Monday, June 09, 2003

GAY BISHOPS & REPENTANCE

Adelphoi,

In commenting on WHY a lot of seemingly decent church people just accept innovations in morality and doctrine (with reference specifically to the appointment of two men as bishops who have been in "gay partnerships") I offered the following as a major reason:

"If we buy into the popular understanding of human rights (and such is assumed in the language of general culture) then we have to concede that other people - even in the church - have the right to be and to do what we may think (by God's revealed standards) is wrong, even sinful. Christian doctrine is thereby adjusted to accommodate human rights and reasons (tolerance, fairness, compassion etc) are given.

Homosexually active persons [and their supporters] have brilliantly incorporated their demands into the assumptions and language of human rights with the result that many good and decent people feel it is wrong for them to oppose those rights - for in this culture one does not oppose the human rights of another. To do so is the sin of sins."

Perhaps this explanation has more force in New Hampshire, USA, than in the Diocese of Oxford, England.

One of my correspondents in England wrote:

"I suggest a more pragmatical explanation. You might expect that when the church shrinks the faithful remnant will be the most devoted. But when the church shrinks because the bishops are feeble-minded the majority of the minority who don't abandon her are those who don't mind feeble-mindedness, and will take whatever is handed out...

In the case in point, however, as reported by the newspapers, there is perhaps no scandal. The man appointed to Reading is reported to have ceased to practise homosexuality. If so, depending on the state he is thought to be in, there is no reason why he should not be a bishop is there? If he is repentant and is bringing forth fruits worthy of repentance he is in the same state as all Christians. If the church refused penitent sinners there would be no bishops, and Paul and Augustine would have failed at the first hurdle.

But of course the media don't report whether the suffragan-designate is penitent or whether he has just given up his former life through old age or exhaustion."

I comment as follows.

The pragmatical explanation - which relates to bad leadership by the appointed leaders - perhaps applies both in Oxford and New Hampshire (the ECUSA has dropped from 4.5. millions in the 1960s to 2.0 millions in 2003 and the C of E is also down in active membership). Yet as an explanation it can easily sit with the human rights explanation that I offered.

As to repentance. The Early Church had systems of penance (which included suspension from Holy Communion) for clergy and laity alike as part of their U-turn back to biblical doctrine and morality. One could not go straight from a life of open sin or aberration into the status as a communicant and certainly not be promoted to a senior position in the diocese (if ever at all).

Further, in moral theology and canon law there have always been certain offences that, even where the person committing them has repented, prohibit the entry of this person into certain offices of the Church. Here the reason is obvious - the good name of the Church and the possibility of the sin being constantly remembered and used to discredit the ministry of this person. Today, a life in a gay relationship would seem to qualify as a prohibition of being elevated to the office of bishop even where there is repentance and a departure from this partnership - at least because the person in question would be open to publicity and blackmail and all kinds of pressures detracting him from the work. (The same stricture would apply to a man who had been living with a woman who is not his wife.) And, at the very least, even where human rights are prominent in a modern church, there should be a period for the proof of the repentance to be seen! Offer of promotion, and then giving up the life-style of an active gay partnership to fit into it, is hardly appropriate in terms of repentance or holiness or good order. So the appointment of the Bishop of Reading ought to be rescinded.

Apparently the American bishop-elect intends to carry on in his partnership and the effect of this will be to confirm for many people in the USA and elsewhere that the Episcopal Church is more conformed to the world than it is seeking to be conformed to the will of God for the Church. There will be little effective protest within the ECUSA because its bishops and membership are so secularised in their moral thinking. Protests from abroad will last for a while and die out.

Meanwhile the Anglican Communion will survive the pain and better days lie ahead by the grace of God.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),
Christ Church, Biddulph Moor & St Anne's, Brown Edge;
Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large of The Prayer Book Society of America.

Letter from the Revd Dr Peter Toon to the Church Times

Sir,

I offer a comment on the appointing of homosexually active priests to the office of bishop by providing two examples.

1. A “gay” priest as a matter of conscience ceased his “relationship[s]”, lived in a celibate manner for some time, excelled as a parish priest and then was nominated and appointed bishop, without seeking this “promotion” and intending to stay celibate.

2. A “gay” priest living in a “faithful partnership” decides to cease this partnership and to seek to live as a celibate when (but not before) he is offered the office of a bishop.

The first example may be said to reflect Christian thinking and behaviour while the latter could be charged with opportunism and of lacking repentance (although it may be genuine repentance).

Repentance for sin in some cases requires public penance and certainly always requires amendment of life. And penance can include non-admission both to Holy Communion and to privileges and offices of the Church.

Further, it has always been the case that some men have been refused ordination because of what they committed as crimes or sins before they became active Christians. The reasoning here can be that there is always the possibility that those crimes/sins will be used to bring discredit upon the person and/or the church and thus destroy his ministry. Perhaps the appointing of (once) actively gay men, however talented and affable they be, to the office of bishop comes in this category.

Yours truly

Peter Toon,
The Rectory,
Biddulph Moor, ST8 7HP

The Preface for Trinity Sunday

Adelphoi,

Trinity Sunday & the Proper Preface for "The Order of Holy Communion"

In the Prayer of Consecration [or The Eucharistic Prayer] there is after "Sursum Corde" ["Lift up your hearts." etc.] a Proper Preface which is related to the time in the Christian Year.

In the BCP (1549) Archbishop Cranmer provided for The Feast of the Trinity the following Preface (based on the Latin Preface which had been in use in England in the Sarum Rite):

"It is very meet, right and our bounden duty, that we should at all times, and in all places, gives thanks to thee O Lord, almighty everlasting God, which art one God, one Lord, not one only Person, but three Persons in one substance. For that which we believe of the glory of the Father, the same we believe of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, without any difference, or inequality: whom the Angels and Archangels laud and magnify..."

It will be noticed that this Preface is addressed to the Trinity as a Unity, the One God & Lord who is Three Persons in One Substance [Deity/Godhead/Divinity]. As such it accords with the Collect for Trinity Sunday which is also addressed to the Trinity as a Unity, the One God who is a Trinity of Persons.

The Collect is: "Almighty and everlasting God, who hast given unto us thy servants grace, by the confession of a true faith, to acknowledge the glory of the eternal Trinity, and in the power of the Divine Majesty to worship the Unity: We beseech thee, that thou wouldest keep us stedfast in this faith, and evermore defend us from all adversities, who livest and reignest, one God, world without end. Amen."

In the BCP (1662) the Preface and Collect both follow the 1549 texts.

The Preface in the Sarum Rite is actually addressed to the Father and in translation [*The Sarum Missal in English* (no author; anon.); London, 1868] reads:

"It is very meet, right, just, and our bounded duty that we should at all times and in all places give thanks unto Thee, O Lord Holy Father Almighty, everlasting God, Who with Thy only Begotten Son and The Holy Ghost art one God, art one Lord, not one only Person, but three Persons in one substance. For that which we believe of Thy Glory which Thou hast revealed, the same do we believe of Thy Son, and of the Holy Ghost, without difference or inequality: that in the confession of a true and everlasting Godhead both Distinction in the Persons, and Unity in Being, and Equality in Majesty, be worshipped: which Angels and Archangels praise, Cherubim also and Seraphim, Who cease not to cry with one voice, saying, ... "]

Thus in the 1549 & 1662 editions of the BCP the logic is as follows for Trinity Sunday: From "Lift up your hearts" until the end of the "Holy, Holy, Holy" the Prayer is addressed to the Holy Trinity as One Divinity, while the rest of the Prayer is addressed to the Father through the Son and with the Holy Ghost. In contrast, in the Sarum Rite the whole is addressed to the Father but with a theological doxology to the Trinity added.

The Council of Trent

In the Eucharistic Prayer of the Council of Trent ("The Tridentine Rite") from the sixteenth century, the Preface is much the same as Sarum and is addressed to the Father in these words:

"It is very meet, right and profitable for our salvation that we should at all times and in all places give thanks unto thee, holy Lord, Father Almighty, Everlasting God: who together with thine only-begotten Son, and the Holy Ghost, art one God, one Lord: not in the oneness of a single Person, but in the Trinity of one substance. For what we believe by thy Revelation of thy glory, the same do we believe of thy Son, the same of the Holy Ghost, without difference or inequality. So that in confessing the true and everlasting Godhead, distinction in Persons, unity in Being, and equality in Majesty may be adored, which the Angels and Archangels, the Cherubim also and the Seraphim do praise."

[It will be noticed that there is a switch to the third person from "so that." in order to acclaim the dogma of the Trinity as a Mystery for doxology.]

The American BCP

The American edition of the BCP of 1928 makes certain changes in order to make the Preface for Trinity Sunday accord with the address to the Father through the Son which is found in the rest of the Prayer of Consecration. Thus it reads:

It is very meet, right, and our bounden duty, that we should at all times and in all places, give thanks unto thee O Lord, Holy Father, Almighty, Everlasting God, who, with thine only-begotten Son, and the Holy Ghost, art one God, one Lord, in Trinity of Persons and in Unity of Substance. For that which we believe of thy glory, O Father, the same we believe of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, without any difference of inequality. Therefore with Angels...

We may claim that both the 1549-1662 Preface and the 1928 Preface are faithful to the received dogma of the Holy Trinity, but in different ways.

The Preface of 1549 clearly warns us against modern "Modalism", the doctrine that God is One Person with Three Primary Names and Modes of Being. God the LORD is not one Person but THREE Persons!

The Preface of 1928 clearly reminds us of the divine order in the Trinity as we find this revealed in the New Testament --- the Father together with His only Son and His Holy Spirit.

1979 & 2001

In the American 1979 Prayer Book, the Preface is addressed to the Father and is as follows:

"For with your co-eternal Son and Holy Spirit, you are one God, one Lord, in Trinity of Persons and in Unity of Substance; and we celebrate the one and equal glory of you, O Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit."

[Of this Preface Hatchet writes: "The new translation is better adapted for use as a proper preface" because the earlier ones were "more like doctrinal formularies than eucharistic Prayers". And he claims that "it set forth more clearly than the old the unity, equality and co-eternity of the Triune God." The translation is made from the Latin in the Gelasian Sacramentary, no 680, and the Gregorian no 1621.]

In the latest Church of England Prayer Book, "Common Worship" of 2001, the Preface addressed to the Father reads:

"And now we give you thanks because you have revealed the glory of your eternal fellowship of love with your Son and with the Holy Spirit, three persons equal in majesty, undivided in splendour, yet one God, every to be worshipped and adored."

[I am not sure whether this is a creation especially for this Book or that it is a free translation or adaptation of some earlier text. It would have been better to keep to the word "communion" so that it is an eternal communion of love rather than fellowship.]

Reflections on the American 1979 Preface

The 1979 Preface appears to have two important shifts from that of 1928. First, the shift from "believe" (which is connected to the idea of a "saving faith") to "celebrate" (which can be taken more metaphorically and avoids any specific, objective statement of belief). The second is a shift from the via negativa (without any difference of [or in 1549- inequality), which leaves room for mystery and the contemplation of the divine order, to the via positiva, so that a positive statement is made ("celebrated,") of "the one and equal glory." Hatchet's claims for its superiority are not well founded!

Probably most people will not take notice of this second shift. What it permits in the long term is the "communal" and "egalitarian" "Trinity" (so common today in church literature and ecumenical reports) that we encounter in the application of the human rights agenda to theology. The statement does not necessitate a communal Trinity, but it does make it more possible, since the more hesitant "lack of difference" is ever so much more cautious than the plain statement of "equality" (the highest of all modern "values"). This new statement is certainly much more confident before the Mysterium Tremendum that is God as THE LORD.

Returning to the 1549 Preface we may claim that Cranmer's instincts about the need to protect major dogmas were better than those of his successors. His objective Trinity is a bulwark against the subjectified Trinity that so many heretics have taught before and after his time. One should never remove safety devices, especially if one is not completely clear about what is being guarded against. The only good argument for the 1928 adjustment made to the 1549 version is the consistency of the address to the Father. On the other hand, a special, once a year exception has its merits precisely because of its being unusual and startling, and thus having teaching and worship value.

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Sunday, June 08, 2003

Gay Bishops & Human Rights

Adelphoi,

For your consideration...a discussion starter


On why dioceses accept Bishops & priests who are active homosexually ("gay").

Within the North ("West") of the Anglican Communion we have seen in the very recent past a statement from the Primates that same-sex partnerships are not morally acceptable for clergy & laity and also the appointment of two bishops (in C of E & ECUSA) who are or have been in such partnerships.

Why do the Dioceses in New Hampshire USA and Reading/Oxford in the UK make such appointments of gay priests as bishops?

We could say that the Church is deeply affected by the Zeitgeist (which is true), that the Church is deeply penetrated by secular standards (which is true), that the Church is seeking to be inclusive and tolerant (which is true), and that the Church is subject to falling to the temptations of the world, the flesh and the devil (which is true).

But why do seemingly decent people in the Diocese of Oxford, UK and in the Diocese of New Hampshire, USA not vocally and with their pocketbooks/checks oppose these innovations? Why do few decent people oppose them?

If there is one general reason I think that it is this. The theme of human rights has become for the West the general language of morality. So it is assumed that I can do whatever I feel is right for me unless it seriously harms another, and no one should interfere.

If we buy into the popular understanding of human rights (and such is assumed in the language of general culture) then we have to concede that other people - even in the church - have the right to be and to do what we may think (by God's revealed standards) is wrong, even sinful. Christian doctrine is thereby adjusted to accommodate human rights and reasons (tolerance, fairness, compassion etc) are given..

Homosexually active persons [and their supporters] have brilliantly incorporated their demands into the assumptions and language of human rights with the result that many good and decent people feel it is wrong for them to oppose those rights - for in this culture one does not oppose the human rights of another. To do so is the sin of sins. (The same kind of reasoning applies to the rights of couples who are heterosexual to live together as partners be they previously divorced or not - of seven weddings I am scheduled to officiate at this summer in semi-rural England all seven couples are living together as partners.)

For the Church to recover her previous moral doctrine and reasoning She needs to come to terms with the way that human rights have entered into her very soul and sort out where human rights begin and end and where God's law is in force! Merely to condemn the appointment of gay bishops or the permission to bless gay couples and to cite Scripture is not enough; it merely misses the target.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.),
Christ Church, Biddulph Moor & St Anne's, Brown Edge;
Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large of The Prayer Book Society of America.

Canon Gene Robinson elected Bishop Coadjutor of New Hampshire

In England, it is at Reading in Diocese of Oxford, in the USA in New Hampshire -- the times are a changing!

ACNS 3462 | USA | 7 JUNE 2003

[ACNS source: Diocese of New Hampshire] The Revd Canon Gene V Robinson was elected bishop coadjutor of the Episcopal Diocese of New Hampshire today on the 2nd ballot.

Canon Robinson is the first openly gay man in the Episcopal Church to be elected as a bishop.

The other nominees were: the Revd Ruth Lawson Kirk, rector of St Peter's Church in Glenside, PA; the Revd Canon Pamela Mott, pastor at Trinity Cathedral in Portland, OR; and the Revd Robert Tate, rector of St Martin-in-the-Fields parish in Philadelphia, PA. A fifth nominee, the Revd Joe Goodwin Burnett was elected bishop of Nebraska in May.

The leadership of the national Episcopal Church now must ratify Canon Robinsons election during the General Convention, meeting in Minneapolis in late July. Both the House of Bishops and the House of Deputies will need to approve his election by a two-thirds majority.

Canon Robinson has served as canon to the ordinary in New Hampshire since 1988 where he coordinates diocesan staff and ministry of the current bishop, the Rt Revd Douglas E Thuener. Since 1983, Canon Robinson has served as executive secretary of the Episcopal Province of New England, and since 2001 on the Board of Trustees of the General Theological Seminary in New York.

A 1969 graduate of the University of the South, Sewanee, Tennessee, he has a BA in American Studies/History. In 1973, he completed the MDiv at General Theological Seminary; after ordination he served as curate at Christ Church, Ridgewood, New Jersey. Upon moving to New Hampshire in 1975, he co-owned and directed an accredited girls' summer camp and horse farm. As founding director of Sign of the Dove Retreat Center in Temple, New Hampshire, he facilitated spiritual direction and designed programs for a variety of groups. He also managed the diocesan Living into Our Baptism program of spiritual growth and development.

Canon Robinson enjoys entertaining and cooking, gardening, music and running. The father of two grown daughters, Jamee and Ella, he lives with his partner Mark Andrew, employed by the New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services.

[A photo of the Revd Canon Gene Robinson is available from: http://www.anglicancommunion.org/acns/articles/34/50/acns3462.html

Pope Pays Tribute to Feminine "Genius" When Beatifying 1st Croatian Woman Honors Sister Maria of Jesus Crucified Petkovic

DUBROVNIK, Croatia, JUNE 6, 2003 (Zenit.org).- John Paul II stressed the need to make room for the "genius" of woman in society and the ecclesial community, as he beatified the first Croatian woman.

In this port city, some 50,000 people attended the eucharistic celebration for the beatification of Sister Maria of Jesus Crucified Petkovic (1892-1966), founder of the Franciscan Congregation of Daughters of Mercy.

The figure of the new blessed led the Pope to think of "those who are wives and mothers, those whose lives were for ever changed by the grief of losing a family member in the cruel war of the 1990s, or by other bitter troubles which they have endured."

"I think of you, dear women, because by your sensitivity, generosity and strength, you enrich the world's understanding and help to make human relations more honest and authentic," he said.

"In a special way, God has entrusted children to your care, and thus you are called to become an important support in the life of every person, especially within the context of the family," the Pope said.

"The frenetic pace of modern life can lead to an obscuring or even a loss of what is truly human," he added. "Perhaps more than in other periods of history, our time is in need of that genius which belongs to women, and which can ensure sensitivity for human beings in every circumstance.

"Women of Croatia, conscious of your lofty vocation as wives and mothers, continue to see every person with the eyes of the heart. Continue to reach out to them and to stand beside them with the sensitivity born of your maternal instinct."

The Holy Father added: "Your presence is indispensable in the family, in society and in the ecclesial community."

He also highlighted the decisive role of consecrated women, like Maria Petkovic, whom he invited to accept "the invitation to follow the undivided heart of Jesus Christ, chaste, poor and obedient."

"May the daily experience of God's freely given love inspire you to give your lives unreservedly to the service of the Church and of your brothers and sisters, commending all things, present and future, to his hands," he added.

Among those present, under an intense sun, were pilgrims from Bosnia and Herzegovina, Serbia and Montenegro, and other neighboring countries.

Virtually all of Dubrovnik's 46,000 inhabitants turned out to receive the Pope, who is visiting their country for the third time in less than 10 years.

Overnight, a group of young people from the Dubrovnik Diocese, accompanied by pilgrims, staged a five-hour vigil in Gruz, the city's port. The vigil included prayer and spiritual talks.

The roads leading from the airport to the port of Dubrovnik, where the beatification took place, were full of flags and banners welcoming John Paul II.

During the homily, the Pontiff paid tribute to Dubrovnik's tradition of freedom and justice. A maritime republic during the 15th and 16th centuries, it later became part of the Austrian Empire. As early as 1416, it abolished slavery.

Recalling the figure of Maria Petkovic, the Holy Father highlighted her total dedication "to the spiritual and material well-being of those most in need," and her missionary spirit which her spiritual daughters would take to Latin America.

After the beatification ceremony, the Pope lunched at the residence of Bishop Zelimir Puljic of Dubrovnik, together with priests of the diocese.

He later toured the historic center of Dubrovnik in the "popemobile." UNESCO has declared the city a cultural heritage of humanity.

Saturday, June 07, 2003

Congregational Survey in the Episcopal Church USA

Adelphoi,

For your perusal....


In the Blue Book of General Convention 2003, inside the report of the Liturgy & Music Commission (page 211 - link requires Adobe Acrobat Reader) there is printed the result of a congregational survey done over the last 2 years.

The findings are not surprising but are interesting.

Here are some of them.


•Most Episcopal Churches are small congregations.
•Most do not have Morning or Evening Prayer as public services.
•Most have two Eucharists on Sunday, one without music and one with music.
•Rite II (modern language) is most generally used for both Eucharists.
•Services usually last one hour with 10 mins or so of preaching.
•Use of the 1979 prayer book is virtually universal, supplemented by "Enriching our Worship" in some places
•Use of 1982 Hymnal is virtually universal and the organ primary instrument to make music
•Generally people stand for the opening rite, kneel for most of the Eucharistic Prayer and stand for the dismissal.
•Prayers are almost always "Prayers of the People" from 1979 prayer book.
•Most clergy wear eucharistic vestments and celebrate facing the people.
•Lay people take part in planning and conducting the Eucharist.
•Most people dress casually or semi-casually for worship services.
•The passing of the peace is almost universal as a major part of the services.

This means that those who still have Morning Prayer (with sermon) as a major service, who use Rite I [traditional language rites] of the 1979 book or who use the 1928 BCP for MP or Holy C., who use the 1940 Hymnal, and where the priest faces East for the Eucharistic Prayer are in a minority.

It also means that those who are way out to the left using experimental liturgies dominated by inclusive language are also in a minority - though vocal.

The majority of ECUSA congregations have popular eucharistic worship using the 1970s rites of the 1979 prayer book and with minimal time given to biblical exposition in preaching. This means that they are open to the absorption of modern ideas of God, salvation and sexuality because of the nature and content of these services with their openness to human rights, self-expansion and realisation.

From an evangelical, reformed catholic, biblical standpoint, it is very difficult to see how genuine revival can begin in majority of churches of the ECUSA since there is little or no sure foundation being provided in the average type of worship that comes with a popular type of modern celebratory eucharist, where there is little or no emphasis upon human sin before God and on the holiness and majesty of the Father Almighty.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

CAMPAIGN TO REMOVE SHAPE AND TEXT

On Page 212 of the Blue Book for the 2003 General Convention in the report of the Standing Commission on Liturgy & Music (link requires Adobe Acrobat Reader) we read:

“Resulting from the diocesan and congregational surveys and from the Standing Commission’s discussion with communities representing a variety of cultures in our church, the following recommendations are made…Launch a diversified campaign inviting the whole church to move beyond worship that is primarily shaped and bound by text into worship that is intentionally open to the renewing power of God transforming the world.”

Then there are further recommendations for the fulfilment of this basic one.

In order to understand how revolutionary this proposal is we need to recall.

(a) that the whole of the Anglican tradition of worship since 1549 has been based on The Book of Common Prayer and its texts. By having an excellent text, worshippers have been taught and encouraged to rise with and via the text in the Spirit and through Jesus Christ to the Father in worship in spirit and in truth.

(b) Worship that is without text and shape is possible but extremely difficult for mortals to engage in successfully, but it has never been part of the Anglican Way of Reformed Catholic Faith and Practice.

In order to see the determination of the revolutionaries and innovators we need to notice that they desire “to launch a diversified campaign” – that is a kind of spiritual warfare to overturn enemy structures. However, “campaign” is softened by the use of “invite”!

But whatever words are chosen, here is a total revolution proposed. Anglicans are being called to give up the guidance of a prepared text (be it the classic text of the BCP 1928 or the revised texts of the 1979 prayer book) in order to be open to the immanent God who is supposedly present in the reforming of this world. In contrast, the God to whom the classic texts point is the God of glory and majesty who while being with us in this world as we witness for Him also calls us out of its ethos and sin to look for and wait for a world that is “above” and “supernatural” and is “the kingdom of heaven.”

We have had campaigns in the recent pas in the ECUSA to reject the shape and texts of the classic Prayer Book (1662 & 1928 editions) to be replaced with the new shape (cf. Dix, Shape of the Liturgy) and with varied modern ingredients to put into the new shape – even as we have had campaigns to incorporate feminist, inclusive, lesbigay, multicultural, multigenerational & other concerns. Since the innovatory 1979 prayer book we have had a host of further services approved by Gen Conv. to incorporate these concerns, and now it seems we enter a new and uncharted era.

Now we are to trust in God’s power (to be differentiated from the Zeitgeist?) to worship God (the Holy Trinity of biblical revelation? Or a vague Unitarianism?) without reliance on texts and presumably without reliance on the doctrinal content of the Anglican Formularies.

We know from observing pentecostalist, charismatic and free church congregations that claims to be open to the Spirit and to God’s concerns often mean no more than being led by the emotions and feelings and/or by the convictions of leaders or mentors or dominant personalities. Texts are used by the better congregations!

The Standing Commission is calling in essence for a campaign for the abolition of the historic Anglican Way and for the ECUSA resources (land, buildings, money, institutions etc) to be devoted to a vague kind of experiental Unitarianism or Pantheism or Panentheism that sees the Christian hope primarily in this worldly terms.

Be sure to pray the classic LITANY.

[Be sure also this Pentecost season to hear the classic C of E Homily for this Festival -- hear it read on the Biddulph website www.christchurch-biddulph.fsnet.co.uk]

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Liturgy ECUSA Style

ECUSA $300.000.00 for Liturgy in the triennium (03-06)

Hanging on to "Common"

In Resolution A107 (page 107, link requires Adobe Acrobat Reader) the Standing Commission for Liturgy and Music will ask the General Convention of the ECUSA in August 2003 for Three hundred thousand dollars “to implement the vision for the Renewal and Enrichment of the Common Worship of this Church.”

As in the Church of England, so now in the Episcopal Church of the USA the dominant expression is COMMON WORSHIP. In fact, over the last thirty or forty years we have seen first the attempt to change the meaning of Common Prayer and then the move to use of Common Worship.

Not very long ago, everywhere and by all Common Prayer meant both the Book of Common Prayer (first edition 1549) and the set services from that book (in the USA, three editions, 1789, 1892 & 1928). Then from the 1970s the ECUSA attempted to change the meaning by calling its prayer book of 1976/79, which has a variety of choices for services and a new shape to them, by the title “Common Prayer” – instead of “An American Prayer Book” or the like. This was part of a movement to discredit the classic definition and use of the inherited Prayer Book by claiming that “Common Prayer” really referred to the use of common elements (e.g., Creed, Lord’s Prayer etc), a common shape or structure (into which can be inserted varied ingredients) and to that which an Anglican Province authorized for use in its territory.

This process was assisted ecumenically by the use of the term “Common Lectionary” ( a lectionary that several churches have in common). But more recently, having nearly destroyed the classic understanding of Common Prayer, the ECUSA has preferred to refer to its expanding choice of authorized services as “common worship” where this title seems to mean “that which, despite its great variety and internal inconsistencies, is authorized by the Church for use in all or part of the same Church”. Thus the forthcoming creation and authorization of new liturgies, which will form eventually a replacement for the 1979 prayer book and all other services authorized since 1979, is called “Common Worship.”

In the Church of England, “Common Worship” since 2000 refers to a Directory of volumes (CD’s) that is slowly increasing and offering choices for every kind of service for use in the parishes of the Church. However, it has not officially replaced The Book of Common Prayer (1662) which remains the Formulary of the Church (with the Articles of Religion and the Ordinal). Yet in the first volume of the Directory called Common Worship, services from the Book of Common Prayer (slightly adapted) are included – presumably in the hope that people will not need to use the classic Prayer Book at all.

Thus we find that the ECUSA, as the C of E, is hanging on to the word “common” for something that hardly fits the meaning of “common” at all. With “Common Lectionary” it may be said that here is a List of Sunday Readings which are used in common by several Churches, but “Common Worship” is hardly a Directory of services which are used in common by parishes in one province. Rather the latter means “that which is authorized by the Synod/Convention for use whether or not it is used at all and whether or not it conforms to a basic doctrinal foundation.”

Why does the ECUSA not simply speak of “the Directory” or simply “Worship”? Why does it insist on using “Common”? Perhaps to claim a link with the past; perhaps to offer a legitimisation for introducing new shapes and doctrines; perhaps to help people feel good about the major innovations that are being introduced.

It is entirely possible (if strong requests are made) that within the new Directory or “Common Worship” of the ECUSA, there will be placed the whole of or part of the classic texts of “The Book of Common Prayer, 1928” – just as is so in the C of E’s “Common Worship.” What is now called “Rite One” (i.e., services in traditional language) would then presumably not be needed. Once the definition of “common” has reached its present width, there is no logical reason why what is deemed as the old text cannot be made a part of the present offering of variety.

(See further on this general theme: Peter Toon, Common Worship Considered, Edgeways Books, September 03 – www.edgewaysbooks.com)

PLEASE NOTE THAT THE HOMILY FOR PENTECOST/WHITSUN FROM THE OFFICIAL BOOK OF HOMILIES OF THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND IS NOW AVAILABLE FOR YOUR HEARING -- CLICK HERE. PLEASE MAKE A VISIT AND HEAR THIS CLASSIC HOMILY ON THE HOLY GHOST!

The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)

Thursday, June 05, 2003

C S Lewis and the ECUSA

The following Collect and Bible readings are to be approved at the G. Convention in 2003.

November 22, Clive Staples Lewis. Apologist & Spiritual Writer, 1963

[The collect is offered in so called traditional and contemporary language and they are identical except for the pronouns.]

O God of searing truth and surpassing beauty, we give you thanks for Clive Staples Lewis whose sanctified imagination lights fires of faith in young and old alike; Surprise us also with joy and draw us into that new and abundant life which is ours in Christ Jesus, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.

Psalm 139:109; Lesson 1 Peter 1:3-9; John 16: 7-15. Preface of a Saint (3) from 1979 prayer book.

Comment.

I cannot imagine that C S Lewis favoured the placing in the Calendar of persons like himself. He has certainly been and to some extent remains influential, especially amongst American Evangelicals with a good education. And the fact that he married a needy divorcee in a gracious manner, has helped his reputation with people living in a divorce culture.

We must presume that there is some direct connection between the description of God in the address and the achievement of C S Lewis in the thanksgiving. Further we note that Lewis used more than his imagination (even in the books for children), he also used his intellect and his vast knowledge of classical literature in his apologetic writings.

The choice of the relatively rare word, searing, which usually means the act of burning or cauterising is rather odd when used of God and his truth. A searing iron, yes, searing truth in and of God – probably no? But perhaps the relation is with lighting fires of faith or maybe this is an allusion to something Lewis wrote or said.

Then what should we make of surpassing beauty – surpassing what? Perhaps the beauty of creation on earth and in heaven. God’s Beauty (as Augustine tells) is a unique Beauty.

But this way of addressing God is too impersonal. It would have been better to follow classical usage and make use of the relative clause to recall before God, the Father, divine attributes & activities that actually were special to Lewis or which provide the basis for the petition in the collect. (Instead the relative clause is used in relation to Lewis!)

Whether Lewis as a writer only lights fires of faith is a matter of debate. He helps different people in different ways, but not all people!

Before “Surprise” a colon not a semi-colon is needed to justify the upper case “S”. Then it is not clear why “also” is needed in the petition for there has not been an earlier petition. Further, while the petition has merit as a petition of Christian people, it does not naturally relate to or flow from the descriptions of God and of C S Lewis in the first half of the collect. From truth, beauty, imagination and faith, there is a move to joy and to new and abundant life, and it is not clear why this occurs.

Obviously the “Surprise with Joy” is meant to recall the title of a book of Lewis, but only a few would possess this information who actually hear this prayer. And even if they did recognize it, what is the logical relation of being surprised by joy to what has been said already?

Then, finally, such a petition does not need a full doxological ending, which has been traditionally reserved for collects of major festivals in the classic tradition.

Back to the drawing board! Better still, forget about a collect for CS Lewis, whose writings alone stand as a worthy testimony to the man.


The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon M.A., D.Phil. (Oxon.)