sources Chrétiennes" began publishing, 1943, Pope Pius XII issued the encyclical, "Divino Afflante Spiritu." This encyclical was the magna carta for Catholic biblical scholarship.
However, just at the moment that Catholic biblical scholars believed they had won the right to study the Bible historically, another group of Catholic scholars were urging a reappropriation of the classical Christian way of interpreting the Bible.
So there is some tension between how the Church fathers interpret and use the Bible and how modern historical scholarship views things. Yet I don't think that they are in fundamental conflict, and in many respects they complement one another.
Q: Could you give an example?
Wilken: You will remember the well-known passage in Romans 10 where St. Paul says it is not possible to believe unless one has heard, and one cannot hear without a preacher. Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the preaching of Christ. Then he quotes from Psalm 19, "Their voice has gone out to all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world."
In its original setting the first part of Psalm 19 -- Psalm 18 in the Vulgate -- celebrates the silent witness of the heavens to the majesty of God. "The heavens are telling the glory of God; and the firmament proclaims his handiwork. ... There is no speech, nor are there words; their voice is not heard."
Paul, however, interprets the text not in relation to the knowledge of God displayed in creation but as a psalm about the mission of the apostles. He understands the psalm in relation to the new thing that had happened, the coming of Christ and the preaching of the Gospel. In other words, he gives the passage another sense than its obvious or plain meaning.
Paul's interpretation of the psalm had large consequences, for it passed over into the Church's worship, most notably in daily prayer. Whenever we celebrate the feast of an apostle, one of the psalms appointed to be read in the office of readings is Psalm 19 whose words "their voice has gone out to the limits of the earth, their words to the end of the world" are used as the antiphon.
For those who pray with the Church the apostolic interpretation of Psalm 19 is as familiar and natural as the original or plain sense of the psalm.
This does not mean that the original meaning of the psalm is abandoned. It stands confidently as a testimony to the witness of creation to the mystery and majesty of God. At the same time the allegorical or spiritual interpretation became a precious and fixed part of the Church's life and worship. The two interpretations live comfortably side by side.
Q: It is interesting that the example you chose comes from the Church's prayer, from worship. What is the relation between liturgy and the interpretation of the Bible?
Wilken: The Church fathers were men of prayer and even when writing learned treatises in their studies they were never far from the Church's worship. In the liturgy they came to know Christ not so much as a historical figure from the past, but as a living person present in the Eucharist.
When they opened their Bibles they discovered this same Christ not only in the writings of the evangelists and St. Paul but also in the Old Testament. In the liturgy the words of the Scripture are alive and filled with the mystery of Christ.
For example, in the great Vigil of Easter in ancient times, when the newly baptized were preparing to receive communion for the first time, Psalm 42 was sung: "As the deer yearns for living waters, so longs my soul for you, O Lord."
The regular reading of the Scriptures in the liturgy and the recitation of the psalms in daily prayer worked powerfully on the minds of Christian interpreters. One might say that the Bible provided a lexicon of words for Christian speech and the liturgy a grammar of how they are to be used.
Q: What is the enduring significance of the early Christian understanding of the Bible?
Wilken: In spite of its many accomplishments, a strictly historical approach to the Bible can only give us a medley of documents from different times and places in the ancient world. It cannot give us the book of the Church, the Scriptures as heard by Christians for centuries, the psalms imprinted on the Church's soul, the words and images that bear witness to the Holy Trinity.
If we ignore the first readers of the Bible we are left with a collection of fragments, interesting in their own right, but lacking the unity that only the living Christ can give.
ZE03061926
Friday, June 20, 2003
Thought for the Day as propaganda
Adelphoi,
I got this message from a member of the General Synod of the C of E today. The Thought for the Day is meant to be devotional! But the Bishop used it for propaganda.
Friday morning 20th
Did you hear the Bishop of Oxford's 'Thought for the Day' on Radio 4 this morning? It amounted to moral blackmail, in my view, and neatly conflated the distinct issues of sexual leanings and sexual practice.
You can find the text of the talk at:
www.oxford.anglican.org/tftd.php?id=454
P.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
I got this message from a member of the General Synod of the C of E today. The Thought for the Day is meant to be devotional! But the Bishop used it for propaganda.
Friday morning 20th
Did you hear the Bishop of Oxford's 'Thought for the Day' on Radio 4 this morning? It amounted to moral blackmail, in my view, and neatly conflated the distinct issues of sexual leanings and sexual practice.
You can find the text of the talk at:
www.oxford.anglican.org/tftd.php?id=454
P.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Letter to the Church Times
My letter is printed in the Church Times in pride of place on the letters page. I expect some angry calls and messages...
From The Revd Dr Peter Toon
Sir,
In your editorial of 13 June on the nomination of Jeffrey John to the bishopric of Reading, you write: "People might have questions about his earlier life, but sexual history is not usually something with which the Church concerns itself. Most couples now cohabit before marriage, and yet the Church does not consider marrying them confers some approval of this."
You are suggesting that it is not necessary or appropriate to consider the (publicly known) sexual history of one who is either to be ordained/consecrated or married in church. Perhaps in most cases with respect to marriage it is "not necessary"; but, in the former case of consecration to the episcopate it is "necessary". How a priest has behaved publicly and what he has taught in the Church certainly ought to be "something with which the Church concerns itself" in choosing a bishop.
Your argument may well fit into a modern church morality based on human rights and be the norm in some dioceses for the choosing of ordinands. However, the Church of yesterday had a different approach. One has only to look at canon law to see this. Not only was repentance of heart and mind looked for but also public penance was imposed for sins, offences & irregularities against God's law and Church law. Such penance included non-admission to Holy Communion and/or suspension or removal from an office of ordained ministry.
Fornication and adultery of any kind are still sins as far as God, the Bible and the Formularies of the Church are concerned. And they are still sins when committed by affable, attractive and gifted persons.
What is not considered in your editorial is this possibility - that for the eternal salvation & spiritual health of the person himself, as well as for the holiness, edification and good name of Church of God, he who has been a fornicator or an adulterer [or involved in a sexual partnership] while ordained, be not considered for any preferment, even if he has turned from that sin, sought forgiveness and has been through a period of penance.
Ordination or consecration is not a human right but a gift of the exalted Lord Christ to his Church for the edification and holiness of that Church, and it has always been the case that certain irregularities constitute the possibility of exclusion or expulsion from the sacred Ministry. In this day and age, it can surely be argued that for the true good of the Church of God and for the man's own spiritual and moral progress, a priest who has been in a homosexual partnership or an adulterous relationship or is divorced [and remarried] ought to be excluded from preferment to the office of bishop. He may be an excellent person in terms of gifts, abilities and energy but he has no right to preferment because of them.
Let him in penitence excel in the presbyterate and therein reveal the mercy of God.
Peter Toon,
The Rectory,
Biddulph Moor, ST8 7HP
From The Revd Dr Peter Toon
Sir,
In your editorial of 13 June on the nomination of Jeffrey John to the bishopric of Reading, you write: "People might have questions about his earlier life, but sexual history is not usually something with which the Church concerns itself. Most couples now cohabit before marriage, and yet the Church does not consider marrying them confers some approval of this."
You are suggesting that it is not necessary or appropriate to consider the (publicly known) sexual history of one who is either to be ordained/consecrated or married in church. Perhaps in most cases with respect to marriage it is "not necessary"; but, in the former case of consecration to the episcopate it is "necessary". How a priest has behaved publicly and what he has taught in the Church certainly ought to be "something with which the Church concerns itself" in choosing a bishop.
Your argument may well fit into a modern church morality based on human rights and be the norm in some dioceses for the choosing of ordinands. However, the Church of yesterday had a different approach. One has only to look at canon law to see this. Not only was repentance of heart and mind looked for but also public penance was imposed for sins, offences & irregularities against God's law and Church law. Such penance included non-admission to Holy Communion and/or suspension or removal from an office of ordained ministry.
Fornication and adultery of any kind are still sins as far as God, the Bible and the Formularies of the Church are concerned. And they are still sins when committed by affable, attractive and gifted persons.
What is not considered in your editorial is this possibility - that for the eternal salvation & spiritual health of the person himself, as well as for the holiness, edification and good name of Church of God, he who has been a fornicator or an adulterer [or involved in a sexual partnership] while ordained, be not considered for any preferment, even if he has turned from that sin, sought forgiveness and has been through a period of penance.
Ordination or consecration is not a human right but a gift of the exalted Lord Christ to his Church for the edification and holiness of that Church, and it has always been the case that certain irregularities constitute the possibility of exclusion or expulsion from the sacred Ministry. In this day and age, it can surely be argued that for the true good of the Church of God and for the man's own spiritual and moral progress, a priest who has been in a homosexual partnership or an adulterous relationship or is divorced [and remarried] ought to be excluded from preferment to the office of bishop. He may be an excellent person in terms of gifts, abilities and energy but he has no right to preferment because of them.
Let him in penitence excel in the presbyterate and therein reveal the mercy of God.
Peter Toon,
The Rectory,
Biddulph Moor, ST8 7HP
Thursday, June 19, 2003
AN ACT OF PIRACY.
The Status of "The Book of Common Prayer" in the Constitution of the Episcopal Church.
There appears to be since 1979 a double meaning to "The Book of Common Prayer" in the Constitution of the Episcopal Church. It is referred to in the important Preamble and then is the subject of Article X where its use and revision are discussed.
The Preamble to the Constitution of the Episcopal Church is as follows:
"The Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America, otherwise known as the Episcopal Church., is a constituent member of the Anglican Communion, a Fellowship within the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, of those duly constituted Dioceses, Provinces, and regional Churches in communion with the See of Canterbury, upholding and propagating the historic Faith and Order as set forth in the Book of Common Prayer. This Constitution, adopted in General Convention in Philadelphia in October 1789, as amended in subsequent General Conventions, sets forth the basic Articles for the government of the Church, and of its overseas missionary jurisdictions."
The first American Prayer Book, a revised form of the English 1662 Prayer Book, was created in America, approved in the Church of England and then adopted for use in the new Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA in 1789. The American Church wanted the approval of the English Bishops for their new edition of the classic Prayer Book, even as she wanted consecration of her nominees for bishops by them. That is, the Church in the former 13 colonies wished to begin on a sound footing sharing the same worship, doctrine, polity and discipline of the mother Church.
So the reference to The Book of Common Prayer in this Constitution refers to that Book whose first edition was in 1549 and whose major edition has been that of 1662. This edition has been translated into over 150 different languages and used with minor changes to accommodate different political & social settings all over the world. The English Bishops agreed that the 1789 American edition was a true Book of Common Prayer, propagating the same historic Faith and Order contained in the English 1662 edition (wherein are also the Ordinal and the Articles of Religion).
It is common knowledge that the Protestant Episcopal Church made gentle and minor revisions of its Prayer Book in 1892 & 1928. In both editions the historic Faith and Order were maintained.
But in the 1970s the same Church, now calling herself "The Episcopal Church" , engaged in liturgical revision. Instead of doing a gentle revision of the received Prayer Book (edition of 1928) or instead of producing (as in Australia, England, Canada etc.) a "Book of Additional/Alternative Services" to exist alongside the Prayer Book of 1928, the Episcopal Church produced a Book of Varied & Alternative Services, which included some edited texts from the 1928 BCP as part of the choice, and then without sense of propriety and in a great act of piracy, proceeded to call the result, "The Book of Common Prayer, edition of 1979".
In other words, the nature, shape, content and doctrine of Common Prayer, as understood in the Anglican Communion and by the See of Canterbury since 1549, was rejected and replaced by a Book containing a totally new approach to the definition and meaning of Common Prayer. The classic Book of Common Prayer was set aside and replaced by the new Book, as if the transition were like that from the 1789 edition to that of 1892 or from 1892 to 1928. Piracy was thus disguised.
In other words, without consultation with Canterbury or with the whole Communion, the American province, the ECUSA, deliberately changed the meaning of Common Prayer and thus provided for itself a novel reading of its own Constitution, and especially the Preamble thereof. If the Preamble is read as if it refers to the 1979 book then there is a major problem in interpreting the Constitution for in Britain and at Canterbury "The Book of Common Prayer" is the name of the legal Prayer Book of the National Church and such editions and translations as are in strict conformity to it. And its name cannot be pirated by another book, however similar or different it maybe. The same applies in Wales, Scotland, Canada, Australia, and so on.
However, in the ECUSA in Article X of the Constitution the expression, "The Book of Common Prayer", which once referred to the classic editions of this Book, must now be taken to refer to the 1979 Prayer Book and to any official revisions of the same.
Thus the situation is that in the Preamble, if it is to make sense and be a valid historical statement, the Book of Common Prayer must refer to the editions of 1789/1892/1928, wherein is the historic Faith and Order contained in the services, while in Article X, the reference which is internal to the ECUSA must be to that Book of this Name which is currently authorized by the General Convention.
REGRETTABLY, there was not sufficient protest from within the ECUSA or from abroad (from the C of E especially) in the late 1970s concerning the terrible act of PIRACY whereby the American Province took a hallowed name, and a name full of historical meaning, and gave it to a new creation of the post 1960s world. By this act of piracy the ECUSA has caused deep confusion as to her true identity and vocation in the USA and the world, and she has led many souls astray. How much better and simpler it would have been had the 1979 Prayer Book been called "An American Prayer Book" and the 1928 edition of The BCP left intact!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
There appears to be since 1979 a double meaning to "The Book of Common Prayer" in the Constitution of the Episcopal Church. It is referred to in the important Preamble and then is the subject of Article X where its use and revision are discussed.
The Preamble to the Constitution of the Episcopal Church is as follows:
"The Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America, otherwise known as the Episcopal Church., is a constituent member of the Anglican Communion, a Fellowship within the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, of those duly constituted Dioceses, Provinces, and regional Churches in communion with the See of Canterbury, upholding and propagating the historic Faith and Order as set forth in the Book of Common Prayer. This Constitution, adopted in General Convention in Philadelphia in October 1789, as amended in subsequent General Conventions, sets forth the basic Articles for the government of the Church, and of its overseas missionary jurisdictions."
The first American Prayer Book, a revised form of the English 1662 Prayer Book, was created in America, approved in the Church of England and then adopted for use in the new Protestant Episcopal Church of the USA in 1789. The American Church wanted the approval of the English Bishops for their new edition of the classic Prayer Book, even as she wanted consecration of her nominees for bishops by them. That is, the Church in the former 13 colonies wished to begin on a sound footing sharing the same worship, doctrine, polity and discipline of the mother Church.
So the reference to The Book of Common Prayer in this Constitution refers to that Book whose first edition was in 1549 and whose major edition has been that of 1662. This edition has been translated into over 150 different languages and used with minor changes to accommodate different political & social settings all over the world. The English Bishops agreed that the 1789 American edition was a true Book of Common Prayer, propagating the same historic Faith and Order contained in the English 1662 edition (wherein are also the Ordinal and the Articles of Religion).
It is common knowledge that the Protestant Episcopal Church made gentle and minor revisions of its Prayer Book in 1892 & 1928. In both editions the historic Faith and Order were maintained.
But in the 1970s the same Church, now calling herself "The Episcopal Church" , engaged in liturgical revision. Instead of doing a gentle revision of the received Prayer Book (edition of 1928) or instead of producing (as in Australia, England, Canada etc.) a "Book of Additional/Alternative Services" to exist alongside the Prayer Book of 1928, the Episcopal Church produced a Book of Varied & Alternative Services, which included some edited texts from the 1928 BCP as part of the choice, and then without sense of propriety and in a great act of piracy, proceeded to call the result, "The Book of Common Prayer, edition of 1979".
In other words, the nature, shape, content and doctrine of Common Prayer, as understood in the Anglican Communion and by the See of Canterbury since 1549, was rejected and replaced by a Book containing a totally new approach to the definition and meaning of Common Prayer. The classic Book of Common Prayer was set aside and replaced by the new Book, as if the transition were like that from the 1789 edition to that of 1892 or from 1892 to 1928. Piracy was thus disguised.
In other words, without consultation with Canterbury or with the whole Communion, the American province, the ECUSA, deliberately changed the meaning of Common Prayer and thus provided for itself a novel reading of its own Constitution, and especially the Preamble thereof. If the Preamble is read as if it refers to the 1979 book then there is a major problem in interpreting the Constitution for in Britain and at Canterbury "The Book of Common Prayer" is the name of the legal Prayer Book of the National Church and such editions and translations as are in strict conformity to it. And its name cannot be pirated by another book, however similar or different it maybe. The same applies in Wales, Scotland, Canada, Australia, and so on.
However, in the ECUSA in Article X of the Constitution the expression, "The Book of Common Prayer", which once referred to the classic editions of this Book, must now be taken to refer to the 1979 Prayer Book and to any official revisions of the same.
Thus the situation is that in the Preamble, if it is to make sense and be a valid historical statement, the Book of Common Prayer must refer to the editions of 1789/1892/1928, wherein is the historic Faith and Order contained in the services, while in Article X, the reference which is internal to the ECUSA must be to that Book of this Name which is currently authorized by the General Convention.
REGRETTABLY, there was not sufficient protest from within the ECUSA or from abroad (from the C of E especially) in the late 1970s concerning the terrible act of PIRACY whereby the American Province took a hallowed name, and a name full of historical meaning, and gave it to a new creation of the post 1960s world. By this act of piracy the ECUSA has caused deep confusion as to her true identity and vocation in the USA and the world, and she has led many souls astray. How much better and simpler it would have been had the 1979 Prayer Book been called "An American Prayer Book" and the 1928 edition of The BCP left intact!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
The 74th General Convention 2003 & Continuing Change within the ECUSA
Adelphoi,
A few thoughts on...
The 74th General Convention 2003 & Continuing Change within the ECUSA
The Blue Book (Reports to the 74th General Convention) now published in preparation for the July 30th meeting in Minneapolis provides only one indication of possible, further dramatic and substantial changes in the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Episcopal Church - a Church that been involved in innovation in major areas since the 1960s. Other indications of change come through surprises in necessary business and through resolutions submitted by dioceses.
One indication of a major change that many people are aware of is the probable acceptance by a majority in both the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies of that person approved by a majority within the Diocese of New Hampshire to be its new bishop. The confirmation of persons duly elected by dioceses is commonplace at Conventions; but, this one will be different in that the candidate is not only a divorced man (once a barrier but no longer) but is also a gay man, living in a sexual partnership with another man. If he is approved then the ECUSA will have - by the back door as it were - made it clear that it is acceptable for a bishop (and therefore for a priest or lay person) to be active homosexually, while serving as a bishop. In one stroke of the pen, as it were, the received doctrine of the Church of God of the Old and New Testaments will have been set aside.
If this bishop-elect were not approved there would be a revolt within the Convention, the like of which we have not seen in recent years. For there is a vocal minority that intends to have gay partnerships approved one way or another NOW, not tomorrow.
In terms of continuing changes in Liturgy (structure, content, doctrine & style) what seems to be the intention of the Standing Commission on Liturgy & Music is as follows:
Do studies of what is going on now in the churches and of what people say they need and of what the Commission thinks that people need.
Use these studies to call for innovation.
Do not set aside the 1979 prayer book as yet, but supplement it with a growing corpus of alternatives. Also use the 1979 prayer book in a revised form - introducing a full agenda of non-excluding or inclusive language into it.
Keep on producing new services for every conceivable perceived need in a multi-cultural, multi-generational etc. church. Take note of innovations being developed around the church and publicise the best of them.
Call that which is evolving nationally and locally by the term "Common Worship" and so give it a kind of historically-based respectability and of a kind of tie to the Church of England where the new Directory of Services if called "Common Worship".
When there is the production of so much material and where the general claim is made that "the law of praying is the law of believing" (i.e. that liturgy creates doctrine) and where that which is produced bears little relation to historic texts in terms of the theological content and syntax/style, then a revolution is occurring and all without the production of a new prayer book. That is "Common Worship" is said to exist and to do so in a vast corpus of materials, the full scope of which only a few truly are aware of.
In the Reports of other Commissions - Mission & Evangelism, Ecumenical Relations and so on - there is likewise innovation being pursued in many major areas but only a careful examination of the proposals in the context of knowing what have been the doctrines of the Church, the Sacraments, and Salvation in the Anglican Way will lay bare what these are. And this requires a long essay.
It would appear that most Episcopalians, brainwashed since the 1960s by constant innovation and change, do not generally recognize how far away from classic doctrine and practice their Church has moved. It is only in such areas as accepting gay partnerships that they really note innovation these days. The changing doctrines of God, the Holy Trinity, the Person and Work of Christ, Salvation, Christian Hope and so on seem to occur and arrive with little notice! Pantheism, Panentheism and Unitarianism, for example, enter the door and people clap, not recognizing that without the Confession of the Trinity as a Unity and a Unity in Trinity there may be religion but there cannot be Christianity.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
A few thoughts on...
The 74th General Convention 2003 & Continuing Change within the ECUSA
The Blue Book (Reports to the 74th General Convention) now published in preparation for the July 30th meeting in Minneapolis provides only one indication of possible, further dramatic and substantial changes in the worship, doctrine and discipline of the Episcopal Church - a Church that been involved in innovation in major areas since the 1960s. Other indications of change come through surprises in necessary business and through resolutions submitted by dioceses.
One indication of a major change that many people are aware of is the probable acceptance by a majority in both the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies of that person approved by a majority within the Diocese of New Hampshire to be its new bishop. The confirmation of persons duly elected by dioceses is commonplace at Conventions; but, this one will be different in that the candidate is not only a divorced man (once a barrier but no longer) but is also a gay man, living in a sexual partnership with another man. If he is approved then the ECUSA will have - by the back door as it were - made it clear that it is acceptable for a bishop (and therefore for a priest or lay person) to be active homosexually, while serving as a bishop. In one stroke of the pen, as it were, the received doctrine of the Church of God of the Old and New Testaments will have been set aside.
If this bishop-elect were not approved there would be a revolt within the Convention, the like of which we have not seen in recent years. For there is a vocal minority that intends to have gay partnerships approved one way or another NOW, not tomorrow.
In terms of continuing changes in Liturgy (structure, content, doctrine & style) what seems to be the intention of the Standing Commission on Liturgy & Music is as follows:
Do studies of what is going on now in the churches and of what people say they need and of what the Commission thinks that people need.
Use these studies to call for innovation.
Do not set aside the 1979 prayer book as yet, but supplement it with a growing corpus of alternatives. Also use the 1979 prayer book in a revised form - introducing a full agenda of non-excluding or inclusive language into it.
Keep on producing new services for every conceivable perceived need in a multi-cultural, multi-generational etc. church. Take note of innovations being developed around the church and publicise the best of them.
Call that which is evolving nationally and locally by the term "Common Worship" and so give it a kind of historically-based respectability and of a kind of tie to the Church of England where the new Directory of Services if called "Common Worship".
When there is the production of so much material and where the general claim is made that "the law of praying is the law of believing" (i.e. that liturgy creates doctrine) and where that which is produced bears little relation to historic texts in terms of the theological content and syntax/style, then a revolution is occurring and all without the production of a new prayer book. That is "Common Worship" is said to exist and to do so in a vast corpus of materials, the full scope of which only a few truly are aware of.
In the Reports of other Commissions - Mission & Evangelism, Ecumenical Relations and so on - there is likewise innovation being pursued in many major areas but only a careful examination of the proposals in the context of knowing what have been the doctrines of the Church, the Sacraments, and Salvation in the Anglican Way will lay bare what these are. And this requires a long essay.
It would appear that most Episcopalians, brainwashed since the 1960s by constant innovation and change, do not generally recognize how far away from classic doctrine and practice their Church has moved. It is only in such areas as accepting gay partnerships that they really note innovation these days. The changing doctrines of God, the Holy Trinity, the Person and Work of Christ, Salvation, Christian Hope and so on seem to occur and arrive with little notice! Pantheism, Panentheism and Unitarianism, for example, enter the door and people clap, not recognizing that without the Confession of the Trinity as a Unity and a Unity in Trinity there may be religion but there cannot be Christianity.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Wednesday, June 18, 2003
THE LIMITS OF CONSERVATISM
My good friend, David Mills, a R C layman and formerly an Anglican wrote this. I cannot disagree.
ECUS Evangelicals have lived happily with the divorce culture within the church, the ordination of women and the liturgy of 1979 (with its great weaknesses in terms of classic dogma) and now they protest vehemently about that which is merely a continuation of what they have approved or not opposed. Once you open the doors the Zeitgeist blows in and forces the windows open as well!
THE LIMITS OF CONSERVATISM: From Touchstone Magazine's Mere Comments
Conservative Episcopalians have reacted against the election of Canon Gene Robinson to be the Episcopal Bishop of New Hampshire because he is living with another man. They should howl and hoot, of course, but I must admit that a friendly outsider like me feels bemused when reading their reactions.
They long ago weakened their ability to protest the approval of homosexuality with any great coherence and effect, to the extent that they are now like a man trying to throw punches while sinking in quicksand. Just read through the following.
From the Rt. Rev’d James Stanton, the Episcopal bishop of Dallas and head of a group called the American Anglican Council:
From the Very Rev’d Dr. Peter Moore, dean of Trinity Episcopal School for Ministry (my former boss and a man I like and admire, let me make clear):
From the Rev’d Todd H. Wetzel, director of Episcopalians United:
From the Rt. Rev’d Edward Salmon and the Rt. Rev’d William Skilton, Episcopal bishop and suffragan bishop of South Carolina:
You may have noticed that everything these men say against approving homosexual living could be said against approving the ordination of women, which all these men approve, I think rather enthusiastically (I know almost all of them). They all appeal to a tradition they themselves do not obey. They appeal to a unity they themselves helped shatter. They appeal to a way of reading Scripture they have already disregarded.
Mr. Wetzel even asserts the requirement that the bishop be the husband of one wife, and therefor not the husband of one husband, without noticing that husbands are male. (I don’t think his organization has ever protested the ordination of anyone with two or more spouses living, though his use of St. Paul’s rule leads one to think they object to it as strongly as they do to the ordination of a homosexual man.)
Anyway, one does raise one’s eyebrows to hear men who believe in ordaining women speak out against the violation of 2000 years of tradition and call such an innovation hubris, and declare that “nowhere is the Holy Spirit seen in the New Testament to contradict God’s revelation in prior ages” while advancing an apparent contradiction. They helped push a boulder over the edge of the cliff and are now angry that it did not stop rolling halfway down the hill, and though they didn't mind it smashing the homes of people who lived near the top, are upset that it's now smashing into their homes.
They would argue that the two cases are different, and that there are biblical arguments to be made for ordaining women as well as men, arguments we have only in the last thirty or forty years seen and understood. But then that is exactly what Canon Robinson’s supporters say. And with as much reason. The conservatives don’t have any reason, beyond a belief in their own exegesis, to say that their innovation is Godly and the homosexualists’ ungodly. They cannot appeal to tradition as the authority for their reading of Scripture now, when they disregarded it then.
When faced with the election of Canon Robinson, the approval of which (certain to come) will be the Episcopal Church's official approval of homosexual coupling, their approval of the first innovation leaves them, as I said, like a man trying to throw punches while sinking in quicksand.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
By the way, all these quotes were taken from stories published by the Episcopal news service Virtuosity.
—David Mills
7:26 AM
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),
ECUS Evangelicals have lived happily with the divorce culture within the church, the ordination of women and the liturgy of 1979 (with its great weaknesses in terms of classic dogma) and now they protest vehemently about that which is merely a continuation of what they have approved or not opposed. Once you open the doors the Zeitgeist blows in and forces the windows open as well!
THE LIMITS OF CONSERVATISM: From Touchstone Magazine's Mere Comments
Conservative Episcopalians have reacted against the election of Canon Gene Robinson to be the Episcopal Bishop of New Hampshire because he is living with another man. They should howl and hoot, of course, but I must admit that a friendly outsider like me feels bemused when reading their reactions.
They long ago weakened their ability to protest the approval of homosexuality with any great coherence and effect, to the extent that they are now like a man trying to throw punches while sinking in quicksand. Just read through the following.
From the Rt. Rev’d James Stanton, the Episcopal bishop of Dallas and head of a group called the American Anglican Council:
Some will say the direction taken by New Hampshire is the leading of the Holy Spirit in a new age. But the apostles’ teaching is that the Spirit leads to unity with God and one another, not to greater division. And nowhere is the Holy Spirit seen in the New Testament to contradict God’s revelation in prior ages.
Some will say the growing conflict is about justice and compassion. But without faithfulness to the apostles’ teaching — the church’s charter — only disorder will be the result. And disorder never leads to either justice or compassion.
From the Very Rev’d Dr. Peter Moore, dean of Trinity Episcopal School for Ministry (my former boss and a man I like and admire, let me make clear):
Only hubris can have motivated otherwise well-intentioned people to scorn the wisdom of the church that through its history has taught that sex belongs within the covenant of heterosexual marriage.
From the Rev’d Todd H. Wetzel, director of Episcopalians United:
[Canon Robinson’s] exemplary capabilities do not warrant an exception to 2000 years of the teaching of Scripture. The Old and New Testaments, are clear in defining a homosexual relationship as an abomination — clearly in violation of God’s will. Further, the New Testament declares that a man engaged in ministry must be the husband of one wife (not several; or of another man.) (1st Timothy 3:2).
. . . By Scripture and the world-wide Anglican Lambeth Conference of 1998 and by past resolutions of our General Convention, he can not be a bishop at all.
The election strongly highlights the low state to which the Authority of Scripture, theological discussion and submission to the wider Anglican Communion have fallen in Episcopal circles, and how sentiment has replaced reason in the voting of many Episcopalians.
From the Rt. Rev’d Edward Salmon and the Rt. Rev’d William Skilton, Episcopal bishop and suffragan bishop of South Carolina:
The Anglican Communion now faces one of its greatest crises ever over the question of whether or not same sex relationships are sinful or to be blessed by the church.
. . . The union in which Canon Robinson participates is not Holy Matrimony but an intimate relationship outside the bounds of marriage. This would be true whether he were cohabiting with a man or with a woman. For the church implicitly to sanction such a partnership will be a clear repudiation of the teaching of Holy Scripture and the tradition of the church; it also would signify a massive overhaul of the Christian theology of marriage by the Episcopal Church.
You may have noticed that everything these men say against approving homosexual living could be said against approving the ordination of women, which all these men approve, I think rather enthusiastically (I know almost all of them). They all appeal to a tradition they themselves do not obey. They appeal to a unity they themselves helped shatter. They appeal to a way of reading Scripture they have already disregarded.
Mr. Wetzel even asserts the requirement that the bishop be the husband of one wife, and therefor not the husband of one husband, without noticing that husbands are male. (I don’t think his organization has ever protested the ordination of anyone with two or more spouses living, though his use of St. Paul’s rule leads one to think they object to it as strongly as they do to the ordination of a homosexual man.)
Anyway, one does raise one’s eyebrows to hear men who believe in ordaining women speak out against the violation of 2000 years of tradition and call such an innovation hubris, and declare that “nowhere is the Holy Spirit seen in the New Testament to contradict God’s revelation in prior ages” while advancing an apparent contradiction. They helped push a boulder over the edge of the cliff and are now angry that it did not stop rolling halfway down the hill, and though they didn't mind it smashing the homes of people who lived near the top, are upset that it's now smashing into their homes.
They would argue that the two cases are different, and that there are biblical arguments to be made for ordaining women as well as men, arguments we have only in the last thirty or forty years seen and understood. But then that is exactly what Canon Robinson’s supporters say. And with as much reason. The conservatives don’t have any reason, beyond a belief in their own exegesis, to say that their innovation is Godly and the homosexualists’ ungodly. They cannot appeal to tradition as the authority for their reading of Scripture now, when they disregarded it then.
When faced with the election of Canon Robinson, the approval of which (certain to come) will be the Episcopal Church's official approval of homosexual coupling, their approval of the first innovation leaves them, as I said, like a man trying to throw punches while sinking in quicksand.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
By the way, all these quotes were taken from stories published by the Episcopal news service Virtuosity.
—David Mills
7:26 AM
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),
Tuesday, June 17, 2003
Triad, Trinitas, Trinity
Concerning an error introduced in 1966 by ECUSA.
Here is my response:
Let us name & adore the Holy Trinity aright!
The Church of God made use of her best minds and devout hearts over a long period of heated debate to reach basic agreement as to the identity, the name and the doctrine of The Trinity.
Today, too many in the Church of God seem to think that we can discount that profound debate and those holy conclusions and frame for ourselves, after minimal study, statements that rightly name The Trinity.
When we take short cuts, and presume that we can do the work with only a passing glance at the labour of the Church of God in the patristic and medieval periods, we may think that we have confessed The Holy Trinity when in fact we have confessed a doctrine, even a heresy, which the Fathers and Scholastics were intent on avoiding!
In this realm of Christian discourse only precise expressions will suffice and this means also close attention to the construction of sentences and to syntax and style and (if we write in English or Greek) to the use of the definite article.
In 1966/7 in its new liturgy of the Holy Communion the ECUSA introduced a novel way of naming the Holy Trinity and that way has stuck through thick and thin to the present day (and has even been adopted by the Church of England in certain texts of its Common Worship). As far as I can tell this form had not been used before in English. In looking at it we have to pay careful attention not merely to the words used but to the construction of the sentences.
"Blessed be God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
And blessed be his kingdom, now and for ever."
It is claimed that this form of words is the dynamic equivalent of the Blessing in the Orthodox Liturgy which is usually translated from the Greek
thus: "Blessed be the kingdom of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, now and always, even unto ages of ages."
One thing may be said of the Divine Liturgy of the Orthodox Churches and it is this. The doctrine therein and the form of words used all conform most precisely to the dogma of the seven ecumenical councils.
If one takes as one's starting point the authority of the dogma set forth in the ecumenical councils, then various problems arise with the novel American acclamation/blessing. If it is intended to follow the Greek Blessing then it should have been: "Blessed be the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit". Here there is the use of the definite article to make clear the precise identity of the Three Persons.
By introducing the word "God", leaving out the definite articles, and introducing of all things, the colon, the American liturgists (probably Massey Shepherd Jr) introduced confusion. Certainly those with orthodox minds and charitable hearts can make the novel form of words speak orthodoxy; but, for those without a training in patristic and medieval dogma the novel form of words does not in a natural reading and meaning proclaim orthodoxy.
The most natural meaning is that there is a God who has an unique kingdom and that this God has Three unique( or special) Names - Father, Son and Holy Spirit (or as in modern renderings of this is Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier). In other words, the ancient and common heresy of Modalism is here being proclaimed - if we read these words in their natural meaning and take note of the colon. That is, there is One Person of God, who has Three Names (or Three Modes of Being, or Three Basic Functions), and this God has a kingdom which is blessed for ever.
So, if we really want rightly to Name the Trinity and adore this Triune God, let us keep to the hallowed expressions of the traditional Liturgies (e.g., the Roman begins, "In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit"). If we feel obliged to use this 1967 ECUSA novelty then let us change it back to the original to read:
"Blessed be the kingdom of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, now and always, even unto ages of ages. Amen." (The priest to say everything except the Amen.)
The vocation of the Church of God today is not to innovate in dogma or morality but to proclaim the one Faith in a way that people can hear and receive. The jurisdiction known as the ECUSA was in the 1960s and 1970s much influenced by liberal and latitudinarian Catholicism and the effects of this are to be seen throughout its new liturgies and thus in the 1979 book, which so often has the appearance of catholic dogma but presents in fact ancient and modern heresy!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
From: "Ronald Thomas"
To: "PETER TOON"
Sent: Monday, June 16, 2003 8:58 PM
Subject: Re: Triad, Trinitas, Trinity
Peter, do run again, if you please, the piece about why "In the name of God:Father, Son, and Holy Spirit" is novel and erroneous. I think others might benefit from it as much as I did.
Thanks, Ron
Here is my response:
Let us name & adore the Holy Trinity aright!
The Church of God made use of her best minds and devout hearts over a long period of heated debate to reach basic agreement as to the identity, the name and the doctrine of The Trinity.
Today, too many in the Church of God seem to think that we can discount that profound debate and those holy conclusions and frame for ourselves, after minimal study, statements that rightly name The Trinity.
When we take short cuts, and presume that we can do the work with only a passing glance at the labour of the Church of God in the patristic and medieval periods, we may think that we have confessed The Holy Trinity when in fact we have confessed a doctrine, even a heresy, which the Fathers and Scholastics were intent on avoiding!
In this realm of Christian discourse only precise expressions will suffice and this means also close attention to the construction of sentences and to syntax and style and (if we write in English or Greek) to the use of the definite article.
In 1966/7 in its new liturgy of the Holy Communion the ECUSA introduced a novel way of naming the Holy Trinity and that way has stuck through thick and thin to the present day (and has even been adopted by the Church of England in certain texts of its Common Worship). As far as I can tell this form had not been used before in English. In looking at it we have to pay careful attention not merely to the words used but to the construction of the sentences.
"Blessed be God: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
And blessed be his kingdom, now and for ever."
It is claimed that this form of words is the dynamic equivalent of the Blessing in the Orthodox Liturgy which is usually translated from the Greek
thus: "Blessed be the kingdom of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, now and always, even unto ages of ages."
One thing may be said of the Divine Liturgy of the Orthodox Churches and it is this. The doctrine therein and the form of words used all conform most precisely to the dogma of the seven ecumenical councils.
If one takes as one's starting point the authority of the dogma set forth in the ecumenical councils, then various problems arise with the novel American acclamation/blessing. If it is intended to follow the Greek Blessing then it should have been: "Blessed be the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit". Here there is the use of the definite article to make clear the precise identity of the Three Persons.
By introducing the word "God", leaving out the definite articles, and introducing of all things, the colon, the American liturgists (probably Massey Shepherd Jr) introduced confusion. Certainly those with orthodox minds and charitable hearts can make the novel form of words speak orthodoxy; but, for those without a training in patristic and medieval dogma the novel form of words does not in a natural reading and meaning proclaim orthodoxy.
The most natural meaning is that there is a God who has an unique kingdom and that this God has Three unique( or special) Names - Father, Son and Holy Spirit (or as in modern renderings of this is Creator, Redeemer and Sanctifier). In other words, the ancient and common heresy of Modalism is here being proclaimed - if we read these words in their natural meaning and take note of the colon. That is, there is One Person of God, who has Three Names (or Three Modes of Being, or Three Basic Functions), and this God has a kingdom which is blessed for ever.
So, if we really want rightly to Name the Trinity and adore this Triune God, let us keep to the hallowed expressions of the traditional Liturgies (e.g., the Roman begins, "In the Name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit"). If we feel obliged to use this 1967 ECUSA novelty then let us change it back to the original to read:
"Blessed be the kingdom of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, now and always, even unto ages of ages. Amen." (The priest to say everything except the Amen.)
The vocation of the Church of God today is not to innovate in dogma or morality but to proclaim the one Faith in a way that people can hear and receive. The jurisdiction known as the ECUSA was in the 1960s and 1970s much influenced by liberal and latitudinarian Catholicism and the effects of this are to be seen throughout its new liturgies and thus in the 1979 book, which so often has the appearance of catholic dogma but presents in fact ancient and modern heresy!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Monday, June 16, 2003
Corpus Christi & the Church of England
From at least the fourteenth century in the West and thus within the Ecclesia Anglicana the Feast of Corpus Christi was held on the Thursday following Trinity Sunday. Usually there were processions through the streets headed by the Blessed Sacrament.
In the middle of the 16th century, the reformed Catholic Church of England ceased to keep the Feast because of doctrinal considerations; but the Roman Catholic Church has continued to keep it to this day and recently has given it the new name, Corpus et Sanguis Christi (Body & Blood of Christ). And, somewhat surprisingly, the Church of England has set in motion the revival of the Feast by making it a part of the Christian Year/Calendar in Common Worship 2000 (her new Directory of worship which is an alternative to The Book of Common Prayer of 1662) and providing a Collect and readings for it.
In origin Corpus Christi was inextricably associated with the doctrine of transubstantiation, the view that the whole bread is changed in the act of consecration in the Mass into the true Body of Christ. Thus, this Body is not only to be consumed as Bread from heaven but also adored as Christ present amongst his people. Because of their rejection of the medieval doctrine of the Mass, it was inevitable that the Reformers should also reject this Feast. Thus there is no sign of it within The Book of Common Prayer.
Common Worship (volume 1) informs us on page 407 that “the Thursday after Trinity Sunday may be observed as ‘The Day of Thanksgiving for the Institution of Holy Communion (Corpus Christi)’.” The liturgical colour is white, the Collect is addressed to “Lord Jesus Christ” and the Post Communion Prayer to “our God and Father”. The Epistle is 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 and the Gospel is John 6:51-58.
In a Reformed Catholic Church, one wonders why this celebration is necessary since if Holy Week is kept there is a suitable recognition of the institution of this Sacrament on Maundy Thursday. It is true that some Anglo-Catholics have long kept this day but this is because they are committed to the doctrine of transubstantiation, which they freely accept has never been the doctrine of the reformed Church of England.
Apparently the liturgists responsible for Common Worship thought it would be good to follow the modern Roman Catholic festival of “The Body and Blood of Christ” but to soften it by giving it a generalised and apparently harmless title. However, the Collect (though based on an original said to be by St Thomas Aquinas) is somewhat vague and may be taken as either validating the doctrine of transubstantiation or simply stating a very high view of this Sacrament in terms of the value of the consecrated elements.
“Lord Jesus Christ, we thank you that in this wonderful sacrament you have given us the memorial of your passion: grant us so to reverence the sacred mysteries of your body and blood that we may know within ourselves and show forth in our lives the fruits of your redemption;…”
The opening declaration is fine. The petition introduces the idea of reverencing the consecrated elements as “the sacred mysteries of your body and blood”. To reverence the elements is presumably to attribute to them divine content or quality or character. But on the basis of which C of E doctrine is this done?
This Collect is a revised form of the Latin Collect for the medieval festival of Corpus Christi. In 1929 the Scottish Episcopal Church provided a similar Collect as an additional Collect for Maundy Thursday and in 1979 the American Episcopal Church did the same, stating that it was especially suitable for use on any Thursday. More recently several Provinces of the Anglican Communion have included “Thanksgiving for Holy Communion” in their Calendars for the Thursday after Trinity Sunday.
In origin the doctrine of transubstantiation led to the festival of Corpus Christi. Now it seems a love of festivals and a desire to imitate Rome by liturgists are causing the revival of the festival under a new name and without the doctrine of transubstantiation to support it. Thus it hangs in vague space to be blown by any wind that touches it.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
In the middle of the 16th century, the reformed Catholic Church of England ceased to keep the Feast because of doctrinal considerations; but the Roman Catholic Church has continued to keep it to this day and recently has given it the new name, Corpus et Sanguis Christi (Body & Blood of Christ). And, somewhat surprisingly, the Church of England has set in motion the revival of the Feast by making it a part of the Christian Year/Calendar in Common Worship 2000 (her new Directory of worship which is an alternative to The Book of Common Prayer of 1662) and providing a Collect and readings for it.
In origin Corpus Christi was inextricably associated with the doctrine of transubstantiation, the view that the whole bread is changed in the act of consecration in the Mass into the true Body of Christ. Thus, this Body is not only to be consumed as Bread from heaven but also adored as Christ present amongst his people. Because of their rejection of the medieval doctrine of the Mass, it was inevitable that the Reformers should also reject this Feast. Thus there is no sign of it within The Book of Common Prayer.
Common Worship (volume 1) informs us on page 407 that “the Thursday after Trinity Sunday may be observed as ‘The Day of Thanksgiving for the Institution of Holy Communion (Corpus Christi)’.” The liturgical colour is white, the Collect is addressed to “Lord Jesus Christ” and the Post Communion Prayer to “our God and Father”. The Epistle is 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 and the Gospel is John 6:51-58.
In a Reformed Catholic Church, one wonders why this celebration is necessary since if Holy Week is kept there is a suitable recognition of the institution of this Sacrament on Maundy Thursday. It is true that some Anglo-Catholics have long kept this day but this is because they are committed to the doctrine of transubstantiation, which they freely accept has never been the doctrine of the reformed Church of England.
Apparently the liturgists responsible for Common Worship thought it would be good to follow the modern Roman Catholic festival of “The Body and Blood of Christ” but to soften it by giving it a generalised and apparently harmless title. However, the Collect (though based on an original said to be by St Thomas Aquinas) is somewhat vague and may be taken as either validating the doctrine of transubstantiation or simply stating a very high view of this Sacrament in terms of the value of the consecrated elements.
“Lord Jesus Christ, we thank you that in this wonderful sacrament you have given us the memorial of your passion: grant us so to reverence the sacred mysteries of your body and blood that we may know within ourselves and show forth in our lives the fruits of your redemption;…”
The opening declaration is fine. The petition introduces the idea of reverencing the consecrated elements as “the sacred mysteries of your body and blood”. To reverence the elements is presumably to attribute to them divine content or quality or character. But on the basis of which C of E doctrine is this done?
This Collect is a revised form of the Latin Collect for the medieval festival of Corpus Christi. In 1929 the Scottish Episcopal Church provided a similar Collect as an additional Collect for Maundy Thursday and in 1979 the American Episcopal Church did the same, stating that it was especially suitable for use on any Thursday. More recently several Provinces of the Anglican Communion have included “Thanksgiving for Holy Communion” in their Calendars for the Thursday after Trinity Sunday.
In origin the doctrine of transubstantiation led to the festival of Corpus Christi. Now it seems a love of festivals and a desire to imitate Rome by liturgists are causing the revival of the festival under a new name and without the doctrine of transubstantiation to support it. Thus it hangs in vague space to be blown by any wind that touches it.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)