Thursday, November 14, 2002
From where do the Collects of the BCP come?
While the Collects of The Book of Common Prayer (PECUSA,1928) generally conform to a common structure, they come from a variety of sources. Most of them are derived from the English editions of the BCP (1549 & 1662). So let us look at from where the Collects of the 1662 Prayer Book derive.
We find that (a) the largest group is made up of translations (chiefly by Archbishop Thomas Cranmer) from the Latin Collects of the Missal in the "Use of Sarum", and behind this medieval English source, to original Latin collections from late patristic times; (b) the middle-size group are English prose creations of Thomas Cranmer himself (or of a colleague) written for the first BCP of 1549; and the smallest group is by Bishop John Cosin in the 17th century.
The "Use of Sarum" was created by Bishop Osmund of Salisbury (Sarum) in 1085 and quickly became the principal text for the Liturgy/ Mass in the Ecclesia Anglicana, the Latin-speaking Church of England. And it remained in use until the sixteenth century, being still the norm during most of the reign of Henry VIII. It was similar to, yet different in details from, the Roman Use/Liturgy. In assembling this Use, Bishop Osmund collected and edited existing liturgical texts and sources from the Early Church. The Collects, Epistles & Gospels were taken chiefly from three ancient Sacramentaries (hand written books containing the Collects and the major part of the Mass) related to the names of Pope Leo I (d.461), Pope Gelasius (d.496), and Pope Gregory the Great (d.604). About fifty- three from these sources, as found in the "Use of Sarum" were used in The Book of the Common Prayer (1529).
Five of the Collects used by Cranmer for Holy Communion come from the Leonine Sacramentary. They are those for the Third Sunday after Easter, and for the Fifth, Ninth, Thirteenth and Fourteenth Sundays after Trinity.
Twenty and a half of the Collects used by Cranmer for Holy Communion come from the Gelasian Sacramentary. They are those for the 4th in Advent, Innocents Day, Palm Sunday, Good Friday II, Easter Day (1/2), 4th & 5th after Easter & I, II, VI, VII, VIII, X, XI, XII, XV, XVI, XVIII, XIX, XX, & XXI after Trinity; then, also, in addition to the Eucharistic prayers, the Morning and Evening Collects for Peace, the Evening Collect for Aid against all Perils, the Prayer for Clergy and People, the Confirmation Prayer for the seven-fold Spirit and others are from there as well.
And twenty-seven and a half of the Collects used by Cranmer for Holy Communion come from the Gregorian Sacramentary. They are those for St Stephen's & St John Evangelist, the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th & 5th after Epiphany, Septuagesima, Sexagesima, the 2nd, 3rd, 4th & 5th Sundays in Lent, Good Friday I, Easter Day (1/2), Ascension, Whitsun, III, IV, XVII, XXII, XXIII, XXIV & XXV after Trinity, the Purification, the Annunciation & Michaelmas; then also others in the Litany and Baptismal Service, and such others as "Prevent us,O Lord.".
Now we move on to note the creations of the sixteenth century, particularly the hand of Cranmer. Six of the Sunday Collects - Advent I & II, Lent I, Quinquagesima, Easter I & II, and fourteen others - Christmas Day, All Saints' and twelve Saints' Days. All these are written in the same prose, style and structure as the translations from the Latin of the others.
In 1661 in preparation for the BCP (1662) Bishop John Cosin of Durham wrote three new Collects (Advent III, Epiphany VI and Easter Even) and made major adjustments to that for St Stephen's Day.
Then, not in the BCP (1662) but in the American BCP (1928) there are Collects for "A Saint's Day" from William Bright, "Dedication of a Church" from John Dowden, "Ember Days" from William Heathcote DeLancey, "Rogation Days" from John Cosin, "Independence Day" from Edward Lambe Parsons, "Burial of the Dead" from John Wordsworth, and a few others whose authorship is not known.
The Collects of the reformed Catholic or Anglican way, it has been said, like the truths of the Gospel, are both old and new. Some of them were made new in the sixteenth century; but, the very Collects that were old then became new because of the freshness of the translation into English. So in the first Prayer Book of 1549 there are 48 old collects translated, 9 altered and 25 made new. And the structure and style of the new ones are based upon those of the old ones. They are excellent prayers to learn by heart!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
WHAT IS A COLLECT?
We find in classic editions of The Book of Common Prayer that the word "Collect" is distinguished from both the Litany and the Eucharistic Prayer and appears to be used in two senses, a precise and also a general sense.
In the strict or precise sense, it may be said that only those are truly Collects which are used with the Epistle and Gospel in the Eucharistic Lectionary, and as the Collects of the Day in the Morning and Evening Prayer.
To these we may add (a) the last prayer in the Order for the Burial of the Dead (1662) which originally had an Epistle and Gospel attached to it, and
(b) the opening prayer of the Order for Holy Communion, the Collect for purity, which summarises the preparation of the people of God for this eucharistic service.
Then in a less precise sense we have the Collects in the Services of Holy Baptism being (a) the two prayers before the Gospel in The Ministration of the Publick Baptism of Infants (1662) and (b) the prayer before the Gospel in The Ministration of Holy Baptism (1928). Then in an even less precise
sense: (c) the two sets of two Collects, which follow the Collect of the Day in both Morning and Evening Prayer; (d) the prayers at the end of the Litany, introduced by "Let us pray" and (e) the "Collect or Prayer" for all Conditions of men.
Collecta is the original Latin word, meaning a gathering of any sort. So what does the Collect gather together? There are various possibilities and there appears to be a measure of truth in each of them:
1.The gathering together in a precise form certain aspects of the teaching in the Epistle and/or Gospel to which it is attached. 2.The gathering together of the thoughts (recollection) of the people of God, a collectedness of mind. 3.The prayer to be used when people actually assemble together for worship - oratio ad collectum.
The Collects, precisely so called, normally have a common structure, though sometimes one of the parts thereof is missing.
First, there is the Invocation where God (usually God the Father, but sometimes the Lord Jesus Christ) is addressed and invoked.
In the second place, there is the Recital and remembrance of some doctrine or else fact of a biblical topic or theme - e.g., of salvation, redemption, or providence.
Then, thirdly, there is the Petition, which constitutes the body of the short prayer.
In the fourth place, there is the Aspiration or devout wish.
Finally, there is the Pleading of the Name of Jesus, the Mediator, when the prayer is to the Father.
This structure may be illustrated from the long Collect appointed for the Burial of the Dead (1662).
"O Merciful God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is the resurrection and the life; in whom whosoever believeth shall live, though he die; and whosoever liveth, and believeth in him, shall not die eternally; who also hath taught us, by his holy Apostle Saint Paul, not to be sorry, as men without hope, for them that sleep in him: We meekly beseech thee, O Father, to raise us up from the death of sin unto the life of righteousness; that when we shall depart this life, we may rest in him, as our hope is this our brother/sister doth; and that, at the general resurrection in the last day, we may be found acceptable in thy sight; and receive that blessing, which they well-beloved Son shall then pronounce to all that love and fear thee, saying, Come ye blessed children of my Father, receive the kingdom prepared for you from the beginning of the world. Grant this, we beseech thee, O Merciful Father, through Jesus Christ, our Mediator and Redeemer."
Invocation: "O Merciful God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ."
Recital: "who is the Resurrection and the Life.that sleep in him."
Petition: "We meekly beseech thee, O Father, to raise us up from the death of sin unto the life of righteousness."
Aspiration: "that when we shall depart this life, we may rest in him.world."
Pleading: "Grant this, we beseech thee, O Merciful Father, through Jesus Christ, our Mediator and Redeemer."
There are other ways of expressing the Structure of the Collect, e.g., "(i) an introductory address and commemoration, on which is based (ii) a single central prayer: from this in turn (iii) other clauses of petition or desire are developed, and (iv) the whole concludes with some fixed form of ending" the last usually being, if the prayer is addressed to the Father, a variant on "per Iesum Christum dominum nostrum" sometimes followed by a doxology.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
In the strict or precise sense, it may be said that only those are truly Collects which are used with the Epistle and Gospel in the Eucharistic Lectionary, and as the Collects of the Day in the Morning and Evening Prayer.
To these we may add (a) the last prayer in the Order for the Burial of the Dead (1662) which originally had an Epistle and Gospel attached to it, and
(b) the opening prayer of the Order for Holy Communion, the Collect for purity, which summarises the preparation of the people of God for this eucharistic service.
Then in a less precise sense we have the Collects in the Services of Holy Baptism being (a) the two prayers before the Gospel in The Ministration of the Publick Baptism of Infants (1662) and (b) the prayer before the Gospel in The Ministration of Holy Baptism (1928). Then in an even less precise
sense: (c) the two sets of two Collects, which follow the Collect of the Day in both Morning and Evening Prayer; (d) the prayers at the end of the Litany, introduced by "Let us pray" and (e) the "Collect or Prayer" for all Conditions of men.
Collecta is the original Latin word, meaning a gathering of any sort. So what does the Collect gather together? There are various possibilities and there appears to be a measure of truth in each of them:
1.The gathering together in a precise form certain aspects of the teaching in the Epistle and/or Gospel to which it is attached. 2.The gathering together of the thoughts (recollection) of the people of God, a collectedness of mind. 3.The prayer to be used when people actually assemble together for worship - oratio ad collectum.
The Collects, precisely so called, normally have a common structure, though sometimes one of the parts thereof is missing.
First, there is the Invocation where God (usually God the Father, but sometimes the Lord Jesus Christ) is addressed and invoked.
In the second place, there is the Recital and remembrance of some doctrine or else fact of a biblical topic or theme - e.g., of salvation, redemption, or providence.
Then, thirdly, there is the Petition, which constitutes the body of the short prayer.
In the fourth place, there is the Aspiration or devout wish.
Finally, there is the Pleading of the Name of Jesus, the Mediator, when the prayer is to the Father.
This structure may be illustrated from the long Collect appointed for the Burial of the Dead (1662).
"O Merciful God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is the resurrection and the life; in whom whosoever believeth shall live, though he die; and whosoever liveth, and believeth in him, shall not die eternally; who also hath taught us, by his holy Apostle Saint Paul, not to be sorry, as men without hope, for them that sleep in him: We meekly beseech thee, O Father, to raise us up from the death of sin unto the life of righteousness; that when we shall depart this life, we may rest in him, as our hope is this our brother/sister doth; and that, at the general resurrection in the last day, we may be found acceptable in thy sight; and receive that blessing, which they well-beloved Son shall then pronounce to all that love and fear thee, saying, Come ye blessed children of my Father, receive the kingdom prepared for you from the beginning of the world. Grant this, we beseech thee, O Merciful Father, through Jesus Christ, our Mediator and Redeemer."
Invocation: "O Merciful God, the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ."
Recital: "who is the Resurrection and the Life.that sleep in him."
Petition: "We meekly beseech thee, O Father, to raise us up from the death of sin unto the life of righteousness."
Aspiration: "that when we shall depart this life, we may rest in him.world."
Pleading: "Grant this, we beseech thee, O Merciful Father, through Jesus Christ, our Mediator and Redeemer."
There are other ways of expressing the Structure of the Collect, e.g., "(i) an introductory address and commemoration, on which is based (ii) a single central prayer: from this in turn (iii) other clauses of petition or desire are developed, and (iv) the whole concludes with some fixed form of ending" the last usually being, if the prayer is addressed to the Father, a variant on "per Iesum Christum dominum nostrum" sometimes followed by a doxology.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Wednesday, November 13, 2002
TRINITY XXV (= Epiphany VI) Meditation on the Collect
RUBRIC for November 17th, 2002:
so that on the Sunday immediately before Advent Sunday the appointed Collect, Epistle and Gospel for "the Sunday next before Advent" can be used for those who use the ancient Eucharistic Lectionary in the BCP:
The Epistle: 1 John 3:1-8 The Gospel: St Matthew 24:23-31
This Collect was written by Bishop Cosin in 1661 for the BCP of 1662 and is an excellent example of 17th century writing of a compact prayer for public worship.
The Prayer begins by the people of God recalling in the presence of God the Father Almighty some of the primary reasons why his only-begotten Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, became Incarnate of the Blessed Virgin Mary. Three are stated - to destroy the works of the devil, to make us sons (children) of God, and to make us the heirs of eternal life.
St John tell us that "for this purpose the Son of God was manifested that he might destroy (literally "loose", apply a solvent to) the works of the devil" (1 John 3:8). Jesus successfully resisted the temptations of the devil in the wilderness, was continually casting devil/demons out of sick people, and saw his sacrificial death upon the Cross as the final part of his battle with the devil. The death of Jesus, instigated by the devil, was in the wisdom of God the great means of defeating the devil. Of his apostles he said, "In my name they shall cast out devils" (Mark 16:17).
Those who believe on the name of the Lord Jesus are forgiven, justified and made the children of God by adoption and heirs of eternal life with the same Lord Jesus in heaven. "If children then heirs, heirs of God and joint-heirs with Christ" (Romans 8:17).
The Son of God's Incarnation and Saving Work has a twofold aspect. It is both destructive and creative - destructive of sin which is in origin the devil's work, and creative of divine sonship & eternal life, which is in totality divine work.
From recollection of the purpose of the Incarnation, the prayer turns to petition, basing the petition on the declaration of Christian hope already expressed - "sons of God and heirs of eternal life." We pray that "we may purify ourselves even as he is pure" and that "we shall be made like unto him."
Purification corresponds to the destructive work of Christ - to remove & destroy sin in order to be purified. "As Christ was manifested to destroy sin by his sacrificial blood of the Cross, grant that we, fully cooperating with his grace, may destroy sin in ourselves." (Cf. 2 Corinthians 7:1).
Being made like him in the resurrection of the dead for life in heaven corresponds to the creative and renewing work of the Father through Jesus Christ by the Holy Ghost. "We know that when he shall appear we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is" (1 John 3:2).
The conclusion of the Collect is different from others because of its specific invocation of the First (the Father) and Third (the Holy Ghost) Persons of the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity - "with Thee, O Father, and thee, O Holy Ghost." It has the effect of placing the minds of the petitioners in front of the eternal throne, prostrating themselves in a spirit of adoration before the LORD God, the Father, in Christ Jesus the Son and by the Holy Ghost, unto ages of ages.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
If in any year [as in 2002] there be twenty-six Sundays after Trinity, the service for the Sixth Sunday after the Epiphany shall be used on the Twenty-fifth Sunday.
so that on the Sunday immediately before Advent Sunday the appointed Collect, Epistle and Gospel for "the Sunday next before Advent" can be used for those who use the ancient Eucharistic Lectionary in the BCP:
O God, whose blessed Son was manifested that he might destroy the works of the devil, and make us the sons of God, and heirs of eternal life: Grant us, we beseech thee, that, having this hope, we may purify ourselves, even as he is pure; that, when he shall appear again with power and great glory, we may be made like unto him in his eternal and glorious kingdom; where with thee, O Father, and thee, O Holy Ghost, he liveth and reigneth, ever one God, world without end. Amen.
The Epistle: 1 John 3:1-8 The Gospel: St Matthew 24:23-31
This Collect was written by Bishop Cosin in 1661 for the BCP of 1662 and is an excellent example of 17th century writing of a compact prayer for public worship.
The Prayer begins by the people of God recalling in the presence of God the Father Almighty some of the primary reasons why his only-begotten Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, became Incarnate of the Blessed Virgin Mary. Three are stated - to destroy the works of the devil, to make us sons (children) of God, and to make us the heirs of eternal life.
St John tell us that "for this purpose the Son of God was manifested that he might destroy (literally "loose", apply a solvent to) the works of the devil" (1 John 3:8). Jesus successfully resisted the temptations of the devil in the wilderness, was continually casting devil/demons out of sick people, and saw his sacrificial death upon the Cross as the final part of his battle with the devil. The death of Jesus, instigated by the devil, was in the wisdom of God the great means of defeating the devil. Of his apostles he said, "In my name they shall cast out devils" (Mark 16:17).
Those who believe on the name of the Lord Jesus are forgiven, justified and made the children of God by adoption and heirs of eternal life with the same Lord Jesus in heaven. "If children then heirs, heirs of God and joint-heirs with Christ" (Romans 8:17).
The Son of God's Incarnation and Saving Work has a twofold aspect. It is both destructive and creative - destructive of sin which is in origin the devil's work, and creative of divine sonship & eternal life, which is in totality divine work.
From recollection of the purpose of the Incarnation, the prayer turns to petition, basing the petition on the declaration of Christian hope already expressed - "sons of God and heirs of eternal life." We pray that "we may purify ourselves even as he is pure" and that "we shall be made like unto him."
Purification corresponds to the destructive work of Christ - to remove & destroy sin in order to be purified. "As Christ was manifested to destroy sin by his sacrificial blood of the Cross, grant that we, fully cooperating with his grace, may destroy sin in ourselves." (Cf. 2 Corinthians 7:1).
Being made like him in the resurrection of the dead for life in heaven corresponds to the creative and renewing work of the Father through Jesus Christ by the Holy Ghost. "We know that when he shall appear we shall be like him, for we shall see him as he is" (1 John 3:2).
The conclusion of the Collect is different from others because of its specific invocation of the First (the Father) and Third (the Holy Ghost) Persons of the Blessed, Holy and Undivided Trinity - "with Thee, O Father, and thee, O Holy Ghost." It has the effect of placing the minds of the petitioners in front of the eternal throne, prostrating themselves in a spirit of adoration before the LORD God, the Father, in Christ Jesus the Son and by the Holy Ghost, unto ages of ages.
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Tuesday, November 12, 2002
Classic Collects as Golden Bowls full of Incense
"When the Lamb had taken the scroll, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down before the Lamb, each holding a harp, and with golden bowls of incense, which are the prayers of the saints; and they sang a new song, saying, 'Worthy art thou.'" (Rev. 5:8).
In the last book of the Bible, the Revelation of St John, which is filled with fascinating imagery, Jesus Christ is called the LAMB twenty-nine times. Though he still bears the marks of his being slaughtered, he also has the marks of exaltation (for his seven horns [= omnipotence] and seven eyes [= omniscience]). And his heavenly habitat is filled with music, as Christian Rosetti once said: "Heaven is revealed to earth as the homeland of music." The praise is from all creation (represented by the four living creatures) and from the elect people of God of the Old and New Covenants ( 12 + 12, 24 elders). It is also from the myriad of angels. The whole creation, visible and invisible joins in the praise of the Creator.
In this picture of a whole universe praising Christ, the prayers of the saints, who still labour on earth for the kingdom of God, are described as golden vessels filled with the sweet odour of incense. This picture recalls the use of incense of the Jewish Temple: "Let my prayer be set before thee as incense; and the lifting up of my hands as the evening sacrifice."
Prayer comes from the depths of the soul and it is expressed in words created by the mind and uttered by the lips. In personal, private prayer the words are often ejaculatory and extempore. But no so in public, common prayer where normally there is the reaching for excellence and thus prepared forms of prayer.
In the vision from Revelation 5 the prayers of the saints are in a golden cup, vessel or bowl. Gold was the most precious of metals and thus the golden vial points to the sound, sterling quality of the words and their felicitous and elegant arrangement. But there is more to prayers than their excellence in grammar, syntax and style. They are to be through Christ Jesus unto God the Father as sweet smelling odour, as holy incense. That is, they are to be biblical and in conformity with God's will and mind, and arising from purified affections, desires and intentions of the souls of the baptized.
In the Collects of the classic Book of Common Prayer (e.g., editions of 1549, 1662, 1928) we have the golden bowl, the excellence in words of public prayer to God the Father. First in Latin and then in English they have been for 1400 years as the manna in the wilderness to devout spirits, and are, next to Scripture itself, the clearest standard whereby genuine piety may be discerned; the surest guidance by which its progress may be directed; the highest mark to which its wishes would aspire. Obviously their passionate and elegant words need to be matched by appropriately devout affections, desires and intentions of the soul in the congregation of the saints.
As naturally as kindled incense ascends upwards, the public prayers of the congregation of the saints also ascend to the Father because of the merits of his Son, and they are "an odour of a sweet smell, a sacrifice acceptable, well-pleasing to God" (Phil. 4:18).
If a choice has to be made between, on the one hand, the use of excellent Collects [as in the classic BCP] by an apostate congregation, and, on the other, the use of poorly constructed Collects [as in some modern Anglican Liturgy] by a faithful congregation, then the devout soul will choose the latter; but, he will surely wish that this faithful congregation would use the excellency of the golden bowl of incense, rather than one made of an inferior metal!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
In the last book of the Bible, the Revelation of St John, which is filled with fascinating imagery, Jesus Christ is called the LAMB twenty-nine times. Though he still bears the marks of his being slaughtered, he also has the marks of exaltation (for his seven horns [= omnipotence] and seven eyes [= omniscience]). And his heavenly habitat is filled with music, as Christian Rosetti once said: "Heaven is revealed to earth as the homeland of music." The praise is from all creation (represented by the four living creatures) and from the elect people of God of the Old and New Covenants ( 12 + 12, 24 elders). It is also from the myriad of angels. The whole creation, visible and invisible joins in the praise of the Creator.
In this picture of a whole universe praising Christ, the prayers of the saints, who still labour on earth for the kingdom of God, are described as golden vessels filled with the sweet odour of incense. This picture recalls the use of incense of the Jewish Temple: "Let my prayer be set before thee as incense; and the lifting up of my hands as the evening sacrifice."
Prayer comes from the depths of the soul and it is expressed in words created by the mind and uttered by the lips. In personal, private prayer the words are often ejaculatory and extempore. But no so in public, common prayer where normally there is the reaching for excellence and thus prepared forms of prayer.
In the vision from Revelation 5 the prayers of the saints are in a golden cup, vessel or bowl. Gold was the most precious of metals and thus the golden vial points to the sound, sterling quality of the words and their felicitous and elegant arrangement. But there is more to prayers than their excellence in grammar, syntax and style. They are to be through Christ Jesus unto God the Father as sweet smelling odour, as holy incense. That is, they are to be biblical and in conformity with God's will and mind, and arising from purified affections, desires and intentions of the souls of the baptized.
In the Collects of the classic Book of Common Prayer (e.g., editions of 1549, 1662, 1928) we have the golden bowl, the excellence in words of public prayer to God the Father. First in Latin and then in English they have been for 1400 years as the manna in the wilderness to devout spirits, and are, next to Scripture itself, the clearest standard whereby genuine piety may be discerned; the surest guidance by which its progress may be directed; the highest mark to which its wishes would aspire. Obviously their passionate and elegant words need to be matched by appropriately devout affections, desires and intentions of the soul in the congregation of the saints.
As naturally as kindled incense ascends upwards, the public prayers of the congregation of the saints also ascend to the Father because of the merits of his Son, and they are "an odour of a sweet smell, a sacrifice acceptable, well-pleasing to God" (Phil. 4:18).
If a choice has to be made between, on the one hand, the use of excellent Collects [as in the classic BCP] by an apostate congregation, and, on the other, the use of poorly constructed Collects [as in some modern Anglican Liturgy] by a faithful congregation, then the devout soul will choose the latter; but, he will surely wish that this faithful congregation would use the excellency of the golden bowl of incense, rather than one made of an inferior metal!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Sunday, November 10, 2002
Bishop Colin Buchanan on Liturgical Reform
The most well-known evangelical advocate of the reform and "renewal" of Liturgy in the last third of the 20th century was Colin Buchanan, as he worked from St John's College, Nottingham and then as a suffragan Bishop in Birmingham. He demonstrated learning, enthusiasm and advocacy for the creation of a whole new, modern liturgy for the Church of England and Anglican Churches abroad. To this day, Grove Books, which he founded, publishes all kinds of liturgical and other studies. (But now in the 21st Century Colin is perhaps best known as an advocate of the dis-establishment of the Church of England.)
In 1982, twenty years ago, he wrote of liturgical reform:
"Essentially, English language revision took place in two stages: 1. 'Thou '-form texts, which ruled unchallenged until 1966, and yet never produced a new text after 1968. 2. 'You'-form texts, which were unthinkable before 1966, and invariable after 1968." ("Liturgical Revision" in LITURGY RESHAPED, ed. K. Stevenson, 1982, p,147)
He went on to claim that this analysis covered the C of E, the R.C. Church & the Methodist Church in Britain, as well as Anglican Church abroad.
We may recall that immediately after Vatican II Roman Catholics used traditional English for translation of the Mass but that this ceased around 1970, with the big push for the use of a modern vernacular translation from Rome. Since 1970 only a modern vernacular translation has been permitted.
But did the production of "Thou-form" texts cease as he says by 1968? I think not. If we look at the 1979 Prayer Book of the ECUSA, we find that there are "Thou-form" services and while they have much in common with those in the 1928 BCP they are certainly not identical. The "shape" of the Communion Rite is changed to fit the "shape" of Rite II and a totally new Prayer of Consecration is provided as an alternative in Rite I. The latter was specially written for the 1979 book. Further, there are verbal (doctrinal) corrections & omissions made in not a few places in traditional prayers and exhortations.
So did the production totally cease with the 1979 book? I think not.
If we look at the "Common Worship" (2000ff.) of the Church of England, we find that there is in the "Thou-form" both the use of modified/adjusted services (Morning & Evening Prayer, Litany & Holy Communion) from "The Book of Common Prayer" (1662), and the creation of new Collects, Prefaces and Prayers to go with Days not covered in the BCP of 1662.
Of course Buchanan is substantially right. No new prayer book as such, or no completely new Rites, have been produced in traditional language since 1968.
So the question comes to mind and surely has to be faced --- WHY 1968? WHY the late 1960s? What was it about the 1960s that caused all the Churches
from Roman Catholic to Pentecostalist to decide to leave behind centuries of hallowed use of the classical English language, idiom and dialect of public prayer and worship?
And a further question arises - WHY do some congregations insist in the 21st century on continuing to use the pre-1966 Rites?
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
In 1982, twenty years ago, he wrote of liturgical reform:
"Essentially, English language revision took place in two stages: 1. 'Thou '-form texts, which ruled unchallenged until 1966, and yet never produced a new text after 1968. 2. 'You'-form texts, which were unthinkable before 1966, and invariable after 1968." ("Liturgical Revision" in LITURGY RESHAPED, ed. K. Stevenson, 1982, p,147)
He went on to claim that this analysis covered the C of E, the R.C. Church & the Methodist Church in Britain, as well as Anglican Church abroad.
We may recall that immediately after Vatican II Roman Catholics used traditional English for translation of the Mass but that this ceased around 1970, with the big push for the use of a modern vernacular translation from Rome. Since 1970 only a modern vernacular translation has been permitted.
But did the production of "Thou-form" texts cease as he says by 1968? I think not. If we look at the 1979 Prayer Book of the ECUSA, we find that there are "Thou-form" services and while they have much in common with those in the 1928 BCP they are certainly not identical. The "shape" of the Communion Rite is changed to fit the "shape" of Rite II and a totally new Prayer of Consecration is provided as an alternative in Rite I. The latter was specially written for the 1979 book. Further, there are verbal (doctrinal) corrections & omissions made in not a few places in traditional prayers and exhortations.
So did the production totally cease with the 1979 book? I think not.
If we look at the "Common Worship" (2000ff.) of the Church of England, we find that there is in the "Thou-form" both the use of modified/adjusted services (Morning & Evening Prayer, Litany & Holy Communion) from "The Book of Common Prayer" (1662), and the creation of new Collects, Prefaces and Prayers to go with Days not covered in the BCP of 1662.
Of course Buchanan is substantially right. No new prayer book as such, or no completely new Rites, have been produced in traditional language since 1968.
So the question comes to mind and surely has to be faced --- WHY 1968? WHY the late 1960s? What was it about the 1960s that caused all the Churches
from Roman Catholic to Pentecostalist to decide to leave behind centuries of hallowed use of the classical English language, idiom and dialect of public prayer and worship?
And a further question arises - WHY do some congregations insist in the 21st century on continuing to use the pre-1966 Rites?
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Space & Place in worship
a discussion starter
One way of stating the needs of the baptized believer attending worship, or the needs of the searching soul also entering the house of worship, is to say that they are needing both "a PLACE of recognition & acceptance" and "a SPACE for privacy before God." If they are provided with both then "blessed are they."
The late Canon W. H.Vanstone wrote: "If a parish church is to provide adequately for the ferment of private and personal life in the parish, it must provide in its worship both ' a place' and 'a space' for each person who comes to worship. One has one's place to the extent that one is individually known and that one's particular needs and aspirations are recognized and met: one has also one's space to the extent that one retains one's privacy and is addressed and treated in worship simply as a creature in the presence of the Creator or as a child of God in the Father's house."
Let us reflect for a moment on "place." If one is warmly greeted at the door, if one's particular prayer requests are addressed, if one is invited to this or that event/meeting, if one is warmly hugged in the passing of the peace, if one is asked to do something in the worship service, if one's children are well catered for, and if one is generally noticed, it may be said that one is experiencing "place" - that is there is a real place for one in this assembly and in this congregation and in this house of worship.
Now let us reflect on "space." If one is allowed to find a pew, given
liberty to pray quietly & meditate in silence, to kneel or stand as one wishes, not be invaded by a hug or tight handshake, not be cajoled into singing loudly, and permitted to leave with minimum fuss then it may be said that one is experiencing "space" - that is one's privacy is being respected and one is being given room to worship according to one's own convictions, without hurting another.
In terms of Anglican worship, we may say that "space" is usually much available at traditional services be they of Holy Communion at 8.a.m. or of Choral Mattins at 10.00.a.m. on Sundays. Here there is no "passing of the peace" and people are usually allowed to come and go with minimal attempts to ascertain by the resident clergy or sidesmen who they are, from where they are and how they are.
Further, we may say that "place" is usually much available in popular, evangelical and charismatic services. The visitor is identified, watched over and gently interrogated. The regulars are noted and celebrated and their particular needs explained and prayed for. All seek to establish the self-worth of each person through such means as fellowship through laid-back singing, the greetings in the "peace," and the jokes in the notices.
It seems to me that it is easier to make provision for "place" in the traditional service where "space" is usually primary, than it is to make provision for "space" in the modern service where "place" is primary.
In traditional congregations, it is possible by restrained but gracious welcomes and goodbyes, by careful naming of needy persons in the intercessions, by measured, attractive and short notices, by appropriate follow-up visiting, by edifying mid-week meetings/services and by a general sense of warmth, to cater for "place" as one provides "space." Of course, the sense of place will never be as overt as with the modern type of services.
To create "space" in modern services where one's "place" is so prominent, exalted and celebrated is a tremendous and difficult task. I confess that I do not know what to suggest in terms of providing it!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Minister of Christ Church, Biddulph Moor,
England & Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large
of The Prayer Book Society of America
One way of stating the needs of the baptized believer attending worship, or the needs of the searching soul also entering the house of worship, is to say that they are needing both "a PLACE of recognition & acceptance" and "a SPACE for privacy before God." If they are provided with both then "blessed are they."
The late Canon W. H.Vanstone wrote: "If a parish church is to provide adequately for the ferment of private and personal life in the parish, it must provide in its worship both ' a place' and 'a space' for each person who comes to worship. One has one's place to the extent that one is individually known and that one's particular needs and aspirations are recognized and met: one has also one's space to the extent that one retains one's privacy and is addressed and treated in worship simply as a creature in the presence of the Creator or as a child of God in the Father's house."
Let us reflect for a moment on "place." If one is warmly greeted at the door, if one's particular prayer requests are addressed, if one is invited to this or that event/meeting, if one is warmly hugged in the passing of the peace, if one is asked to do something in the worship service, if one's children are well catered for, and if one is generally noticed, it may be said that one is experiencing "place" - that is there is a real place for one in this assembly and in this congregation and in this house of worship.
Now let us reflect on "space." If one is allowed to find a pew, given
liberty to pray quietly & meditate in silence, to kneel or stand as one wishes, not be invaded by a hug or tight handshake, not be cajoled into singing loudly, and permitted to leave with minimum fuss then it may be said that one is experiencing "space" - that is one's privacy is being respected and one is being given room to worship according to one's own convictions, without hurting another.
In terms of Anglican worship, we may say that "space" is usually much available at traditional services be they of Holy Communion at 8.a.m. or of Choral Mattins at 10.00.a.m. on Sundays. Here there is no "passing of the peace" and people are usually allowed to come and go with minimal attempts to ascertain by the resident clergy or sidesmen who they are, from where they are and how they are.
Further, we may say that "place" is usually much available in popular, evangelical and charismatic services. The visitor is identified, watched over and gently interrogated. The regulars are noted and celebrated and their particular needs explained and prayed for. All seek to establish the self-worth of each person through such means as fellowship through laid-back singing, the greetings in the "peace," and the jokes in the notices.
It seems to me that it is easier to make provision for "place" in the traditional service where "space" is usually primary, than it is to make provision for "space" in the modern service where "place" is primary.
In traditional congregations, it is possible by restrained but gracious welcomes and goodbyes, by careful naming of needy persons in the intercessions, by measured, attractive and short notices, by appropriate follow-up visiting, by edifying mid-week meetings/services and by a general sense of warmth, to cater for "place" as one provides "space." Of course, the sense of place will never be as overt as with the modern type of services.
To create "space" in modern services where one's "place" is so prominent, exalted and celebrated is a tremendous and difficult task. I confess that I do not know what to suggest in terms of providing it!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Minister of Christ Church, Biddulph Moor,
England & Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large
of The Prayer Book Society of America
U.S. Crisis Linked to Lack of Formation in the Faith
(I personally have found Glendon's books most helpful and the lady herself an exemplary Christian -- P.T.)
Harvard's Mary Ann Glendon Points to Roots of Problems
ROME, NOV. 4, 2002 (Zenit.org).- Mary Ann Glendon believes the sex-abuse scandals involving priests in the United States points up a key lesson: the need for formation.
Glendon, a Harvard law professor and John Paul II's delegate at the World Conference on Woman, said she agreed with theologian Father Richard John Neuhaus, editor in chief of First Things magazine, "when he says that the crisis of 2002 is threefold: fidelity, fidelity and fidelity."
"But, perhaps because I'm a teacher, it seems to me that the problem is not so much fidelity as it is formation, formation and formation -- formation of our theologians, formation of our religious educators, and thus formation of parents," Glendon said.
The professor made her comments today at a conference at the Regina Apostolorum Pontifical Athenaeum on the theme "Ecclesia in America: Reform, Renewal and the Role of the Laity in a Time of Turbulence" (see the Forum section).
She acknowledged that Catholics have long faced problems in the United States.
"When Catholic immigrants began arriving in great numbers, that Puritan anti-Catholicism fused with nativism and erupted into violence," Glendon said. "In 1834, an angry mob in Boston burned an Ursuline convent to the ground while police and firemen stood by and watched."
"The national best seller in 1836 was a book purporting to be the true-life confessions of an ex-nun -- it contained sensational revelations of sexual misconduct by Catholic nuns and priests," the professor continued.
"This book, 'The Awful Disclosures of the Hotel Dieu Nunnery, by Maria Monk,' was a complete fabrication, but it sold 300,000 copies and helped to inflame anti-Catholic passions," she said. "The following year, 1837, arsonists destroyed most of Boston's Irish quarter, and similar atrocities were repeated across the country.
"But the immigrants kept pouring in -- from Ireland, Italy, Germany, Poland and other parts of Eastern Europe. And by the turn of the century, the Roman Catholic Church was the country's largest and fastest growing religious group, with 12 million adherents. Faced with exclusion and discrimination, those immigrant Catholics built their own separate set of primary and high schools, hospitals and colleges. They formed countless fraternal, social, charitable and professional organizations -- Catholic lawyers, Catholic doctors, Catholic labor guilds."
Glendon pointed out the crisis of society and of Catholics at the end of the 1960s.
"The 1960s marked the beginning of a breakdown in sexual mores and a rise in family disruption, accompanied by a culture of dissent as many tried to rationalize their departures from moral norms," she said. "The developed nations were engaged in a massive social experiment, for which neither the Church nor the societies in question were prepared.
"We hardly noticed that many of us Catholics were developing a kind of schizophrenia -- putting our spiritual lives in one compartment and our daily activities in the world of work in another. We hardly noticed how many Catholics were beginning to treat their religion as an entirely private matter, and to adopt a pick-and-choose approach to doctrine."
Regarding a crisis identified with the Church in recent months -- that of clerical sexual abuse -- Glendon raised a skeptical note.
"For months, the press created a climate of hysteria by describing the story as a pedophilia crisis, when in fact only a tiny minority of the reported cases involved pedophiles -- abusers of pre-pubescent children -- as distinct from homosexual relations with teen-aged boys," she explained.
"For months, and to this day, the media has singled out the Catholic Church as a special locus of sexual abuse of minors, whereas all the studies indicate that the incidence of these types of misconduct is actually lower among Catholic priests, than among other groups who have access to young children," law professor Glendon indicated.
Quoting John Paul II's postsynodal apostolic exhortation "Ecclesia in America," Glendon said: "America needs lay Christians able to assume positions of leadership in society.
"It is urgent to train men and women who, in keeping with their vocations, can influence public life and direct it to the common good. That's quite a challenge. In a sense, the time has never been better for Catholics in the U.S. to take up that challenge."
"There are nearly 64 million of us -- almost a fifth of the U.S. population," Glendon said. "And Catholics have arrived -- they have gained enormous influence in social, professional, cultural and political life. One would think that ought to be enough leaven to raise the social loaf." ZE02110406
Harvard's Mary Ann Glendon Points to Roots of Problems
ROME, NOV. 4, 2002 (Zenit.org).- Mary Ann Glendon believes the sex-abuse scandals involving priests in the United States points up a key lesson: the need for formation.
Glendon, a Harvard law professor and John Paul II's delegate at the World Conference on Woman, said she agreed with theologian Father Richard John Neuhaus, editor in chief of First Things magazine, "when he says that the crisis of 2002 is threefold: fidelity, fidelity and fidelity."
"But, perhaps because I'm a teacher, it seems to me that the problem is not so much fidelity as it is formation, formation and formation -- formation of our theologians, formation of our religious educators, and thus formation of parents," Glendon said.
The professor made her comments today at a conference at the Regina Apostolorum Pontifical Athenaeum on the theme "Ecclesia in America: Reform, Renewal and the Role of the Laity in a Time of Turbulence" (see the Forum section).
She acknowledged that Catholics have long faced problems in the United States.
"When Catholic immigrants began arriving in great numbers, that Puritan anti-Catholicism fused with nativism and erupted into violence," Glendon said. "In 1834, an angry mob in Boston burned an Ursuline convent to the ground while police and firemen stood by and watched."
"The national best seller in 1836 was a book purporting to be the true-life confessions of an ex-nun -- it contained sensational revelations of sexual misconduct by Catholic nuns and priests," the professor continued.
"This book, 'The Awful Disclosures of the Hotel Dieu Nunnery, by Maria Monk,' was a complete fabrication, but it sold 300,000 copies and helped to inflame anti-Catholic passions," she said. "The following year, 1837, arsonists destroyed most of Boston's Irish quarter, and similar atrocities were repeated across the country.
"But the immigrants kept pouring in -- from Ireland, Italy, Germany, Poland and other parts of Eastern Europe. And by the turn of the century, the Roman Catholic Church was the country's largest and fastest growing religious group, with 12 million adherents. Faced with exclusion and discrimination, those immigrant Catholics built their own separate set of primary and high schools, hospitals and colleges. They formed countless fraternal, social, charitable and professional organizations -- Catholic lawyers, Catholic doctors, Catholic labor guilds."
Glendon pointed out the crisis of society and of Catholics at the end of the 1960s.
"The 1960s marked the beginning of a breakdown in sexual mores and a rise in family disruption, accompanied by a culture of dissent as many tried to rationalize their departures from moral norms," she said. "The developed nations were engaged in a massive social experiment, for which neither the Church nor the societies in question were prepared.
"We hardly noticed that many of us Catholics were developing a kind of schizophrenia -- putting our spiritual lives in one compartment and our daily activities in the world of work in another. We hardly noticed how many Catholics were beginning to treat their religion as an entirely private matter, and to adopt a pick-and-choose approach to doctrine."
Regarding a crisis identified with the Church in recent months -- that of clerical sexual abuse -- Glendon raised a skeptical note.
"For months, the press created a climate of hysteria by describing the story as a pedophilia crisis, when in fact only a tiny minority of the reported cases involved pedophiles -- abusers of pre-pubescent children -- as distinct from homosexual relations with teen-aged boys," she explained.
"For months, and to this day, the media has singled out the Catholic Church as a special locus of sexual abuse of minors, whereas all the studies indicate that the incidence of these types of misconduct is actually lower among Catholic priests, than among other groups who have access to young children," law professor Glendon indicated.
Quoting John Paul II's postsynodal apostolic exhortation "Ecclesia in America," Glendon said: "America needs lay Christians able to assume positions of leadership in society.
"It is urgent to train men and women who, in keeping with their vocations, can influence public life and direct it to the common good. That's quite a challenge. In a sense, the time has never been better for Catholics in the U.S. to take up that challenge."
"There are nearly 64 million of us -- almost a fifth of the U.S. population," Glendon said. "And Catholics have arrived -- they have gained enormous influence in social, professional, cultural and political life. One would think that ought to be enough leaven to raise the social loaf." ZE02110406
Friday, November 08, 2002
Church Times and Women's Ordination
Adelphoi,
The Church Times of London has in the issue of 8th November an 8-page supplement on the Tenth Anniversary of the Decision to Ordain Women taken by the General Synod of November 11, 1992. I am one of the many quoted to say where I was and how I heard about the decision (I was in Wisconsin in an anglo-catholic setting and the decision was received with horror.)
In the interview with the C T reporter to ascertain where I was, I explained to her that little attention was being paid to the doctrine of Reception, and, not surprisingly to me, when I looked through the 8-page supplement I found no reference to it.
Once you ordain women in a Church where not all are in favour of this innovation (and where some of these believe it to be an act of defiance against Divine Order), you have created a situation of imperfect or broken communion. True enough the basic communion created by the Spirit and water in baptism remains in place, but eucharistic communion of all becomes difficult or impossible if women are to be celebrants.
The doctrine of reception, first suggested in ecumenical discussions, was taken up and developed by the Eames Commission (see Report, 1994) in order to find a way and a context wherein all Anglicans could stay together in basic fellowship until, through time, the mind of the Lord was wholly and fully known on this matter.
The acceptance of this doctrine requires especially bishops, but also national church and diocesan synods, to treat women's ordination as a form of ministry that is being experienced and tested over the longish term in order that, by the kind providence of God, there will come a time in the future when it will become clear, and commonly believed, that this innovation is to be permanent or is to be undone.
In this period of reception, it is important that a majority on one side of the divide or the other does not treat the question as finally settled. In the ECUSA, the General Convention has decided that it is over and the matter is finally settled. Thus there are penalties imposed on the minority. It seems that such also is the case in some dioceses of the Anglican Church of Canada and of the C of E.
What I think we need to bear in mind in all talk of women's ordination is that it remains an innovation, and that, according to the accepted doctrine of the Lambeth Conference and the Primates' Meeting etc. it is a privileged innovation in the process of being received and tested, by careful discernment. It is not sure to remain as a permanent feature of the Church.
Some Episcopalians want to add to the innovations being received and tested the blessing of homosexual partners and the ordaining of active homosexual persons. This is worrying.
Why not order from Bill Atwood of Ekklesia Society, a copy of the book which I helped him to produce for the Primates - TO MEND THE NET (ed. Archbishop Gomez and P Bishop Sinclair, 2001) - and in which there is an essay, written by me, and approved by the Primates, on Reception?
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
The Church Times of London has in the issue of 8th November an 8-page supplement on the Tenth Anniversary of the Decision to Ordain Women taken by the General Synod of November 11, 1992. I am one of the many quoted to say where I was and how I heard about the decision (I was in Wisconsin in an anglo-catholic setting and the decision was received with horror.)
In the interview with the C T reporter to ascertain where I was, I explained to her that little attention was being paid to the doctrine of Reception, and, not surprisingly to me, when I looked through the 8-page supplement I found no reference to it.
Once you ordain women in a Church where not all are in favour of this innovation (and where some of these believe it to be an act of defiance against Divine Order), you have created a situation of imperfect or broken communion. True enough the basic communion created by the Spirit and water in baptism remains in place, but eucharistic communion of all becomes difficult or impossible if women are to be celebrants.
The doctrine of reception, first suggested in ecumenical discussions, was taken up and developed by the Eames Commission (see Report, 1994) in order to find a way and a context wherein all Anglicans could stay together in basic fellowship until, through time, the mind of the Lord was wholly and fully known on this matter.
The acceptance of this doctrine requires especially bishops, but also national church and diocesan synods, to treat women's ordination as a form of ministry that is being experienced and tested over the longish term in order that, by the kind providence of God, there will come a time in the future when it will become clear, and commonly believed, that this innovation is to be permanent or is to be undone.
In this period of reception, it is important that a majority on one side of the divide or the other does not treat the question as finally settled. In the ECUSA, the General Convention has decided that it is over and the matter is finally settled. Thus there are penalties imposed on the minority. It seems that such also is the case in some dioceses of the Anglican Church of Canada and of the C of E.
What I think we need to bear in mind in all talk of women's ordination is that it remains an innovation, and that, according to the accepted doctrine of the Lambeth Conference and the Primates' Meeting etc. it is a privileged innovation in the process of being received and tested, by careful discernment. It is not sure to remain as a permanent feature of the Church.
Some Episcopalians want to add to the innovations being received and tested the blessing of homosexual partners and the ordaining of active homosexual persons. This is worrying.
Why not order from Bill Atwood of Ekklesia Society, a copy of the book which I helped him to produce for the Primates - TO MEND THE NET (ed. Archbishop Gomez and P Bishop Sinclair, 2001) - and in which there is an essay, written by me, and approved by the Primates, on Reception?
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Tenth Anniversary.
In some circles, especially feminist-inclined, there will be celebration this weekend, for there is an important TENTH anniversary of a victory for women.
The Church of England decided by a majority vote in its General Synod on November 11, 1982 that henceforth women could be ordained as presbyters/priests in the Church. Looking back over the ten years (and of course much longer in the Episcopal Church of the USA) what can one say, in brief, about the decision? I offer some thoughts as discussion starters.
1.It was a major innovation for there is no sure record of women as presbyters in the Catholic Church before this time. Whether it was right or wrong, good or bad, it was an innovation, which both the R C and Orthodox Church state that they can never follow. As an innovation it has changed the nature of the Threefold Ministry as it is known in the Anglican Family.
2. As an innovation, it involved the Church of England in pressing to the limits, or probably beyond the limits, the doctrine of provincial autonomy. This innovatory doctrine had not been first decided by the whole Anglican Communion and then implemented locally where desired, but simply adopted by individual provinces claiming their rights as autonomous units. It helped to establish thereby a dangerous precedent.
3. As an innovation it was energised, if not given birth by, the human rights and feminist movements in secular culture. This is not to say that MANY godly women were not caught up in it and had the best of motives to serve the Lord, but it is to say that without these secular movements and agendas, there would not have been such decisions for women presbyters made by Church Synods. These godly women would have remained godly but laywomen.
4. Once the innovation was in place, and once its knock-on effects were seen & felt in terms of impaired communion and relations within the Anglican Communion of Churches, then there was need for further innovation in terms of creating a doctrine to cover this strange and disturbing state of affairs. So a Commission produced the doctrine of reception, which states that the view that women are proper recipients of the sacrament of ordination is a doctrine which is in the process of being received for the purpose of testing within the Communion of Churches. And as such, the final result of the reception and testing could be the wholesale adoption or the general rejection of the innovation. (It has to be said that in practice only lip service is usually paid to this doctrine by provinces which have women in place as priests. Too often people do not know or pretend not to know that this doctrine exists! Thus those who do not favour the ordination of women are passed over for promotion and sidelined in general.)
5. Again, once the innovation was in place the calls intensified from the feminists for adjusting the language of worship, doctrine, and practical faith. They insisted that women as ministers of word and sacrament could not be expected to use language that was supposedly heavily laden with sexism, patriarchalism and androcentricism and the like. And their cries have been heard. Modern liturgical language is thus wholly unstable for it is in a continual process of adaptation to the last call for inclusion.
6. Since the C of E legislation of 1992 only covered the ordaining of women as priests, there is now in place a Commission looking into the ordaining of women as bishops and the impact this will have on the Church. It is likely that this Commission will suggest ways for protecting the consciences and livelihoods of those who cannot receive women as bishops. If it does so then it will have learned a lesson from North America!
7. Once a Church knowingly and deliberately innovates in a major area and that area is one which runs parallel to what is happening in society (as with ordaining of women) then it has made it more difficult not to innovate in other areas when there is societal & cultural pressure - as we see with such matters as divorced persons remarrying in church, divorced clergy being licensed to serve in parishes, active homosexual persons being ordained and placed in important church positions, and so on. The more the Church door is opened the more the wind from outside is felt inside. Instead of overcoming the world for Christ's sake the present tendency in the western Church seems to be absorbing the world for the devil's sake - that is if you believe that the 1960s and post 1960s zeitgeist is not wholly from the Lord!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Minister of Christ Church, Biddulph Moor,
England & Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large
of The Prayer Book Society of America
The Church of England decided by a majority vote in its General Synod on November 11, 1982 that henceforth women could be ordained as presbyters/priests in the Church. Looking back over the ten years (and of course much longer in the Episcopal Church of the USA) what can one say, in brief, about the decision? I offer some thoughts as discussion starters.
1.It was a major innovation for there is no sure record of women as presbyters in the Catholic Church before this time. Whether it was right or wrong, good or bad, it was an innovation, which both the R C and Orthodox Church state that they can never follow. As an innovation it has changed the nature of the Threefold Ministry as it is known in the Anglican Family.
2. As an innovation, it involved the Church of England in pressing to the limits, or probably beyond the limits, the doctrine of provincial autonomy. This innovatory doctrine had not been first decided by the whole Anglican Communion and then implemented locally where desired, but simply adopted by individual provinces claiming their rights as autonomous units. It helped to establish thereby a dangerous precedent.
3. As an innovation it was energised, if not given birth by, the human rights and feminist movements in secular culture. This is not to say that MANY godly women were not caught up in it and had the best of motives to serve the Lord, but it is to say that without these secular movements and agendas, there would not have been such decisions for women presbyters made by Church Synods. These godly women would have remained godly but laywomen.
4. Once the innovation was in place, and once its knock-on effects were seen & felt in terms of impaired communion and relations within the Anglican Communion of Churches, then there was need for further innovation in terms of creating a doctrine to cover this strange and disturbing state of affairs. So a Commission produced the doctrine of reception, which states that the view that women are proper recipients of the sacrament of ordination is a doctrine which is in the process of being received for the purpose of testing within the Communion of Churches. And as such, the final result of the reception and testing could be the wholesale adoption or the general rejection of the innovation. (It has to be said that in practice only lip service is usually paid to this doctrine by provinces which have women in place as priests. Too often people do not know or pretend not to know that this doctrine exists! Thus those who do not favour the ordination of women are passed over for promotion and sidelined in general.)
5. Again, once the innovation was in place the calls intensified from the feminists for adjusting the language of worship, doctrine, and practical faith. They insisted that women as ministers of word and sacrament could not be expected to use language that was supposedly heavily laden with sexism, patriarchalism and androcentricism and the like. And their cries have been heard. Modern liturgical language is thus wholly unstable for it is in a continual process of adaptation to the last call for inclusion.
6. Since the C of E legislation of 1992 only covered the ordaining of women as priests, there is now in place a Commission looking into the ordaining of women as bishops and the impact this will have on the Church. It is likely that this Commission will suggest ways for protecting the consciences and livelihoods of those who cannot receive women as bishops. If it does so then it will have learned a lesson from North America!
7. Once a Church knowingly and deliberately innovates in a major area and that area is one which runs parallel to what is happening in society (as with ordaining of women) then it has made it more difficult not to innovate in other areas when there is societal & cultural pressure - as we see with such matters as divorced persons remarrying in church, divorced clergy being licensed to serve in parishes, active homosexual persons being ordained and placed in important church positions, and so on. The more the Church door is opened the more the wind from outside is felt inside. Instead of overcoming the world for Christ's sake the present tendency in the western Church seems to be absorbing the world for the devil's sake - that is if you believe that the 1960s and post 1960s zeitgeist is not wholly from the Lord!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Minister of Christ Church, Biddulph Moor,
England & Vice-President and Emissary-at-Large
of The Prayer Book Society of America
Tuesday, November 05, 2002
A Cautionary Tale
The story of how the American R C Church got to where it is now in respect to sexuality is, I suggest, a cautionary tale.
As early as the 1950s & early 1960s when R C Bishops heard about priests interfering sexually with children, they worried more about bad publicity from the media than the judgment of Almighty God and so moved these priests on to other parishes, hoping the problem would go away. But it did not. Now the whole of the world knows about some of this immoral activity.
Likewise, the Bishops always knew about active homosexuality in seminaries, a practice that goes on to the present day, and again they have done little or nothing about it, apparently fearing bad publicity more than they fear God himself.
Likewise in regard to Pope Paul’s encyclical “Humanae Vitae” in July 1968, which was greeted by massive public dissent led by professors and religious in the rebellious 1960s, the Bishops have done little to insist that its teaching is to be followed by faithful Catholics. In fact they issued “norms of licit dissent” in late 1968 and have not prevented those who dissented from the official teaching on birth control from being promoted to high positions in the Church in the USA. So those Catholics who seek to be faithful to the Church’s teaching on sexuality and defend it are regarded as extremists and those who teach a modified version of what general, western culture holds, as put into a Christian dress, are regarded as normal.
In other words, artificial birth control has become as essential to pursuing the good life as owning an automobile or having air conditioning for most Catholics. Sexuality is seen as a source of personal pleasure and self fulfilment as long as it is between consenting adults and is respectful of each person concerned. Further, with the creative use of psychology and misuse of canon law, the reality of divorce and remarriage in catholic parishes has been addressed by massively extending the giving of annulments so that some (but not all of) the divorced and remarried can stay in membership of the Church.
Of course, what the secular media has primarily focused on is not the tremendous rebellion of married R Catholics against the law of God for marriage, or of the presence of much homosexual practice in seminaries, or on the abuse of giving annulments for less than good reasons, but on cases of priestly abuse of minors and it is this only which the Bishops, under the watchful eye of the Vatican, have begun seriously to address (but to address apparently not as Prophets of God but rather as Managers and Psychotherapists) this year.
But here is the cautionary tale for those with ears to hear as told by a leading R C layman.
“If the Church has taught wrongly that every marriage act must be open to the transmission of life, as the dissenters believe and teach and as the bishops, in effect allow – that is, if there is no necessary connection between the use of our human sexual faculties and the procreation and education of children in Christian marriage – then there is similarly no necessary connection between the use of these same sexual faculties and marriage itself: Sex need not be limited to marriage in other words.
Moreover by the same logic, the use of the sexual faculties for mere sexual satisfaction or expression need not be limited to actions between those of different sexes: sexual acts carried out on oneself or between people of the same sex cannot be excluded (if there is no necessary connection between sex and procreation). It all hangs together. Further, the same logic applies if we try to exclude sex between adults and children….” (Kenneth D. Whitehead, in latest Touchstone magazine)
If the R C Bishops only truly address the problem of priestly interference with minors then they are not facing the root cause. If the R C Church is to prosper and be true to herself as the Church of GOD in the USA, then she must not only officially teach the whole truth but her Bishops must do all in their power to implement that teaching. They must fear God much more than they fear the media or their own professorial & professional members.
I think that a parallel story can be told of the ECUSA, which also during the 1960s took major steps away from her heritage and continues to reap the bad fruit of the sowing of new seed then. Here again the bishops are a major part of the problem, for they have offered no apostolic leadership.
The Episcopal Church (as did the Lambeth Conference!) welcomed the arrival of birth control, but at the same time, not intentionally at first, absorbed the secular culture that went with it! So it was not long before all kinds of adjustments were being made to the doctrine of marriage, of sexual satisfaction therein and the like; the word “relationship” came into its own first to describe adulterous liaisons and then other (previously sinful) ones; divorce became common and so did remarriage in church; homosexual and lesbian persons saw their opportunity (if sex is for personal satisfaction and enhancement, why not for us as well…etc) and began their successful push for recognition as normal; male priests divorced and remarried; many incoming female clergy came in looking for a career after a divorce; falling membership in ECUSA was buttressed (a) by incoming Roman Catholics who because of marital problems did not feel welcome in their own church, and (b) lesbigay persons seeking a safe home; stories of interference with minors by clergy, organists etc increased and so checks on everybody who came anywhere near children began; and so on.
Merely to address the problem of the abuse of minors (which has to be addressed) or merely (as seems to be the current evangelical approach) to oppose the blessing of homosexual partnerships (which has to be opposed) will not solve any problems in the long term and it will not bring the Church in line with the will of God. Of course abusing children is wrong and so is active homosexuality, but so is (a) much if not most of the modern teaching on the meaning and purpose of marriage in terms of personal autonomy, satisfaction and fulfilment and (b) the present practice of divorce and remarriage of clergy and laity in the church. There has to be a fully positive agenda as well as a negative one in place!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
As early as the 1950s & early 1960s when R C Bishops heard about priests interfering sexually with children, they worried more about bad publicity from the media than the judgment of Almighty God and so moved these priests on to other parishes, hoping the problem would go away. But it did not. Now the whole of the world knows about some of this immoral activity.
Likewise, the Bishops always knew about active homosexuality in seminaries, a practice that goes on to the present day, and again they have done little or nothing about it, apparently fearing bad publicity more than they fear God himself.
Likewise in regard to Pope Paul’s encyclical “Humanae Vitae” in July 1968, which was greeted by massive public dissent led by professors and religious in the rebellious 1960s, the Bishops have done little to insist that its teaching is to be followed by faithful Catholics. In fact they issued “norms of licit dissent” in late 1968 and have not prevented those who dissented from the official teaching on birth control from being promoted to high positions in the Church in the USA. So those Catholics who seek to be faithful to the Church’s teaching on sexuality and defend it are regarded as extremists and those who teach a modified version of what general, western culture holds, as put into a Christian dress, are regarded as normal.
In other words, artificial birth control has become as essential to pursuing the good life as owning an automobile or having air conditioning for most Catholics. Sexuality is seen as a source of personal pleasure and self fulfilment as long as it is between consenting adults and is respectful of each person concerned. Further, with the creative use of psychology and misuse of canon law, the reality of divorce and remarriage in catholic parishes has been addressed by massively extending the giving of annulments so that some (but not all of) the divorced and remarried can stay in membership of the Church.
Of course, what the secular media has primarily focused on is not the tremendous rebellion of married R Catholics against the law of God for marriage, or of the presence of much homosexual practice in seminaries, or on the abuse of giving annulments for less than good reasons, but on cases of priestly abuse of minors and it is this only which the Bishops, under the watchful eye of the Vatican, have begun seriously to address (but to address apparently not as Prophets of God but rather as Managers and Psychotherapists) this year.
But here is the cautionary tale for those with ears to hear as told by a leading R C layman.
“If the Church has taught wrongly that every marriage act must be open to the transmission of life, as the dissenters believe and teach and as the bishops, in effect allow – that is, if there is no necessary connection between the use of our human sexual faculties and the procreation and education of children in Christian marriage – then there is similarly no necessary connection between the use of these same sexual faculties and marriage itself: Sex need not be limited to marriage in other words.
Moreover by the same logic, the use of the sexual faculties for mere sexual satisfaction or expression need not be limited to actions between those of different sexes: sexual acts carried out on oneself or between people of the same sex cannot be excluded (if there is no necessary connection between sex and procreation). It all hangs together. Further, the same logic applies if we try to exclude sex between adults and children….” (Kenneth D. Whitehead, in latest Touchstone magazine)
If the R C Bishops only truly address the problem of priestly interference with minors then they are not facing the root cause. If the R C Church is to prosper and be true to herself as the Church of GOD in the USA, then she must not only officially teach the whole truth but her Bishops must do all in their power to implement that teaching. They must fear God much more than they fear the media or their own professorial & professional members.
I think that a parallel story can be told of the ECUSA, which also during the 1960s took major steps away from her heritage and continues to reap the bad fruit of the sowing of new seed then. Here again the bishops are a major part of the problem, for they have offered no apostolic leadership.
The Episcopal Church (as did the Lambeth Conference!) welcomed the arrival of birth control, but at the same time, not intentionally at first, absorbed the secular culture that went with it! So it was not long before all kinds of adjustments were being made to the doctrine of marriage, of sexual satisfaction therein and the like; the word “relationship” came into its own first to describe adulterous liaisons and then other (previously sinful) ones; divorce became common and so did remarriage in church; homosexual and lesbian persons saw their opportunity (if sex is for personal satisfaction and enhancement, why not for us as well…etc) and began their successful push for recognition as normal; male priests divorced and remarried; many incoming female clergy came in looking for a career after a divorce; falling membership in ECUSA was buttressed (a) by incoming Roman Catholics who because of marital problems did not feel welcome in their own church, and (b) lesbigay persons seeking a safe home; stories of interference with minors by clergy, organists etc increased and so checks on everybody who came anywhere near children began; and so on.
Merely to address the problem of the abuse of minors (which has to be addressed) or merely (as seems to be the current evangelical approach) to oppose the blessing of homosexual partnerships (which has to be opposed) will not solve any problems in the long term and it will not bring the Church in line with the will of God. Of course abusing children is wrong and so is active homosexuality, but so is (a) much if not most of the modern teaching on the meaning and purpose of marriage in terms of personal autonomy, satisfaction and fulfilment and (b) the present practice of divorce and remarriage of clergy and laity in the church. There has to be a fully positive agenda as well as a negative one in place!
The Rev'd Dr. Peter Toon
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)